Extraordinary blowing snow transport events in East Antarctica
- 1.2k Downloads
In the convergence slope/coastal areas of Antarctica, a large fraction of snow is continuously eroded and exported by wind to the atmosphere and into the ocean. Snow transport observations from instruments and satellite images were acquired at the wind convergence zone of Terra Nova Bay (East Antarctica) throughout 2006 and 2007. Snow transport features are well-distinguished in satellite images and can extend vertically up to 200 m as first-order quantitatively estimated by driftometer sensor FlowCapt™. Maximum snow transportation occurs in the fall and winter seasons. Snow transportation (drift/blowing) was recorded for ~80% of the time, and 20% of time recorded, the flux is >10−2 kg m−2 s−1 with particle density increasing with height. Cumulative snow transportation is ~4 orders of magnitude higher than snow precipitation at the site. An increase in wind speed and transportation (~30%) was observed in 2007, which is in agreement with a reduction in observed snow accumulation. Extensive presence of ablation surface (blue ice and wind crust) upwind and downwind of the measurement site suggest that the combine processes of blowing snow sublimation and snow transport remove up to 50% of the precipitation in the coastal and slope convergence area. These phenomena represent a major negative effect on the snow accumulation, and they are not sufficiently taken into account in studies of surface mass balance. The observed wind-driven ablation explains the inconsistency between atmospheric model precipitation and measured snow accumulation value.
KeywordsSurface mass balance Blowing snow Climate impact Snow transport Katabatic wind East Antarctica
The extreme environmental conditions and remote location of Antarctica have long inhibited the systematic study of its climate and snow accumulation processes. Measurement of blowing snow in Antarctica is very difficult and limited, and data are only available for a few sites (e.g., Mann et al. 2000; Nishimura and Nemoto 2005). Atmospheric models estimate that the horizontal divergence of snow by wind transport is of minor significance for integrated ice sheet SMB because the model simulations assume that katabatic winds tend to remove mass from the interior regions of the continent and displace it to coastal/convergence areas (Déry and Yau 2002; van den Broeke et al. 2006). Moreover, the blowing snow process and direct export into the ocean are not explicitly included in numerical weather forecasting and general circulation models (Gallée et al. 2001; Genthon and Krinner 2001; Krinner et al. 2007; van den Broeke et al. 2006).
In this study, field measurements are integrated with satellite image analysis to make the first-order quantitative estimation of blown snow exported to the atmosphere and ocean in a slope/coastal katabatic wind convergence area, the Terra Nova Bay (East Antarctica).
2 Site characteristics and instruments
The Larsen Glacier (Fig. 1; 74°57′S, 161°46′E; about 1,350 m above sea level in altitude) is located between the Reeves and David Glaciers, about 50 km inland from Terra Nova Bay (Northern Victoria Land, East Antarctica). Katabatic winds that frequently exceed 25 m s−1 blow from the south and converge along the David, Reeves, and Priestley valleys in Terra Nova Bay, deflecting from the S-N to W-E and NW-SE directions (Bromwich et al. 1990). The site is at the limit of the Antarctic plateau before an orographic jump of more than 1,200 m over less than 20 km from the plateau to the coast. Another instrument was installed at midpoint (MdPt), a plateau site about 600 km from the coast (Fig. 1: 75°32′S, 145°51′E; 2,510 m above sea level in altitude).
A snow transport instrument and an automatic weather station (AWS) were installed in early January 2006 and in January 2007, respectively, on rock outcrops in the upper part of Larsen Glacier (Fig. 1). Snowdrift measurements were carried out using a driftometer sensor FlowCapt™ of IAV Acoustics and Vibration Engineering (Chritin et al. 1999), which is able to survey extended snow transportation events in a remote area under harsh conditions (Jaedicke 2001). Snow drift/blowing impact induces a measurable acoustic vibration in the sensor body. The instrument can supply mass flux rate assuming that the particles all have the same elastic characteristics and the impact depends on particle momentum. Using frequency filtering, the sensor precisely discriminates the low frequency wind effect from the high frequency snowdrift signal. The instrument is calibrated by the manufacturer and offers reproducibility in the ±5% range at the nominal single working point (Chritin, IAV Engineering, personal communication). However, the real accuracy of a FlowCapt flux measurement is an open question among the scientific community (Cierco et al. 2007). The instrument seems to underestimate flux in cold conditions (temperature < −5°C) with low-density snow flux and overestimate during warm and high snow density conditions (Lehning et al. 2002). Moreover, Cierco et al. (2004, 2007) have argued the instrument needs to be improved because the snow grain type and particle velocity play significant roles in flux rate estimation. Nevertheless, the extreme temperature condition registered for the Larsen site (never above −10°C, even during the austral summer) allows us to consider the measured fluxes as a lower limit of the real snow transportation.
The Larsen snow transportation instrument has four sensor segments, each of which is 1 m length and samples at nominal heights of 0.7, 1.7, 2.7, and 3.7 m, respectively. It measures hourly snow transport flux (FC) data (kg m−2 s−1), the datalogger internal temperature (°C), and an index proportional to the hourly maximum wind speed (m s−1). Unfortunately, the AWS (wind speed and direction, temperature, humidity) did not collect any data due to a problem with the datalogger battery.
Standard similarity theory ceased to be valid during strong events because the constancy assumption for turbulent fluxes above the surface is inaccurate (Bintanja 1998) and the power law does not fit the data. During those cases, the density is considered constant over the sensor length and Q T is calculated by simply summing the measured fluxes.
Precipitation (P) and evaporation (E) are evaluated from ECMWF +24 h operational forecasts because P and E are not analysed but only predicted in ECMWF. The forecast temporal resolution is chosen to avoid errors associated with the spin-up model that arise from the adjustment of the simulated atmosphere that are performed to ensure consistency with the physics at model initialization (Genthon et al. 2003). Snow transport divergence, and surface and blowing snow sublimation are calculated using the same approach of Déry and Yau (2002), initialized with zonal, meridional surface wind, temperature and dewpoint temperature at 2 m from the ECMWF operational analysis data. Snowmelt is a negligible phenomenon in the Terra Nova Bay area (annual temperature mean at sea level −15°C).
The lifetime of a blown snow particle is calculated using the basic formula for the change in mass of a spherical ice particle in an environment with a water vapour deficit, as described in Taylor et al. (2006). This approach has been widely used in other studies of blowing snow in Antarctic environments (Déry et al. 1998; Mann et al. 2000).
Snow transportation by saltation (within 0.3 m in elevation) starts at wind speeds between 2 and 5 m s−1, transportation by suspension (drift snow) starts at velocities greater than 5 m s−1 (within 2 m), and blowing snow (snow transportation higher than 2 m) starts at velocities between 7 and 11 m s−1 (see Frezzotti et al. 2004 and references therein). The threshold wind speed at which the sublimation of blowing snow starts to contribute substantially to katabatic flows in a feedback mechanism appears to be 11 m s−1 (Kodama et al. 1985; Wendler et al. 1993). An increase in drifting snow leads to an increase in air density due to cooling from drifting snow sublimation and to particle incorporation, thus increasing katabatic flow speeds by another 20–30% (Kodama et al. 1985). AWS and wind morphology (Frezzotti et al. 2002a) along the transect from Terra Nova Bay to Dome C show that within 600 km from the coast, wind speed is higher than 2 m s−1 for 90% of the time (drift snow), higher than 5 m s−1 65–80% of the time (blowing snow), and wind speeds higher than 11 m s−1 occur 15–40% of the time.
Analysis from August 2005 to October 2008 clearly shows the minimum observation of “billows” over the summer period (from mid-November to January), while this phenomenon occurs more than 90% of the time during the spring and fall months with maximum values in April and September (no image is available from May until August).
The calculation of transport rate (Q T ) integrated over 12 m in height gives the value of 5 × 106 kg m−1 summed over the entire campaign period, and 55% of the mass is transported in drift conditions (within 2 m). About 3 × 106 kg m−1 is carried at times when the density decreases with height from the surface, whereas some less typical transport occurs when the density increases with height. Measurements of snow transportation at the MidPoint site show a value of 0.1 × 106 kg m−1 for 7 months of measurements, between December 2005 and November 2006. Due to low temperatures, the instrument did not record transportation from April to August 2006.
The Q T is determined by a complex interaction between surface conditions and turbulent flow. A number of transport rate field studies have been performed in different parts of the world: at the Halley site (Antarctica) during the British Antarctic Survey’s second stable Antarctic boundary layer experiment (Mann et al. 2000); at the Byrd station, Antarctica (Budd 1966); at the Mizuho station, Antarctica (Takahashi 1985; Nishimura and Nemoto 2005); at Laramie, Wyoming (Schmidt 1982); and the Canadian Prairies (Pomeroy 1988). It is very difficult to generalise drift processes or compare results obtained in different sites. However, it can be noted that a value of 5.2 × 105 kg m−1 for Q T during December, January, and February 2007 obtained for Larsen is very close to the 5.5 × 105 kg m−1 for the same months in 1991 at the Halley site, presented by Mann et al. (2000). More general comparisons between parameterisations presented in the literature and measurements at the Larsen site highlight a good agreement for small transport rates, in particular for the Takahashi (1985) formula. But, they also show a trend of underestimating higher transport rates. Comparisons of our Q T instrumental measurements and atmospheric models show a value one order of magnitude greater than Déry and Yau (2002), and similar value to that estimated by van den Broeke et al. (2006). The dissimilar estimation by Déry and Yau (2002) is probably caused by differences in the model data used to initialize the calculation (ERA15 respect to RAMCO 2/ANT) and parameterisations.
Sublimation processes (Q S 57 kg m−2 year−1; E 34 kg m−2 year−1) remove 91 kg m−2 year−1 at the Larsen site (Fig. 5) and 17 kg m−2 year−1 at the MidPoint site (Q S 14 kg m−2 year−1; E 3 kg m−2 yr−1). Estimation of sublimation processes agrees well with the results proposed by another SMB study (van den Broeke et al. 2006; Déry and Yau 2002). The majority of snowfall (P) events occur when u is less than 8 m s−1, but no particular dependence on P intensity is apparent with wind speed. A wind increase is clear in 2007, especially during the fall and winter seasons when the mean u value is ~6.5 m s−1, which is ~2.5 m s−1 higher than the mean velocity for the same periods in 2006. No correlation has been found in the ECMWF data between snow transportation phenomena and snowfall.
Snow accumulation at Terra Nova Bay is about 150–200 kg m−2 year−1 (Stenni et al. 2000; Frezzotti et al. 2004) in a relatively undisturbed wind area. The Larsen site Q T (2.5 × 106 kg m−1 year−1), integrated over a 12 m height, is about four orders of magnitude greater than the annual snow accumulation. At the MidPoint site, Q T is about 0.05 × 106 kg m−1 year−1, three orders of magnitude greater than the snow accumulation (40–60 kg m−2 year−1). The calculation is affected by significant uncertainties, but most calculations represent the lower limit and can result in underestimation. Examples of such underestimations are: the underestimation of flux by FlowCaptTM driftometer in cold conditions, the complete lack of recognition of suspended particle distribution at heights of over 4 m (about 20% of events), a phenomenon that contributes to snow transport in some cases, and also the underestimation of u using model data. The blue ice area of the Nansen Ice Sheet occurs downwind of the Larsen site, therefore the blowing snow that transits at this site is completely sublimated in the atmosphere (mainly) or exported directly to the polynya.
During heavy billow events, the height of transport fluxes can be estimated at up to a 200 m through, as shown by a comparative analysis between shadows produced by the Larsen Glacier walls and those projected by the billows’ turbulent features. Incorporating the known sun elevation at the image time survey and the length of the shadows on the satellite image, we were able to calculate the elevation of the billows and atmospheric dunes. The snow transportation thickness is comparable with lidar measurements at the South Pole as published by Mahesh et al. (2003), who proposed a mean blowing snow layer of up to 400 m, with approximately 50% of the layer less than 200 m in thickness. Other authors (e.g., Budd et al. 1966; Wendler et al. 1993) report, based on visual observation, that the plumes of suspended blowing snow can reach heights of hundreds of metres, and that a snow load of 10−2 kg m−3 is not rare with heavy winds (Loewe 1974). Satellite images show that billow features sometimes disappear just before reaching the Larsen site due to sublimation of flux. Comparisons between snow transport evaluated by instruments and the presence of heavy billow features at the Larsen site indicate that it is probably not possible to survey some of the billow features because of the position of the site, delivering a clear underestimation of snow transportation.
Satellite images frequently show spectacular snow transportation phenomena with wave-like features or atmospheric dunes (with 5–10 km wavelengths) close to Mt Nansen where katabatic winds strike against the mountain slope opposite to the wind direction (Fig. 7). The position of the “atmospheric dune” is persistent between images and is well correlated to the change in slope. The relationship between the “atmospheric dune” shadow and billow shadow indicates that the “dune” forms at higher levels (tens of metres) of billow. These peculiar wave-like features look like the dune and megadune features that were recorded by snow radar survey under the ice sheet surface (Anschutz et al. 2006; Frezzotti et al. 2002a, 2007). To explain the formation of dunes and megadunes, authors hypothesised that the formation of a resonant gravity-inertia wave disturbs the katabatic wind flow at the break of the slope (Pettré et al. 1986; Frezzotti et al. 2002b).
As observed at the South Pole, larger values of blown snow transport rates are not always correlated to higher wind speed (Mahesh et al. 2003). Blowing snow is correlated to snow available for transportation (Gallée et al. 2001) and to the wind speed threshold at which the sublimation of blowing snow begins contributing substantially to the katabatic flows in a feedback mechanism (Fig. 5). Stronger winds promote greater sublimation of blowing snow because air moving down the Antarctic slope is adiabatically warmed, resulting in unsaturated air (Wendler et al. 1993). This allows particles to sublime completely in strong winds, whereas in medium-strength winds they may remain saturated with respect to ice and transportation could occur (Mahesh et al. 2003). Snow radar and remote sensing surveys show that wind-driven ablation (blowing sublimation and snow transport) is strictly correlated to slope along wind direction (Frezzotti et al. 2004, 2007) and not correlated to divergence/convergence versus ablation/deposition processes. Wind-driven ablation removed from the surface has an average value from 55 (GPS2) to 35% (M2 and MdPt) of the precipitation, and reaches a maximum value of ablation at 85% (M2) of the precipitation (Frezzotti et al. 2004, 2005). The extensive erosion confirmed by wind crust presence on the slope convergence area and the wide presence of blue ice in the area downwind of the coastal area show that transported snow is primarily exported directly in the atmosphere (blowing sublimation) and secondarily in the ocean. Snow depositional processes are very rare and negligible in the SMB.
Most of the East Antarctic coast is characterised by a katabatic wind confluence area associated with snow transportation. Loewe (1972) pointed out that along Wilkes Land (George V Coast), blowing snow exports about 70 × 109 kg km−1 into the sea, which accounts for around 30% of the Mertz, Ninnis and Cook Glacier’s ice discharge. Satellite images of this area show very similar conditions to the Terra Nova Bay area, including surface condition (wind crust and blue ice area) and blowing snow phenomena (billows). SMB measurements in Adelie Land show that wind-driven processes are the largest contribution to ablation, removing much of the precipitation and showing very high interannual variability in SMB (Genthon et al. 2007).
The blowing snow phenomenon shows great variability over both spatial and temporal scales. The source site of snow transported toward measurement sites is dependent on the time required by the particle to sublimate in the wind flux once it is uplifted. Model simulations of sublimation processes (Taylor et al. 2006) on a plateau for particles of different radii (50–250 μm) show that particles have short mean lives and are able to cover between 20 and 50 km, depending on, u in thermodynamic environments that simulate summer conditions. On the other hand, for late fall conditions, particles can travel up to 200 km, because model sublimation rates are reduced with decreasing ambient temperature due to the reduction in vapour pressure (Pomeroy and Gray 1995). The analysis of snow δ18O, performed every 5 km along the traverse Terra Nova Bay–Dome C, shows that the sampled snow was not blown from far away but fell within few a tenths of a kilometre from the sample site (Proposito et al. 2002; Becagli et al. 2004).
On a temporal scale, snow transport is strongly related to the condition that wind flux exceeds threshold speed values, which depends on snow surface conditions and particle uplift. On the basis of these conditions, 64% of transport during 2007 occurred in the fall and winter seasons when the mean u increased compared to the same periods of the previous year during which the residual 36% of transport occurred. The AWS wind speed data for Mario Zucchelli Station (MZS) is in accordance with u of ECMWF, and shows an increase of 10% in events of exceeding 5 m s−1 from 2006 to 2007.
Snow accumulation measurements from stake farms (more than 40 stakes in 4 km2) at two sites within the drainage basin area of the Terra Nova Bay glaciers (MidPoint: MdPt and Talos Dome: TD sites) show a decrease of ~30% in 2007 (MdPt: 33 kg m−2 year−1, average 1998–2007: 47 kg m−2 year−1; TD: 52 kg m−2 year−1, average 2001–2007: 73 kg m−2 year−1) with respect to 2006 values (MdPt 57 kg m−2 year−1, TD 90 kg m−2 year−1), whereas ECMWF analysis for both sites shows relatively constant precipitation through the 2 years. The observed increase in the wind regime in 2007 compared with 2006 causes enhanced snow transport/sublimation of up to 30%. This in turn accounts for the same magnitude decrease in accumulation rate measured at different sites.
Atmospheric model studies compute a mass divergence that tends to remove mass where ice sheet slope diverges and displace snowdrift deposition to coastal areas or convergence zones, with a balance that is close to nil.
Field and remote sensing analysis in the Terra Nova Bay and a similar site in East Antarctica (George V Coast) do not show any kind of snowdrift deposition as supposed by atmospheric model mass divergence/convergence parameterisation. Instead, there is an ablation surface (blue ice and wind crust) in the katabatic wind convergence area and downwind of it. Our instrumental observations (FlowCapt) integrated with previous snow accumulation survey (snow radar, firn core, remote sensing) suggest that the combined processes of blowing snow sublimation and snow transport remove (mainly in the atmosphere) up to 50% of precipitation in the coastal and slope convergence area. The observed wind-driven ablation explains the inconsistency between the atmospheric model precipitation (e.g., ECMWF) and the measured snow accumulation value.
Due to uncertainties in snow transportation, in particular stemming from high snow fluxes with particles transported up to 200 m above the earth’s surface and limited instrumental accuracy, the presented evaluation must be considered first order quantitative and the lower bound value of snow transportation. The transport divergence is the most difficult term to estimate, and its modelled value can have large variation depending on which wind/transport relationship is used.
An increase in snow precipitation coupled with an increase in temperature and/or wind could increase the surface mass balance in the inner part of East Antarctica if it was considered alone. However, it could cause a significant decrease in surface mass balance in the windy areas that represent 90% of the East Antarctic surface. Recent studies point to wind-induced circulation changes in the ocean as the dominant cause of the recent ice losses through the draining of the glaciers on the ice sheet (Holland et al. 2008; Thoma et al. 2008). Both the use of numerical simulation to predict the ice sheet’s contribution to sea level rise as well as remote sensing (GRACE, Radar-laser altimeter) measurements are significantly hampered by the lack of evaluation of wind-driven processes in ice sheet mass balances.
Blowing snow is also an important source of ocean freshening, and it should be taken into account particularly in the polynya area (Terra Nova Bay, George V Coast etc.). Jacobs et al. (2002) studied a freshening of the Ross Sea during the late 20th Century that appears to have resulted from a combination of factors, including increased precipitation. Although no increase in accumulation has been observed from atmospheric models or ice cores (Monaghan et al. 2006; Frezzotti et al. 2007), the observed freshening could be related to the increase of blowing snow from the continent to the coastal area.
This research was carried out as part of the framework of the Project on Glaciology and Observatory of the PNRA-MIUR, and was financially supported by the PNRA Consortium through collaboration with ENEA and INGV Roma and Ice2sea Project funded by the EU FP7. Comments by two anonymous referees greatly improved the text.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
- Agnoletto L (2009) Verifica dei modelli meteorologici: verifiche di punto e di area dei modelli operazionali a scala globale e mesoscala utilizzati per le previsioni meteorologiche in Antartide nella Terra Vittoria. Ph.D. Thesis, University of SienaGoogle Scholar
- Becagli S, Proposito M, Benassai S, Flora O, Genoni L, Gragnani R, Largiuni O, Pili SL, Severi M, Stenni B, Traversi R, Udisti R, Frezzotti M (2004) Chemical and isotopic snow variability in East Antarctica along the 2001/02 ITASE traverse. Ann Glaciol 39:473–482. doi: 10.3189/172756404781814636 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Bintanja R (1998) The contribution of snowdrift sublimation to the surface mass balance of Antarctica. Ann Glaciol 27:251–259Google Scholar
- Budd WF (1966) The drifting of non-uniform snow particles. In: Rubin MJ (ed) Studies in Antarctic meteorology. Antarctic research series, vol 9. American Geophysical Union, Washington, DC, pp 59–70Google Scholar
- Budd WF, Dingle WR, Radok U (1966) The Byrd snow drift project: outline and basic results. AGU Antarct Res Ser 9:51–134Google Scholar
- Cierco FX, Naaim-Bouvet F, Bellot H (2004) Snow transport rate: field measurements at short time scales. In: Proceedings of international snow science workshop, Jackson Hole, 19–24 September 2004Google Scholar
- Frezzotti M, Pourchet M, Flora O, Gandolfi S, Gay M, Urbini S, Vincent C, Becagli S, Gragnani R, Proposito M, Severi M, Traversi R, Udisti R, Fily M (2004) New estimations of precipitation and surface sublimation in East Antarctica from snow accumulation measurements. Clim Dyn 23:7–8. doi: 10.1007/s00382-004-0462-5 Google Scholar
- Frezzotti M, Pourchet M, Flora O, Gandolfi S, Gay M, Urbini S, Vincent C, Becagli S, Gragnani R, Proposito M, Severi M, Traversi R, Udisti R, Fily M (2005) Spatial and temporal variability of snow accumulation in East Antarctica from traverse data. J Glaciol 51(172):113–124. doi: 10.3189/172756505781829502 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Kodama Y, Wendler G, Gosink J (1985) The effect of blowing snow on katabatic winds in Antarctica. Ann Glaciol 6:59–62Google Scholar
- Loewe F (1972) The land of storms. Weather 27:110–121Google Scholar
- Loewe F (1974) Considerations concerning the winds of Adelie Land. Z Gletsch kd Glazialgeol 10:189–197Google Scholar
- Mann GW (1998), Surface heat and water vapour budges over Antarctica. Ph.D. Thesis, Environment Centre, University of Leeds, Leeds, pp 279Google Scholar
- Monaghan AJ, Bromwich DH, Fogt RL, Wang SH, Mayewski PA, Dixon DA, Ekaykin A, Frezzotti M, Goodwin I, Isaksson E, Kaspari SD, Morgan VI, Oerter H, van Ommen T, van der Veen CJ, Wen J (2006) Insignificant change in Antarctic snowfall since the international geophysical year. Science 313:827–831. doi: 10.1126/science.1128243 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Pettré P, Pinglot JF, Pourchet M, Reynaud L (1986) Accumulation distribution in Terre Adélie, Antarctica: effect of meteorological parameters. J Glaciol 32(112):486–500Google Scholar
- Pomeroy JW (1988) Wind transport of snow. Ph.D. Thesis, Division of Hydrology, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, pp 226Google Scholar
- Pomeroy JW, Gray DM (1995) Snow cover accumulation, relocation and management. NHRI Science report No. 7, Saskatoon, pp 144Google Scholar
- Proposito M, Becagli S, Castellano E, Flora O, Gragnani R, Stenni B, Traversi R, Udisti R, Frezzotti M (2002) Chemical and isotopic snow variability along the 1998 ITASE traverse from Terra Nova Bay to DC (East-Antarctica). Ann Glaciol 35:187–194. doi: 10.3189/172756402781817167 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Shiotanai M, Arai H (1967) On vertical distribution of blowing snow. In: Oura H (ed) Physics of snow and ice. Part 2, vol 1. Hokkaido University, Institute of Low Temperature Science, Sapporo, pp 1075–1083Google Scholar
- Takahashi S (1985) Characteristics of drifting snow at Mizuho Station, Antarctica. Ann Glaciol 6:71–75Google Scholar
- Wendler G, André JC, Pettré P, Gosink J, Parish T (1993) Katabatic winds in Adélie Coast. In: Bromwich DH, Stearns CR (eds) Antarctic meteorology and climatology: studies based on automatic weather stations. American Geophysical Union, Washington. Antarctic Res Ser 61:23–46Google Scholar