Advertisement

OR Spectrum

, Volume 34, Issue 2, pp 319–348 | Cite as

Organizing hospitals into networks: a hierarchical and multiservice model to define location, supply and referrals in planned hospital systems

  • Ana Maria Mestre
  • Mónica Duarte Oliveira
  • Ana Barbosa-Póvoa
Regular Article

Abstract

Health care planners in countries with a system based on a National Health Service (NHS) have to make decisions on where to locate and how to organize hospital services, so as to improve the geographic equity of access in the delivery of care while accounting for efficiency and cost issues. This study proposes a hierarchical multiservice mathematical programming model to inform decisions on the location and supply of hospital services, when the decision maker wants to maximize patients’ geographical access to a hospital network. The model considers the multiservice structure of hospital production (with hospitals producing inpatient care, emergency care and external consultations) and the costs associated with reorganizing the hospital network. Moreover, it considers the articulation between different hospital services and between hospital units, and the ascendant and descendent flows related to two-way referrals of patients in the hospital hierarchy. The proposed approach differs from previous literature by accounting simultaneously for these issues and provides crucial information for health care planners on referral networks, on hospital catchment areas, on the location and structure of hospital supply as well as on the costs required to improve access. The results from applying the model are illustrated in an application to the South region of the Portuguese NHS. Three scenarios are portrayed to describe how the model can be used in distinct institutional settings and policy contexts and when there is uncertainty concerning the key parameters of the model.

Keywords

Public facility planning Location models Network design Health care management 

List of symbols

Abbreviations

DH

District hospital

CH

Central hospital

Sets

\({i\in I}\)

Demand points

\({j,l\in J}\)

Potential locations for DH

\({k\in K}\)

Potential locations for CH

\({w,v,a\in W}\)

Hospital services (w = 1 for inpatient care, w = 2 for emergency service and w = 3 for external consultation)

Parameters

\({d_{ij}^{1}\, d_{ik}^2 }\)

Travel time between a demand point iand a DH j/CH k

\({d_{jk}^{3}}\)

Travel time between DH j and CH k

\({D_{i}^{w}}\)

Demand for service w in demand point i

DCwv

Share of demand transferred from service w in a DH to service v in a CH

CDwv

Share of demand transferred from service v in a CH to service w in a DH

pwv

Share of demand transferred from service w to v within the same hospital

adw acw

Length of stay spent in service w in a DH/CH

DHw CHw

Maximum capacity allowed for service w operating in a DH and in a CH

dhw chw

Minimum capacity required for service w operating in a DH and in a CH

α (0 ≤ α ≤ 1)

Weighting factor to differentiate first from second attendances (expressing planners’ preferences)

βw(0 ≤ βw ≤ 1)

Weighting factor to differentiate hospital services (expressing planners’ preferences)

popj

Population located in demand point j

popmin

Minimum population located in a demand point required to open a new hospital

n

Number of facilities to be opened

stnd

Maximum travelling time allowed for a population to access a hospital

\({{\rm DHc}_j^w \,{\rm CHc}_k^w }\)

Total unit costs for delivering care in a DH j and in a CH k

DHecj DHicj

Cost of expanding/investing one bed in an existing/new DH located in j

\({{\rm icap}\_X_j^w }\)

Current capacity of DH j

TOC

Total annual operating costs for all DHs

TIC

Total investment costs for all DHs

Variables

\({X_j^w }\)

Determines the opening (=1) or closure (=0) of a DH in location j that provides service w

\({Y_k^w }\)

Determining the opening (=1) or closure (=0) of a CH in location k that provides service w

\({{\rm fd}_{ij}^w }\)

Flow from population point i to DH j for service w

\({{\rm fc}_{ik}^w }\)

Flow from population point i to CH k for service w

\({{\rm zdc}_{jk}^{wv}}\)

Ascendant flow from service w in DHj to service v in CH k

\({{\rm zcd}_{kj}^{wv}}\)

Descendent flow from service w in CH k to service v in DH j

\({{\rm td}_j^{wv}}\)

Flow between service w and v inside DH j (auxiliary variable)

\({{\rm tc}_k^{wv}}\)

Flow between service w and v inside CH k (auxiliary variable)

\({{\rm cap}\_X_j^w }\)

Capacity for service w in a DH j

\({{\rm cap}\_Y_k^w }\)

Capacity for service w in a CH k

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Algarve Health Region (2004) Plano Director Regional da Saúde do Algarve (Regional plan for health in Algarve). FaroGoogle Scholar
  2. Culyer A (2001) Equity—some theory and its policy implications. J Med Ethics 27: 275–283CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Current J, Min H, Schilling D (1990) Multiobjective analysis of facility location decisions. Eur J Oper Res 49(3): 295–307CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Daskin M (1995) Network and discrete location. Wiley, New YorkCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Daskin M (2008) What you should know about location modelling. Nav Res Logist 55: 283–294CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Eiselt HA, Laporte G (1995) Objectives in location problems. Drezner Z (ed) Facility location—a survey of applications and methods Springer, New York, pp 151–180Google Scholar
  7. Folland S, Goodman A, Stano M (1997) The economics of health and health care, 2nd edn. Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle RiverGoogle Scholar
  8. Galvão RD, Espejo A, Gonzalo L, Boffey B (2002) A hierarchical model for the location of perinatal facilities in the municipality of Rio de Janeiro. Eur J Oper Res 138(3): 495–517CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Galvão RD, Acosta E, Luis G, Boffey B, Yates D (2006) Load balancing and capacity constraints in a hierarchical location model. Eur J Oper Res 172(2): 631–646CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. GAMS (2010) General algebraic modeling system version 23.6.5. Washington, DC, USAGoogle Scholar
  11. Gerrard R, Church R (1996) Closest assignment constraints and location models: properties and structure. Locat Sci 4(4): 251–270CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Health Ministry (1990) Lei no 48/90: Lei de Bases da Saúde (fundamental principles of health) Diário da Républica: I série, no 195 de 24 de AgostoGoogle Scholar
  13. Health Ministry (2002) Rede de referenciação hospitalar em oncologia (hospital network in oncology). LisbonGoogle Scholar
  14. Health Ministry (2003) Centros de saúde e hospitais: recursos e produção do SNS (primary care centre and hospitals: production and resources of the NHS). LisbonGoogle Scholar
  15. Health Ministry (2006a) Reordenamento das capacidades hospitalares da cidade de Lisboa (redevelopment of hospital capacity in the city of Lisbon). LisbonGoogle Scholar
  16. Health Ministry (2006b) Contabilidade Analítica—Hospitais do SNS (cost accounting). LisbonGoogle Scholar
  17. Health Ministry (2007) Proposta da rede de urgências—Relatório Final (proposal of the emergency network—final report). LisbonGoogle Scholar
  18. Marianov V, Serra D (2004) Location problems in the public sector In: Drezner Z, Hamacher H (eds) Facility location: applications and theory. Springer, Berlin, pp 119–143Google Scholar
  19. Marsh MT, Schilling DA (1994) Equity measurement in facility location analysis: a review and framework. Eur J Oper Res 74(1): 1–17CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Mayhew LD, Leonardi G (1982) Equity, efficiency, and accessibility in urban and regional health-care systems. Environ Plan A 14(11): 1479–1507CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. McAllister DM (1976) Equity and efficiency in public facility location. Geogr Anal 8(1): 47–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Melo MT, Nickel S, Saldanha-da-Gama F (2009) Facility location and supply chain management—a review. Eur J Oper Res 196(2): 401–412CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Mestre A, Oliveira M, Barbosa-Póvoa A (2009) Aplicação do modelo hierárquico Multi-Serviço ao planeamento hospitalar na Região de Saúde do Norte (Application of the hierarchical multi-service model for hospital Planning in the Portuguese North Health Region). Internal report, LisbonGoogle Scholar
  24. Morgan G, Henrion M (1990) Uncertainty: a guide to dealing with uncertainty in quantitative risk and policy analysis. Cambridge University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  25. Narula SC (1986) Minisum hierarchical location-allocation problems on a network: a survey. Ann Oper Res 6: 257–272CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Oliveira MD, Bevan G (2006) Modelling the redistribution of hospital supply to achieve equity taking account of patient’s behaviour. Health Care Manag Sci 9(1): 19–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Oliveira MD, Pinto CG (2005) Health care reform in Portugal: an evaluation of the NHS experience. Health Econ 14(S1): S203–S220CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Owen SH, Daskin MS (1998) Strategic facility location: A review. Eur J Oper Res 111(3): 423–447CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Portuguese National Institute of Statistics (2006) XIV census. Accessed info service: http://www.ine.pt
  30. Rahman S, Smith DK (2000) Use of location-allocation models in health service development planning in developing nations. Eur J Oper Res 123(3): 437–452CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. ReVelle CS, Eiselt HA (2005) Location analysis: a synthesis and survey. Eur J Oper Res 165(1): 1–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Rice N, Smith P (2001) Capitation and risk adjustment in health care financing: an international progress report. Milbank Q 79(1): 81–113CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Rosko MD, Broyles R (1988) The economics of health care: a reference handbook Greenwood Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  34. Ruth RJ (1981) A mixed integer programming model for regional planning of a hospital inpatient service. Manag Sci 27(5): 521–533CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Sahin G, Süral H (2007) A review of hierarchical facility location models. Comput Oper Res 34(8): 2310–2331CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Salema M, Póvoa A, Novais A (2009) A strategic and tactical model for closed-loop supply chains. OR Spectr 31(3): 573–599CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Savas ES (1978) Equity in providing public-services. Manag Sci 24(8): 800–808CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Smith HK, Harper PR, Potts CN, Thyle A (2009a) Planning sustainable community health schemes in rural areas of developing countries. Eur J Oper Res 193(3): 768–777CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Smith HK, Laporte G, Harper PR (2009b) Locational analysis: highlights of growth to maturity. J Oper Res Soc 60: 140–148CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Smith H, Harper P, Potts C (2010) Bicriteria efficiency/equity hierarchical location models. Working paper, 152075. University of SouthamptonGoogle Scholar
  41. Teixeira J, Antunes A, Peeters D (2007) An optimization-based study on the redeployment of a secondary school network. Environ Plan B 34(2): 296–315CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Truelove M (1993) Measurement of spatial equity. Environ Plan C 11(1): 19–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. ViaMichelin Maps and route planner. http://www.viamichelin.co.uk. Accessed 2006

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  • Ana Maria Mestre
    • 1
  • Mónica Duarte Oliveira
    • 1
  • Ana Barbosa-Póvoa
    • 1
  1. 1.Centre for Management Studies of Instituto Superior TécnicoTechnical University of LisbonLisbonPortugal

Personalised recommendations