Evaluation of a Novel Bony Landmark-Based Method for Teaching Percutaneous Insertion of Subclavian Venous Catheters in Pediatric Patients
Surgical trainees performing subclavian vein (SCV) cannulation often incorrectly perceive needle trajectory and anatomical relations. As surface landmark-based methods derived from adult surgical practice may be less effective in younger patients, we developed and evaluated a novel bony landmark-based method for teaching SCV cannulation for central venous access device (CVAD) placement in children.
Over 2 sequential 3-year periods, pediatric surgical trainees were taught infraclavicular SCV cannulation via surface- and bony-landmark approaches, respectively. We prospectively recorded patient, surgeon and operative details on all Hickman line and port-a-cath insertions placed by trainees as the first surgeon via percutaneous infraclavicular SCV puncture and compared procedural outcomes and complications across both periods.
Of 271 cases included in the study, trainees performed 52 (50.5%) and 92 (54.8%) procedures in the first and second periods, respectively. Patients in both periods did not differ by gender, disease, CVAD device, or prior CVAD, chemotherapy or infection status. In the second (bony landmark) period, although patients were younger (6.0 vs. 8.7 years, P = 0.003) mean procedural duration was shorter (42.5 vs. 58.3 min, P < 0.001). Also, cannulation attempts and complication rates did not differ significantly between study periods (P = 0.257 and 1.0, respectively).
With the bony landmark approach, trainees could perform the procedures faster despite operating on younger patients, without impacting complication rates and cannulation attempts. Bony landmarks may better approximate SCV position across a range of ages, thus improving the consistency of SCV cannulation in CVAD placements in children.
We thank Dr Evan Lim, DVM, MSc (Medical Art); Ms. Germaine Liew and Ms. Jillian Teo, Singapore Childhood Cancer Registry; Ms. Tan Sheng Hui, VIVA-KKH Paediatric Brain and Solid Tumor Program; Ms. Candy Choo, Department of Paediatric Surgery, KK Hospital.
This work was supported by the VIVA Foundation for Children with Cancer (AHP Loh), and Children’s Cancer Foundation.
- 12.Araujo CC, Lima MC, Falbo GH (2007) Punção percutênea da veia subclávia em crianças e adolescentes: sucesso, complicações e fatores associados. Jornal de Pediatria 83:64–70Google Scholar
- 18.Thompson E, Calver L (2005) Safe subclavian vein cannulation. Am Surg 71(2):180–183Google Scholar
- 24.Fukutome T, Shigematsu A (1986) Prediction of subclavian vein location using plain chest radiography. Resusc 14(4):237–243Google Scholar