Environmental Management

, Volume 47, Issue 4, pp 573–583

Marine Protected Area Management in South Africa: New Policies, Old Paradigms

  • Merle Sowman
  • Maria Hauck
  • Lance van Sittert
  • Jackie Sunde
Article

Abstract

A historical perspective on MPA identification and governance in South Africa reflects the continued influence of a top-down and natural science-based paradigm, that has hardly changed over the past half century, despite the wealth of literature, and a growing consensus, that advocates the need to adopt a more integrated and human-centered approach. Based on extensive research in two coastal fishing communities, the paper highlights impacts and conflicts arising from this conventional approach to MPA identification, planning and management. It argues that failure to understand the particular fishery system in all its complexity, in particular the human dimensions, and involve resource users in planning and decision-making processes, undermines efforts to achieve conservation and fisheries management objectives. The customary rights of local resource users, and their food and livelihood needs in relation to marine resources, need to be acknowledged, prioritized and integrated into planning and decision-making processes. Convincing ecologists, fisheries scientists and managers, that MPA success depends on addressing the root causes of resource decline and incorporating social factors into MPA identification, planning and management, remains a huge challenge in South Africa.

Keywords

Marine protected areas South Africa Human dimensions Customary rights Social factors 

References

  1. Agardy MT (1994) Advances in marine conservation: the role of marine protected areas. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 9:267–270CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Alcala AC (2001) Marine reserves in the Philippines: historical development, effects and influences on marine conservation policy. The Bookmark Inc, Makati CityGoogle Scholar
  3. Anchor Environmental Consulting (2008) Olifants Estuary Situation Assessment. University of Cape Town, Cape TownGoogle Scholar
  4. Attwood CG, Harris JM, Williams J (1997a) International experience of Marine Protected Areas and their relevance to South Africa. South African Journal of Marine Science 18:311–332Google Scholar
  5. Attwood CG, Mann BQ, Beaumont J, Harris JM (1997b) Review of the state of marine protected areas in South Africa. South African Journal of Science 18:341–367Google Scholar
  6. Beaumont J (1997) Community participation in the establishment and management of Marine Protected Areas: a review of selected international experience. South African Journal of Marine Science 18:333–340Google Scholar
  7. Beinart W (2003) The rise of conservation in South Africa: settlers, livestock and the environment. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  8. Bewana A (2009) A re-assessment of the State of Marine Protected Areas Management in South Africa: 2008. MSc thesis, Department of Zoology, University of Cape Town, South AfricaGoogle Scholar
  9. Branch GM, Hauck M, Smith G (2007) Report of the rock lobster co-management compliance workshop, 22 January 2007. University of Cape TownGoogle Scholar
  10. Brechin S, Wilshusen P, Fortwangler C, West P (eds) (2003) Contested nature: promoting international biodiversity and social justice in the twenty-first century. State University of New York Press, AlbanyGoogle Scholar
  11. Carruthers J (1989) The creation of a national park, 1910 to 1926. Journal of Southern African Studies 15:188–216CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Charles T, Wilson L (2009) Human dimensions on marine protected area management. ICES Journal of Marine Science 66:6–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Christie P, White AT (2007) Best practices in governance and enforcement of marine protected areas: an overview. In: FAO expert workshop on marine protected areas and fisheries management: review of issues and considerations. FAO, Rome, pp 183–220Google Scholar
  14. Christie P, McCay BJ, Miller ML, Lowe C, White AT, Stoffle R, Fluharty DL, McManus LT, Chuenpagdee R, Pomeroy C, Suman DO, Blount BG, Huppert D, Eisma R-LV, Orac E, Lowry K, Pollnac RB (2003) Toward developing a complete understanding: a social science research agenda for Marine Protected Areas. Fisheries 28:22–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Cram D (1981) Hidden elements in the development and implementation of marine resource conservation policy: the case of the South West African/Namibian fisheries. In: Glantz MH, Thompson JD (eds) Resource management and environmental uncertainty: lessons from coastal upwelling fisheries. Wiley, New York, pp 137–156Google Scholar
  16. DEAT (Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism) (2004) Notice of intention to declare the Cape Peninsula marine protected area under Section 43 of the Marine Living Resources Act, 18 of 1998. Department of Environmental Affairs and TourismGoogle Scholar
  17. DEAT (Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism) (2008) Recreational fishing information brochure. Marine and Coastal Management Branch, Cape TownGoogle Scholar
  18. Driver A, Maze K, Rouget M, Lombard AT, Nel J, Turpie JK, Cowling RM, Desmet P, Goodman P, Harris J, Jonas Z, Reyers B, Sink K, Strauss T (2005) National Spatial Biodiversity Assessment 2004: priorities for biodiversity conservation in South Africa. Strelitzia 17. South African National Biodiversity Institute, PretoriaGoogle Scholar
  19. Edwards CTT, Rademeyer RA, Butterworth DS, Plagányi EE (2008) Investigating the consequences of Marine Protected Areas for the South African deep-water hake (Merluccius paradoxus) resource. ICES Journal of Marine Science 66:72–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Emanuel BP, Bustamante RH, Branch GM, Eekhout S, Odendaal FJ (1992) A zoogeographic and functional approach to the selection of marine reserves on the west coast of South Africa. South African Journal of Marine Science 12:341–354Google Scholar
  21. Grove R (1989) Scottish missionaries, evangelical discourses and the origins of conservation thinking in southern Africa. Journal of Southern African Studies 15:22–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Hauck M (2009) Rethinking small-scale fisheries compliance: from criminal justice to social justice. PhD thesis, University of Cape Town, South AfricaGoogle Scholar
  23. Hauck M, Kroese M (2006) Fisheries compliance in South Africa: a decade of challenges and reform 1994–2004. Marine Policy 30(1):74–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Hauck M, Sowman M (2005) Coastal and fisheries co-management in South Africa: is there an enabling legal environment. South African Journal of Environmental Law and Policy 12(1):1–21Google Scholar
  25. Hilborn R, Stokes K, Maguire J-J, Smith T, Botsford LW, Mangel M, Orensanz J, Parma A, Rice J, Bell J, Cochrane KL, Garcia S, Hall SJ, Kirkwood GP, Sainsbury K, Stefansson G, Walters C (2004) When can marine reserves improve fisheries management? Ocean and Coastal Management 47:197–205CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Hockey PAR, Branch GM (1997) Criteria, objectives and methodology for evaluating Marine Protected Areas in South Africa. South African Journal of Marine Science 18:369–383Google Scholar
  27. Isaacs M (2006) Small-scale fisheries reform: expectations, hopes and dreams of ‘a better life for all’. Marine Policy 30(1):51–59CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Jones PJS (2006) Collective action problems posed by no take zones. Marine Policy 30(2):143–156CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Jones PJS (2009) Equity, justice and power issues raised by no-take marine protected area proposals. Marine Policy 33:759–765CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Kaiser MJ (2005) Are marine protected areas a red herring or fisheries panacea? Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 62(5):1194–1199CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Kearney J (2005) Community-based fisheries management in the Bay of Fundy: sustaining communities through resistance and hope. In: Child B, Lyman MW (eds) Natural resources as community assets: lessons from two continents. Aspen Institute, Washington, DC, pp 83–100Google Scholar
  32. Kolding J (2006) MPAs in relation to fisheries—what are the biological and fish stock implications? Paper presented at the Norwegian Fisheries Forum, 24–26 October 2006Google Scholar
  33. Laffoley D (ed) (2008) Towards networks of Marine Protected Areas. The MPA plan of action for IUCN’s world commission on protected areas. IUCN WCPA, GlandGoogle Scholar
  34. Lemm S, Attwood C (2003) State of marine protected area management in South Africa. WWF, South AfricaGoogle Scholar
  35. McClanahan TR, Cinner AT, Kamukuru AT, Abunge C, Ndagala J (2009a) Management preferences, perceived benefits and conflicts among resource users and managers in the Mafia Island Marine Park, Tanzania. Environmental Conservation 35(4):340–350CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. McClanahan TR, Castilla JC, White A, Defeo O (2009b) Healing small-scale fisheries by facilitating complex social-ecological systems. Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries 19(1):33–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Melville-Smith R, van Sittert L (2005) Historical west coast rock lobster (Jasus lalandii) landings in South African waters. African Journal of Marine Science 27:33–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Moorsom R (1984) A future for Namibia: fishing exploiting the sea. CIIR, LondonGoogle Scholar
  39. Nursey-Bray M, Rist P (2009) Co-management and protected area management: achieving effective management of a contested site, lessons from the Great Barrier Reef World Heritage Area (GBRWHA). Marine Policy 33:118–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Parkington J (1977) Soaqua: hunter-fisher-gatherers of the Olifants River Valley Western Cape. South African Archeological Bulletin 32:150–157CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Pinkerton E, Weinstein M (1995) Fisheries that work: sustainability through community-based management. David Suzuki Foundation, Vancouver, 199 ppGoogle Scholar
  42. Pollnac RB, Crawford BR, Urdal BT (2001) Discovering factors that influence the success of community-based marine protected areas in the Visayas, Philippines. Ocean and Coastal Management 44:683–710CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Pomeroy R, Mascia M, Pollnac R (2007) Marine protected areas: the social dimensions. In: FAO expert workshop on marine protected areas and fisheries management: review of issues and considerations. FAO, Rome, pp 149–275Google Scholar
  44. Probart (1915) Report by Mr Probart, Supt. Namaqualand Communal Reserves on his inspection at Ebenezer and Doornkraal to obtain information for the Native Affairs DepartmentGoogle Scholar
  45. Province of the Cape of Good Hope Official Gazette no. 1529 (1934) Proclamation 139, 14 September 1934Google Scholar
  46. Reitz D (1929) Commando, a Boer journal of the Boer War. Faber, LondonGoogle Scholar
  47. Republic of South Africa (1972) Report by the select committee on charges by members (Sc3-72). Government Printer, Pretoria, 266 ppGoogle Scholar
  48. Republic of South Africa (1975) Commission of inquiry into allegations of improper conduct made against the Honourable Mr Justice Frederik Simon Steyn (RP16-1975). Government Printer, Pretoria, 36 ppGoogle Scholar
  49. Robinson GA (1992) Benguela upwelling: how does it affect South Africa’s conservation philosophy? South African Journal of Marine Science 12:1063–1067Google Scholar
  50. Ruddle K, Hickey FR (2008) Accounting for the mismanagement of tropical nearshore fisheries. Environment, Development and Sustainability 10:565–589CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Schoeman BM (1980) Die Geldmag: Suid-Afrika se Onsigbare Regering. Aktuele Publikasies, PretoriaGoogle Scholar
  52. Sowman M, Beaumont J, Bergh M, Maharaj G, Salo K (1997) An analysis of emerging co-management arrangements for the Olifants River Harder fishery, South Africa. Fisheries Co-management in Africa. In: Proceedings from a regional workshop on fisheries co-management research, Boadzulu Lakeshore Resort, Mangochi, Malawi, from 18–20 March, Research Report 12, p 326Google Scholar
  53. Sunde J (2004) We want to be heard, enough is enough: a report on the Fisher Human Rights Hearings held in Kalk Bay 13–14 August 2004. Masifundise, Unpublished Report, Observatory, Cape TownGoogle Scholar
  54. Sunde J, Isaacs M (2008) Marine conservation and coastal communities…who carries the costs? A study of Marine Protected Areas and their impact on traditional small-scale fisher communities in South Africa. Document prepared for the International Collective in Support of FishworkersGoogle Scholar
  55. UNEP-WCMC (2008) National and regional networks of marine protected areas: a review of progress. UNEP-WCMC, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  56. van Sittert L (1993a) Making like America: the industrialisation of the St Helena Bay fisheries, 1936–1956. Journal of Southern African Studies 19:442–464Google Scholar
  57. van Sittert L (1993b) More in the breach than in the observance: crayfish, conservation and capitalism. Environmental History Review 17:21–46Google Scholar
  58. van Sittert L (1994) Red gold and black markets: the political economy of the illegal crayfish trade c.1890–c.1990. Department of History, University of Cape Town, South AfricaGoogle Scholar
  59. van Sittert L (2001) Velddrift: the making of a South African company town 1930–1960. Urban History 28:194–217Google Scholar
  60. van Sittert L (2002) Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it: comparing fisheries reforms in South Africa. Marine Policy 26:295–305CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. van Sittert L (2003a) The tyranny of the past: why local histories matter in the South African fisheries. Ocean and Coastal Management 46:199–219CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. van Sittert L (2003b) Making the Cape floral kingdom: the discovery and defence of indigenous flora at the Cape c. 1890–1939. Landscape Research 28:113–129CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. van Zyl D (2001) MCM internal memorandum regarding experimental fishing-knol at Hout Bay sanctuary. 7 August 2001Google Scholar
  64. White AT, Salamanca A, Courtney CA (2002) Experience with marine protected area planning and management in the Philippines. Coastal Management 30:1–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  • Merle Sowman
    • 1
  • Maria Hauck
    • 1
  • Lance van Sittert
    • 2
  • Jackie Sunde
    • 1
  1. 1.Environmental Evaluation Unit, Department of Environmental and Geographical ScienceUniversity of Cape TownCape TownSouth Africa
  2. 2.History Studies DepartmentUniversity of Cape TownCape TownSouth Africa

Personalised recommendations