Corticospinal tractography with morphological, functional and diffusion tensor MRI: a comparative study of four deterministic algorithms used in clinical routine
Diffusion tensor imaging permits study of white matter fibre bundles; however, its main limitation is lack of validation on anatomical data, especially in crossing fibre regions. Our study aimed to compare four deterministic tractography algorithms used in clinical routine. We studied the corticospinal tract, the bundle mediating voluntary movement. Our study seeks to evaluate tractography provided by algorithms through comparative analysis by expert neuroradiologists.
MRI data from 15 right-handed volunteers (30.8 years) were studied. Regions of interest (ROIs) were segmented on morphological and functional MRI. Diffusion weighted images (15 directions) were performed, then for each voxel the tensor was estimated. Tractography of the corticospinal tract was performed using four fibre-tracking algorithms. Three numerical integration methods Euler, Runge–Kutta second (RK2) and fourth order (RK4), and a tensor deflection method (TEND). Quantitative measurement was performed. Qualitative evaluation was carried out by two expert neuroradiologists using Kappa test concordance.
For the quantitative aspect, only RK2 and TEND presented no significant difference concerning the number of fibres (p = 0.58). There was no difference between right and left side for each algorithm. Regarding the qualitative aspects, there was a lack of fibres from the ventrolateral part of the functional ROIs. Comparison by expert neuroradiologists revealed low rather than high concordance. The algorithm ranked first was RK2 according to expert preferences.
Different algorithms used in clinical routine failed to show realistic anatomical bundles. The most mathematically robust algorithm was not selected, nor was the algorithm defining more fibres. Validation of anatomical data provided by tractography remains a challenge.
KeywordsCorticospinal tract Deterministic tractography Diffusion tensor imaging Anatomy MRI
The authors would like to warmly thank Pierre Forlodou and Douraied Ben Salem, neuroradiologists in Brest, for their assistance in the realisation of this study.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest in the realisation of this study
- 12.Dellatolas G, De Agostini M, Jallon P, Poncet M, Rey M, Lellouch J (1988) Mesure de la préférence manuelle par autoquestionnaire dans la population française adulte. Rev Psychol appl 38:117–136Google Scholar
- 18.Hasan KM, Walimuni IS, Abid H, Hahn KR (2011) A review of diffusion tensor magnetic resonance imaging computational methods and software tools. Comput Biol Med 41:1062–1072Google Scholar
- 33.Schimrigk SK, Bellenberg B, Schluter M, Stieltjes B, Drescher R, Rexilius J, Lukas C, Hahn HK, Przuntek H, Koster O (2007) Diffusion tensor imaging-based fractional anisotropy quantification in the corticospinal tract of patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis using a probabilistic mixture model. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 28:724–730PubMedGoogle Scholar
- 35.Stamm A, Perez P, Barillot C (2011) Diffusion directions imaging (DDI). Technical report, INRIA. http://hal.inria.fr/inria-00608706/en
- 36.Talairach J, Tournoux P (1988) Coplanar stereotaxic atlas of the human brain, Thieme, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- 41.Wiest-Daesslé N, Prima S, Morrisey SP, Barillot C (2007) Validation of a new optimisation algorithm for registration tasks in medical imaging In: 4th IEEE International symposium on biomedical imaging: from Nano to Macro, ISBI 41–44Google Scholar
- 42.Yamada K, Sakai K, Hoogenraad FG, Holthuizen R, Akazawa K, Ito H, Oouchi H, Matsushima S, Kubota T, Sasajima H, Mineura K, Nishimura T (2007) Multitensor tractography enables better depiction of motor pathways: initial clinical experience using diffusion-weighted MR imaging with standard b-value. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 28:1668–1673PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 44.Zhang Y, Zhang J, Oishi K, Faria AV, Jiang H, Li X, Akhter K, Rosa-Neto P, Pike GB, Evans A, Toga AW, Woods R, Mazziotta JC, Miller MI, van Zijl PC, Mori S (2010) Atlas-guided tract reconstruction for automated and comprehensive examination of the white matter anatomy. Neuroimage 52:1289–1301PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar