Environmental Management

, Volume 50, Issue 4, pp 633–644 | Cite as

Trade-Offs Between Biodiversity Conservation and Economic Development in Five Tropical Forest Landscapes

  • Marieke Sandker
  • Manuel Ruiz-Perez
  • Bruce M. Campbell
Article

Abstract

This study explores how conservation and development are interlinked and quantifies their reciprocal trade-offs. It identifies interventions which hold a promise to improve both conservation and development outcomes. The study finds that development trajectories can either be at the cost of conservation or can benefit conservation, but in all cases sustained poverty negatively affects conservation in the long term. Most scenarios with better outcomes for conservation come at a cost for development and the financial benefits of payments for environmental services (PES) are not sufficient to compensate for lost opportunities to earn cash. However, implementation of strategies for reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation in locations with low population densities come close to overcoming opportunity costs. Environmental services and subsistence income enhance the attractiveness of conservation scenarios to local people and in situations where these benefits are obvious, PES may provide the extra cash incentive to tip the balance in favor of such a scenario. The paper stresses the importance of external factors (such as industrial investments and the development of the national economy) in determining landscape scale outcomes, and suggests a negotiating and visioning role for conservation agencies.

Keywords

ICDP Participatory modeling PES REDD Scenarios 

Notes

Acknowledgments

The authors acknowledge the Livelihoods and Landscapes Initiative (LLS) from the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) for their financial support for the research done in several of the study locations.

References

  1. Agrawal A, Redford K (2006) Poverty, development, and biodiversity conservation: shooting in the dark? Wildlife Conservation Society, New York.Google Scholar
  2. Albrechtsen L, Fa JE, Barry B, MacDonald DW (2006) Contrasts in availability and consumption of animal protein in Bioko Island, West Africa: the role of bushmeat. Environmental Conservation 32:340–348CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Andrianto A (2006) The role of district government in poverty alleviation: case studies in Malinau and West Kutai districts, East Kalimantan. Center for International Forestry Research, BogorGoogle Scholar
  4. Apaza L, Wilkie D, Byron E, Huanca T, Leonard W, Perez E, Reyes-Garcıa V, Vadez V, Godoy R (2002) Meat prices influence the consumption of wildlife by the Tsimane’ Amerindians of Bolivia. Oryx 36:1–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Barr C, Wollenberg E, Limberg G, Anau N, Iwan R, Sudana M, Moeliono M, Djogo T (2001) The impacts of decentralization on forests and forest-dependent communities in Kabupaten Malinau, East Kalimantan (case study 3) In: Case studies on Decentralization and Forests in Indonesia. Center for International Forestry Research, BogorGoogle Scholar
  6. Blake S (2005) Long term system for monitoring the illegal killing of elephants (MIKE). Central African forests: final report on population surveys 2003–2004 Report. Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora MIKE Programme, Washington DCGoogle Scholar
  7. Brandon K (2001) Moving beyond intergrated conservation and development projects (ICDPs) to achieve biodiversity conservation. In: Lee DR, Barrett CB (eds) Trade-offs or synergies?, Chapt 22. CAB International, Wallingford, pp 417–432Google Scholar
  8. Butler RA, Koh LP, Ghazoul J (2009) REDD in the red: palm oil could undermine carbon payment schemes. Conservation Letters 2:67–73CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Capoor K, Ambrosi P (2008) State and trends of the carbon market 2008. The World Bank, Washington DCGoogle Scholar
  10. CarbonPositive (2009) Indonesia reveals REDD revenue shares. http://www.carbonpositive.net/viewarticle.aspx?articleID=1602. Accessed 17 Sept 2009
  11. CEFAID (Centre pour l’Education, la Formation et l’Appui aux Initiatives de Développement au Cameroun) (2005) Etude socio-économique effectuée dans les villages voisins de l’Unité Forestière d’Aménagement 10064. CEFAID, YokadoumaGoogle Scholar
  12. IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) (2000) In: Watson RT, Noble IR, Bolin B, Ravindranath NH, Verardo DJ, Dokken DJ (eds.) Land use, land-use change and forestry, Cambridge University Press pp 375Google Scholar
  13. Chapin M (2004) A challenge to conservationists. Worldwatch Institute, Wahington DCGoogle Scholar
  14. Christensen J (2004) Win–win illusions. Over the past two decades, efforts to heal the rift between poor people and protected areas have foundered. So what next? Conservation in Practice 5:12–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. CIB (Congolaise Industrielle des Bois) (2006) Plan d’aménagement de l’Unité Forestière d’Aménagement de Kabo (2005–2034). CIB, KaboGoogle Scholar
  16. Costanza R, d’Arge R, de Groot R, Farber S, Grasso M, Hannon B, Limburg K, Naeem S, O’Neill RV, Paruelo J, Raskin RG, Sutton P, Van den Belt M (1997) The value of the world’s ecosystem services and natural capital. Nature 387:253–260CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Cowlishaw G, Mendelson S, Rowcliffe JM (2004) The bushmeat commodity chain: patterns of trade and sustainability in a mature urban market in West Africa. ODI wildlife policy brief 7. Overseas Development Institute, LondonGoogle Scholar
  18. Culas RJ (2007) Deforestation and the environmental Kuznets curve: an institutional perspective. Ecological Economics 61:429–437CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Czesnik F (2007) Mission d’appui-conseil financier pour le renforcement de la coopération avec la Commune de Bayanga. GFA Consulting Group and Dzanga-Sangha Project, BayangaGoogle Scholar
  20. De Bruijn A (2005) Carbon dynamics simulation in Malinau Research Forest, Borneo, Indonesia. Dissertation, Wageningen University and Research CenterGoogle Scholar
  21. Disrtict Report (2005) Wasa Amenfi West district data report. Wasa Amenfi West district services, AsankrangwaGoogle Scholar
  22. District Forestry and Estate Crops Service (2006) Dinas Kehutanan dan Perkebunan Kabupaten Malinau. District Forestry and Estate Crops Service, MalinauGoogle Scholar
  23. District Forestry Service (2008) Dinas Kehutanan dan UNIPA. Master Plan Kehutanan Kabupaten Kaimana. District Forestry Service, ManokwariGoogle Scholar
  24. Ekobo A (1998) Large mammals and vegetation surveys in the Boumba-Bek and Nki project area. World Wildlife Fund, YokadoumaGoogle Scholar
  25. Fisher B, Kulindwa K, Mwanyoka I, Turner RK, Burgess ND (2010) Common pool resource management and PES: lessons and constraints for water PES in Tanzania. Ecological Economics 69:1253–1261CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Frost P, Campbell B, Luckert M, Mutamba M, Mandondo A, Kozanayi W (2007) In search of improved rural livelihoods in semi-arid regions through local management of natural resources: lessons from case studies in Zimbabwe. World Development 35:1961–1974CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Garreau JM (1994) Enquête sur le revenue des ménages à Bayanga et Moussapoula, Rapport. Dzanga-Sangha Project, BayangaGoogle Scholar
  28. GFW (Global Forest Watch) (2005) Interactive forestry atlas of Cameroon. World Resources Institute, Washington DCGoogle Scholar
  29. Godoy R, Wilkie DS, Reyes-Garcia V, Leonard WR, Huanca T, McDade T, Vadez V, Tanner S (2006) Human body-mass index (weight in kg/stature in m2) as a useful proxy to assess the relation between income and wildlife consumption in poor rural societies. Biodiversity and Conservation 15:4495–4506CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. GTZ (German development cooperation) (2001) Etude Socio–économique de l’UTO Sud-est. GTZ, YokadoumaGoogle Scholar
  31. Ickowitz A (2006) Shifting cultivation and deforestation in tropical Africa: critical reflections. Development and Change 37:599–626CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Kaimana Statistics Centre (2008) Kaimana in figures. Badan Pusat Statistik, KaimanaGoogle Scholar
  33. Kaimowitz D, Angelsen A (1998) Economic models of tropical deforestation: a review. Center for International Forestry Research, BogorGoogle Scholar
  34. Kamiss A (2006) Recensement de la populations des villages de la Réserve Spéciale de Dzanga Sangha au des année 2005. Dzanga-Sangha Project, BayangaGoogle Scholar
  35. Karsenty A (2007) Questioning rent for development swaps: new marketbased instruments for biodiversity acquisition and the land-use issue in tropical countries. International Forestry Review 9:503–513CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Koop G, Tole L (1999) Is there an environmental Kuznets curve for deforestation? Journal of Development Economics 58:231–244CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Kremen C, Merenlender AM, Murphy DD (1994) Ecological monitoring: a vital need for integrated conservation and development programs in the tropics. Conservation Biology 8:388–397CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Levang P, Dounias E, Sitorus S (2005) Out of the forest, out of poverty? Forests, Trees and Livelihoods 15:211–236CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Malinau Statistics Centre (2006) Badan Pusat Statistik Kabupaten Malinau Dalam Angka. BPS, MalinauGoogle Scholar
  40. McShane TO, Wells MP (2004) Getting biodiversity projects to work: towards more effective conservation. Colombia University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  41. Moeliono M, Wollenberg E, Limberg G (2008) The decentralization of forest governance: politics, economics and the fight for control of forests in Indonesian Borneo. Earthscan Publications Ltd, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  42. Noss AJ (1998) The impact of cable snare hunting on wildlife populations in the forest of the Central African Republic. Conservation Biology 12:390–398CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Nzooh ZL (2003) Suivi écologique dans le Parc National de Lobéké et sa zone périphérique : données de base sur la dynamique des populations de grands et moyens mammifères et des activités anthropiques. World Wildlife Fund, YokadoumaGoogle Scholar
  44. Nzooh ZL, Bassama C, Ndinga H (2005) Populations des grands et moyens mammifères dans les UFA 10–008, 10–009, 10–010, 10–012: données de base pour l’aménagement durable des concessions. World Wildlife Fund, YokadoumaGoogle Scholar
  45. Oates JF (1999) Myth and reality in the rainforest: how conservation strategies are failing in Africa. University of California Press, BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
  46. Rodrigues ASL, Ewers RM, Parry L, Souza C, Verissimo A, Blamford A (2009) Boom-and-bust development patterns across the Amazon deforestation frontier. Science 12:1435–1437CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Sandker M, Suwarno A, Campbell BM (2007) Will forests remain in the face of oil palm expansion? Simulating change in Malinau, Indonesia. Ecology and Society 12:37. Online [http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol12/iss2/art37/]Google Scholar
  48. Sandker M, Campbell BM, Nzooh Z, Sunderland T, Amougou V, Defo L, Sayer J (2009) Exploring the effectiveness of integrated conservation and development interventions in a Central African forest landscape. Biodiversity and Conservation 18:2875–2892CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Sandker M, Nyame SK, Förster J, Collier N, Shepherd G, Yeboah D, Ezzine-de Blas D, Machwitz M, Vaatainen S, Garedew E, Etoga G, Ehringhaus C, Anati J, Quarm ODK, Campbell BM (2010a) REDD payments as incentive for reducing forest loss. Conservation Letters 3:114–121CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Sandker M, Puntodewo A, Sitorus F, Purnomo H, Yumte Y, Ruiz-Pérez M, Campbell BM (2010b) Spatial projections of participatory system dynamics modeling outcomes: exploring oil palm and REDD consequences for local livelihoods in Papua, Indonesia. In: International Conference of Landscape Modelling, MontpellierGoogle Scholar
  51. Sandker M, de Semboli BB, Roth P, Pellisier C, Ruiz-Pérez M, Sayer J, Turkalo AK, Omoze F, Campbell BM (2011) Logging or conservation concession: exploring conservation and development outcomes in Dzanga-Sangha, Central African Republic. Conservation and Society 9(4):299–310CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Shepherd G and staff from PEMALI and PERDU (2009) People and forest-based livelihoods in Kaimana district: planning a sustainable future. Working paper for IUCN Livelihoods and Landscapes Programme, GlandGoogle Scholar
  53. Shiferaw BA, Okello J, Reddy RV (2009) Adoption and adaptation of natural resource management innovations in smallholder agriculture: reflections on key lessons and best practices. Environment, Development and Sustainability 11:601–619CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Swallow B, van Noordwijk M, Dewi S, Murdiyarso D, White D, Gockowski J, Hyman G, Budidarsono S, Robiglio V, Meadu V, Ekadinata A, Agus F, Hairiah K, Mbile P, Sonwa DJ, Weise S (2007) Opportunities for avoided deforestation with sustainable benefits. ASB Partnership for the Tropical Forest Margins, NairobiGoogle Scholar
  55. Terborgh J (1999) Requiem for nature. Island Press, Washington DCGoogle Scholar
  56. Thomas V, Dailami M, Dhareshwar A, López RE, Kaufmann D, Kishor N, Wang Y (2000) The quality of growth. Oxford University Press, New YorkCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Turkalo A (2005) Rapport d’activité. Projet Dzanga Sangha, BayangaGoogle Scholar
  58. UN (United Nations) (2006) World urbanization prospects: the 2005 revision. Department of Economic and Social Affairs, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  59. UN (United Nations) (2009) World population prospects: the 2008 revision. Department of Economic and Social Affairs, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  60. UNFPA (United Nations Population Fund) (2007) Country profiles for population and reproductive health, policy developments and indicators 2005. UNFPA, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  61. Wauters JB, Coudert S, Grallien E, Jonard M, Ponette Q (2008) Carbon stock in rubber tree plantations in Western Ghana and Mato Grosso (Brazil). Forest Ecology and Management 255:2347–2361CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Wells M, Guggenheim S, Khan A, Wardojo W, Jepson P (1999) Investing in biodiversity: a review of Indonesia’s integrated conservation and development projects. The World Bank, Washington DCGoogle Scholar
  63. Wilkie DS, Carpenter JF (1999) Bushmeat hunting in the Congo Basin: an assessment of impacts and options for mitigation. Biodiversity and Conservation 8:927–955CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Wilkie DS, Starkey M, Abernethy K, Effa EN, Telfer P, Godoy R (2005) Role of prices and wealth in consumer demand for Bushmeat in Gabon, Central Africa. Conservation Biology 19:268–274CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. World Bank (2009a) Commodity price data (pink sheet). http://go.worldbank.org/2O4NGVQC00. Accessed 17 Sept 2009
  66. World Bank (2009b) Prospects for the global economy: commodity forecast. http://go.worldbank.org/9VQJ4ACJZ0 Accessed 17 Sept 2009
  67. Wunder S (2001) Poverty alleviation and tropical forests—what scope for synergies? World Development 29:1817–1833CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Wunder S (2005) Payments for environmental services: Some nuts and bolts. Occasional paper 42. Center for International Forestry Research, BogorGoogle Scholar
  69. Wunder S, Campbell B, Frost PGH, Sayer JA, Iwan R, Wollenberg L (2008) When donors get cold feet: the community conservation concession in Setulang (Kalimantan, Indonesia) that Never Happened. Ecology and Society 13:12. Online [http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol13/iss1/art12/]

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2012

Authors and Affiliations

  • Marieke Sandker
    • 1
  • Manuel Ruiz-Perez
    • 1
  • Bruce M. Campbell
    • 2
  1. 1.Autonomous University of Madrid (UAM)MadridSpain
  2. 2.Department of Agriculture and EcologyUniversity of Copenhagen, Challenge Program on Climate Change, Agriculture and Food Security (CCAFS)CopenhagenDenmark

Personalised recommendations