Planar momentum balance in three-dimensional flows: applications to load estimation
Load estimation from the momentum balance for a planar control volume is investigated, a configuration which is ubiquitous in experimental fluid mechanics. The classical formulation relies on an assumption of two-dimensional flow which is violated for instantaneous turbulent or transitional flow fields, and to varying degrees in measured mean and second order statistics. A rigorous formulation required for the exact momentum balance over the planar control volume is derived here, involving additional terms related to the three-dimensional momentum fluxes and viscous forces. The formulation is verified using instantaneous and mean control volume load estimations based on synthetic measurements extracted from direct numerical simulations and experimental particle image velocimetry measurements of flow over a cylinder in a turbulent wake regime. The main result is the demonstration of the significance of area integrals involving out-of-plane velocity and velocity gradients, which are shown to be required for accurate estimation of instantaneous sectional loads and cause a sensitivity to experimental conditions for mean sectional load estimates. If volumetric measurements are unavailable to the experimentalist, the divergence-free condition on the velocity field for incompressible flow may be invoked to account for a subset of the three-dimensional terms. This enables higher accuracy, particularly for the mean drag estimates in the statistically three-dimensional flow encountered in experiment. The findings highlight common issues responsible for inconsistent estimates of instantaneous and mean sectional loads for three-dimensional flows using control volume methods, and offer practical recipes for detecting and minimizing errors due to flow three-dimensionality.
The authors gratefully acknowledge the contribution of the Natural Science and Engineering Research Council (NSERC) (Grant no. RGPIN-04222) to the funding of this research.
- Baur T, Köngeter J (1999) Piv with high temporal resolution for the determination of local pressure reductions from coherent turbulent phenomena. In: 3rd Int. Workshop on Particle Image Velocimetry, Santa Barbara, pp 101–106Google Scholar
- Betz A (1925) A method for the direct determination of wing-section drag., Technical Report 337, NACA Tech. MemGoogle Scholar
- Gurka R, Liberzon A, Hefetz D, Rubinstein D, Shavit U (1999) Computation of pressure distribution using PIV velocity data. In: 3rd Int. Workshop on Particle Image Velocimetry, Santa Barbara, pp 671–676Google Scholar
- Jones BM (1936) The measurement of profile drag by the pitot-traverse method. Technical Report 1688, Air Ministry—Aeronautical Research Committe Reports and MemorandaGoogle Scholar
- McClure J, Yarusevych S (2016) Vortex shedding and structural loading characteristics of finned cylinders. J Fluids Stuct 10:100–101Google Scholar
- Neatby H, Yarusevych S (2012) Towards reliable experimental drag measurements of an airfoil at low Reynolds numbers. In: 42nd AIAA fluid dynamics conference and exhibit. ASME, New Orleans, LouisianaGoogle Scholar
- Stansby P (1974) The effect of end plates on the base pressure coefficient of a circular cylinder. Aeronaut J 78:36–37Google Scholar
- Takahashi T (1997) On the decomposition of drag components from wake flow measurements. In: 35th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit. Reno, Nevada, pp 1–10Google Scholar
- Zaman K, Culley D (2008) Flow separation control over an airfoil: implication of wake velocity-deficit reduction. In: 4th Flow Control Conference’, Seattle, Washington, pp 1–20Google Scholar