Thrombus imaging in acute stroke: correlation of thrombus length on susceptibility-weighted imaging with endovascular reperfusion success
- 1.9k Downloads
Susceptibility-weighted imaging (SWI) enables visualization of thrombotic material in acute ischemic stroke. We aimed to validate the accuracy of thrombus depiction on SWI compared to time-of-flight MRA (TOF-MRA), first-pass gadolinium-enhanced MRA (GE-MRA) and digital subtraction angiography (DSA). Furthermore, we analysed the impact of thrombus length on reperfusion success with endovascular therapy.
Consecutive patients with acute ischemic stroke due to middle cerebral artery (MCA) occlusions undergoing endovascular recanalization were screened. Only patients with a pretreatment SWI were included. Thrombus visibility and location on SWI were compared to those on TOF-MRA, GE-MRA and DSA. The association between thrombus length on SWI and reperfusion success was studied.
Eighty-four of the 88 patients included (95.5 %) showed an MCA thrombus on SWI. Strong correlations between thrombus location on SWI and that on TOF-MRA (Pearson’s correlation coefficient 0.918, P < 0.001), GE-MRA (0.887, P < 0.001) and DSA (0.841, P < 0.001) were observed. Successful reperfusion was not significantly related to thrombus length on SWI (P = 0.153; binary logistic regression).
In MCA occlusion thrombus location as seen on SWI correlates well with angiographic findings. In contrast to intravenous thrombolysis, thrombus length appears to have no impact on reperfusion success of endovascular therapy.
• SWI helps in assessing location and length of thrombi in the MCA
• SWI, MRA and DSA are equivalent in detecting the MCA occlusion site
• SWI is superior in identifying the distal end of the thrombus
• Stent retrievers should be deployed over the distal thrombus end
• Thrombus length did not affect success of endovascular reperfusion guided by SWI
KeywordsAcute stroke Intracranial thrombus Magnetic resonance imaging Digital subtraction angiography Thrombectomy
Digital subtraction angiography
Gadolinium-enhanced magnetic resonance angiography
Intravenous recombinant tissue plasminogen activator
Middle cerebral artery
Minimum intensity projection
Modified Rankin scale
National Institutes of Health stroke scale
Susceptibility vessel sign
Thrombolysis in cerebral infarction
Time-of-flight magnetic resonance angiography
Improved functional outcome following acute ischemic stroke is strongly correlated with successful vessel recanalization . A study on middle cerebral artery (MCA) stroke demonstrated that intravenous thrombolysis had nearly no potential for recanalizing thrombi measuring more than 8 mm in length .
Susceptibility-weighted imaging (SWI), a fully velocity-compensated high-resolution 3D gradient-echo sequence, is becoming an essential technique in the primary and follow-up MRI evaluation of patients with cerebrovascular disease . SWI helps in distinguishing structures that have different susceptibility values than their surroundings . Applications of SWI in stroke imaging include the exclusion of intracranial haemorrhage before administration of intravenous thrombolytics, visualization of prominent cortical veins that have been shown to indicate cerebral misery perfusion  and detection of haemorrhagic infarct transformation. An additional application of SWI is the direct visualization of thrombotic material . A recent study has shown an excellent correlation between thrombus length as measured on T2* gradient-echo sequences compared to that determined by digital subtraction angiography (DSA) in patients with acute anterior and posterior circulation stroke .
The aim of this study was first to analyse the accuracy of SWI in visualizing the occlusion site compared to traditional MRI angiographic sequences as well as DSA and second, to investigate whether thrombus length as measured on SWI affects the success of endovascular reperfusion therapy of MCA occlusions.
Patients and methods
A total of 396 consecutive acute ischemic stroke patients treated by endovascular means at our stroke unit, from March 2010 to May 2012, were screened. Inclusion criteria were isolated MCA M1 and/or M2 segment occlusion, pre-interventional MRI including SWI, and endovascular reperfusion therapy. A total of 88 patients fulfilled the inclusion criteria. The study was approved by our institutional review board. All patients gave written informed consent prior to enrolment in our stroke registry. If patients did not have the capacity to consent, written informed consent was obtained from their nearest relatives.
Clinical data on patients with acute ischemic stroke were prospectively recorded in our stroke database. Neurologic deficits were scored by a neurologist using the National Institutes of Health stroke scale (NIHSS). Clinical outcome was assessed 3 months after stroke using the modified Rankin scale (mRS).
Standard stroke MRI protocol was performed, which included diffusion-weighted imaging, T2-weighted imaging, time-of-flight magnetic resonance angiography (TOF-MRA), SWI, perfusion imaging, 3D first-pass gadolinium-enhanced MRA (GE-MRA) of the cervical and intracranial arteries, and T1-weighted post-contrast imaging. The images were acquired with a 1.5-T and 3-T MRI (Magnetom Avanto and Magnetom Verio; Siemens, Erlangen, Germany).
For the 1.5-T device, the SWI parameters were TR 49 ms, TE 40 ms, number of averages 1, FoV read 230 mm, FoV phase 75.0 %, voxel size 0.9 × 0.7 × 1.8 mm, flip angle 15°, acquisition time 2:59 min. For the 3-T device the parameters were as follows: TR 28 ms, TE 20 ms, number of averages 1, FoV read 230 mm, FoV phase 75.0 %, voxel size 0.9 × 0.9 × 2.0 mm, flip angle 15°, acquisition time 2:59 min. The SWI and minimum intensity projection (mIP) images were generated automatically by the scanner software.
The TOF-MRA parameters were as follows: 36 slices per slab, 4 slabs, 0.60 mm thickness, TR 22 ms, TE 3.6 ms, number of averages 1, FoV read 200 mm, FoV phase 90.6 %, voxel size 0.5 × 0.5 × 0.6 mm, flip angle 18°, acquisition time 5:16 min.
For the GE-MRA of the cranial and cervical arteries 88 coronal slices were acquired with 0.9 mm thickness, TR 3.21 ms, TE 1.2 ms, number of averages 1, FoV read 300 mm, FoV phase 100 %, voxel size 1.0 × 0.8 × 0.9 mm, flip angle 25°, 4 measurements, acquisition time 1:30 min.
DSA was performed via a transfemoral approach using a biplane, high-resolution angiographic system (Axiom Artis zee; Siemens, Erlangen, Germany).
Pre-interventional SWI and mIP series were analysed for the presence of a susceptibility vessel sign (SVS) in the MCA by three radiologists (C.W., R.K.V., A.K.). SVS was defined as an area of signal drop within the course of an artery that either exceeded the diameter of the contralateral non-occluded vessel, or that of the adjacent vessel segment on both the SWI and mIP series . Discrepancies between reviewers regarding thrombus visibility on SWI were resolved in consensus. After analysis of the SWI the presence of a vessel occlusion on TOF-MRA and GE-MRA corresponding to the proximal thrombus end on SWI was determined. The reviewers were aware of the presence of an MCA occlusion, but were blinded to lesion side and clinical symptoms.
The following endovascular recanalization techniques were applied: stent retriever thrombectomy, thromboaspiration, extra- and intracranial stenting, intra-arterial thrombolysis or any combination of these. The interventional team selected material and thrombectomy techniques on the basis of the thrombus extension and angioarchitecture of the arteries proximal and distal to the occlusion site as seen on multimodal stroke MRI protocol. Stent retrievers were always deployed with the tip distal to the thrombus end. Cerebral reperfusion was assessed at the end of the endovascular intervention, on biplane or 3D rotational angiography, according to the thrombolysis in cerebral infarction (TICI) grading system .
Continuous variables are presented as mean ± standard deviation (SD) if not stated otherwise. Successful reperfusion was defined as TICI grades 2b–3. Pearson correlation coefficients were used to compare thrombus location (distance of proximal thrombus end to midline) between the different imaging modalities (i.e. SWI, TOF-MRA, GE-MRA and DSA). Bland–Altman plots were used to identify systematic differences between measurements of thrombus location on SWI and the other imaging modalities . Binary logistic regression was used to compare thrombus length on SWI with reperfusion success. The correlation between thrombus length on SWI and NIHSS score on admission was studied by Kendall’s τ rank correlation test. Associations between thrombus location and NIHSS score on admission were analysed with the Kruskal–Wallis test. A P value less than 0.05 was considered significant. Interobserver reliability for the detection of the SVS was studied using Cohen’s κ statistics. Statistics were performed with SPSS version 21 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA) and R version 3.0.3 (R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria).
A total of 46 women and 42 men were studied. Their mean age was 66.5 ± 15.9 years (range 13–89 years).
Imaging of occluding thrombi
A total of 69 patients had an occlusion of the M1, 17 of the M2 and two of both the M1 and M2 segments. Interobserver reliability for the detection of SVS on SWI was fair to excellent and ranged from 0.535 to 0.788 between pairs of reviewers (Cohen’s κ). After consensus review, an SVS corresponding to the occluding thrombus was found in 84 of the 88 patients (95.5 %). TOF-MRA detected a vessel occlusion in 87 patients (98.9 %). In 79 of 81 patients (97.5 %) in whom a GE-MRA was performed, a vessel occlusion was identified. In DSA, which served as the gold standard in our study, a vessel occlusion was found in all patients. In the 84 patients with SVS, mean thrombus length on SWI was 10.9 ± 4.7 mm (range 4.6–30.5 mm).
Imaging, clinical and procedural characteristics in 88 patients with middle cerebral artery occlusion
Time from symptom onset to MRI, min, mean (SD)
Time from symptom onset to DSA, min, mean (SD)
Baseline NIHSS score, median (range)
Large artery disease, n (%)
Cardioembolic, n (%)
Other determined aetiology, n (%)
Unknown aetiology, n (%)
Intravenous bridging thrombolysis, n (%)
Successful reperfusion (TICI 2b–3), n (%)
Interventional characteristics, n (%)
Stent retriever thrombectomy
Extra- and intracranial stenting
Favourable outcome (mRS, 0–2) at 3 months, n (%)
Dead at 3 months, n (%)
Most patients underwent multimodal endovascular therapy and in the majority, stent retriever thrombectomy was performed.
Association of thrombus length and location with clinical parameters and reperfusion success
A weak correlation was found between thrombus length on SWI and baseline NIHSS score (Kendall’s τ coefficient 0.197; P = 0.010). When analysing the association between occlusion site and baseline NIHSS score the Kruskal–Wallis test demonstrated a non-significant trend (P = 0.055). Patients with M1 or a combination of M1 and M2 occlusions had higher median NIHSS scores on admission compared to patients with isolated M2 occlusions (NIHSS score 15 versus 9).
Successful reperfusion (TICI 2b–3) was achieved independent of thrombus length on SWI (P = 0.153; OR 0.924; 95 % CI, 0.830–1.030) using multimodal endovascular technique.
In our series of patients with MCA occlusions, 95.5 % of the thrombi were clearly definable on SWI. This detection rate is in line with those recently reported for SWI and T2* gradient-echo imaging in anterior circulation stroke [7, 11]. We propose a new technique for defining thrombus location that is applicable to different imaging modalities (Fig. 1). Using this technique we found a strong correlation between the location of the proximal thrombus end as seen on SWI and that on TOF-MRA, GE-MRA and DSA. These findings support previous reports which showed that SWI and T2* gradient-echo imaging can reliably depict thrombus location when compared to TOF-MRA  and DSA . Moreover, we demonstrated that thrombus length as measured on SWI did not appear to have an impact on success of endovascular reperfusion therapy of MCA occlusions.
The latter finding is of particular interest. Various studies have shown that the success of vessel recanalization with intravenous thrombolysis seems to depend on clot burden. Clot burden was defined either on thin-slice non-enhanced CT, CT-angiography, or recently on T2* gradient-echo images measuring either absolute thrombus length  or applying a scoring system based on thrombus location [12, 13]. MCA thrombi measuring more than 8 mm in length were found to have nearly no potential for recanalization with intravenous thrombolysis . Lower clot burden scores, indicating a higher thrombus burden, showed significant associations with worse clinical outcome [12, 13].
The effect of thrombus burden on reperfusion success and clinical outcome after endovascular treatment remains less clear. A study by Puetz et al. analysing clinical outcome in relation to the clot burden score on CT-angiography found no differential effect on outcome between patients treated by intravenous thrombolysis, endovascular means or a combination of both . Barreto et al. used the modified TIMI criteria to assess thrombus burden in patients undergoing endovascular therapy alone or in combination with bridging thrombolysis . In his study, a significant association between high clot burden and worse clinical outcome at 3 months was observed. Although the percentage of patients with successful reperfusion (TICI 2b–3) was higher in the group with lower clot burden compared to those with larger clots, this difference was not significant . In the present study, thrombus length as measured on SWI did not significantly affect reperfusion success (P = 0.153). Our findings suggest that when using multimodal endovascular revascularization techniques, thrombus length does not affect the chances of successful reperfusion. It has to be noted that the comparability between the aforementioned studies is limited because of the variable methods used to assess clot burden or size.
Detection rates of vessel occlusions were similar between SWI (95.5 %), TOF-MRA (98.9 %) and GE-MRA (97.5 %). In two of the four patients with no definable SVS, the interpretability of SWI was limited because of severe motion artefacts and in one patient with a proximal M1 occlusion, the MCA was partially obscured by susceptibility artefacts in the proximity of the skull base. In the fourth patient the thrombus could not be detected on SWI for unknown reasons, even in direct comparison with TOF-MRA, GE-MRA and DSA which clearly depicted a vessel occlusion.
Interestingly, small but systematic differences were found between the distances of the proximal thrombus end to the midline measured on SWI and those obtained on TOF-MRA (mean bias 1.6 mm; percentage error 6.4 %) using Bland–Altman statistics (Fig. 3). On TOF-MRA slow flow, such as seen proximal to an occlusion, can lead to inadequate depiction of vessel segments that are still patent, potentially resulting in overestimation of the occlusion [15, 16]. This phenomenon might explain the shorter distance measured from midline to proximal thrombus end on TOF-MRA compared with the other angiographic methods.
Our study has some limitations. One could argue that it is unknown to what extent the distal end of the susceptibility vessel sign is caused by the thrombus itself, and to what extent by stagnating, deoxyhaemoglobin-rich blood distal to the occlusion, resulting in overestimation of the real thrombus length. A recent study addressed this uncertainty by showing an excellent correlation between the thrombus length as measured on T2* gradient-echo imaging and that on DSA . To avoid the limited sensitivity of SWI in proximity to the skull base, i.e. intracranial segment of the internal carotid artery and posterior circulation arteries, we decided to assess only MCA occlusions to correlate the sensitivity of SWI with various angiographic techniques. The sensitivity of gradient-echo imaging in detecting thrombi appears to be lower for the posterior circulation . Only few patients presented with isolated occlusions of the M2 segment and none had an occlusion of the M3/4 segments. The generalizability of the results regarding the thrombus location defined by vessel segment is therefore limited because of the rather small patient number. Furthermore, all patients included in our study underwent endovascular treatment. Such patients usually present with more proximal and larger thrombi compared to those treated by intravenous thrombolysis alone. Thrombus length has been shown to influence detectability of thrombi on T2* gradient-echo imaging . An additional bias may have been introduced by obtaining SWI at two different field strengths (1.5 T and 3 T). A study analysing the effect of field strength on the diameter of cerebral microbleeds as measured on SWI showed an increase in size with higher field strength . Likewise, the length of the SVS on SWI may slightly vary with field strength. Finally, SWI tends to overestimate the real proportions of material with different magnetic susceptibility than the surrounding tissue (e.g. microbleeds, thrombi) [19, 20], probably resulting in a slight overestimation of maximal thrombus length.
This study demonstrates that SWI is a valuable addition to the standard stroke MRI protocol. Thrombus location on SWI correlated strongly with that on TOF-MRA, GE-MRA and DSA. Reperfusion success of multimodal endovascular treatment techniques seems not to be affected by thrombus length as measured on SWI if information on thrombus extension with regard to the individual patient’s angioarchitecture is included in endovascular treatment planning.
The scientific guarantor of this publication is Prof. Dr. Gerhard Schroth. The authors of this manuscript declare no relationships with any companies whose products or services may be related to the subject matter of the article. The authors state that this work has not received any funding. Pietro Ballinari and Martin Zbinden kindly provided statistical advice for this manuscript. Institutional review board approval was obtained. Written informed consent was obtained from all patients, or in case patients did not have the capacity to consent from their nearest relatives, in this retrospective, diagnostic study performed at one institution. The authors appreciate the support of the MRI technologists, headed by Carole Stuker, and angiography technologists, headed by Thierry Horisberger, at our institute.
Christian Weisstanner and Pascal P. Gratz contributed equally to this study.
- 15.Axel L (1986) Blood flow effects in magnetic resonance imaging. Magn Reson Annu 237–244Google Scholar
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.