Development of the lung
- 3.1k Downloads
To fulfill the task of gas exchange, the lung possesses a huge inner surface and a tree-like system of conducting airways ventilating the gas exchange area. During lung development, the conducting airways are formed first, followed by the formation and enlargement of the gas exchange area. The latter (alveolarization) continues until young adulthood. During organogenesis, the left and right lungs have their own anlage, an outpouching of the foregut. Each lung bud starts a repetitive process of outgrowth and branching (branching morphogenesis) that forms all of the future airways mainly during the pseudoglandular stage. During the canalicular stage, the differentiation of the epithelia becomes visible and the bronchioalveolar duct junction is formed. The location of this junction stays constant throughout life. Towards the end of the canalicular stage, the first gas exchange may take place and survival of prematurely born babies becomes possible. Ninety percent of the gas exchange surface area will be formed by alveolarization, a process where existing airspaces are subdivided by the formation of new walls (septa). This process requires a double-layered capillary network at the basis of the newly forming septum. However, in parallel to alveolarization, the double-layered capillary network of the immature septa fuses to a single-layered network resulting in an optimized setup for gas exchange. Alveolarization still continues, because, at sites where new septa are lifting off preexisting mature septa, the required second capillary layer will be formed instantly by angiogenesis. The latter confirms a lifelong ability of alveolarization, which is important for any kind of lung regeneration.
KeywordsLung development Branching morphogenesis Alveolarization Microvascular maturation Pulmonary acinus
A tree of purely conducting airways (bronchi and bronchioles) transporting the air to and from the gas exchange region as well as many small trees of gas exchanging airways representing the acini (respiratory bronchioles and alveolar ducts). An acinus is defined as the unit that is served by the most distal purely conducting airways (terminal bronchioles). It represents the functional unit of the lung (Storey and Staub 1962; Tyler 1983).
A very large surface area possessing a very thin air–blood barrier for gas exchange. It is located inside the acini (Gehr et al. 1978).
Stages of lung development and their time scale
Monkey: n.d. – E55
Human: E26–E49 (4–7 weeksa)
Anlage of the two lungs; organogenesis; formation of major airways and pleura.
Monkey: E55 – E85
Human: E35–E119 (5–17 weeks)
Formation of bronchial tree and large parts of prospective respiratory parenchyma; birth of the acinus even if the acinar epithelia are not yet differentiated.
Human: E112–E182 (16–26 weeksa)
Formation of the most distal airways leading to completion of branching morphogenesis; first air-blood barrier; appearance of surfactant, acini are detectable due to epithelial differentiation.
Saccular or terminal sac
Human: E168–E266 (24–38 weeksa)
Expansion of (future) airspaces.
Alveolarization, classical alveolarization (first phase)
Rabbit: E30–term (E31)
Sheep: E120–term (E145)
Mouse: P4 – P21
Rat: P4 – P21
Monkey: E125– <P180b
Human: E252 (36 weeks* preterm) – 3 years
Formation of secondary septa (septation) resulting in the formation of the alveoli; most of the alveolar septa are still immature and contain a double layered capillary network. Depending on the species alveolarization starts before or after birth.
Alveolarization, continued alveolarization (second phase)
Rabbit: term (E31) – n.d.
Sheep: term (E145) – n.d.
Mouse: P14 – young adulthood (∼P36)
Rat: P14 – young adulthood (∼P60)
Monkey: < P180b– young adulthood (7–8 years)
Human: 2 years – young adulthood (17–21 years)
Formation of secondary septa (septation) but now lifting off of mature alveolar septa containing a single layered capillary network.
Mouse: P4 – young adulthood (∼P36)
Rat: P14 – young adulthood (∼P60)
Human: ∼term – ∼3–21 years (timing uncertain)
Remodeling and maturation of interalveolar septa and of the capillary bed (the double layered capillary network is transformed to a single layered network). In a first approximation it takes place in parallel to alveolarization.
In a more general view, the inner surface of the lung is formed by two very different mechanisms, branching morphogenesis and septation (also called alveolarization) (Schittny and Burri 2008). The two lung buds (lung anlage) elongate and start a repetitive process of branching and of growth into the surrounding mesenchyme. Each branching generates a new generation of airways. Branching of epithelial tubes represents a very old developmental principle. It is also used during the development of glands (e.g., salivary and mammary glands) and the kidneys. All airways are formed by branching morphogenesis (Schittny and Burri 2008). Roughly 10% of the gas exchange surface area is formed by branching morphogenesis because, during the canalicular stage, the first future air–blood barriers are formed in the future alveolar ducts and saccules. The remaining ∼90% are formed by a completely different mechanism that is unique to lung development. The airspaces of the alveolar ducts and the respiratory bronchioles (if present) are subdivided by the formation of new inter-airspace walls called alveolar septa. This process is called septation for dividing airspaces by septa or alveolarization because the newly formed airspaces are called alveoli (Boyden and Tompsett 1965; Dubreuil et al. 1936; Engel 1953). The last step towards a mature gas exchange apparatus represents a thinning of the alveolar septa and a maturation of their microvasculature (stage of macrovascular maturation). Until recently, it was believed that this maturation takes place after alveolarization ceased (Burri 1975). However, the novel concept that alveolarization continues until young adulthood implies that alveolarization and microvascular maturation are parallel processes (Schittny et al. 2008).
This review mainly reports on human lung development, even if many of the mechanisms have been studied in animal models. All prenatal days and weeks are given as embryonic days (E), post-conceptional (p.c.) or gestational age, respectively. In clinical settings, the weeks of postmenstrual age is commonly used, which is equal to the gestational age plus 2 weeks.
Embryonic period/organogenesis (weeks 4–7)
Anlage of the lung and trachea
The primitive foregut divides into the esophagus and trachea after a deepening and joining of the laryngotracheal sulci of the lateral walls of the foregut. Mesenchymal cells surrounding the forming trachea are condensing focally and differentiate into precursors of cartilage towards the end of the embryonic period. With further development of the bronchial tree, the formation of the cartilage moves distally until it reaches the smallest bronchi (25 weeks).
During weeks 5–7, the visceral pleura forms as a product of the splanchnic mesoderm. In parallel, the parietal pleura forms out of the somatic mesoderm layer covering the inner surface of the body wall. Thereafter, the visceral pleura starts to fold into the lung separating the tissues surrounding the lobar bronchi. It forms the lobar fissure separating the lung lobes. In parallel with the formation of the pleura, the pleuropericadial folds meet and fuse with the foregut mesenchyme. Caudally at the posterior body wall, the two pleuroperitoneal membranes start growing towards the posterior edge of the septum transversum. All of them meet and fuse, resulting in a closure of the pleural cavities (Sadler 2014; Schoenwolf et al. 2015).
Because the anlage of the lungs forms out of the primitive foregut, the future lung epithelia are of endodermal descent. The mesoderm, where the epithelial tubes push in, is obviously of mesodermal descent. The dual descent of the lung tissue is of importance for the branching morphogenesis, because branching is governed by an intensive cross-talk between epithelial and mesenchymal cells and the factors they are producing. The epithelial cells are supported by a basement membrane and surrounded by an extracellular matrix that is in large parts produced by the mesenchymal cells. The components of the extracellular matrix including the basement membrane are different at the terminal bud, the branching points and in the more proximal parts of the bronchial tree where epithelial differentiation already started (Schittny and Burri 2004). A very specific differential expression of factors like fibroblast growth factor 10 (FGF-10), bone morphogenic protein 4 (BMP-4), Sonic Hedgehog (Shh), retinoic acid, Notch, TGF-β and others give the instructions for the branching morphogenesis. During this process, the epithelial tubes go through repetitive circles of branching and outgrowth into the surrounding mesenchyme (for reviews, see Cardoso and Lu 2006; Hines and Sun 2014; Swarr and Morrisey 2015).
Vasculogenesis of pulmonary circulation
The pulmonary arteries are running in parallel to the airways, delivering the blood to the capillary network of the alveoli. The pulmonary veins collect the blood and run inter-axially at the surface of the pulmonary units, be it segments, sub-segments or as the smallest unit the acini. The veins are embedded in the inter-axial connective tissue. In order to reach the hilum, the large venous branches join the arteries and airways in the most central areas (Verbeken et al. 1996). The first pulmonary vessels are formed as a plexus in the mesenchyme surrounding the lung buds by vasculogenesis—the de novo formation of vessels due to a differentiation of mesenchymal cells. The plexus is cranially connected to the aortic sac and caudally to the left atrium. During branching of the future airways, a new capillary plexus is formed as a halo surrounding each newly formed bud. Each plexus adds to the future pulmonary circulation. The final structure is achieved by intussusceptive remodeling, pruning and angiogenesis of the primary formed vessels. Thus, the forming bronchial tree of airways serves as a template for the vascular tree of blood vessels and lymphatic drainage (Burri 1985; Djonov and Burri 2006).
Clinical aspects of the embryonic period
Malformations during organogenesis are often related to lung bud formation and development, tracheal/esophageal separation and an incomplete formation of the diaphragm. As for any other organ, these abnormalities show a high mortality and postnatal morbidity. Structural malformations like pulmonary agenesis or aplasia, as well as pulmonary valve stenosis are generally viewed as nonsurvivable, whereas others show variable degrees of morbidity. An incomplete closure of the pericardial–peritoneal canals causes a diaphragmatic hernia and a compression of the developing lung resulting in pulmonary hypoplasia (Kinane 2007). A variety of permutations of abnormal connections between the trachea and the esophagus represent a common congenital malformation during pulmonary organogenesis. It includes tracheaoesophageal fistula and esophageal atresia, a defect where the upper and lower segments of the esophagus do not connect. In full-term infants, the postsurgical survival is high but in low-birth-weight babies, these malformations are often accompanied by other congenital defects resulting in a higher risk for poor outcomes (Kovesi and Rubin 2004).
Pseudoglandular stage (weeks 5–17)
Formation of the bronchial tree
Epithelial and smooth muscle cell differentiation
Starting proximally, the future airways are lined by a very high columnar epithelium (Fig. 3d). The height of the epithelial cells decreases continuously toward the terminal branches where cuboidal epithelium is found. The cuboidal epithelia of the terminal buds maintain their undifferentiated state until branching morphogenesis is completed during the canalicular stage. In some species like human, branching morphogenesis may even continue until the saccular stage. During the pseudoglandular stage, the first ciliated, goblet and basal cells appear in the proximal airways. Thereafter, epithelial differentiation progresses into the periphery (Burri 1985).
A continuous layer of α-smooth muscle actin-positive cell starts to form around the most proximal future airways. The layer becomes discontinuous in the more distal parts of the bronchial tree and ends in front of the terminal buds. These contractile cells start to perform spontaneous contractions pushing peristaltic waves of inter-bronchial fluid into the periphery, causing a rhythmic extension of the distal airways including the terminal buds. It was postulated that these movements stimulate branching morphogenesis and prevent uncontrolled expansion of the airways as pulmonary fluid is secreted into the lung (Schittny et al. 2000; Sparrow et al. 1994).
Arteries and veins
During the pseudoglandular stage, the arteries and veins continue to develop as already described in the previous sections (organogenesis). However, the arterial tree contains a higher number of generations than the bronchial tree. On average, there are 20% additional branches in the arterial tree versus the bronchial tree. These so-called “supernumerary” arteries do not strictly follow the same bronchial tree as the conventional ones but split off at right angles. Usually they serve the “recurrent” gas exchange tissue adjacent to the larger airways (Hislop and Reid 1973; Hislop 2002).
Clinical aspects of the pseudoglandular stage
During the pseudoglandular stage, lung development depends on mechanical stimuli. The spontaneous contractions of the airways have already been discussed above. Around 10 weeks p.c., fetal breathing movements start in humans. These movements cause additional stretching of the lung tissue and move fluid in and out of the lungs (Koos and Rajaee 2014). Recent studies have demonstrated that mechanical stimuli upregulate the release of serotonin via mechanosensitive channels promoting differentiation of epithelial cells (Pan et al. 2006). In addition, stretching stimulates epithelial cell proliferation (Liu et al. 1999) and increases the secretion of surfactant lipids by type II epithelial cells (Scott et al. 1993).
A congenital diaphragmatic hernia leads to pulmonary hypoplasia and hypertension if an ascension of the abdominal organs into the chest cavity and a compression of the lung(s) takes place. The compression leads to a reduction of the bronchial generations and later to a reduction of the gas exchange surface area. These conditions lead to a high rate of mortality (Kitagawa et al. 1971). An elevation of the inter-pulmonary pressure by an occlusion of the trachea improved the outcome in animal experiments. However, side effects prevented this measure being applied clinically (Vuckovic et al. 2013; Wilson et al. 1993).
A prolonged imbalance of the pressure between the extra-luminal space and the inter-luminal airway has lasting negative effects on lung development. These conditions are encountered due to a fetal exposure to an oligohydramnios. It causes pulmonary hypoplasia and an 80% higher risk of respiratory failure as compared to unaffected fetuses (Chien et al. 2014). An oligohydramnios is often part of an autosomal recessive polycystic kidney disease. Because kidney development also includes branching morphogenesis, the pulmonary hypoplasia may be caused by a combination of the genetic defect and the compression of the developing lung (Hartung and Guay-Woodford 2014).
Canalicular stage (weeks 16–26)
The canalicular stage comprises the differentiation of the epithelia that allows the morphological distinction between conducting and respiratory airways. This distinction permits the recognition of the acinus/ventilatory unit for the first time (Boyden 1971). However, most of the acinar airways are already formed during the pseudoglandular stage and only the very distal generations are formed during the canalicular stage (Kitaoka et al. 1996). Furthermore, the alveolar epithelium comes into close contact with the mesenchymal capillary network in order to form the first future air–blood barriers.
“Canalization” of the lung parenchyma
At the end of the saccular stage, the mesenchyme located between the future airways contains a loose three-dimensional vascular network. This network starts to proliferate due to intensive angiogenesis resulting in a high capillary density. The future airways that will transform to alveolar ducts start to grow in width and length, change their shape and appear like “canaliculi” (Fig. 3a→b). The canalization of the mesenchyme by respiratory airways and capillaries gave this stage its name. The growth of the airways causes a condensation of the mesenchyme (Fig. 3a→b). Programmed cell death (apoptosis) contributes to the condensation of the mesenchyme, where not only the volume but also the total number of mesenchymal cells is reduced (Rogelj et al. 1989).
Epithelial differentiation: formation of the air–blood barrier
Currently, the formation of the air–blood barrier is poorly understood. It is likely that an intensive “cross-talk” between the endodermally-derived epithelium and the mesodermally-derived endothelium takes place. This hypothesis is supported by observations made in a transgenic mouse model where the sequence coding for the nitrogen-binding site of laminin (γ1III4, within the laminin-γ1-chain) was selectively deleted. The basement membranes of the air–blood barrier are missing or disrupted in a large part in these mice. The mice die neonatally due to a failure of pulmonary gas exchange (Willem et al. 2002).
Shortly after their appearance, type II epithelial cells start to produce surfactant. The accumulation of surfactant becomes morphologically visible by the intracellular formation of lamellar bodies. In most species, surfactant appears at about 80–90% of the total duration of the gestational period. In humans, surfactant appears earlier. Small amounts are already present at 60% of gestation (weeks 22–24) (Burri 1999). At first, surfactant appears to be less abundant in basal lung regions than in apical ones (Howatt et al. 1965). This finding may explain clinical observations that in preterm infants hyaline membrane disease is more pronounced in basal than in apical lung regions.
Type II alveolar epithelial cells represent the progenitor of type I epithelial cells (Bachofen and Weibel 1977). Therefore, it is not surprising that the future alveolar epithelial cells contain a few, small, lamellated bodies before differentiation into type I and type II cells becomes morphologically visible (Mercurio and Rhodin 1976).
At the bronchioalveolar duct junction (BADJ), an abrupt change of the epithelia from ciliated and Club cells (originally called Clara cells; Winkelmann and Noack 2010) to type I and type II alveolar epithelial cells takes place. This junction is formed during the canalicular stage when epithelial differentiation occurs and is of particular importance because it represents a stem cells niche (McQualter et al. 2010; Nolen-Walston et al. 2008). Very recently, it was shown by the group of the author that the bronchioalveolar junction stays constant throughout lung development at the location or better at the generation of the airways, where it was originally formed (Barre et al. 2014, 2016). In animals like mice and rats that do not possess respiratory bronchioles, the bronchioalveolar duct junction represents the entrance to the acinus (Tyler 1983). Therefore, in these animals, the entrance of the acini also stays constant and, as a consequence, the number of acini is first defined during the canalicular stage and stays constant throughout lung development into adulthood. Furthermore, the growth of the lung parenchyma in volume and surface area takes place exclusively inside the acini without increasing their number (Barre et al. 2016).
Pulmonary acini are defined as the small trees of gas exchanging airways that are ventilated by the most distal purely conducting airways (terminal bronchioles). In mammals like humans that possess respiratory bronchioles, the acinus starts approximately 3–4 generations proximal of the bronchioalveolar duct junction and ends ∼4 generations of alveolar ducts distal of the bronchioalveolar duct junction (Tyler 1983). The region of the alveolar ducts is called the ventilatory unit (Storey and Staub 1962) and represents the corresponding region of the rodent acinus. Even if it was not measured in humans, it may be hypothesized that the number of ventilatory units stays constant after they have been formed during the canalicular stage. The future respiratory bronchioli are formed during the pseudoglandular stage but they are not detectable until their alveoli are formed much later during alveolarization. Therefore, during lung development, the entrance of an acinus should be defined as its most proximal future respiratory bronchiole. Based on this definition, the number of acini also stays constant in humans, even if it takes until the start of alveolarization that they become visible (Barre et al. 2016).
Clinical aspects of the canalicular stage
Reaching the canalicular stage is very important for very immature and prematurely born infants. At this time point, first future air–blood barriers are formed and at least a minimal production of surfactant is produced. A survival is feasible but only with specialized support of a neonatal intensive care unit. It is mostly dependent on the amount of available gas exchange surface area in the neonatal lung. First, the air–blood barriers have to be formed at that point and, second, the lung has to be inflated. The latter mostly depends on the amount of available surfactant. Unwanted side effects of the intensive treatment are correlating with the immaturity of the lungs and may cause a chronic lung disease called bronchopulmonary dysplasia (see below).
In patients with alveolar capillary dysplasia (ACD), the alveolar epithelium is surrounded by mesenchyme containing small blood vessels instead of capillaries. In addition, ACD is often accompanied by a misalignment of the pulmonary veins. The malformation results in a reduced capillary density, reduced air–blood interface, thickened alveolar septa and pulmonary hypertension. Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) are linked to this lethal congenital lung abnormality (Groenman et al. 2005; Kool et al. 2014).
Saccular stage (weeks 24–38)
The saccular stage represents an intermediate stage, when branching morphogenesis ceases and alveolarization has yet to start. This intermediate stage may be necessary because branching morphogenesis and alveolarization are completely different genetic programs that apparently do not take place in parallel (Cardoso and Lu 2006; Morrisey et al. 2013). Most likely, the most distal generations of the airways were already formed at the end of the canalicular stage. However, depending on the species, very few terminal airways may also be formed during the saccular stage by branching morphogenesis (Woods and Schittny 2016).
Expansion of the gas-exchange area
At the beginning of the saccular stage, the terminal (acinar) airways are growing in length and are widening. They form clusters of larger airspaces. Especially, the terminal ends are widening and form so-called sacculi, which give their name to this stage (Fig. 3c). The enlargement of the future gas exchange region causes a condensation of the mesenchyme. At locations where two airspaces meet, primary septa are formed. The capillary networks stay very close to the septal surfaces and are separated by a central layer of condensed mesenchyme forming a core of connective tissue. As a result, the primary septa contain a double-layered capillary network. Most of the surface of the primary septa is covered by type I epithelial cells. The remaining surface is filled in by type II epithelial cells that produce surfactant and serve as progenitor cells for the type I epithelial cells (Fig. 3f). During this stage, smooth muscle cell precursors move in and start to lay down a fibrous network of elastic fiber and collagen fibrils that represent a prerequisite for the following alveolarization.
Time point of birth
The stage of lung development at term correlates with the physical activity of the newborn. The marsupial quokka wallaby (Setonix brachyurus) is born in the canalicular stage and may be the least physically mature mammal directly after birth (Makanya et al. 2001). Insessorial mammals like mice and rats are born during the saccular stage (Amy et al. 1977; Burri 1974). In precocial mammals like sheep (Alcorn et al. 1981) and guinea pigs (Sosenko and Frank 1987), alveolarization starts well before birth and at term their lungs appear nearly mature. The physical activities of human newborns are in between insessorial and precocial mammals and therefore at term human lung development is in its early alveolar stage (Zeltner et al. 1987). Regardless of the stage of lung development at term, alveolarization continues at least as long as the lungs are growing.
Clinical aspects of the saccular stage
Very early prematurely born infants have to use their lungs for gas exchange at the end of the canalicular stage and during the saccular stage. As a life-saving measure, many of them receive surfactant, steroids, or oxygen and are mechanically ventilated, causing damage at the cellular level due to oxygen toxicity and volutrauma. In addition, these infants have to cope with pulmonary inflammation and a steroid-induced re-programming lung development. As a result, alveolarization does not progress as well as in term-born infants. The resulting disease is called bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD). Infants showing BPD have fever and therefore larger alveoli, insufficient vascularization and airflow limitations. All of these conditions cause a reduction of gas exchange in its own right. BPD-induced alterations of the lungs often persist into adulthood or throughout the whole life (Caskey et al. 2016; Madurga et al. 2013).
Alveolarization (week 36–young adulthood)
- Alveoli have an irregular shape that is a result of its space-filling arrangement (Fig. 7) (Mund et al. 2008; Tsuda et al. 2008). Therefore, they do not represent 2/3 of a ball as shown in many text books (Netter 2014). This insight is very important for the alveolar ventilation and deposition of particles, because the 3D microstructure has a significant influence on these two processes, especially at the entrance of the acini (Fishler et al. 2015; Henry et al. 2012; Sznitman et al. 2010). In addition, the irregular structure of the alveoli most likely contributes to an irregular distribution of the strain inside the alveolar septa during breathing and mechanical ventilation (Rausch et al. 2011).
In the classical model of alveolarization, it was postulated that alveolarization ceases after the capillary layers in the alveolar septa mature during microvascular maturation (Burri et al. 1974). Using recently developed techniques, it was shown for rabbits (Kovar et al. 2002), rhesus monkey (Hyde et al. 2007), rats (Schittny et al. 2008), mice (Mund et al. 2008) and humans (Herring et al. 2014; Narayanan et al. 2012) that alveolarization continues at least as long as the lungs are growing.
- New alveolar septa may be lifted off both immature and mature alveolar septa. Therefore, new septa or new alveoli, respectively, may be formed principally at any time, even during adulthood. Two phases of alveolarization are distinguished: classical (or bulk) alveolarization (Fig. 8a–d) and continued alveolarization (Figs. 8e–f, 9) (Schittny et al. 2008; Tschanz et al. 2014; Woods and Schittny 2016). However, the rate of increase in the number of alveoli is smaller during continued alveolarization than during classical alveolarization (Hyde et al. 2007; Tschanz et al. 2014).
- A reexamination of microvascular maturation (Roth-Kleiner et al. 2005; and own unpublished results, Figs. 10, 11) revealed that the maturation of the capillary layers of the alveolar septa takes place roughly in parallel to alveolarization. However, the bulk of the maturation occurs mostly during the originally proposed period (Burri 1975; Caduff et al. 1986).
Classical alveolarization (week 36–∼3 years)
At the end of the saccular stage, the lung parenchyma possesses thick, immature septa that contain a double-layered capillary network. Both capillary layers are separated by a core of connective tissue (Figs. 8a, 10a, c). During classical alveolarization, new septa are lifted off immature preexisting septa and will divide the existing airspaces. The upfoldings are visible in 3D images of the lung parenchyma first as low and later as fully grown septa (Fig. 7) and are called secondary septa in order to distinguish them from the primary septa formed by differential growth after branching morphogenesis. The upfoldings appear at locations where smooth muscle cell (precursors) laid down a string of elastic fibers and collagen fibrils (Burri 1974; Lindahl et al. 1997). In addition, tenascin-C is highly expressed at this location (Roth-Kleiner et al. 2014) (Fig. 8a). During folding, the “strings” stay close to the free septal edge of the new septum. The capillary layer facing the airspace takes part in the folding process and the free edge of its folding stays in close contact to the “string” (Fig. 8b). The additional surface area of the capillary network is most likely formed by intussusceptive angiogenesis (Caduff et al. 1986). After the formation of the new septum is initiated, the septum rises up to its full height and the first alveoli are formed (Fig. 8c). In humans (Herring et al. 2014), rhesus monkey (Hyde et al. 2007), rat (Schittny et al. 2008; Tschanz et al. 2014) and mice (Mund et al. 2008), alveolarization shows a bi-phasic behavior. Classical alveolarization starts as a burst and reduces its speed during the switch to continued alveolarization (see below).
Microvascular maturation (week 36–young adulthood)
Immature primary and secondary septa contain a double-layered capillary network (Fig. 10a, c). These immature septa are rather inefficient in terms of the building material needed for gas exchange. During microvascular maturation, the septa are thinning and the two capillary layers fuse in order to form a more efficient single-layered capillary network in a thin septum (Fig. 10b, d) (Burri 1975; Caduff et al. 1986). This process includes multi-focal fusing of capillary segments and differential growth of the mature single-layered capillary network (Roth-Kleiner et al. 2005; Schittny and Burri 2008). In addition, the interstitial tissue volume decreases significantly (Burri 1974; Kauffman et al. 1974) and a peak of apoptosis was observed during the transition from classical to continued alveolarization (Schittny et al. 1998). The septum of connective tissue is now interwoven with the single-layered capillary network (Fig. 10b).
Originally, the stage of microvascular maturation was described as a stage following the stage of alveolarization, including a large overlap between these two stages (Burri 1975; Caduff et al. 1986). Recently, it was recognized that alveolarization continues until young adulthood (see next section). This new finding triggered a re-examination of the timing of the process of microvascular maturation. Based on stereological estimations done during rat lung development, it turned out that the microvascular maturation takes place in parallel to alveolarization. However, the bulk of maturation happens approximately during the original proposed period (Fig. 11). In order to adapt our view of lung development to these new findings, I would like to propose to recognize the same timing for both processes, meaning that both alveolarization and microvascular maturation start after the saccular stage and continue until young adulthood. This timing takes into account that every newly formed septum first possesses an immature capillary network that will mature shortly afterwards (Fig. 8g, h). Therefore, microvascular maturation has to continue as long as new septa or alveoli are formed. This view is based on rat (Fig. 11) and mice data (own unpublished observations). Stereology-based human or monkey data are not yet available.
Maturation of the pulmonary structural elements does not only include the maturation of the microvasculature but also a maturation of the extracellular matrix including basement membranes. Tissue transglutaminase specifically cross-links proteins by the introduction of γ-glutamyl-ε-lysine-crosslinks. Extracellular tissue transglutaminase stabilizes the extracellular matrix and slows down remodeling. During alveolarization, the appearance of γ-glutamyl-ε-lysine-crosslinks correlates with the maturation of the conducting and respiratory airways including the alveolar septa (Schittny et al. 1997).
Continued alveolarization (∼2 years–young adulthood)
It was correctly postulated that the formation of a new alveolar septum requires a double-layered capillary network. As a consequence, it was supposed that, after maturation of the microvasculature, no new alveoli may be formed any more (Burri 1975; Caduff et al. 1986). However, in time several cases of alveolarization after microvascular maturation was completed were observed. First, after pneumonectomy, a re-growth of the lung including alveolarization was observed not only in animals (Cagle and Thurlbeck 1988; Hsia et al. 1994) but also in at least one human (Butler et al. 2012). Second, a treatment with glucocorticoids during classical alveolarization strongly decreases the number of alveoli, while a prolonged treatment caused a permanent decrease (Massaro and Massaro 1986) and a short, high-dose treatment caused only a transient one (Tschanz et al. 2003). However, even the permanent alveolar reduction could be rescued by a treatment with retinoic acid after the microvasculature matured (Massaro and Massaro 2000). Third, after starving of small laboratory animals, the number of alveoli was reduced. However, after refeeding, the alveolar number returned to normal (Kalenga et al. 1995a, b). Similar observations were carried out for nutritional emphysema in humans (Coxson et al. 2004). And fourth, studying 3D images of the lung parenchyma, low ridges dividing existing airspaces during rat lung development were observed after maturation of the microvasculature. These rides were indicative of ongoing alveolarization (Fig. 7) (Schittny et al. 2008). At least these four cases triggered a quantitative reinvestigation of alveolarization. Using either the number of alveoli or the length of the free septal edge as a measure, as well as 3He-MRI, it was shown for rabbits, rhesus monkey, rats, mice and humans that alveolarization certainly continues until young adulthood, which is later than the originally proposed end of the maturation of the microvasculature (rabbits, Kovar et al. 2002; rhesus monkey, Hyde et al. 2007; rats, Schittny et al. 2008; mice, Mund et al. 2008; and humans, Herring et al. 2014; Narayanan et al. 2012).
Now the classical model of alveolarization had to be refined. Studying high-resolution tomographic images of vascular casts of the alveolar region, a duplication of the single-layered capillary network at sites where the capillary layer folds up to form a new septum was observed by the author (Fig. 9). For very “young” septa where the new septum was just starting to fold up, the duplications of the single-layered capillary network were not yet complete (Fig. 8e, f). A little bit “older” new septa showed complete duplications (Fig. 8g). Therefore, as already postulated in the 1970s (Amy et al. 1977; Burri 1975), a double-layered capillary network represents a prerequisite for the formation of new septa. However, if due to microvascular maturation only one layer is present (Fig. 8e), the required second one will be formed instantly by angiogenesis. As a result, the newly formed septum possesses a folded capillary network or—expressed differently—an immature double-layered capillary network. In a final step, the newly formed septa will mature like any other septum (Fig. 8h) (Schittny et al. 2008).
Alveolarization of the respiratory bronchioles
Until now, the alveolarization of the respiratory bronchioles have been studied in only one species, the rhesus monkey (Tyler et al. 1988). Alveolarization begins in the most proximal respiratory bronchioles approximately in parallel to the alveolarization of the future alveolar duct and the saccules. It moves distally by time and takes only 5 days in monkeys. The alveoli are formed by an out-pocketing of the future respiratory bronchioles into the surrounding extracellular matrix. They occur on the side opposite to the accompanying pulmonary arteriole. The out-pocketings are first lined with a cuboidal epithelium that later flattens and forms the air–blood barrier (Tyler et al. 1988). The formation of the alveoli of the respiratory bronchioles shows more similarities with the differentiation of the epithelia during the canalicular stage than with the classical or continued alveolarization of the ventilator units. Therefore, it rather resembles the formation of the gas exchanging area of the saccules (primary septa) than of the alveoli (secondary septa).
Clinical aspects of alveolarization
Meanwhile, it has been shown in many studies (see above) that the lung possesses the ability to form new alveoli as long as it is growing and even during adulthood. Clinically, this potential is very important. First, for lungs thought to be permanently impaired by bronchopulmonary dysplasia, a late recovery has been observed (Carraro et al. 2013). Second, after pneumonectomy or lobe-ectomy, compensatory lung growth including the formation of new alveoli was shown in humans using 3HeMRI at least in one case (Butler et al. 2012). In laboratory animals, it was shown that mechanical stretch represents one important factor for this kind of lung recovery (Ravikumar et al. 2013). And third, after treatment of laboratory animals with glucocorticoids, a partial to full recovery of impaired lung development was observed during continued alveolarization. The grade of recovery was dependent on the length of the glucocorticoid treatment (Corroyer et al. 2002; Luyet et al. 2002; Massaro and Massaro 1986; Tschanz et al. 1995, 2003). Recovery could be facilitated in animal experiments by an additional treatment with retinoic acid (Massaro and Massaro 1996; Massaro et al. 2000). However, these experiments also show that the developing lung is susceptible to side effects of a treatment with different drugs including glucocorticoids and retinoic acid derivate.
At a first view, the animal lungs seem to be more adaptive than human lungs. However, while animal studies were done either during or shortly after continued alveolarization was completed, human patients are typically much older than the corresponding age in the animal studies. Therefore, the observed difference between animal studies and clinical experience may be due to age differences. However, regardless of the age of the patient, it is not understood how to re-activate continued alveolarization in order to cure structural lung diseases like pulmonary emphysema and fibrosis, as well as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). In principle, it may be possible but our understanding of the molecular mechanism involved is still too limited.
Even if the first still rudimentary knowledge about the structural lung development goes as far back as Galen (Aelius Galenus von Pergamon, ∼129–216) and Andreas Vesalius (1514–1564), new insights about this topic are currently being obtained. Especially, the newly involved methods of high-resolution 3D structural and functional imaging of the lung are contributing to this. Furthermore, proteomics and gene array methodologies applied down to cellular level will provide new insights into physiological and pathological lung development and function. Combining imaging with molecular analysis has the potential to give us a 3D map of expression patterns and cellular behavior. It is postulated that such maps will enable us to understand regional differences of lung function. The latter is not only a question of lung physiology but also very important for the emerging field of drug delivery via a pulmonary deposition of aerosolized drugs.
I would like to thank Peter Burri, my mentor, who brought me into the field of lung development, for his continued support for more than 20 years. Furthermore, I would like to thank the former and current members of my group and my collaborators for their commitment to push forward our understanding of lung development. I am grateful for the support of the Swiss National Science Foundation (grant 310030–153468).
Compliance with ethical standards
The author declares that he has no conflict of interest.
- Barre SF, Haberthur D, Cremona TP, Stampanoni M, Schittny JC (2016) The total number of acini remains constant throughout postnatal rat lung development. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 00325:02016Google Scholar
- Burri PH (1985) Development and growth of the human lung. In: Fishman AP, Fisher AB (eds) Handbook of physiology, section 3: the respiratory system, chapter 1. American Physiological Society, BethesdaGoogle Scholar
- Burri PH (1997) Structural aspects of pre- and postnatal development and growth of the lung. In: McDonald J (ed) Growth and development of the lung. M. Dekker, New York, pp 1–35Google Scholar
- Burri PH (1999) Lung development and pulmonary angiogenesis. In: Gaultier C, Bourbon J, Post M (eds) Lung disease. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 122–151Google Scholar
- Burri PH, Weibel ER (1977) Ultrastructure and morphometry of the developing lung. In: Hodson WA (ed) Development of the lung. Lung biology in health and disease. M. Dekker, New York, pp 215–268Google Scholar
- Djonov V, Burri PH (2006) Vascular development: vasculogenesis and angiogenesis. In: Shepro D (ed) Microvascular research: biology and pathology. Elsevier, Philadelphia, pp 91–96Google Scholar
- Dubreuil G, Lacoste A, Raymond R (1936) Observations sur le développement du poumon humain. Bull Histol Tech Microsc 13:235–245Google Scholar
- Morrisey EE, Cardoso WV, Lane RH, Rabinovitch M, Abman SH, Ai X, Albertine KH, Bland RD, Chapman HA, Checkley W, Epstein JA, Kintner CR, Kumar M, Minoo P, Mariani TJ, McDonald DM, Mukouyama YS, Prince LS, Reese J, Rossant J, Shi W, Sun X, Werb Z, Whitsett JA, Gail D, Blaisdell CJ, Lin QS (2013) Molecular determinants of lung development. Ann Am Thorac Soc 10:S12–S16PubMedPubMedCentralCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Narayanan M, Owers-Bradley J, Beardsmore CS, Mada M, Ball I, Garipov R, Panesar KS, Kuehni CE, Spycher BD, Williams SE, Silverman M (2012) Alveolarization continues during childhood and adolescence: new evidence from helium-3 magnetic resonance. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 185:186–191PubMedPubMedCentralCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Netter FH (2014) Atlas of human anatomy. Saunders Elsevier, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
- Nolen-Walston RD, Kim CF, Mazan MR, Ingenito EP, Gruntman AM, Tsai L, Boston R, Woolfenden AE, Jacks T, Hoffman AM (2008) Cellular kinetics and modeling of bronchioalveolar stem cell response during lung regeneration. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 294:L1158–L1165PubMedPubMedCentralCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Rogelj S, Klagsbrun M, Atzmon R, Kurokawa M, Haimovitz A, Fuks Z, Vlodavsky I (1989) Basic fibroblast growth-factor is an extracellular-matrix component required for supporting the proliferation of vascular endothelial-cells and the differentiation of Pc12 cells. J Cell Biol 109:823–831PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Roth-Kleiner M, Berger TM, Gremlich S, Tschanz SA, Mund SI, Post M, Stampanoni M, Schittny JC (2014) Neonatal steroids induce a down-regulation of tenascin-C and elastin and cause a deceleration of the first phase and an acceleration of the second phase of lung alveolarization. Histochem Cell Biol 141:75–84PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Sadler TW (2014) Langman’s medical embryology. Lippincott Williams & Wilki, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
- Schittny JC (2014) Strukturelle Entwicklung – von der Anlage zur adulten Lunge Mutius In: von Mutius E, Gappa M, Ebner E, Frey U (eds) Pädiatrische Pneumologie. Springer, Berlin (in press)Google Scholar
- Schittny JC, Burri PH (2008) Development and growth of the lung. In: Fishman AP, Elias JA, Fishman JA, Grippi MA, Kaiser LR, Senior RM (eds) Fishman’s pulmonary diseases and disorders, vol 1. McGraw-Hill, New-York, pp 91–114Google Scholar
- Schittny JC, Mund SI (2008) A re-examination of the maturation of the alveolar septa revealed that microvascular maturation takes place in parallel to alveolarization. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 177:A317Google Scholar
- Schoenwolf GC, Bleyl SB, Brauer PR, Francis-West PH, Philippa H (2015) Larsen’s human embryology. Churchill Livingstone, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Stampanoni M, Reichold J, Weber B, Haberthur D, Schittny J, Eller J, Buchi FN, Marone F (2010) Deciphering complex, functional structures with synchrotron-based absorption and phase contrast tomographic microscopy. Developments in X-Ray Tomography Vii 7804:78040LGoogle Scholar
- Vasilescu DM, Gao ZY, Saha PK, Yin LL, Wang G, Haefeli-Bleuer B, Ochs M, Weibel ER, Hoffman EA (2012) Assessment of morphometry of pulmonary acini in mouse lungs by nondestructive imaging using multiscale microcomputed tomography. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 109:17105–17110PubMedPubMedCentralCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Wilson JM, DiFiore JW, Peters CA (1993) Experimental fetal tracheal ligation prevents the pulmonary hypoplasia associated with fetal nephrectomy: possible application for congenital diaphragmatic hernia. J Pediatr Surg 28:1433–1440Google Scholar
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.