Fecal immunochemical tests (FITs) have been developed to address analytical problems inherent in the older guaiac-based fecal occult blood tests (g-FOBTs). Our aim was to compare the performance characteristics of one g-FOBT (Hemoccult II) and two FITs (the Hemoccult ICT and MagStream HemSp) relative to colonoscopy for the detection of colorectal cancer and significant precursor lesions. We also examined whether a 1-day collection strategy would negatively impact test diagnostic performance.
We used a prospective observational cohort design in a Canadian population eligible for screening. All participants received colonoscopy after performing the occult blood tests.
One thousand seventy-five individuals were enrolled (mean age 56.3 years, 53.8 % females). Using colonoscopy as the gold standard, the sensitivity for screen-relevant neoplasm was determined for Hemoccult II (7.2, 95 % CI: 1.1–13.4), Hemoccult ICT (23.2 %: 13.2–33.1), and MagStream HemSp using 67 μg/gram stool as the cut-off (23.2 %: 13.2–33.1). The Magstream HemSp, using a cut-off threshold of 30 μg/gram stool, had the lowest specificity at 87.6 % (85.4–89.6), while the Hemoccult II had the highest at 98.8 % (98.1–99.5). Single-day stool testing reduced the false-positive rates of all tests without significantly reducing the sensitivity.
We found that FITs have a significantly increased sensitivity but reduced specificity for screen-relevant neoplasm compared to g-FOBT using colonoscopy as the gold standard. Optimal threshold levels for hemoglobin detection depend on the desired trade off between sensitivity and false-positive rate. Single-day testing with an FIT may be an option to enhance population compliance with screening.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.
Buy single article
Instant unlimited access to the full article PDF.
Price includes VAT for USA
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
This is the net price. Taxes to be calculated in checkout.
Fecal occult blood tests
Fecal immunochemical tests
Guaiac-based occult blood tests
Hardcastle JD, Thomas WM, Chamberlain J, Pye G, Sheffield J, James PD, Balfour TW, Amar SS, Armitage NC, Moss SM (1989) Randomised, controlled trial of faecal occult blood screening for colorectal cancer. Results for first 107,349 subjects. Lancet 1:1160–1164
Faivre J, Dancourt V, Lejeune C, Tazi MA, Lamour J, Gerard D, Dassonville F, Bonithon-Kopp C (2004) Reduction in colorectal cancer mortality by fecal occult blood screening in a French controlled study. Gastroenterology 126:1674–1680
Mandel JS, Bond JH, Church TR, Snover DC, Bradley GM, Schuman LM, Ederer F (1993) Reducing mortality from colorectal cancer by screening for fecal occult blood. Minnesota Colon Cancer Control Study. N Engl J Med 328:1365–1371
Mandel JS, Church TR, Ederer F, Bond JH (1999) Colorectal cancer mortality: effectiveness of biennial screening for fecal occult blood. J Natl Canc Inst 91:434–437
Kronborg O, Fenger C, Olsen J, Jorgensen OD, Sondergaard O (1996) Randomised study of screening for colorectal cancer with faecal-occult-blood test. Lancet 348:1467–1471
Young GP, St John DJ, Winawer SJ, Rozen P (2002) Choice of fecal occult blood tests for colorectal cancer screening: recommendations based on performance characteristics in population studies: a WHO (World Health Organization) and OMED (World Organization for Digestive Endoscopy) report. Am J Gastroenterol 97:2499–2507
Allison JE, Tekawa IS, Ransom LJ, Adrain AL (1996) A comparison of fecal occult-blood tests for colorectal-cancer screening. N Engl J Med 334:155–159
Rozen P, Knaani J, Samuel Z (1997) Performance characteristics and comparison of two immunochemical and two guaiac fecal occult blood screening tests for colorectal neoplasia. Dig Dis Sci 42:2064–2071
Zappa M, Castiglione G, Paci E, Grazzini G, Rubeca T, Turco P, Crocetti E, Ciatto S (2001) Measuring interval cancers in population-based screening using different assays of fecal occult blood testing: the District of Florence experience. Int J Cancer 92:151–154
Hol L, Wilschut JA, van Ballegooijen M, van Vuuren AJ, van der Valk H, Reijerink JC, van der Togt AC, Kuipers EJ, Habbema JD, van Leerdam ME (2009) Screening for colorectal cancer: random comparison of guaiac and immunochemical faecal occult blood testing at different cut-off levels. Br J Cancer 100:1103–1110
Federici A, Giorgi Rossi P, Borgia P, Bartolozzi F, Farchi S, Gausticchi G (2005) The immunochemical faecal occult blood test leads to higher compliance than the guaiac for colorectal cancer screening programmes: a cluster randomized controlled trial. J Med Screen 12:83–88
Hughes K, Leggett B, Del Mar C, Croese J, Fairley S, Masson J, Aitken J, Clavarino A, Janda M, Stanton WR, Tong S, Newman B (2005) Guaiac versus immunochemical tests: faecal occult blood test screening for colorectal cancer in a rural community. Aust N Z J Public Health 29:358–364
Cole SR, Young GP, Esterman A, Cadd B, Morcom J (2003) A randomised trial of the impact of new faecal haemoglobin test technologies on population participation in screening for colorectal cancer. J Med Screen 10:117–122
Morikawa T, Kato J, Yamaji Y, Wada R, Mitsushima T, Shiratori Y (2005) A comparison of the immunochemical fecal occult blood test and total colonoscopy in the asymptomatic population. Gastroenterology 129:422–428
Beckman Coulter I (2003) Hemoccult II product instructions. In: Editor (ed)^(eds) Book Hemoccult II product instructions. Beckman Coulter, Inc., City, pp
Beckman Coulter I Hemoccult ICT. In: Editor (ed)^(eds) Book hemoccult ICT. Beckman Coulter, Inc., City, pp
Alonzo TA, Pepe MS, Moskowitz CS (2002) Sample size calculations for comparative studies of medical tests for detecting presence of disease. Stat Med 21:835–852
Hundt S, Haug U, Brenner H (2009) Comparative evaluation of immunochemical fecal occult blood tests for colorectal adenoma detection. Ann Intern Med 150:162–169
Levi Z, Rozen P, Hazazi R, Vilkin A, Waked A, Maoz E, Birkenfeld S, Leshno M, Niv Y (2007) A quantitative immunochemical fecal occult blood test for colorectal neoplasia. Ann Intern Med 146:244–255
Park DI, Ryu S, Kim YH, Lee SH, Lee CK, Eun CS, Han DS (2010) Comparison of guaiac-based and quantitative immunochemical fecal occult blood testing in a population at average risk undergoing colorectal cancer screening. Am J Gastroenterol 105:2017–2025
Rex DK, Johnson DA, Anderson JC, Schoenfeld PS, Burke CA, Inadomi JM (2009) American College of Gastroenterology guidelines for colorectal cancer screening 2009 [corrected]. Am J Gastroenterol 104:739–750
Rabeneck L, Rumble RB, Thompson F, Mills M, Oleschuk C, Whibley A, Messersmith H, Lewis N (2012) Fecal immunochemical tests compared with guaiac fecal occult blood tests for population-based colorectal cancer screening. Can J Gastroenterol 26:131–147
Levin B, Lieberman DA, McFarland B, Andrews KS, Brooks D, Bond J, Dash C, Giardiello FM, Glick S, Johnson D, Johnson CD, Levin TR, Pickhardt PJ, Rex DK, Smith RA, Thorson A, Winawer SJ (2008) Screening and surveillance for the early detection of colorectal cancer and adenomatous polyps, 2008: a joint guideline from the American Cancer Society, the US Multi-Society Task Force on Colorectal Cancer, and the American College of Radiology. Gastroenterology 134:1570–1595
Rozen P, Comaneshter D, Levi Z, Hazazi R, Vilkin A, Maoz E, Birkenfeld S, Niv Y (2010) Cumulative evaluation of a quantitative immunochemical fecal occult blood test to determine its optimal clinical use. Cancer 116:2115–2125
Taylor KL, Shelby R, Gelmann E, McGuire C (2004) Quality of life and trial adherence among participants in the prostate, lung, colorectal, and ovarian cancer screening trial. J Natl Canc Inst 96:1083–1094
Castiglione G, Zappa M, Grazzini G, Sani C, Mazzotta A, Mantellini P, Ciatto S (1997) Cost analysis in a population-based screening programme for colorectal cancer: comparison of immunochemical and guaiac faecal occult blood testing. J Med Screen 4:142–146
Fenton JJ, Elmore JG, Buist DS, Reid RJ, Tancredi DJ, Baldwin LM (2010) Longitudinal adherence with fecal occult blood test screening in community practice. Ann Fam Med 8:397–401
van Rossum LG, van Rijn AF, Laheij RJ, van Oijen MG, Fockens P, van Krieken HH, Verbeek AL, Jansen JB, Dekker E (2008) Random comparison of guaiac and immunochemical fecal occult blood tests for colorectal cancer in a screening population. Gastroenterology 135:82–90
Allison JE, Sakoda LC, Levin TR, Tucker JP, Tekawa IS, Cuff T, Pauly MP, Shlager L, Palitz AM, Zhao WK, Schwartz JS, Ransohoff DF, Selby JV (2007) Screening for colorectal neoplasms with new fecal occult blood tests: update on performance characteristics. J Natl Canc Inst 99:1462–1470
Haug U, Hundt S, Brenner H (2010) Quantitative immunochemical fecal occult blood testing for colorectal adenoma detection: evaluation in the target population of screening and comparison with qualitative tests. Am J Gastroenterol 105:682–690
Fraser CG, Allison JE, Halloran SP, Young GP (2012) A proposal to standardize reporting units for fecal immunochemical tests for hemoglobin. J Natl Cancer Inst E-pub ahead of print
The study was funded by the Capital Health Authority, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada. Beckman Coulter Inc, USA provided Hemoccult ICT collection cards and test devices. Fujirebio Inc, Japan provided the Magstream HT. Reagents and support were provided by Fujirebio Diagnostics Inc, USA. Grammatical revisions and manuscript formatting was performed by Joanne Simala-Grant and Kathleen Ismond (funding from Dr DC Sadowski, Academic Trust Account).
Conflict of interest
No conflicts relevant to the manuscript for all authors.
About this article
Cite this article
Wong, C.K.W., Fedorak, R.N., Prosser, C.I. et al. The sensitivity and specificity of guaiac and immunochemical fecal occult blood tests for the detection of advanced colonic adenomas and cancer. Int J Colorectal Dis 27, 1657–1664 (2012) doi:10.1007/s00384-012-1518-3
- Fecal occult blood tests
- Colon cancer screening
- Tumor markers
- Disease prevention