A comparison between an in vitro ureteroscopic stone size estimation and the stone size measurement with the help of a scale on stone baskets
- 127 Downloads
Endoscopic treatment of ureter stones and renal calculi relies on the surgeon’s estimation of the stone size for both lithotripsy and removal of stones or stone fragments. We therefore compared precision and reliability of the endoscopic estimation of stone size by the surgeon with measurements on a scale on a stone basket.
Materials and methods
Two surgeons (one high experienced and one low experienced) first estimated, then measured the size of 12 stones differing in size and color using different stone baskets (2.5, 3.0, 4.0 Ch) each via a semirigid renoscope in an artificial ureter under water repeatedly on two different days. All together, we had 288 measurements and 288 estimations.
On the whole, the accuracy of the estimation diminished with bigger stones. There is an increasing underestimation with increasing stone size. Factors, which significantly influence the estimation, are the operating surgeon, the color of the stone, the time sequence, and the size of the closed basket, which was held beside the stone. The accuracy of the measurement of the stone baskets is not as good as the estimation. The small 2.5-Ch basket is the most accurate in measuring big stones (>6 mm), the 3.5 Ch in intermediate stones (3–6 mm), the big basket (4.0 Ch) in small stones (<3 mm).
This first attempt at validation of a scale on stone baskets shows different results for each basket which could be systematically improved. Until now, the estimation of the surgeons is better than the measurement, but it is also influenced by factors like the surgeon or the color of the stone.
KeywordsStone size estimation Endourology Stone basket
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
- 5.Cordes J, Lange B, Jocham D, Kausch I (2011) Destruction of stone extraction basket during an in vitro lithotripsy: a comparision of four lithotripters. J Endourol 25(1–4):58–61Google Scholar
- 8.Stoeckel D (2001) Umformung von NiTi-Legierungen - Einen Herausforderung. Neuere Entwicklungen in der Massivumformung Siegert K (Hrsg.) 141–157Google Scholar