OeFAD8, OeLIP and OeOSM expression and activity in cold-acclimation of Olea europaea, a perennial dicot without winter-dormancy
- 1.4k Downloads
Cold-acclimation genes in woody dicots without winter-dormancy, e.g., olive-tree, need investigation. Positive relationships between OeFAD8, OeOSM , and OeLIP19 and olive-tree cold-acclimation exist, and couple with increased lipid unsaturation and cutinisation.
Olive-tree is a woody species with no winter-dormancy and low frost-tolerance. However, cold-tolerant genotypes were empirically selected, highlighting that cold-acclimation might be acquired. Proteins needed for olive-tree cold-acclimation are unknown, even if roles for osmotin (OeOSM) as leaf cryoprotectant, and seed lipid-transfer protein for endosperm cutinisation under cold, were demonstrated. In other species, FAD8, coding a desaturase producing α-linolenic acid, is activated by temperature-lowering, concomitantly with bZIP-LIP19 genes. The research was focussed on finding OeLIP19 gene(s) in olive-tree genome, and analyze it/their expression, and that of OeFAD8 and OeOSM, in drupes and leaves under different cold-conditions/developmental stages/genotypes, in comparison with changes in unsaturated lipids and cell wall cutinisation. Cold-induced cytosolic calcium transients always occurred in leaves/drupes of some genotypes, e.g., Moraiolo, but ceased in others, e.g., Canino, at specific drupe stages/cold-treatments, suggesting cold-acclimation acquisition only in the latter genotypes. Canino and Moraiolo were selected for further analyses. Cold-acclimation in Canino was confirmed by an electrolyte leakage from leaf/drupe membranes highly reduced in comparison with Moraiolo. Strong increases in fruit-epicarp/leaf-epidermis cutinisation characterized cold-acclimated Canino, and positively coupled with OeOSM expression, and immunolocalization of the coded protein. OeFAD8 expression increased with cold-acclimation, as the production of α-linolenic acid, and related compounds. An OeLIP19 gene was isolated. Its levels changed with a trend similar to OeFAD8. All together, results sustain a positive relationship between OeFAD8, OeOSM and OeLIP19 expression in olive-tree cold-acclimation. The parallel changes in unsaturated lipids and cutinisation concur to suggest orchestrated roles of the coded proteins in the process.
KeywordsCuticle Fatty acid desaturase (FAD8) Linolenic acid LIP transcription factor Lipidome Osmotin
Fatty acid desaturases
Free fatty acid
Weeks after flowering
Some plants are able to tolerate near zero/subzero temperatures by the process known cold-acclimation, acquired by exposure to progressively lower, non-freezing, temperatures up to the acquisition of a freezing tolerance (Browse and Xin 2001). Acclimation acquisition is genotype-dependent (Sun et al. 2009). How plants sense low temperatures and decode this message into transcriptome changes leading to acclimation still remains a widely unresolved question (Knight and Knight 2012). A lot of genes have been found to be active in cold-acclimation of herbaceous plants, e.g. Arabidopsis and winter cereals (Chinnusamy et al. 2010, and references therein), whereas knowledge about genes active in woody plants is much more limited. Moreover, in woody perennials, cold acclimation is generally coupled with endo-dormancy acquisition, and deciduousness, with these processes, possibly sharing gene activity, and together causing tree survival in winter under prolonged subzero temperatures (Welling and Palva 2006). However, there are also trees, which are evergreen, lack winter-dormancy, but remain able to cold acclimate (Arora et al. 1992). The molecular induction/regulation of cold-acclimation in such perennial plants is widely unknown, and particularly in fruiting dicots. Olive tree is a woody dicot of the Mediterranean Basin without winter-dormancy, and with economic value for the oil of its drupe. The areas of the Mediterranean Basin account for more than 90 % of the world olive oil production (Hatzopoulos et al. 2002), however cultivation is progressively extending to countries uncharacterized by the Mediterranean climate, where the trees have to survive to colder winters (Matteucci et al. 2011, and references therein). Olive tree is a cultigen complex (Green 2002), composed of genotypes retaining genetic characteristics over hundreds/thousands of years, because a vegetative propagation applied over centuries (Hatzopoulos et al. 2002). It is a species maintaining the leaves all over the year, and the drupes for months during fall/early winter. Olive tree exhibits a general low cold-tolerance with serious problems for survival below −12 °C (D’Angeli et al. 2003, and references therein). However, in colder regions of its distribution area, there are genotypes, empirically selected, which produce a better oil because an increased formation of ω3 and ω6 unsaturated fatty acids (FAs) in the drupe (Matteucci et al. 2011). Leccino, Canino and Picual are among the genotypes traditionally known as cold-tolerant, Frantoio has been reported to be semi-tolerant, and Moraiolo and Taggiasca cold-sensitive (D’Angeli et al. 2003; de la O Leyva-Pérez et al. 2015), however, the genetic base of their cold-resistance differences are still widely unknown.
Transient increases in cytosolic calcium ([Ca2+]cyt) are among the early responses to low temperatures, ceasing when cold acclimation is acquired (Knight and Knight 2012). In accordance, exogenously applied calcium chelators inhibit acclimation, whereas calcium ionophores induce it at higher temperatures, as in alfalfa (Monroy and Dhindsa 1995). Because [Ca2+]cyt transients mainly occur by apoplastic calcium influx, the protoplasts are more suitable than the whole cells for their monitoring, being devoid of calcium rich cell walls, and similarly viable (Monroy and Dhindsa 1995, and references therein; D’Angeli et al. 2003, and references therein). Moreover, the cold-shock-induced [Ca2+]cyt response by protoplasts is representative of the whole plant, as shown in Nicotiana plumbaginifolia by comparing leaf protoplasts with plants constitutively expressing the recombinant calcium indicator aequorin which produces a luminescence directly related to [Ca2+]cyt (Mazars et al. 1997). Cold-induced changes in [Ca2+]cyt have been also found in olive tree leaf and drupe protoplasts from numerous genotypes (D’Angeli et al. 2003; D’Angeli and Altamura 2007; Matteucci et al. 2011).
The cuticle provides a protective hydrophobic coating for aerial plant organs and plays a pivotal role during plant interaction with the environment, with dynamic qualitative and quantitative changes (Borisjuk et al. 2014; Martin and Rose 2014). Water deficit has been reported to trigger an increase in cuticular thickness as an adaptation response to summer drought, e.g. in numerous species of the Mediterranean region, including olive tree (Bacelar et al. 2004). Moreover, in many broad-leaf evergreens, the formation of a thick cuticle also occurs as protection to the cold-induced winter drought (Goodwin and Jenks 2005). Cutin, its major component, prevalently consists of hydroxyl-FAs, derived by C16- and C18-FAs and glycerol-molecules (Borisjuk et al. 2014). Fruit and leaf cuticles generally contain the same classes of compounds, however, genotype-specific changes may occur during the stress responses, e.g., in olive tree genotypes in response to drought and pathogens (Bacelar et al. 2004; Gomes et al. 2012). By [Ca2+]cyt-signalling investigations in cold-shocked protoplasts, and overexpression/immuno-localization studies, the tobacco PR-5 protein osmotin was proposed as cryoprotectant for olive-tree leaves because its over-expression blocked cold-induced [Ca2+]cyt-transients in non-cold-acclimated protoplasts (D’Angeli and Altamura 2007). An osmotin-like protein with cryoprotective activity has been also found in Solanum dulcamara leaves, and a role in freezing tolerance has been suggested (Newton and Duman 2000), although the mechanism of action not yet determined. An osmotin, associated with cuticle biogenesis, is active in tomato fruit (Yeats et al. 2010), and an olive tree osmotin (OeOSM) has been found to be active in olive tree seed (D’Angeli et al. 2013). In the latter, oleic (C18:1) and linoleic (C18:2) FAs, produced by specific FA-desaturases (FADs), are components of the endosperm-cuticle, which increases under temperature-lowering, and OeOSM is involved in the lipid-trafficking necessary for this thickening (D’Angeli et al. 2013). Taken together, there is the possibility that OeOSM is involved in the cold-acclimation of olive tree leaves/drupes through a role on cutinisation, possibly also requiring specific FAD(s) activity(ies).
FAD-activity is also required for the membrane restructuring related to cold-acclimation, because increased desaturation of glycerolipids serves as compensation to cold-caused decrease in membrane fluidity (Szymanski et al. 2014). In olive tree, numerous OeFAD genes are expressed in the drupe during the oil production phase, ceasing in expression at the end of this phase, and, among them, OeFAD2.2, and OeFAD7 show an increased expression in response to cold (Matteucci et al. 2011), but are not related with cold acclimation. In fact, these genes, coding FADs for the conversion of C18:1 into C18:2, and C18:2 into C18:3 (α-linolenic acid), respectively, are active in leaves of the cold-tolerant Picual during early cold-exposure, but down-regulated under long lasting cold-exposure (de la O Leyva-Pérez et al. 2015). The same genes are up-regulated in cold-stressed drupes of both Canino and Moraiolo, but always transiently (Matteucci et al. 2011). In Arabidopsis two ω3-FAD genes, i.e., AtFAD7 and AtFAD8, encode two ω3-FAD plastidial isozymes which are the major contributors of C18:3 in the leaves (McConn et al. 1994). Despite a high degree of structural relatedness, the activities of the two isozymes are regulated differentially by temperature, with AtFAD8 induced by the low temperatures (Matsuda et al. 2005 and references therein). Increases in 18:3/18:2 ratio in leaves/fruits have been associated with an enhanced cold-tolerance also in tomato (Domínguez et al. 2010), and in other plants, e.g. rice, FAD8 transcript levels rise under low temperatures (Wang et al. 2006). An OeFAD8 gene has been found in olive tree (Poghosyan et al. 1999; Matteucci et al. 2011), but it is expressed only in traces during the oleogenic phase of the drupe (Matteucci et al. 2011). However, this does not exclude that it may be specifically active during olive tree cold-acclimation.
Low-temperature-induction is a feature of the LIP19 (Low-Temperature Induced Protein) subfamily members of the basic–domain leucine zipper (bZIP) transcription factors (TFs; Yang et al. 2001). A positive relationship between cold-induced [Ca2+]cyt-signalling and the expression of genes of the subfamily has been demonstrated (Berberich and Kusano 1997; Ito et al. 1999). In wheat, the expression of a LIP19 is higher in freezing-tolerant genotypes than in cold-sensitive ones, and the gene over-expression improves freezing-tolerance in tobacco (Kobayashi et al. 2008). Moreover, the expression under low temperatures of a LIP19 in maize increases concomitantly to that of ZmFAD8 (Berberich et al. 1998), suggesting a possible relationship between the two genes. No of LIP19 TFs has yet been identified in olive tree.
The present research aimed to find LIP19 gene(s) in olive-tree genome, and analyze it/their expression, and those of OeFAD8 and OeOSM, under different cold-conditions/drupe-developmental stages, in comparison with possible changes in unsaturated lipids and cell wall cutinisation, in drupes and leaves of genotypes traditionally known for a different cold-tolerance, with the goal of establishing whether and how these genes were involved in cold-acclimation.
Results showed that an OeLIP19 gene was present in olive tree genome, and that, together with OeFAD8 and OeOSM, was involved in cold-acclimation starting from its induction. Changes in unsaturated lipids and cutinisation paralleled the changes in the transcription of these genes, suggesting orchestrated roles of the coded proteins in the cold acclimation process.
Materials and methods
Plant growth conditions
Trees of Olea europaea L. cv. Canino, endemic of the volcanic areas of Northern Lazio, cv. Leccino from Northern Tuscany, cv. Frantoio from Southern Tuscany, cv. Moraiolo from Central Italy, and cv. Taggiasca from Ligury (Jacoboni and Fontanazza 1981) were grown in pots under the same conditions (i.e., standard sandy loam soil, daily irrigation) in the Botanical Garden of the Environmental Biology Department (Sapienza University, Rome, 41°53′33.5″ latitude North, 12°29′31″ longitude West, 20 meters above sea level). The trend of mean temperature-changing was similar in the years of the experiment (http://www.arsial.it/portalearsial/agrometeo). The experiments were planned in the way that each year 6-year-old specimens were used per genotype. Each year, the genotypes synchronously showed full blooming (last week of May), and drupe development during the weeks after flowering (WAFs).
In the first 2 years (2009–2010), specimens from all genotypes were used, whereas in the lasting 3 years (2011–2013) only those from cv. Canino, cv. Moraiolo and cv. Frantoio.
Cold treatments applied to the plant
Three trees per experiment coming from the open-air stocks of Canino and Moraiolo were put at specific WAFs in a plant growth-chamber XL15E (Labco, Milan, Italy), under 16 h/8 h (light/dark) photoperiod (300 μmol photons m−2 s−1), and exposed to cold-treatments of various intensity/duration. In detail, plants at the beginning of oleogenesis in the drupes, i.e. at WAF 10 (Matteucci et al. 2011), when the open-air temperature was 25 °C, were put in the growth-chamber at 6 °C either for 6 h (A1-type cold treatment), or for 24 h (A2-type cold treatment), or for 72 h (A3-type cold treatment). Alternatively, the plants were exposed at 0 °C for 2 h, and then at 10 °C for 14 days (B-type cold treatment). The controls were kept at 25 °C. In some cases A3-type cold treatment was also applied at WAF19 (end of oleogenesis in the drupes, Matteucci et al. 2011).
Full winter plants (WAF26) were also put in the growth-chamber, and progressively exposed to a temperature decrease from 7 °C (open-air temperature) to −10 °C into 35 h, maintained at −10 °C for 2 h, and then exposed to a temperature increase up to 7 °C into other 35 h (C-type cold treatment). The controls were kept at 7 °C. WAF 26 was chosen because it was several weeks after the end of oleogenesis (Matteucci et al. 2011).
Protoplast isolation, viability, and fluorescence measurements
Protoplasts were obtained from leaves from the fourth apical node of the youngest twigs [i.e., those that had been elongated in the spring of the year of the experiment (twigs of the year according to D’Angeli et al. 2003)], and/or from drupes (epi-mesocarp), collected at specific WAFs, i.e. WAF10 (beginning of oleogenesis), WAF19 (end of oleogenesis), WAF22 (drupe maturation, Matteucci et al. 2011), and WAF26 (full winter). Protoplast isolation was performed at 22 °C room temperature both for specimens coming from open-air and for those exposed to cold-treatments of various intensity/duration. Cell viability after isolation was evaluated with fluorescein diacetate (values higher than 70 % in each genotype). The protoplasts were incubated in the same enzymatic solution of isolation. The variations in [Ca2+]cyt after cold-shocks of cooling rate (ΔT/Δt) (Plieth et al. 1999) of 10 °C/60 s starting from 22 °C were detected incubating the protoplasts with Calcium-Crimson-AM fluorochrome (5 μM, Invitrogen, Italy). The fluorescence signal was evaluated by means of a Zeiss Axiolab (Carl Zeiss, Italy) epifluorescent microscope equipped with a DFC350F (Leica Microsystems, Italy) cooled camera, quantified with an Optilab 2.6 software (Graftek, Mirmande, France), and expressed as average pixel intensity (D’Angeli et al. 2003). Two technical replicates per year and genotype were carried out (data from the first replicate of the second year shown).
Electrolyte leakage procedure
Electrolyte leakage test is a means to assess the extent of plant injury in relation to low temperature exposure. Electrolyte diffusion from cells increases when membranes are damaged, and is reduced in the presence of cold acclimation (Lindén et al. 2000; Rohde et al. 2004). The samples are frozen and then thawed, and the electrolyte (ion) leakage in the bathing solution measured. The freeze–thaw damage is quantified as the mean percentage of the conductivity of the bathing solution relative to the conductivity of the solution after releasing all electrolytes from membranes by boiling (Rohde et al. 2004, and other references therein). Briefly, three WAF10-plants per olive tree genotype (Canino and Moraiolo) were exposed to either A3-type or B-type cold treatment, and other three plants maintained under the open-air temperature of the WAF (control plants). Other three WAF19-plants per genotype, coming from the open air stocks, were used for the test. Discs (5-mm-in-diameter) were excised from the leaf lamina and the drupe epi-mesocarp, and one gram/fresh weight per organ type was frozen at a rate of 2 °C/h up to −10 °C, and maintained at −10 °C for 30 min (Rohde et al. 2004). The frozen samples were then slowly thawed on ice. Parallel samples were kept on ice as unfrozen controls. All samples were then immersed in distilled water and placed on a shaker for either 24 or 16 h (Rohde et al. 2004) at 4 °C under darkness. Electrolyte leakage was determined at room temperature (22 °C) using an HI 8333 conductivity meter (Hanna Instruments), and expressed as mean percentage (±SE) of conductivity of the bathing solution before boiling relative to the after-boiling conductivity of the same solution. Because no difference in ion leakage percentage was present between shaking at 24 and 16 h, the three technical replicates for experiment here reported were carried out with a 16 h shaking.
Lipid detection, histological staining, and OeOSM immunolocalization
Five samples of epi-mesocarp and leaves per genotype (Canino and Moraiolo) were selected randomly at WAF19, and 50 mg/dry weight (DW) of each sample extracted. The samples were split in two aliquots. One aliquot was used for quantitative analysis of oxylipins by LC–MS/MS, as reported by Ludovici et al. (2014), and the other one for the quantification of α-linolenic acid [C18:3 (n-3)] as free FA (FFA), and FA bound in triacylglycerol (TAG) and polar lipid (PL) fractions by GC-FID analysis, according to D’Angeli et al. (2013) (data from two independent determinations per year and genotype, results of the third year shown).
Ten drupes and leaves per year and genotype (Canino, Moraiolo, and Frantoio) were randomly collected at WAF19 and WAF22, hand-cut, and oil bodies and cutin detected by SUDAN IV staining. Epi-mesocarp and leaf samples were either fixed, dehydrated, embedded, sectioned, and stained with toluidine blue, or attached on a scanning electron microscopy stub, and treated as in Matteucci et al. (2011). Moreover, OeOSM immuno-localization was carried out in resin embedded leaf and drupe samples according to D’Angeli and Altamura (2007), and the absence of staining verified in the controls treated without the primary antibodies (data not shown). Images were acquired as in Matteucci et al. (2011). Two technical replicates per year were carried out, data from the first one of the third year shown.
RNA extraction, cDNA synthesis, real time PCR (qPCR), gene sequencing and alignment
Total RNA was isolated from ten drupes (epi-mesocarp) and leaves of Canino and Moraiolo, collected from specimens either grown under open-air, or exposed to A- to C-types of cold-treatments, as specified in the Results. Moreover, at WAF26 ten leaves per genotype were excised from open-air grown plants and incubated in 5 μM solution of A23187 calcium ionophore (Sigma; D’Angeli et al. 2003) for 72 h before RNA extraction.
Primer sequences used for qPCR and sequencing (OeLIP) analyses in leaves and drupes of Canino and Moraiolo
Forward primer sequence
Reverse primer sequence
FAD3 (HQ DQ788673)
Cry2 was used as housekeeping gene for qPCR based on the stability of its mRNA expression in different plant tissues and developmental stages, and in presence of temperature variations, in accordance with previously reported housekeeping gene selection in the same species (Table S2 in D’Angeli et al. 2013).
Three technical replicates for two independent experiments/year were carried out for all the analyses and expressed as means (±SE). Data from the third year shown.
A normality test was applied before analysis of variance (Instat 3, GraphPad, La Jolla, CA, USA), and one-way/two-way ANOVA (P < 0.05), followed by Tukey’s post test (Prism 6.0, GraphPad), used to compare mean values (±SE) of the same organ, either within the same genotype or between different genotypes. Alternatively, means (±SE) in pairs were compared by Student’s t test. Results were similar in all the crop years.
Cold-shock-induced cytosolic calcium response changes in parallel in leaves and drupes, and no change in cytosolic calcium, but a reduction in ion leakage from cell membranes, occur in both organs when cold acclimation is reached
Cold-responsiveness was verified in leaves and drupes of open-air grown specimens of Canino, Leccino, Moraiolo, Frantoio, and Taggiasca genotypes at WAF10 and WAF19, i.e., at the beginning and end, respectively, of the oleogenesis, and related FAD activities, in the drupes (Matteucci et al. 2011), by monitoring [Ca2+]cyt-transients in their protoplasts under ΔT/Δt = 10 °C/60 s cold-shocks (D’Angeli et al. 2003, and “Materials and methods”).
Transient [Ca2+]cyt-rises were always present at WAF10, but remained present only in Frantoio, Taggiasca and Moraiolo at WAF19, showing that Canino and Leccino had acquired acclimation during this WAF-interval, whereas the other genotypes had remained cold-sensitive, as exemplified by Canino and Moraiolo in Fig. S1a–d. At WAF22, also leaves and drupes of Frantoio did not show any [Ca2+]cyt-rise after the same cold-shock (Fig. S1e), showing acclimation acquisition during the interval between WAF19 and WAF22, in accordance with previous results for the drupes (D’Angeli et al. 2013).
Based on these results, the following analyses were focussed on Canino and Moraiolo because representative of the cold responsiveness of the other genotypes, after having confirmed the acquisition (Canino), and the non-acquisition (Moraiolo) of cold acclimation at WAF19 by the application of the ion leakage test (see “Materials and methods”). In fact, the mean percentage of ion leakage was 68 % (±1) in the leaves, and 79 % (±0.1) in the drupes of Canino, and 86 % (±0.1) in the leaves, and 91 % (±0.2) in the drupes of Moraiolo. The statistical analysis of data showed that the leakage percentage from the leaves was significantly (P < 0.0001) lower than from the drupes in both genotypes, however it was significantly (P < 0.0001) reduced in Canino in comparison with Moraiolo independently of the organ.
To verify whether Moraiolo might become cold-acclimated later than WAF19, the cytosolic-calcium response induced by the cold-shock in the leaf protoplasts (the drupes were fallen from the tree) was evaluated at WAF26 (full winter) in the open-air grown specimens. Calcium rises continued to be present, sustaining that Moraiolo had remained cold-sensitive (Fig. S2c). When, at WAF26, the plants were exposed to a C-type cold treatment before protoplast isolation, the inability of Moraiolo to acquire cold-acclimation was confirmed, because its protoplasts still showed presence of [Ca2+]cyt-rises under cold-shocking [4.1 (±0.5) mean value, Fig. 1d)].
Cold-acclimation couples with increased epicarp/leaf cutinisation, and OeOSM expression/immunolocalization
Thickness (mean value in μm ± SE) at WAF19 of the cutinized outer cell wall of the epicarp and the adaxial leaf epidermis from the cold-sensitive Moraiolo and the cold-acclimated Canino
22.95 ± 0.76
30.1 ± 0.67***
Adaxial leaf epidermis
9.28 ± 0.3
20.66 ± 0.9***
As for drupes, at WAF19, cutinisation of the outer cell walls of adaxial leaf epidermis was significantly higher in Canino than Moraiolo (Table 2). All together results showed that even if a thicked cuticle as an adaptation response to summer drought in numerous species of the Mediterranean region, including olive tree (Bacelar et al. 2004), there was a further increase in both the aerial organs related to cold acclimation acquisition. However, thickening in the outer cell walls of adaxial leaf epidermis did not continue at WAF22 in any genotype.
The OBs were present in the cytoplasm of both epidermal and adjacent palisade cells (Fig. 2f, g), and micro-channel-like striations appeared in the inner cutinized outer cell wall of Canino, in particular (Fig. 2f). To exclude that the increase in thickening of the outer cell wall of Canino leaf/drupe was due to peculiarities of the genotype unrelated with the acquired cold-acclimation, the thickness of the outer cell wall was also measured in Frantoio, in the absence (WAF19) and presence (WAF22) of acclimation (Fig. S1e). Results confirmed that the increased cutinisation was related to acclimation independently of the genotype, but also showed that the thickness reached at acclimation was genotype-dependent. In fact, in comparison with Canino and Moraiolo at WAF19 (Table 2), in Frantoio, at the same WAF, the outer cell walls of the epicarps and adaxial leaf epidermides showed a thickness comparable to that of the non-acclimated Moraiolo (i.e., 20.5 ± 0.9 and 9.2 ± 0.2 μm, in the two organs, respectively), whereas at WAF22 values significantly (P < 0.0001) higher (i.e., 27 ± 0.2 and 16 ± 0.6 μm, in the two organs, respectively), even if statistically lower (P < 0.0001) than those of the WAF19-acclimated Canino.
Moreover, in Canino and Moraiolo, at WAF19, OeOSM was present within the cells of the leaf adaxial epidermis and upper palisade (Fig. 2h–j), and in the epi-mesocarp (Fig. 2k–l). The immuno-localization signal was also present in the inner cutinized outer cell wall (Fig. 2h–l, arrows), including the micro-channel-like striations, and with higher intensity in Canino than Moraiolo (Fig. 2h, j, arrowheads).
To verify whether OeOSM transcripts changed in leaves that had experienced long periods at low temperatures under open-air, an experiment was carried out at WAF26 using the Ca2+-ionophore A23187, because it causes [Ca2+]cyt-transients similarly to cold-shocks in the absence of acclimation (D’Angeli et al. 2003). OeOSM levels were similar in Canino, and always significantly (P < 0.0001) higher than in Moraiolo (Fig. 3b). In the latter, OeOSM expression was calcium-modulated, with progressive rises (P < 0.05 increases at 48 h in comparison with 0 h, P < 0.01 at 72 h in comparison with 48 h, Fig. 3b).
OeFAD8 transcript levels changed with cold differently in the presence and absence of cold-acclimation, as C18:3-lipids
Mean percentage distribution (±SE) of C18:3 in polar lipid (PL), free FA (FFA), and triacylglycerol (TAG) fractions in drupes (epi-mesocarp) and leaves of Canino and Moraiolo at WAF19
Mean % (±SE)
Mean % (±SE)
25.50 ± 0.36a
59.26 ± 0.6a
34.47 ± 0.49b
25.27 ± 0.26b
40.03 ± 0.57c
15.47 ± 0.16c
51.96 ± 0.85d
39.57 ± 0.57d
38.86 ± 0.64e
49.88 ± 0.71e
9.18 ± 0.12f
10.55 ± 0.15f
The presence of the oxylipin 13S-hydroxy-9Z,11E,15Z-octadecatrienoic acid (13-HoTre), a C18:3 oxidation-product, was also evaluated, because it is a stress-induced compound and a possible cutin component (Montillet et al. 2005; Blée et al. 2012). In Canino and Moraiolo, it was present in the drupes at not significantly different micromolar levels, i.e., 0.37 (±0.03) and 0.52 (±0.18), whereas at highly significantly (P < 0.0001) different levels in the leaves [2.24 (±0.2) and 25.75 (±0.33), respectively].
When the plants were exposed to A2-type cold-treatment at WAF10, i.e. at the time, and conditions, not causing cold-acclimation (Fig. S2b), a significant (P < 0.01) reduction in OeFAD8 transcripts occurred in the drupes of both genotypes (Fig. 4b).
When artificial acclimation was induced at WAF10 in Canino and not Moraiolo by the B-type cold treatment (Fig. 1c), in the drupes of the former, after a small, but significant (P < 0.05), increase in OeFAD8 levels at day 2 in comparison with day 0, there was a P < 0.0001 rise at day 7, but no further significant variation (Fig. 4c). By contrast, transcript levels transiently changed in Moraiolo drupes, with a highly significant (P < 0.0001) increase at day 2, a strong decrease at day 7 (up to day 0 value), and a new increase (P < 0.01) at the treatment-end (Fig. 4c). When the naturally (open air)-cold-acclimated WAF19-plants of Canino, and the same-aged, but cold-sensitive, plants of Moraiolo, were exposed to an A3-cold treatment, OeFAD8 levels were very low in Moraiolo, and many-fold higher (P < 0.01 differences with Moraiolo), and stable, in Canino (Fig. 4d).
The application of the Ca2+-ionophore to the leaves at WAF26 showed that OeFAD8 expression was calcium-modulated in Moraiolo, with strong rises in expression (P < 0.0001 increases at 48 and 72 h in comparison with 0 h), whereas it did not change significantly in Canino (Fig. 5c). The possibility that OeFAD7 and OeFAD3 might support OeFAD8 in sustaining leaf acclimation was investigated. However, no relationship of the two genes with cold acclimation was found, because OeFAD3 expression continued to be in traces, and OeFAD7 highly fluctuated also in Canino, and even when the plants experienced a C-type cold treatment (Fig. S5).
A LIP TF is present in olive-tree genome
The partial nucleotide sequence of OeLIP sequenced starting from Canino genotype
OeLIP (ID: KR360744)
OeLIP transcript levels change with cold in drupes and leaves, but differently in the presence and absence of acclimation, and with a trend similar to OeFAD8
When WAF10-plants were exposed to an A2-type cold-treatment, a P < 0.01 reduction in OeLIP transcripts occurred in the drupes of both genotypes in comparison with the control plants (Fig. 7b). A B-type cold treatment applied to the plants starting from WAF10 caused a P < 0.001 increase in OeLIP transcripts in Canino drupes at day 2, and constant values after (Fig. 7c). Conversely, highly significant (P < 0.0001) OeLIP levels were reached in Moraiolo at days 2–7, but were followed by a strong (P < 0.0001) decrease (day 14) (Fig. 7c). When the plants were exposed to an A3-type cold treatment at WAF19, OeLIP levels were quite negligible in Moraiolo, and many-fold higher, and constant, in Canino (Fig. 7d), similarly to OeFAD8 (Fig. 4d).
At WAF26, OeLIP transcripts in the leaves of both genotypes were many-fold lower than at WAF19 (Fig. 8a, b). However, when the plants were exposed to a C-type cold treatment, OeLIP mRNA remained constant in Canino, whereas fluctuated in Moraiolo (Fig. 8b). The ionophore application to the leaves showed that OeLIP expression was highly enhanced by calcium-influx in Moraiolo, with progressive rises, i.e., at 48 h (P < 0.001 difference with 0 h), and 72 h (P < 0.0001 difference with 0 h), whereas did not change significantly in Canino (Fig. 8c), with a response similar to that of OeFAD8 (Fig. 5c).
Cold-acclimation of olive tree leaves and drupes needs enhanced cell wall cutinisation, sustained by OeOSM and OeFAD8 activities
Cuticle is a hydrophobic barrier formed in response to various stresses, with water deficit triggering an increase in cuticular thickness as an adaptation response to both heat- (summer) and cold- (winter) drought (Borisjuk et al. 2014). During the summer, olive tree, like other Mediterranean xerophytes, may be subjected to high air temperatures, high vapour pressure deficits, and limited water availability, but differences in cuticle thickening exist among its genotypes in response to this heat-caused drought-stress (Bacelar et al. 2004). Present data show that a positive relationship between increased cuticle thickening and cold acclimation exists in olive tree, because the aerial organs (leaves and drupes) of the cold-acclimated Canino, and Frantoio, showed a thicker cuticle than those of the cold-sensitive Moraiolo. This increased cutinisation may be interpreted as an adaptation of specific genotypes to strongly limit dehydration during winter by enhancing the resistance to water loss by the cuticle formed during summer. Cutin, i.e., the cuticle polymer matrix, consists of monomers assembled intracellularly, with larger oligomers (cutinsomes, Heredia-Guerrero et al. 2008) requiring exocytosis of OBs outside the plasma membrane (Pollard et al. 2008). Exocytosis of OBs occurs in olive tree seeds (D’Angeli et al. 2013), and here is shown that it also occurs in the leaf epidermis and in fruit epicarp, with OB-flux also interesting innermost cell layers, in accordance with observations in other plants (Martin and Rose 2014). Lipotubuloids, participating with cutinsomes in cuticle formation through the activity of lipid-transfer proteins, have been described in Ornithogalum umbellatum fruit epidermis (Kwiatkowska et al. 2014). The micro-channel-like striations presently observed in the cutinized outer-cell-walls of olive-tree leaf epidermis/epicarp resemble these structures, and show OeOSM immuno-localization signal. Osmotin acts in cryoprotection and dehydration tolerance in numerous plants, and is involved in the extracellular export of cutinsomes in olive tree seeds in response to cold (D’Angeli et al. 2013). Because its presence increased in Canino leaves/drupes at acclimation, a role for the protein, related to acclimation acquisition, by increasing the apoplastic translocation of cutinsomes is plausible. The maintenance of a high OeOSM transcription in the following WAFs in Canino, and not in Moraiolo, suggests that an elevated OeOSM activity might contribute to maintain high dehydration tolerance during acclimation persistence.
In the OBs of olive tree drupe, the TAGs are the main storage lipids (Salas et al. 2000). They too might participate to cutinisation, being involved in the formation of hydroxyl-FAs, as occurs in Arabidopsis (Rani et al. 2010). Present results show that C18:3 levels were high in the TAGs of Canino drupes at WAF19. It is possible that they were needed to sustain the increasing epicarp cutinisation of the following WAFs, necessary to maintain cold-hardiness in these fruits which remain on the tree for a long time. Conversely, in Moraiolo drupes, fated to fall rapidly, C18:3 was detected at low levels, but preferentially in the PLs. It is possible that, under open air, a short-term response to the temperature-lowering at this WAF (still above 0 °C) was activated by these drupes, and involve an enrichment in C18:3-PLs, as in the cold-short-term response of Arabidopsis (Burgos et al. 2011).
Canino showed the highest levels of C18:3 in the leaves, and in the C18:3-PLs, in particular. This suggests that the leaves, unable to further increase cutinisation, differently from the drupes, maintained cold adaptation by enhancing the fluidity of their membranes. In accordance, the electrolyte leakage test at WAF19, i.e., the WAF of acclimation under open-air, showed that the leaves of Canino exhibited a significantly reduced membrane damage in comparison with their drupes, and the leaves and drupes of Moraiolo. Similar changes in the membrane-lipidome in response to cold, causing enhanced cold resistance, have been reported also for Arabidopsis leaves (Routaboul et al. 2000). Moreover, in cowpea, a high C18:3-unsaturation characterizes the leaf membranes of a drought-tolerant cultivar, but not of a sensitive one (Torres-Franklin et al. 2009). This suggests, together with present data, a relationship between cold and drought long-term adaptation involving similar changes in the C18:3 of leaf membranes.
In the cold-sensitive leaves of Moraiolo free C18:3 increased significantly in comparison with the other fractions. It is possible that it was necessary for producing oxylipins via reactive oxygen species (ROS), known to be triggered by the cold stress (Prasad et al. 1994). In accordance, increased levels of the 13-HoTre oxylipin characterized these leaves. Moreover, Moraiolo leaves also showed reduced levels of OeOSM in comparison with the other genotype. These reduced levels might be involved in the ROS enhancement, and the reduced cold-defence of Moraiolo, because osmotin is known, among the other functions, to help in the accumulation of the osmolyte proline, which quenches ROS and free radicals (Kumar et al. 2015, and references therein).
In all cases, however, present data show that many-fold higher levels of C18:3 (all fractions) were present in Canino in comparison with Moraiolo, when acclimation occurred in the former and not in the latter (WAF19). Because the expression of the OeFAD genes, responsible with OeFAD8, of linoleic acid desaturation leading to C18:3 production, i.e., OeFAD3 and OeFAD7, was irrelevant at this time in both genotypes, and only OeFAD7 was present later, but with a genotype-independent fluctuating expression, results show that cold acclimation specifically couples with OeFAD8 expression/OeFAD8 activity in olive tree. In rice the same direct relationship between the low-temperature-dependent C18:3-changes and the transcriptional regulation of OsFAD has been suggested (Gopalakrishnan Nari et al. 2009).
Results showed that OeFAD8 exhibited lower levels during advanced acclimation in comparison with early acclimation, suggesting a lower necessity of OeFAD8-mediated C18:3 production to maintain acclimation during advanced winter. Conversely, in Moraiolo, OeFAD8 levels continued to be low and fluctuating, but increased in full-winter leaves under the calcium-ionophore-treatment. Because Ca2+-ionophores induce [Ca2+]cyt-transients similarly to cold-shocks in the absence of acclimation (D’Angeli et al. 2003, and references therein), it is possible that the gene was activated by calcium-transients for allowing a certain production of C18:3 as an attempt of inducing, at least, a short-term cold protection in the leaves of this genotype.
OeLIP is involved in olive tree cold acclimation
The LIP19 subfamily includes members that might be involved in cold acclimation (Kobayashi et al. 2008). These bZIP-TFs bind DNA sequences containing the ACGT motif, while the sequence flanking this core-region is quite variable according to nature of the target gene and the specificity of the factor involved in the regulation (Izawa et al. 1993; Kusano et al. 1995). Thus, members of the bZIP family have different (although often overlapping) binding site preferences, with the main group binding to the CACGTG (G-box) motif. However, there are bZIP-TFs, belonging to the subfamily, including LIP19 from rice and mlip15 from maize, that bind to a hybrid C-box/G-box motif (Martínez-García et al. 1998). Our results show that an OeLIP, exhibiting the typical features of b-ZIP proteins, and perfectly inserted in the genetic structure among the dicot LIP19 proteins, is present in olive tree genome and its expression is positively related with cold acclimation acquisition and maintenance. However, except the ACGT region, other peculiar nucleotide sequences (or the flanking regions of the ACGT motif) present on OeLIP-target genes, and that should be involved in the interactions with this TF during cold acclimation, remain to be determined. In Arabidopsis, the activation of Rab18, a Cor (cold-responsive)/Lea (Late embryogenesis abundant) gene, coding a dehydrin, is strongly associated to low-temperature stimuli and cold acclimation (Mäntylä et al. 1995). In olive tree, an OeRab18 gene has been identified in the seed, with its expression positively related to cold- and desiccation-tolerance (D’Angeli et al. 2013). For this gene, the possibility that the LIP protein may act as TF is high, and sustained by our preliminary results, which need confirmation by the completion of OeRab18 sequencing. However, in accordance with our hypothesis, an interaction of Wlip19 with wheat Cor/Lea gene promoters, including WRab18, has been demonstrated in common and winter wheat (Kobayashi et al. 2008; Sun et al. 2009).
Moreover, we presently show that OeLIP expression parallels that of OeFAD8 during acclimation. Also in maize, the expression profiles of ZmFAD8 and mlip15 (a LIP19 gene) were similar under prolonged cold-exposure (Berberich et al. 1998). An up-regulation by low temperatures was also reported for rdlip in radish (Ito et al. 1999), and low-temperature-induced levels of a lip19 were maintained stable in rice (Shimizu et al. 2005).
Again, as for OeFAD8, OeLIP levels increased in the full winter leaves of Moraiolo under the calcium-ionophore-treatment, sustaining that, in the absence of acclimation, both genes were activated by cytosolic calcium transients to alleviate prolonged cellular cold stress.
In Arabidopsis, the plasma-membrane-bound NTL6 TF integrates cold signals into plant defense responses, because after cold activation, its transcriptionally active form (NAC) is cleaved and goes to the nucleus to induce PR-5 genes (Seo et al. 2010). An OeNTL6 gene is induced by cold in olive tree seed, with its NAC inducing OeOSM, and OeOSM acting in lipid-trafficking for endosperm cutinisation (D’Angeli et al. 2013). An effect of NTL6 on early activating bZIP proteins to alleviate stress has been recently shown (Yang et al. 2014), and our preliminary results sustain that OeNTL6 activates not only OeOSM, but also OeLIP (Altamura et al. unpublished).
Author contribution statement
All Authors contributed to the writing of the manuscript and approved it.
We thank S. Errico and G. Perrotta of UTT Trisaia ENEA (Italy) for molecular biology support/suggestions to MM, and M. Reverberi and C. Fanelli of Sapienza University (Italy) for FA suggestions/discussion. Funding from Sapienza Grandi Attrezzature C26G13KJHK, C26G14XYEX and from Grandi Progetti C26H157ANK to MMA.
- Arora R, Wisniewski ME, Scorza R (1992) Cold acclimation in genetically related (sibling) deciduos and evergreen peach (Prunus persica L. Batsch). I. Seasonal changes in cold hardiness and polypeptides of bark and xylem tissues. Plant Physiol 99:1562–1568. doi: 10.1104/pp.99.4.1562 CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- de la O Leyva-Pérez M, Valverde-Corredor A, Valderrama R, Jiménez-Ruiz J, Muñioz-Merida A, Trelles O, Barroso JB, Mercado-Blanco J, Luque F (2015) Early and delayed long-term transcriptional changes and short-term transient responses during cold acclimation in olive leaves. DNA Res 22:1–11. doi: 10.1093/dnares/dsu033 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Domínguez T, Hernández M, Pennycooke J, Jiménez P, Martínez-Rivas J, Sanz C, Stockinger E, Sánchez-Serrano J, Sanmartín M (2010) Increasing ω-3 desaturase expression in tomato results in altered aroma profile and enhanced resistance to cold stress. Plant Physiol 153:655–665. doi: 10.1104/pp.110.154815 CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- Hatzopoulos P, Banilas G, Giannoulia K, Gazis F, Nikoloudakis N, Milioni D, Haralampidis K (2002) Breeding, molecular markers and molecular biology of the olive tree. Eur J Lipid Sci Technol 104:574–586. doi: 10.1002/1438-9312(200210)104:9/10<574:AID-EJLT574>3.0.CO;2-1 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Jacoboni N, Fontanazza G (1981) Cultivar. In: Baldini E, Scaramuzzi F (eds) L’olivo. Reda, Roma, pp 9–52Google Scholar
- Kwiatkowska M, Wojtczak A, Poplońska K, Polit JT, Stępiński D, Domínguez E, Heredia A (2014) Cutinsomes and lipotubuloids appear to participate in cuticle formation in Ornithogalum umbellatum ovary epidermis: EM-immunogold research. Protoplasma 251:1151–1161. doi: 10.1007/s00709-014-0623-2 CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- Lindén L, Palonen P, Lindén M (2000) Relating freeze-induced electrolyte leakage measurements to lethal temperature in red raspberry. J Am Soc Hortic Sci 125:429–435Google Scholar
- Martínez-García JF, Moyano E, Alcocer MJC, Martin C (1998) Two bZIP proteins from Antirrhinum flowers preferentially bind a hybrid C-box/G-box motif and help to define a new sub-family of bZIP transcription factors. Plant J 13:489–505. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-313X.1998.00050.x CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Matteucci M, D’Angeli S, Errico S, Lamanna R, Perrotta G, Altamura MM (2011) Cold affects the transcription of fatty acid desaturases and oil quality in the fruit of Olea europaea L. genotypes with different cold hardiness. J Exp Bot 62:3403–3420. doi: 10.1093/jxb/err013 CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- Montillet J-L, Chamnongpol S, Rustérucci C, Dat J, van de Cotte B, Agnel J-P, Battesti C, Inzé D, Van Breusegem F, Triantaphylidès C (2005) Fatty acid hydroperoxides and H2O2 in the execution of hypersensitive cell death in tobacco leaves. Plant Physiol 138:1516–1526. doi: 10.1104/pp.105.059907 CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- Rani SH, Krishna THA, Saha S, Negi AS, Rajasekharan R (2010) Defective in cuticular ridges (DCR) of Arabidopsis thaliana, a gene associated with surface cutin formation, encodes a soluble diacylglycerol acyltransferase. J Biol Chem 285:38337–38347. doi: 10.1074/jbc.M110.133116 CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- Rohde P, Hicha DK, Heyer AG (2004) Heterosis in the freezing tolerance of crosses between two Arabidopsis thaliana accessions (Columbia-0 and C24) that show differences in non-acclimated and acclimated freezing tolerance. Plant J 38:790–799. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-313X.2004.02080.x CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Torres-Franklin M-L, Repellin A, Huynh V-B, d’Arcy-Lameta A, Zuily-Fodil Y, Pham-Thi A-T (2009) Omega-3 fatty acid desaturase (FAD3, FAD7, FAD8) gene expression and linolenic acid content in cowpea leaves submitted to drought and after rehydration. Environ Exp Bot 65:162–169. doi: 10.1016/j.envexpbot.2008.12.010 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Yang S, Berberich T, Sano H, Kusano T (2001) Specific association of transcripts of tbzF and tbz17, tobacco genes encoding basic region leucine zipper-type transcriptional activators, with guard cells of senescing leaves and/or flowers. Plant Physiol 127:23–32. doi: 10.1104/pp.127.1.23 CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.