Methane oxidation in arable soil as inhibited by ammonium, nitrite, and organic manure with respect to soil pH

Abstract

 The effects of inorganic N and organic manure, applied to a loamy arable soil, on CH₄ oxidation were investigated in laboratory incubation experiments. Applications (40 mg N kg^–1) of NH₄Cl, (NH₄)₂SO₄, and urea caused strong instantaneous inhibition of CH₄ oxidation by 96%, 80%, and 84%, respectively. After nitrification of the added N the inhibitory effect was not fully reversible, resulting in an residual inhibition of 21%, 16%, and 25% in the NH₄Cl, (NH₄)₂SO₄, and urea treatments, respectively. With large NH₄ ⁺ applications [240 mg N kg^–1 as (NH₄)₂SO₄] the residual inhibition was as high as 64%. Exogenous NO₂ ^– (40 mg NO₂ ^–-N kg^–1) initially inhibited CH₄ oxidation by 84%, decreasing to 41% after its oxidation. Therefore, applied NO₂ ^– was a more effective inhibitor of CH₄ consumption than NH₄ ⁺. Temporary accumulation of NO₂ ^– during nitrification of added N was small (maximum: 1.9 mg NO₂ ^–-N kg^–1) and thus of minor importance with respect to the persistent inhibition after NH₄ ⁺ or urea application. CH₄ oxidation after NaNO₃ (40 mg N kg^–1) and NaCl addition did not differ to that of the untreated soil. The effect of organic manures on CH₄ oxidation depended on their C/N ratio: fresh sugar beet leaves enhanced mineralization, which caused an instantaneous 20% inhibition, whereas after wheat straw application available soil N was rapidly immobilized and no effect on CH₄ oxidation was found. The 28% increase in CH₄ oxidation after biowaste compost application was not related to its C/N ratio and was probably the result of an inoculation with methanotrophic bacteria. Only with high NH₄ ⁺ application rates (240 mg N kg^–1) could the persistent inhibitory effect partly be attributed to a pH decrease during nitrification. The exact reason for the observed persistent inhibition after a single, moderate NH₄ ⁺ or urea application is still unknown and merits further study.