The Brückner test: extended distance improves sensitivity for ametropia
- 203 Downloads
The Brückner test is usually performed at a distance of 1 m. Due to optical reasons, the test should detect ametropia more sensitively at an extended distance. We compared the sensitivity of the test to detect unilateral ametropia at a distance of 4 m versus the traditional distance of 1 m.
Patients and methods
In this study, five blinded experienced observers (experts) performed the Brückner transillumination test on five emmetropic subjects (age 22.3 +/− 2.3 years) at a distance of 1 m which was then extended up to 4 m. Unilateral ametropia was simulated by both spherical and cylindrical lenses of −1, −2, −3, −4, and +1, +2, +3, +4 diopters in front of one eye and a plano lens in front of the other eye in a randomised order. Controls with plano lenses in front of both eyes were interspersed. The test was considered positive in case of any difference between the red reflexes of both eyes. For spherical ametropia, the procedure was repeated with 25 medical students who examined one subject each.
At a distance of 1 m, unilateral myopia/hypermetropia of more than 1 diopter was detected in 78.7%/71.3% by experts and in 34.7%/53.3% by students. At 4 m, detection rates increased to 99.3%/96.0% and 98.7%/100% respectively. Rates of false positive findings for experts vs students were 3.1% vs 1.5% at 1 m and 4.0% vs 3.0% at 4 m. For unilateral astigmatism, experts’ detection rates were similar at 1 m (64.7%/70.0%) and lower at 4 m (91.7%/90.3%), depending on the astigmatism axis.
The sensitivity of the Brückner reflex for anisometropia improves by extension of the examination distance, especially in the hands of less experienced observers. To detect ametropia more sensitively, a test distance of 4 m is recommended.
KeywordsAmblyopia Anisometropia Brückner test Vision screening
- 3.Tychsen L (1992) Binocular vision. In: Hart WM Jr (ed) Adler’s physiology of the eye: clinical application. Mosby Yearbook, St Louis, pp 837–838Google Scholar
- 5.Coats D, Jenkins R (1997) Vision assessment of the pediatric patient. Refinements, American Academy of Ophthalmology 1:1Google Scholar
- 12.Archer SM (1988) Developmental aspects of the Brückner test. Ophthalmology 95:1096–1101Google Scholar
- 13.Roe LD, Guyton DL (1984) The light that leaks: Brückner and the red reflex. Surv Ophthalmol 28:655–670Google Scholar
- 14.von Noorden GK, Campos EC (2002) Binocular vision and ocular motility. Mosby, St Louis, p 187Google Scholar
- 15.Hald A (1952) Statistical theory with engineering applications. Wiley, LondonGoogle Scholar