Advertisement

Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology

, Volume 164, Issue 1, pp 177–183 | Cite as

Oxygen isotope heterogeneity of the mantle beneath the Canary Islands: a discussion of the paper of Gurenko et al.

  • James M. D. DayEmail author
  • Colin G. Macpherson
  • David Lowry
  • D. Graham Pearson
Discussion

Abstract

Gurenko et al. (Contrib Mineral Petrol 162:349–363, 2011) report laser-assisted fluorination (LF) and secondary ionization mass spectrometry (SIMS) 18O/16O datasets for olivine grains from the Canary Islands of Gran Canaria, Tenerife, La Gomera, La Palma and El Hierro. As with prior studies of oxygen isotopes in Canary Island lavas (e.g. Thirlwall et al. Chem Geol 135:233–262, 1997; Day et al. Geology 37:555–558, 2009, Geochim Cosmochim Acta 74:6565–6589, 2010), these authors find variations in δ18Ool (~4.6–6.0 ‰) beyond that measured for mantle peridotite olivine (Mattey et al. Earth Planet Sci Lett 128:231–241, 1994) and interpret this variation to reflect contributions from pyroxenite-peridotite mantle sources. Furthermore, Gurenko et al. (Contrib Mineral Petrol 162:349–363, 2011) speculate that δ18Ool values for La Palma olivine grains measured by LF (Day et al. Geology 37:555–558, 2009, Geochim Cosmochim Acta 74:6565–6589, 2010) may be biased to low values due to the presence of altered silicate, possibly serpentine. The range in δ18Ool values for Canary Island lavas are of importance for constraining their origin. Gurenko et al. (Contrib Mineral Petrol 162:349–363, 2011) took a subset (39 SIMS analyses from 13 grains from a single El Hierro lava; EH4) of a more extensive dataset (321 SIMS analyses from 110 grains from 16 Canary Island lavas) to suggest that δ18Ool is weakly correlated (R 2 = 0.291) with the parameter used by Gurenko et al. (Earth Planet Sci Lett 277:514–524, 2009) to describe the estimated weight fraction of pyroxenite-derived melt (Xpx). With this relationship, end-member δ18O values for HIMU-peridotite (δ18O = 5.3 ± 0.3 ‰) and depleted pyroxenite (δ18O = 5.9 ± 0.3 ‰) were defined. Although the model proposed by Gurenko et al. (Contrib Mineral Petrol 162:349–363, 2011) implicates similar pyroxenite-peridotite mantle sources to those proposed by Day et al. (Geology 37:555–558, 2009, Geochim Cosmochim Acta 74:6565–6589, 2010) and Day and Hilton (Earth Planet Sci Lett 305:226–234, 2011), there are significant differences in the predicted δ18O values of end member components in the two models. In particular, Day et al. (Geochim Cosmochim Acta 74:6565–6589, 2010) proposed a mantle source for La Palma lavas with low-δ18O (<5 ‰), rather than higher-δ18O (c.f. the HIMU-peridotite composition of Gurenko et al. in Contrib Mineral Petrol 162:349–363, 2011). Here we question the approach of using weakly correlated variations in δ18Ool and the Xpx parameter to define mantle source oxygen isotope compositions, and provide examples of why this approach appears flawed. We also provide reasons why the LF datasets previously published for Canary Island lavas remain robust and discuss why LF and SIMS data may provide complementary information on oxygen isotope variations in ocean island basalts (OIB), despite unresolved small-scale uncertainties associated with both techniques.

Keywords

Ocean island basalt Canary Islands Oxygen isotopes Laser fluorination SIMS Mantle heterogeneity 

Notes

Acknowledgments

This work was performed with support from the National Science Foundation (EAR-1116089) and The San Diego Foundation (C-2011-00204). We thank C. Harris, two anonymous reviewers and Editor J. Hoefs for their constructive comments.

References

  1. Baker JA, Macpherson CG, Menzies MA, Thirlwall MF, Al-Kadasi M, Mattey DP (2000) Resolving crustal and mantle contributions to continental flood volcanism, Yemen; constraints from mineral oxygen isotope data. J Petrol 41:1805–1820CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Bindeman I, Gurenko A, Sigmarsson O, Chaussidon M (2008) Oxygen isotope heterogeneity and disequilibria of olivine crystals in large volume Holocene basalts from Iceland: evidence for magmatic digestion and erosion of Pleistocene hyaloclastites. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 72:4397–4420CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Day JMD, Hilton DR (2011) Origin of 3He/4He ratios in HIMU-type basalts constrained from Canary Island lavas. Earth Planet Sci Lett 305:226–234CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Day JMD, Pearson DG, Macpherson CG, Lowry D, Carracedo JC (2009) Pyroxenite-rich mantle formed by recycled oceanic lithosphere: oxygen-osmium isotope evidence from Canary Island lavas. Geology 37:555–558CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Day JMD, Pearson DG, Macpherson CG, Lowry D, Carracedo JC (2010) Evidence for distinct proportions of subducted oceanic crust and lithosphere in HIMU-type mantle beneath El Hierro and La Palma, Canary Islands. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 74:6565–6589CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Demény A, Cassillas R, Vennemann TW, Hegner E, Nagy G, Ahijado A, De La Nuez J, Sipos P, Pilet S, Milton J (2008) Plume-related stable isotope compositions and fluid–rock interaction processes in the Basal Complex of La Palma, Canary Islands, Spain. In: Coltorti M, Greogoire M (eds) Metasomatism in oceanic and continental lithospheric mantle. Special Publication vol 293, geological society, London, pp 155–175Google Scholar
  7. Eiler JM, Stolper E, McCanta MC (2011) Intra- and intercrystalline oxygen isotope variations in minerals from basalts and peridotites. J Petrol 52:1393–1413CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Goldich S (1938) A study of rock weathering. J Geol 46:17–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Gurenko AA, Sobolev AV, Hoernle KA, Hauff F, Schmincke H-U (2009) Enriched, HIMU-type peridotite and depleted recycled pyroxenite in the Canary plume: a mixed-up mantle. Earth Planet Sci Lett 277:514–524CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Gurenko AA, Bindeman IN, Chaussidon M (2011) Oxygen isotope heterogeneity of the mantle beneath the Canary Islands: insights from olivine phenocrysts. Contrib Mineral Petrol 162:349–363CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Hansteen TH, Troll VR (2003) Oxygen isotope composition of xenoliths from the oceanic crust and volcanic edifice beneath Gran Canaria (Canary Islands): consequences for crustal contamination of ascending magmas. Chem Geol 193:181–193CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Hausrath EM, Navarre-Sitchler AK, Sak PB, Steefel CI, Brantley SL (2008) Basalt weathering rates on Earth and the duration of liquid water on the plains of Gusev crater, Mars. Geology 36:67–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Hoernle K (1998) Geochemistry of Jurassic oceanic crust beneath Gran Canaria (Canary Islands): implications for crustal recycling and assimilation. J Petrol 39:859–880CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Hoernle K, Tilton G (1991) Sr–Nd–Pb isotope data for Fuerteventura (Canary Islands) basal complex and subaerial volcanics: application to magma genesis and evolution. Schweiz Mineral Petrogr Mitt 71:5–21Google Scholar
  15. Hoernle K, Tilton G, Schmincke H-U (1991) Sr–Nd–Pb isotopic evolution of Gran Canaria: evidence for shallow enriched mantle beneath the Canary Islands. Earth Planet Sci Lett 106:44–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Javoy M, Stillman CJ, Pineau F (1986) Oxygen and hydrogen isotope studies on the basal complexes of the Canary Islands: implications on the conditions of their genesis. Contrib Miner Petrol 92:225–235CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Kita NT, Ushikubo T, Fu B, Valley JW (2009) High precision SIMS oxygen isotope analysis and the effect of sample topography. Chem Geol 264:43–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Mattey D, Macpherson C (1993) High-precision oxygen isotope microanalysis of ferromagnesian minerals by laser-fluorination. Chem Geol 105:305–318CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Mattey D, Lowry D, Macpherson C (1994) Oxygen isotope composition of mantle peridotite. Earth Planet Sci Lett 128:231–241CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Pearson DG, Davies GR, Nixon PH, Greenwood PB, Mattey DP (1991) Oxygen isotope evidence for the origin of pyroxenites in the Beni Boussera peridotite massif, N. Morrocco: derivation from subducted oceanic lithosphere. Earth Planet Sci Lett 102:289–301CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Rumble D, Miller MF, Franchi IA, Greenwood RC (2007) Oxygen three-isotope fractionation lines in terrestrial silicate minerals: an inter-laboratory comparison of hydrothermal quartz and eclogitic garnet. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 71:3592–3600CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Sharp ZD (1990) A laser based microanalytical method for the in situ determination of oxygen isotope ratios of silicates and oxides. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 54:1353–1357CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Skelton ADL, Valley JW (2000) The relative timing of serpentinisation and mantle exhumation at the ocean-continent transition, Iberia: constraints from oxygen isotopes. Earth Planet Sci Lett 178:327–338CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Thirlwall MF, Jenkins C, Vroon PZ, Mattey DP (1997) Crustal interaction during construction of oceanic islands: Pb-Sr-Nd-O isotope geochemistry of the shield basalts of Gran Canaria, Canary Islands. Chem Geol 135:233–262CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Valley JW, Kitchen N, Kohn MJ, Neindorf CR, Spicuzza MJ (1995) UWG-2, a garnet standard for oxygen isotope ratios: strategies for high precision and accuracy with laser heating. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 59:5223–5231CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Wang Z, Eiler JM (2008) Insights into the origin of low-δ18O basaltic magmas in Hawaii revealed from in situ measurements of oxygen isotope compositions of olivines. Earth Planet Sci Lett 269:376–386 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Zheng Y-F (1993) Calculation of oxygen isotope fractionation in anhydrous silicate minerals. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 57:1079–1091CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag 2012

Authors and Affiliations

  • James M. D. Day
    • 1
    Email author
  • Colin G. Macpherson
    • 2
  • David Lowry
    • 3
  • D. Graham Pearson
    • 4
  1. 1.Geosciences Research DivisionScripps Institution of OceanographyLa JollaUSA
  2. 2.Department of Earth SciencesUniversity of DurhamDurhamUK
  3. 3.Department of Earth Sciences, Royal HollowayUniversity of LondonSurreyUK
  4. 4.Department of Earth and Atmospheric SciencesUniversity of AlbertaEdmontonCanada

Personalised recommendations