Environmental Management

, Volume 38, Issue 5, pp 853–866 | Cite as

Expert Stakeholders’ Views on the Management of Human Pharmaceuticals in the Environment

Article

Abstract

Human pharmaceuticals are ubiquitous water contaminants that may have subtle detrimental effects on aquatic organisms, and possibly also on human health. The risks of pharmaceuticals, or pharmaceutically active compounds, remain poorly understood. Awareness of the presence of pharmaceuticals in the environment, coupled with evidence of effects such as fish feminization, however, suggest that precautionary management action to reduce the release of pharmaceuticals to the environment should be considered. The purpose of our study was to evaluate the scope of the issue and possible management strategies from the perspectives of expert stakeholders, drawn from government, academia, and the pharmaceutical and consulting industries, involved in scientific research or policy and management activity, from Canada, the United States, and Europe. Twenty-seven interviewees were asked about their views on management strategies such as pharmaceutical-return programs and incentives for the development of “green” pharmaceuticals. Interviewees generally believed that pharmaceuticals in the environment represented a concern for both human and ecosystem health, although they were more concerned about impacts on aquatic ecosystems. They believed that advanced wastewater treatment technology, education of medical professionals to reduce overprescription, pharmaceutical-return programs coupled with public education, and requirements for all municipalities to have a minimum of secondary wastewater treatment were the most effective management strategies to reduce the environmental impacts of pharmaceuticals. These strategies should be considered by governments interested in managing the risks of human pharmaceuticals in the environment. Combinations of management strategies will likely be most effective in mitigating the risks presented by pharmaceuticals.

Keywords

Pharmaceuticals Risk management Environment Interviews Stakeholders Water Aquatic ecosystem 

References

  1. Balcýoðu I. A., M. Ötker. 2003. Treatment of pharmaceutical wastewater containing antibiotics by O3 and O3/H2O2 processes. Chemosphere 50:85–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Barnes K. K., S. C. Christenson, D. W. Kolpin, M. J. Focazio, E. T. Furlong, S. D. Zaugg, M. T. Meyer, L. B. Barber. 2004. Pharmaceuticals and other organic waste water contaminants within a leachate plume downgradient of a municipal landfill. Ground Water Monitoring Remed 24:119–126Google Scholar
  3. Boxall A. B. A., P. Blackwell, R. Cavallo, P. Kay, J. Tolls. 2002. The sorption and transport of a sulphonamide antibiotic in soil systems. Toxicol Lett 131:19–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Boyd G. R., H. Reemtsma, G. A. Grimm, S. Mitra. 2003. Pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) in surface and treated waters of Louisiana, USA and Ontario, Canada. Science Total Envir 311:135–149CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Brain R. A., D. J. Johnson, S. M. Richards, M. L. Hanson, H. Sanderson, M. W. Lam, C. Young, S. A. Mabury, P. K. Sibley, K. R. Solomon. 2004. Microcosm evaluation of the effects of an eight pharmaceutical mixture to the aquatic macrophytes Lemna gibba and Myriophyllum sibiricum. Aquat Toxicol 70:23–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Canadian Standards Association. 1997. CAN/CSA-Q850-97: Risk management: a guideline for decision-makers, Etobicoke, Ontario, 45 ppGoogle Scholar
  7. Carballa M., F. Omil, J. M. Lema, M. Llompart, C. García-Jares, I. Rodríguez, M. Gómez, T. Ternes. 2004. Behavior of pharmaceuticals, cosmetics and hormones in a sewage treatment plant. Water Res 38:2918–2926CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. CEPA. 1999. Canadian Environmental Protection Act. The House of Commons of Canada, Bill C-32, as passed by the House of Commons, June 1, 1999Google Scholar
  9. Christensen F. M. 1998. Pharmaceuticals in the environment—a human risk? Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 28:212–221CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Cleuvers M. 2003. Aquatic ecotoxicity of pharmaceuticals including the assessment of combination effects. Toxicol Lett 142:185–194CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Cordy G. E., N. L. Duran, H. Bower, R. C. Rice, E. T. Furlong, S. D. Zaugg, M. T. Meyer, L. B. Barber, D. W. Kolpin. 2004. Do pharmaceuticals, pathogens, and other organic waste water compounds persist when waste water is used for recharge? Ground Water Monitoring Remed 24:58–69Google Scholar
  12. Covello V. T. 1989. Informing people about risks from chemicals, radiation, and other toxic substances: a review of obstacles to public understanding and effective risk communication. In Leiss W. (ed.), Prospects and problems in risk communication. University of Waterloo Press, Waterloo, Pages 1–49Google Scholar
  13. CPMP. 2001. Discussion paper on environmental risk assessment of non-genetically modified organisms (non-GMO) containing medicinal products for human use. CPMP/SWP/4447/00, Committee for Proprietary Medicinal Products, London, UK, 9 ppGoogle Scholar
  14. Datta L-e. 1997. A pragmatic basis for mixed-method designs. In Greene J. C., Caracelli V. J. (eds.), Advances in mixed-method evaluation: the challenges and benefits of integrating diverse paradigms. New directions for evaluation. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, Pages 33–46Google Scholar
  15. Daughton C. G., T. A. Ternes. 1999. Pharmaceuticals and personal care products in the environment: Agents of subtle change? Envir Health Perspect 107: 907–938Google Scholar
  16. Daughton C. G. 2003a. Cradle-to-cradle stewardship of drugs for minimizing their environmental disposition while promoting human health—Part 1: Rationale and avenues toward a green pharmacy. Envir Health Perspect 111:757–774CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Daughton C. G. 2003b. Cradle-to-cradle stewardship of drugs for minimizing their environmental disposition while promoting human health. II. Drug disposal, waste reduction, and future directions. Envir Health Perspect 111:775–785CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Daughton C. G. 2004. PPCPs in the environment: Future research—beginning with the end always in mind. In K. Kümmerer (ed.), Pharmaceuticals in the environment. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Pages 463–495Google Scholar
  19. Dizer H., B. Fischer, I. Sepulveda, E. Loffredo, N. Senesi, F. Santana, P. D. Hansen. 2002. Estrogenic effect of leachates and soil extracts from lysimeters spiked with sewage sludge and reference endocrine disrupters. Envir Toxicol 17:105–112CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Doerr-MacEwen N. A., M. E. Haight. 2005. Tailoring the precautionary principle to pharmaceuticals in the environment: accounting for experts’ concerns. In A. G. Kungolos, C. A. Brebbia, E. Beriatos (eds.), Sustainable development and planning II (vol. 1). WIT Press, Southampton, Pages 281–291Google Scholar
  21. Eckel W. P., B. Ross, R. K. Isensee. 1993. Pentobarbital found in ground water. Ground Water 31:801–804CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. FDA. 1998. Guidance for industry: Environmental Assessment of human drug and biologics applications. Government of the United States of America, 33 ppGoogle Scholar
  23. Fisher P. M. J., R. Borland. 2003. Gauging the pharmaceutical burden on Sydney’s environment: a preventative response. J Cleaner Production 11:315–320CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Fong P. P. 1998. Zebra mussel spawning is induced in low concentrations of putative serotonin reuptake inhibitors. Biol Bull 194:143–149Google Scholar
  25. Fong P. P. 2001. Antidepressants in aquatic organisms: a wide range of effects. In C. G. Daughton, T. L. Jones-Lepp (eds.), Pharmaceuticals and personal care products in the environment: scientific and regulatory issues. American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, PP 264–281Google Scholar
  26. Golet E. M., I. Xifra, H. Siegrist, A. C. Alder, W. Giger. 2003. Environmental exposure assessment of fluoroquinolone antibacterial agents from sewage to soil. Envir Sci Technol 37:32–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Government of British Columbia. 1997. Waste management act: Post-consumer residual stewardship program regulation. B.C. Reg. 111/97, O.C. 333/97Google Scholar
  28. Greene J. C., V. J. Caracelli. 1997. Defining and describing the paradigm issue in mixed-method evaluation. In J. C. Greene, V. J. Caracelli (eds.), Advances in mixed-method evaluation: the challenges and benefits of integrating diverse paradigms. New directions for evaluation. Jossey-Bass Publishers, San Francisco, Pages 5–18Google Scholar
  29. Greene J. C., V. J. Caracelli, W. F. Graham. 1989. Toward a conceptual framework for mixed-method evaluation designs. Educ Eval Policy Analysis 11:255–274CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Greiner P., I. Rönnefahrt. 2003. Management of environmental risks in the life cycle of pharmaceuticals. Envirapharma, LyonGoogle Scholar
  31. Guardabassi L., A. Petersen, J. E. Olsen, A. Dalsgaard. 1998. Antibiotic resistance in Acinetobacter spp. isolated from sewers receiving waste effluent from a hospital and a pharmaceutical plant. Appl Envir Microbiol 64:3499–3502Google Scholar
  32. Health Canada. 2002. Health Canada to require environmental assessments of products regulated under the Food and Drug Act. http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/english/media/releases/2001.2001_98e.htm
  33. Health Canada. 2003. Environmental assessment regulations: final issue identification paper. http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/ear-ree/final_issue_id_2_e.html
  34. Heberer T. 2002. Occurrence, fate, and removal of pharmaceutical residues in the aquatic environment: a review of recent research data. Toxicol Lett 131:5–17CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Heberer T., D. Feldmann, K. Reddersen, H. Altmann, T. Zimmerman. 2002. Production of drinking water from highly contaminated surface waters: Removal of organic, inorganic, and microbial contaminants applying mobile membrane filtration units. Acta Hydrochim Hydrobiol 30:24–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Heberer T., K. Schmidt-Bäumier, H. J. Stan. 1998. Occurrence and distribution of organic contaminants in the aquatic system in Berlin. Part 1: Drug residues and other polar contaminants in Berlin surface and groundwater. Acta Hydrochim Hydrobiol 26:272–278CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Holm J. V., K. Rugger, P. L. Bjerg, T. H. Christensen. 1995. Occurrence and distribution of pharmaceutical organic compounds in the groundwater downgradient of a landfill (Grinsted, Denmark). Envir Sci Technol 29:1415–1420CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Holtz S. 2006. There is no “away”. Pharmaceuticals, personal care products, and endocrine-disrupting substances: emerging contaminants detected in water. Canadian Institute for Environmental Law and Policy, Toronto, 94 ppGoogle Scholar
  39. Jobling S., M. Nolan, C. R. Tyler, G. Brightly, J. P. Sumpter. 1998 Widespread sexual disruption in wild fish. Envir Sci Technol 32:2498–2506CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Kinney C. A., E. T. Furlong, S. L. Werner, J. D. Cahill. 2006. Presence and distribution of wastewater-derived pharmaceuticals in soil irrigated with reclaimed water. Envir Toxicol Chem 25:317–326CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Kolpin D. W., E. T. Furlong, M. T. Meyer, M. E. Thurman, S. D. Zaugg, L. B. Barber, H. T. Buxton. 2002. Pharmaceuticals, hormones, and other organic wastewater contaminants in U.S. streams, 1999–2000: A national reconnaissance. Envir Sci Technol 36:1202–1211CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Krosnick J. A., L. R. Fabrigar. 1997. Designing rating scales for effective measurement in surveys. In L. Lyberg, P. Biemer, M. Collins, E. de Leeuw, C. Dippo, N. Schwarz, D. Trewin (eds.), Survey measurement and process quality. John Wiley & Sons, New York, Pages 141–164Google Scholar
  43. Larsen T. A., J. Lienert, A. Joss, H. Siegrist. 2004. How to avoid pharmaceuticals in the aquatic environment. J Biotechnol 113:295–304CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Larsson D. G. J., M. Adolfsson-Erici, J. Parkkonen, M. Pettersson, A. H. Berg, P. E., Olsson, L. Förlin. 1999. Ethinyloestradiol—an undesired fish contraceptive? Aquat Toxicol 45:91–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. McGarvin M. 2001. Science, precaution, facts and values. In T. O’ Riordan, J. Cameron, A. Jordan (eds.), Reinterpreting the precautionary principle. Cameron May, London, Pages 35–60Google Scholar
  46. Metcalfe C. D., X. S. Miao, B. Koenig, J. Struger. 2003. Distribution of acidic and neutral drugs in surface waters near sewage treatment plants in the lower Great Lakes, Canada. Envir Toxicol Chem 22:2881–2889CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Mittelstaedt M. 2003. Drug traces found in cities’ water. Page 1 in The Globe and Mail, February 10Google Scholar
  48. Morgan M. G., L. F. Pitelka, E. Shevliakova. 2001. Elicitation of expert judgments of climate change impacts on forest ecosystems. Climatic Change 49:279–307CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Oaks J. L., M. Gilbert, M. Virani, R. T. Watson, C. U. Meteyer, B. A. Rideout, H. L. Shaviprasad, S. Ahmed, M. J. I. Chaudhry, M. Arshad, S. Mahmood, A. Ali, A. A. Khan. 2004. Diclofenac residues as the cause of vulture population decline in Pakistan. Nature 427:630–633CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. O’Brien E., D. R. Dietrich. 2004.Hindsight rather than foresight: reality versus the EU draft guideline on pharmaceuticals in the environment. TRENDS Biotechnol 22:326–330CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. O’Connor D. R. 2002. Report of the Walkerton inquiry: the events of May 2000 and related issues, Part I. Government of Ontario, Toronto, 188 ppGoogle Scholar
  52. Purdom C. E., P. A. Hardiman, V. J. Bye, N. C. Eno, C. R. Tyler, J. R. Sumpter. 1994. Estrogenic effects of effluents from sewage treatment works. Chem Ecol 8:275–285Google Scholar
  53. Product Stewardship Institute. 2004a. PSI Pharmaceuticals Project. http://www.productstewardship.us/prod_pharm_project.html
  54. Product Stewardship Institute. 2004b. Household pharmaceutical waste: regulatory and management issues. San Francisco Department of the Environment. http://www.productstewardship.us/supportingdocs/Pharm_CAWasteMgmt.pdf
  55. Quijano R. F. 2003. Elements of the precautionary principle. In J. A. Tickner (ed.), Precaution, environmental science, and preventive public policy. Island Press, Washington, Pages 21–27Google Scholar
  56. Rönnefahrt I., J. Koschorreck, M. Kolossa-Gehring. 2003. Practical examples for risk management of pharmaceuticals in the framework of authorization, EnvirPharma, Lyon, FranceGoogle Scholar
  57. Sacher F., F. T. Lange, H. J. Brauch, I. Blankenhorn. 2001. Pharmaceuticals in groundwaters. Analytical methods and results of a monitoring program in Baden-Wurtemburg, Germany. J Chromatogr A 938:199–210CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Sanderson H., D. J. Johnson, C. J. Wilson, R. A. Brain, K. R. Solomon. 2003. Probabilistic hazards assessment of environmentally occurring pharmaceuticals: toxicity to fish, daphnids and algae by ECOSARS screening. Toxicol Lett 144:383–395CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Sanderson H., D. J. Johnson, T. Reitsma, R. A. Brain, C. J. Wilson, K. R. Solomon. 2004. Ranking and prioritization of environmental risks of pharmaceuticals in surface waters. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 39:158–183CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Schulman L. J., E. V. Sargent, B. D. Naumann, E. C. Faria, D. G. Dolan, J. P. Wargo. 2002. A human health risk assessment of pharmaceuticals in the aquatic environment. Hum Ecol Risk Assess 8:657–680Google Scholar
  61. Sedlak D. L., K. E. Pinkston. 2001. Factors affecting the concentrations of pharmaceuticals released to the aquatic environment. Water Resources Update 120:56–64Google Scholar
  62. SIGRE. 2002. Por la salud de la naturaleza: Memoria de actividades, 31 ppGoogle Scholar
  63. Slovic P. 1993. Perceived risk, trust, and democracy. Risk Analysis 13:675–682CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Stan H. J., T. Heberer, M. Linkerhagner. 1994. Vorkommen von Clofibrinsaure im aquatischen System—Fuhrt die therapeutische Anwendung zu einer Belastung von Oberflachen-, Grund- und Trinkwasser? Vom Vasser 79:57–68Google Scholar
  65. Stockholm läns landsting. 2005. Environmentally classified pharmaceuticals, Stockholm, 16 ppGoogle Scholar
  66. Stumpf M., T. A. Ternes, R. D. Wilken, S. V. Rodrigues, W. Baumann. 1999. Polar drug residues in sewage and natural waters in the state of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Sci Total Envir 225:135–141CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Ternes T. A. 1998 Occurrence of drugs in German sewage treatment plants and rivers. Water Res 32:3245–3260CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Ternes T. A., J. Stüber, N. Herrmann, D. McDowell, A. Ried, M. Kampmann, B. Teiser. 2003. Ozonation: a tool for removal of pharmaceuticals, contrast media and musk fragrances from wastewater? Water Res 37:1976–1982CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. The Presidential/Congressional Commission on Risk Assessment and Risk Management. 1997 Framework for environmental health risk management: final report, volume 1. US EPA, 70 ppGoogle Scholar
  70. United Nations General Assembly. 1992. Report of the United Nations conference on environment and development. A/CONF.151/26 Vol. I, Rio de Janeiro, 5 ppGoogle Scholar
  71. von Krauss M. P. K., E. A. Casman, M. J. Small. 2004. Elicitation of expert judgments of uncertainty in the risk assessment of herbicide-tolerant oilseed crops. Risk Analysis 24:1515–1527CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Webb S., T. A. Ternes, M. Gibert, K. Olejniczak. 2003. Indirect human exposure to pharmaceuticals via drinking water. Toxicol Lett 142:157–167CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Wennmalm Å. 2003. Management of pharmaceutical drug residues from public health care in Stockholm County Council, Envirpharma Conference, LyonGoogle Scholar
  74. Westerhoff P., Y. Yoon, S. A. Snyder, E. Wert. 2005. Fate of endocrine-disruptors, pharmaceutical, and personal care product chemicals during simulated drinking water treatment processes. Envir Sci Technol 39:6649–6663CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Weterings R. A. P. M., J. C. M. Van Eijndhoven. 1989. Informing the public about uncertain risks. Risk Analysis 9:473–482CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Wiegel S., A. Aulinger, R. Brockmeyer, H. Harms, J. Löffler, H. Reincke, R. Schmidt, B. Stachel, W. von Tümpling, A. Wanke. 2004. Pharmaceuticals in the river Elbe and its tributaries. Chemosphere 57:107–126CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Wiener J. B., M. D. Rogers. 2002. Comparing precaution in the United States and Europe. J Risk Res 5:317–349CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Wilson B. A., V. H. Smith, F. J. Denoyelles, C. K. Larive. 2003. Effects of three pharmaceutical and personal care products on natural freshwater algal assemblages. Envir Sci Technol 37:1713–1719CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Wolf L., I. Held, M. Eiswirth, H. Hötzl. 2004. Impact of leaky sewers on groundwater quality. Acta Hydrochim Hydrobiol 32:361–373CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Zwiener C., F. H. Frimmel. 2000. Oxidative treatment of pharmaceuticals in water. Water Research 34:1881–1885CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.School of PlanningUniversity of WaterlooWaterlooCanada

Personalised recommendations