Advertisement

Toward Active Community Environmental Policing: Potentials and Limits of a Catalytic Model

  • John-Michael DavisEmail author
  • Yaakov Garb
Article
  • 32 Downloads

Abstract

This paper offers a field tested community environmental policing model to address the pressing environmental management challenges of reducing e-waste burning in informal e-waste hubs, and enforcement against informal polluting industries more broadly. This is based on our intervention to reduce e-waste burning in a substantial informal e-waste hub in the West Bank, Palestine, a 45 km2 region in which an estimated 5–10 metric tonnes of cables are burnt daily, causing serious environmental and public health consequences. In analogous e-waste hubs in the global South, environmental management solutions have focused on economically attractive alternatives to replace cable burning or policies that integrate informal recyclers with formal e-waste management systems—achieving little success. Our paper describes a two-pronged intervention in Palestine’s e-waste hub, which reduced e-waste burning by 80% through a combination of economically competitive cable grinding services and an “active” community environmental policing initiative that lowered barriers to and successfully advocated for governmental policing of e-waste burning. Our discussion of this intervention addresses the community environmental policing literature, which has documented few successes stories of real improvements to the enforcement of environmental violations. We argue that existing strategies have relied on “passive” approaches comprised of monitoring and reporting environmental violations to advocate for change. Our strategy offers a template to improve outcomes through a more “active” approach, moving from monitoring environmental violations through understanding the rationale and dynamics of violators, identifying environmental policing barriers, and implementing a feasible and persuasive strategy to overcome them.

Keywords

E-waste Community environmental policing Palestine Informal Environmental governance Citizen science 

Notes

Acknowledgements

This research benefited from the financial support of the Swedish Consulate and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada, Grant #767-2014-2701 and 756-2017-0552. We are grateful to the many local inhabitants, the alert and response team staff, and the many community members and stakeholders who supported the vision and efforts described here.

Compliance with Ethical Standards

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Amoyaw-Osei Y, Agyekum OO, Pwamang JA, Müller E, Fasko R, Schluep M (2011) Ghana e-waste country assessment. SBC e-waste Africa project, 2011111Google Scholar
  2. Ashcroft MB, Gollan JR, Batley M (2012) Combining citizen science, bioclimatic envelope models and observed habitat preferences to determine the distribution of an inconspicuous, recently detected introduced bee (Halictus smaragdulus Vachal Hymenoptera: Halictidae) in Australia. Biol Invasions 14(3):515–527CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bailony MR, Hararah MK, Salhab AR, Ghannam I, Abdeen Z, Ghannam J (2011) Cancer registration and healthcare access in West Bank, Palestine: a GIS analysis of childhood cancer, 1998–2007. Int J Cancer 129(5):1180–1189CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Ballard H, Fernandez-Gimenez M, & Sturtevant V (2008) Integration of local ecological knowledge and conventional science: a study of seven community-based forestry organizations in the USA. Ecology Soc 13(2):1–22Google Scholar
  5. Brigden K, Labunska I, Santillo D, & Johnston P (2008) Chemical contamination at e-waste recycling and disposal sites in Accra and Korforidua, Ghana, Greenpeace Research Laboratories Technical Report, 1–23Google Scholar
  6. Brett EA (2003) Participation and accountability in development management. J Dev Stud 40(2):1–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Cesaro A, Belgiorno V, Gorrasi G, Viscusi G, Vaccari M, Vinti G, Jandric A, Dias MI, Hursthouse A, Salhofer S (2019) A relative riskassessment of the open burning of WEEE. Environ Sci Pollut Res 26(11):11042–11052CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Chi X, Streicher-Porte M, Wang MY, Reuter MA (2011) Informal electronic waste recycling: a sector review with special focus on China. Waste Manag 31(4):731–742CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Cosquer A, Raymond R, Prevot-Julliard AC (2012) Observations of everyday biodiversity: a new perspective for conservation? Ecol Soc 17(4):2CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Davis JM (2013) The informal e-waste sector of Israel–Palestine: contexts, problems and ways forward (Master’s Thesis). Ben Gurion University, Beersheva, IsraelGoogle Scholar
  11. Davis JM, Akese G, Garb Y (2019) Beyond the Pollution Haven Hypothesis: where and why do e-waste hubs emerge and what does this mean for policies and interventions? Geoforum 98:36–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Davis JM, Garb Y (2015) A model for partnering with the informal e-waste industry: rationale, principles and a case study. Resour, Conserv Recycl 105:73–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Davis JM, Garb Y (2016) Cycles des déschets et valorisation. Le systéme israélo- palestinien de traitement des déchets électroniques. Technol Cult 65-66:390–403CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Davis JM, Garb Y (2017) Participatory shaping of community futures in e-waste processing hubs: complexity, conflict, and stewarded convergence in a Palestinian context. Dev Policy Rev 37(1):67–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Davis JM, Garb Y (2018a) Quantifying flows and economies of informal e-waste hubs: learning from the Israeli–Palestinian e-waste sector. Geogr J 185(1):82–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Davis JM, Garb Y (2018b) A strong spatial association between e-waste burn sites and childhood lymphoma in the West Bank, Palestine. Int J Cancer 144(3):470–475CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Davis JM, Garb Y (2019) Extended responsibility or continued dis/articulation? Critical perspectives on e-waste policies from the Israeli–Palestinian case. Environ Plan E: Nat Space 2(2):368–389Google Scholar
  18. Dourojeanni MJ (2002) Political will for establishing and managing parks. Making Parks Work. Island Press, Washington, DC, p 230–334Google Scholar
  19. Gallo T, Waitt D (2011) Creating a successful citizen science model to detect and report invasive species. BioScience 61(6):459–465CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Gidwani V (2015) The work of waste: Inside India’s infra‐economy. Trans Inst Br Geogr 40(4):575–595CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Glausiusz J (2016) Can old computers bring Palestinians and Israelis together? Nature 540(7631):22CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Goldstein J (2017) A pyrrhic victory? The limits to the successful crackdown on informal- sector plastics recycling in Wenan County, China. Mod China 43(1):3–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Grant K, Goldizen FC, Sly PD, Brune MN, Neira M, van den Berg M, Norman RE (2013) Health consequences of exposure to e-waste: a systematic review. Lancet Glob Health 1(6):e350–e361CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Grant R, Oteng-Ababio M (2012) Mapping the invisible and real “African” economy: urban e-waste circuitry. Urban Geogr 33(1):1–21CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Greenwood JJ (2003) The monitoring of British breeding birds: a success story for conservation science? Sci Total Environ 310(1):221–230CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Gullett BK, Linak WP, Touati A, Wasson SJ, Gatica S, King CJ (2007) Characterization of air emissions and residual ash from open burning of electronic wastes during simulated rudimentary recycling operations. J Mater Cycles Waste Manag 9(1):69–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Herbert S (2006) Citizens, cops, and power: recognizing the limits of community. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, USACrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Hicks C, Dietmar R, Eugster M (2005) The recycling and disposal of electrical and electronic waste in China—legislative and market responses. Environ Impact Assess Rev 25(5):459–471CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Huang CL, Bao LJ, Luo P, Wang ZY, Li SM, Zeng EY (2016) Potential health risk for residents around a typical e-waste recycling zone via inhalation of size-fractionated particle-bound heavy metals. J Hazard Mater 317:449–456CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Inverardi-Ferri C (2017) Variegated geographies of electronic waste: policy mobility, heterogeneity and neoliberalism. Area Dev Policy 2(3):314–331CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Jiménez I (2002) Heavy poaching in prime habitat: the conservation status of the West Indian manatee in Nicaragua. Oryx 36(03):272–278CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Kahhat R, Williams E (2012) Materials flow analysis of e-waste: domestic flows and exports of used computers from the United States. Resour, Conserv Recycling 67:67–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Keller M (2006) Assessment of gold recovery processes in Bangalore, India and evaluation of an alternative recycling path for printed wiring board (Master’s Thesis). Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Testing and Research (EMPA), St. Gallen, SwitzerlandGoogle Scholar
  34. Khlaif N, Qumsiyeh MB (2016) Genotoxicity of recycling electronic waste in Idhna, Hebron District, Palestine. Int J Environ Stud 74(1):66–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Kramer KT (2013) There’s a hole in the bucket: rethinking the role of community collected data in environmental justice movements. Int J Disabil Hum Dev 12(4):433–444CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Lau WKY, Liang P, Man YB, Chung SS, Wong MH (2014) Human health risk assessment based on trace metals in suspended air particulates, surface dust, and floor dust from e-waste recycling workshops in Hong Kong, China. Environ Sci Pollut Res 21(5):3813–3825CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Little P (2016) On electronic pyropolitics and Pure Earth friction in Agbogbloshie. Toxic News. https://toxicnews.org/2016/11/08/on-electronic-pyropolitics-and-pure-earth-friction-in-agbogbloshie/, Accessed 1 Jan 2018
  38. Lundquist CJ, Granek EF (2005) Strategies for successful marine conservation: integrating socioeconomic, political, and scientific factors. Conserv Biol 19(6):1771–1778CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Lynch MJ, Stretesky PB (2013) The distribution of water-monitoring organizations across states: implications for community environmental policing and social justice. Polic: Int J Police Strateg Manag 36(1):6–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Manhart A, Osibanjo O, Aderinto A, Prakash S (2011) Informal e-waste management in Lagos, Nigeria: socio-economic impacts and feasibility of inter-national recycling co- operations. Final Rep. Compon 3:1–129Google Scholar
  41. O’Rourke D, Macey GP (2003) Community environmental policing: assessing new strategies of public participation in environmental regulation. J Policy Anal Manag 22(3):383–414CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Ottinger G (2010) Buckets of resistance: standards and the effectiveness of citizen science. Sci, Technol, Hum Values 35(2):244–270CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Overdevest C, Mayer B (2007) Harnessing the power of information through community monitoring: insights from social science. Tex Law Rev 86:1493Google Scholar
  44. Perez R (2015) Tools for informal e-waste recyclers in Agbogbloshie, Ghana (Master’s Thesis). Royal Holloway University of London, LondonGoogle Scholar
  45. Phuong PT, Mol AP (2004) Communities as informal regulators: new arrangements in industrial pollution control in Viet Nam. J Risk Res 7(4):431–444CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Prakash S, Manhart A, Amoyaw-Osei Y, & Agyekum OO (2010) Socio-economic assessment and feasibility study on sustainable e-waste management in Ghana. Öko- Institut eV in cooperation with Ghana Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) & Green Advocacy Ghana, Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and the Environment, VROM- InspectorateGoogle Scholar
  47. Puckett J, Byster L, Westervelt S, Gutierrez R, Davis S, Hussain A, & Dutta M (2002) Exporting Harm: The High-Tech Trashing of Asia. Seattle, Washington, USA: Basel Action NetworkGoogle Scholar
  48. Puckett J, Westervelt S, Gutierrez R, & Takamiya Y (2005) The digital dump: exporting re-use and abuse to Africa. Seattle, Washington, USA: Basel Action NetworkGoogle Scholar
  49. Pure Earth (2015) Transforming Agbogbloshie: from toxic dump into model recycling center. http://www.pureearth.org/blog/photos-transforming-agbogbloshie-from-toxic-e-waste-dump-into-model-recycling-center/ Accessed 1 Jan 2018
  50. Reddy RN (2015) Producing abjection: E-waste improvement schemes and informal recyclers of Bangalore. Geoforum 62:166–174CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Rochat D, Rodrigues W, & Gantenbein A (2008). India: Including the existing informal sector in a clean e-waste channel. In Proceedings of the Waste Management Conference (WasteCon2008)Google Scholar
  52. Schluep M, Hagelüken C, Meskers CE, Magalini F, Wang F, Müller E, … & Sonnemann G (2009) Market potential of innovative e-waste recycling technologies in developing countries. Proceedings of the R, 9Google Scholar
  53. Schmidt CW (2006) Unfair trade e-waste in Africa. Environ Health Perspect. 114(4):A232–A253Google Scholar
  54. Sepúlveda A, Schluep M, Renaud FG, Streicher M, Kuehr R, Hagelüken C, Gerecke AC (2010) A review of the environmental fate and effects of hazardous substances released from electrical and electronic equipments during recycling: examples from China and India. Environ Impact Assess Rev 30(1):28–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Staeheli L (2008) Citizenship and the problem of community. Political Geogr 27(1):5–21CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Shinkuma T, Managi S (2010) On the effectiveness of a license scheme for E-waste recycling: the challenge of China and India. Environ Impact Assess Rev 30(4):262–267CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Stepenuck KF, Green LT (2015) Individual-and community-level impacts of volunteer environmental monitoring: a synthesis of peer-reviewed literature. Ecol Soc 20(3):19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Stern MJ (2008) Coercion, voluntary compliance and protest: the role of trust and legitimacy in combating local opposition to protected areas. Environ Conserv 35(03):200–210CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Sullivan J (2014) Trash or treasure: Global trade and the accumulation of e-waste in Lagos, Nigeria. Afr Today 61(1):89–112CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Wang F, Huisman J, Meskers CE, Schluep M, Stevels A, Hagelüken C (2012a) The Best-of-2-Worlds philosophy: developing local dismantling and global infrastructure network for sustainable e-waste treatment in emerging economies. Waste Manag 32(11):2134–2146CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Wang J, Chen S, Tian M, Zheng X, Gonzales L, Ohura T, Simonich SLM (2012b) Inhalation cancer risk associated with exposure to complex polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon mixtures in an electronic waste and urban area in South China. Environ Sci Technol 46(17):9745–9752CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Williams E, Kahhat R, Bengtsson M, Hayashi S, Hotta Y, Totoki Y (2013) Linking informal and formal electronics recycling via an interface organization. Challenges 4(2):136–153CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Yang J, Lu B, Xu C (2008) WEEE flow and mitigating measures in China. Waste Manag 28(9):1589–1597CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Yarwood R (2007) The geographies of policing. Prog Hum Geogr 31(4):447–465CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Yarwood R (2015) Lost and hound: the more-than-human networks of rural policing. J Rural Stud 39:278–286CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Yu J, Williams E, Ju M, Shao C (2010) Managing e-waste in China: policies, pilot projects and alternative approaches. Resour, Conserv Recycl 54(11):991–999CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Zhao G, Wang Z, Zhou H, Zhao Q (2009) Burdens of PBBs, PBDEs, and PCBs in tissues of the cancer patients in the e-waste disassembly sites in Zhejiang, China. Sci Total Environ 407(17):4831–4837CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Zhang T, Huang YR, Chen SJ, Liu AM, Xu PJ, Li N, Mai BX (2012) PCDD/Fs, PBDD/Fs, and PBDEs in the air of an e-waste recycling area (Taizhou) in China: current levels, composition profiles, and potential cancer risks. J Environ Monit 14(12):3156–3163CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Zheng J, Chen KH, Yan X, Chen SJ, Hu GC, Peng XW, Yang ZY (2013) Heavy metals in food, house dust, and water from an e-waste recycling area in South China and the potential risk to human health. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 96:205–212CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Zheng X, Xu X, Yekeen TA, Zhang Y, Chen A, Kim SS, Huo X (2016) Ambient air heavy metals in PM2.5 and potential human health risk assessment in an informal electronic-waste recycling site of China. Aerosol Air Qual Res 16(2):388–397CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Zuev D (2018) Digital afterlife: (Eco) civilizational politics of the site and the sight of e‐waste in China. Anthropol Today 34(6):11–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2020

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Worcester Polytechnic InstituteThe Global SchoolWorcesterUSA
  2. 2.Department of Sociology and Anthropology & Department of Geography and Environmental DevelopmentBen Gurion University of the NegevBeershevaIsrael

Personalised recommendations