Environmental Management

, Volume 35, Issue 3, pp 311–329 | Cite as

Toward Environmental Management Systems in Australian Agriculture to Achieve Better Environmental Outcomes at the Catchment Scale

A Review

Abstract

Environmental Management Systems (EMS) are being trialed for Australian agricultural industries as society becomes more concerned about agriculture’s environmental performance. EMS is a structured approach used by farm businesses to assess, monitor, and improve environmental performance. Use of EMS in conjunction with other policy tools (such as financial incentives and regulation) in agriculture could enhance management of both on-farm and off-farm environmental issues. Based on the international standard ISO14001, EMS was designed to be applied at the individual business level. However, governments in Australia are exploring its potential to be applied at a catchment scale, among other things, for the purpose of linking farm-level actions to catchment targets. In Australia, governments and catchment management bodies are using Integrated Catchment Management (ICM) as the framework to try to achieve environmental targets set out in catchment plans. In this article, we compare aspects of the EMS and ICM frameworks and comment on the potential of using EMS to achieve catchment-scale environmental outcomes. We conclude that EMS could be a useful policy tool to improve farm management and to contribute, in part, to better off-site outcomes at the catchment/landscape scale. Recommendations on the use of EMS at the catchment scale are discussed. These include using an educational approach for EMS delivery, linking the EMS process to catchment targets, and ensuring catchment targets are realistic and achievable.

Keywords

Catchment management Environmental policy Natural resource management 

Notes

Acknowledgments

The authors are thankful for the helpful comments and information provided by Harold Rudy (Ontario Crop Improvement Association). Thanks to Shayne Annett and Mark Allaway (Department of Primary Industries, East Melbourne) for their comments regarding ICM in Victoria.

Literature Cited

  1. ABS (Australian Bureau of Statistics). 2000. Available at http://www.abs.gov.au
  2. Allen, W., Bosch, O., Kilvington, M., Oliver, J., Gilbert, M. 2001Benefits of collaborative learning for environmental management: Applying the integrated systems for knowledge management approach to support animal pest controlEnvironmental Management27215223CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  3. Altham, W. J., Guerin, T. F. 1999Where does ISO14001 fit into the environmental regulatory frameworkAustralian Journal of Environmental Management68698Google Scholar
  4. ANAO (Australian National Audit Office). 1997. Commonwealth natural resource management and environment programs—Australia’s land, water and vegetation resources. The Auditor General, AGPS, Canberra, Australia. Available at http://audit.ea.gov.au/ANRA/
  5. ASEC (Australian State of the Environment Committee). 2001. Australia State of the Environment 2001: Independent Report to the Commonwealth Minister for the Environment and Heritage. Commonwealth of Australia, Environment Australia, CanberraGoogle Scholar
  6. AS/NZS (Australian/New Zealand Standard). 1996. Environmental Management Systems—general guidelines on principles, systems and supporting techniques. AS/NZS ISO14004:1996. Standard Australia, Homebush NSW and Standards New Zealand, Wellington, New ZealandGoogle Scholar
  7. Ashton, P. 1999. LEAF—promoting integrated crop management (ICM). Pages 180–183 in Proceedings of the Environmental Management Systems in Agriculture Workshop, 26–28 May 1999, Ballina NSW. RIRDC Publication No 99/94. Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation, Kingston, ACT. Available at http://www.rirdc.gov.au/ems/index.html
  8. Banney, S. 2001. Beef property EMS is pilot for the industry. Australian Farm Journal 11(9):10–13. Available at http://www.australianfarmjournal.com/Google Scholar
  9. Bates, G. 2003

    Legal Perspectives

    Dovers, S. eds. Managing Australia’s environmentThe Federation PressAnnandale NSW, Australia255301
    Google Scholar
  10. Bellamy, J. A., Johnson, A. K. L. 2000Integrated resource management: moving from rhetoric to practice in Australian agricultureEnvironmental Management25265280CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  11. Bennett, D. 2002

    Community-based ICM: problem solver or social movement?

    Graham, T. W.Pannell, D. J.White, B. eds. Dryland salinity: Economic issues at farm, catchment and policy levels. Cooperative Research Centre for Plant-Based Management of Dryland SalinityUniversity of Western AustraliaPerth, Australia205220
    Google Scholar
  12. Bond, E., S. Cadman, N. Carey, and M. Hart. 2001. Tasmanian experiences in implementing QA/EMS to supply export markets. In Environmental Management Systems in Agriculture Conference, 6–8 November, Ballina, NSW, AustaliaGoogle Scholar
  13. Bosch, O. J. H., W. J. Allen, and R. S. Gibson. 1996. Monitoring is an integral part of management and policy making. Pages 12–21 in Proceedings of Symposium “Resource Management: Issues, Visions, Practice,” 5–8 July 1996, Lincoln University, New ZealandGoogle Scholar
  14. Campbell, A. 2000

    Formenting synergy: Experiences with facilitating Landcare in Australia

    Roling, N. G.Wagemakers, M. A. E. eds. Facilitating sustainable agriculture: Participatory learning and adaptive management in times of environmental uncertaintyCambridge University PressCambridge232249
    Google Scholar
  15. Carruthers, G., and S. Murray. 1999. Environmental management systems and agriculture: How can they be applied and what are the benefits? In G. Carruthers and G. Tinning (eds.) Proceedings, Production and Environmental Monitoring Workshop, 17–19 March 1999. University of New England, Armidale, NSW. RIRDC Publication No. 99/94. Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation, Kingston, ACT. Available at http://www.rirdc.gov.au/ems/index.html
  16. Carruthers, G., Tinning, G. 2003Where, and how, do monitoring and sustainability indicators fit into environmental management systems? Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture43307323CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Cary, J., T. Webb, and N. Barr. 2002. Understanding landholders’ capacity to change to sustainable practices; insights about practice adoption and social capacity for change. Bureau of Rural Sciences, Canberra. Available at http://www.affa.gov.au/output/ruralscience.html
  18. Cocks, D. 1994Use with care: Managing Australia’s natural resources in the twenty first centuryUniversity of New South Wales PressSydney, AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  19. Coglianese, C., and J. Nash. 2001. Regulating from the inside: Can Environmental Management Systems achieve policy goals? In C. Coglianese and J. Nash (eds.). Resources for the future. Washington DC.Google Scholar
  20. Cole, A., Harris, J. 2003Eco-labelling, credence attributes and the role of governmentDepartment of Primary IndustriesVictoria, AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  21. Cotton Australia. 2003. Best Management Practices. Available at http://www.cottonaustralia.com.au/bmpindex.html) (Accessed October 22, 2003)
  22. Crabb, P. 2003

    Straddling boundaries: Intergovernmental arrangements for managing natural resources

    Dovers, S.Wild River, S. eds. Managing Australia’s environmentThe Federation PressAnnandale, NSW, Australia229254
    Google Scholar
  23. Curtis, A. 2003

    The Landcare experience

    Dovers, S.Wild River, S. eds. Managing Australia’s environmentThe Federation PressAnnandale, NSW, Australia442460
    Google Scholar
  24. DAFF (Department of Agriculture, Fisheries & Forestry Australia). 2004. Environmental Management Systems National Pilot Program. Available at http://www.daff.gov.au/ems
  25. Dore, J., Woodhill, J., Andrews, K., Keating, C. 2003

    Sustainable regional development: Lessons from Australian efforts

    Dovers, S.Wild River, S. eds. Managing Australia’s environmentThe Federation PressAnnandale, NSW, Australia154180
    Google Scholar
  26. Douglas, J., T. Gleeson, and C. Turner. 2002. An Australian Landcare Management System. Synapse Research and Consulting, Brisbane, Queensland. Available at http://www.synapseconsulting.com.au/docs/alms
  27. DLWC (Department of Land and Water Conservation). 2001. Murray Catchment Management Plan Draft: A blueprint for action, October 2001. Department of Land and Water Conservation, NSW. Available at http://www.murraycmc. org.au/
  28. EU (European Union). 2000. European Commission web-site Available at http://www.europa.eu.int/en/ comm/eurostat
  29. Ewing, S. 2003

    Catchment management arrangements

    Dovers, S.Wild River, S. eds. Managing Australia’s environmentThe Federation PressAnnandale, NSW, Australia393412
    Google Scholar
  30. Fraser, I., Hone, P. 2002Development and implementation of Agri-Environmental Policy: English experience and lessons for AustraliaAustralian Journal of Environmental Management9228242Google Scholar
  31. Gunningham, N., Sinclair, D. 2002Leaders and laggards: Next generation environmental regulationGreenleaf Publishing LimitedSheffield, UKGoogle Scholar
  32. Harding, R., Traynor, D. 2003

    Informing ESD: State of the environment reporting

    Dovers, S.Wild River, S. eds. Managing Australia’s environmentThe Federation PressAnnandale, NSW, Australia181228
    Google Scholar
  33. HRSCEH (House of Representatives Standing Committee on Environment and Heritage). 2000. Coordinating Catchment Management: Report of the inquiry into catchment management. Canberra: Parliament of Australia. Available at http://www.aph.gov.au/house/committee/environ/cminq/cmirpt/contents.htm
  34. ISO. 2000. The ISO survey of ISO 9000 and 14000 Certificates Tenth Cycle. Available at http://www.iso.ch/iso/en/iso9000-14000/pdf/survey10thcycle.pdfGoogle Scholar
  35. Johnson, A., Shrubsole, D., Merrin, M. 1996Integrated Catchment Management in Northern Australia: From concept to implementationLand Use Policy13303316CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Kingma O., and W. Musgrave. 2003 Pages 501 514 in S. Dovers and S. Wild River (eds.) Managing Australia’s environment The Federation Press Annandale, NSW, AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  37. Kolb, D. A. 1984Experimental learning: Experience as the source of learning and developmentPrentice-HallEnglewood Cliffs, New JerseyGoogle Scholar
  38. Lawrence, D. N., P. Carberry, S. T. Cawley, J. A. Doughton, and D. Herridge. 2001. Success factors for participatory farming systems projects, field notes from the north. Proceedings 10th Australian Agronomy Conference, Hobart, January 2001Google Scholar
  39. Lang, R. eds. 1990Integrated approaches to resource planning and management. The Banff Centre, School of ManagementUniversity of Calgary PressCalgary, CanadaGoogle Scholar
  40. LEAF (Linking Environment and Farming). 2003. About the LEAF organisation. The National Centre, Warwickshire, UK. Available at http://www.leafuk.org/
  41. Lockie, S., Lyons, K., Lawrence, G., Mummery, K. 2002Eating ‘green’: motivations behind organic food consumption in AustraliaSociologia Ruralis422238Google Scholar
  42. MacFarlane, G., Trewick, K. 2002Environmental Best Management Practice on farms—Workbooks 1 and 2Department of Natural Resources & EnvironmentGeelong, VictoriaGoogle Scholar
  43. MDBMC (Murray Darling Basin Ministerial Council). 2000. Draft Integrated Catchment Management in the Murray Darling Basin. Murray Darling Basin Ministerial Council. Canberra, AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  44. Mech, T., and J. Young. 2001. VEMA’s Voluntary Environmental Management Arrangements: Designing voluntary environmental management arrangements to improve natural resource management in agriculture and allied rural industries. Policy and Economic Research Unit, CSIRO Land & Water. RIRDC Publication No 01/139. Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation, Kingston, ACT. Available at http://www.rirdc.gov.au/reports/Ras/CSL_ 15A.pdf
  45. Mech, T. 2002. Overcoming institutional barriers to EMS implementation in agriculture. In OECD conference: Environmental Management Systems: From Implementation to Communication. March 2002, Salsomaggiore, ItalyGoogle Scholar
  46. Mech, T., Lowe, K., Cole, A. 2003Land stewardship and Environmental Management SystemsDepartment of Sustainability and EnvironmentVictoria, AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  47. Metzenbaum, S. 2001

    Information, environmental performance, and Environmental Management Systems

    Coglianese, C.Nash, J. eds. Regulating from the inside: Can Environmental Management Systems achieve policy goals?Resources for the FutureWashington, DC146180
    Google Scholar
  48. Mitchell, B., Hollick, M. 1993Integrated Catchment Management in Western Australia: Transition from concept to implementationEnvironmental Management17735743Google Scholar
  49. MLA (Meat and Livestock Australia)2002Review—On-farm QA in the Australian Livestock Sector: Summary reportMeat and Livestock Australia Limited, Sydney NSW. Meat and LivestockAustraliaGoogle Scholar
  50. Morelli, J. 1999Voluntary environmental management: The inevitable futureLewis PublishersNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  51. Morrison, J., Cushing, K., Day, Z., Speir, J. 2000Managing a better environment: Opportunities and obstacles for ISO14001 in public policy and commerceReport of the Pacific Institute for Studies in Development, Environment and SecurityOakland, CaliforniaGoogle Scholar
  52. NHT (Natural Heritage Trust). 2003. Environmental Management Systems National Pilot Program. Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry, Canberra. Available at http://www.daff.gov.au/EMS
  53. Nimmo-Bell and Company Limited. 1999. Evaluation of the Focus Farm and Orchard Programme. Commissioned by MAF Policy and Ministry for the Environment, MAF Policy Technical Paper 99/6, New Zealand, June 1999Google Scholar
  54. NSW DPI (New South Wales Department of Primary Industries). 2004. NSW Agriculture and Catchment Management. NSW Department of Primary Industries. Available at http://www.agric.nsw.gov.au/reader/14224
  55. OFEC (Ontario Farm Environmental Coalition). 1996. Ontario Environmental Farm Plan, 2nd ed. Ontario Farm Environmental Coalition, Toronto, Canada. Available at http://www.gov.on.ca/OMAFRA/english/environment/efp/efp.htm
  56. Productivity Commission. 2002. Productivity Commission submission to the Environmental Management Systems Working Group: Towards a National Framework for the Development of Environmental Management Systems in Agriculture. CanberraGoogle Scholar
  57. Rhodes, H. M., Leland, L. S., Niven, B. E. 2002Farmers, streams, information, and money: Does informing farmers about riparian management have any effect? Environmental Management30665677CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  58. Ricegrowers Association of Australia. 2002. How you become the most efficient rice grower in the world. Rice Growers Association, Leeton NSW, Australia. Available: http://www.rga.org.au/environment/champions.asp
  59. Ridley, A. M. 2001. Towards Environmental Management Systems in broad-acre agriculture: rhetoric, reality and future possibilities. In Proceedings 10th Australian Agronomy Conference. Hobart, January 2001Google Scholar
  60. Ridley, A., Paramore, T., Beverly, C., Dunin, F., Froelich, V. 2003aDeveloping environmental monitoring tools from sustainability indicators in the southern RiverinaAustralian Journal of Experimental Agriculture43271284CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Ridley, A., Paramore, T., Seymour, E. 2003bTowards ‘clean and green’ farming systems using group learning to implement Environmental Management SystemsAustralian Journal of Botany5119CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Röling, N. 1993Agricultural knowledge and environmental regulation in the NetherlandsSociologia Ruralis33261280Google Scholar
  63. Rudy, H. 2002Australian Environmental Management Systems—A Canadian’s perspectiveOntario Soil and Crop Improvement Association. Report to the Grains Research and Development CorporationCanberra, AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  64. SCNRMMC (Standing Committee to the Natural Resource Management Ministerial Council). 2002. Australia’s National Framework for Environmental Management Systems (EMS) in Agriculture. Natural Resource Management Standing Committee Report 1. Available at http://www.affa.gov.au/content/ems_navigator
  65. Stoneham, G., A. Ha, V. Chaudhri, and L. Strappazzon. (2002). Auctions for conservation contracts: An empirical examination of Victoria’s BushTender trial. In Conference of the Australian Agricultural Resource and Economics Society, Perth, Western AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  66. Taylor, L. 2001. Blue skies, red earth and a ‘green’ tick. In Proceedings Environmental Management Systems in Agriculture Conference, 6–8 November Ballina NSW. Available at http://www.rirdc.gov.au/ems/index. html
  67. Thurlow, B., and B. Hamilton. 1997. Integrated catchment management in Western Australia. In Proceedings Second National Workshop on Integrated Catchment Management, Advancing Integrated Resource Management: Processes and Policies. Australian National University, River Basin Management Society, Canberra, AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  68. Tinning, G., and G. Carruthers. 2002. Develop your own EMS—A grain farming example. NSW Agriculture, Wollongbar, NSW, Australia. Available at http://www.agric.nsw.gov.au/reader/ems
  69. Twyford-Jones, P., L. Pahl, and R. Sharp. 2003. The Eco-Range project: can the market drive better environmental performance in agriculture? Proceedings 3rd National Conference on Environmental Management Systems in Agriculture 2003. Tanunda, South Australia. Available at http://www.pir.sa.gov.au/pages/rur_sol/ems/index6. htm
  70. USDANRCS (United States Department of Agriculture Natural Resources Conservation Service). 1997. Protecting your resources through a farm and home assessment. USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service, USDA Education & Extension Service, US EPA, Washington, DC. Available at http://www.uwex.edu/farmasyst
  71. US Almanac. 2000. Country statistics at a glance. Available at http://www.infoplease.com/almanac
  72. Vanclay, F., and G. Lawrence. 1994. Farmer rationality and the adoption of environmentally sound practices; a critique of the assumptions of traditional agricultural extension. European Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension 1(1). Available at http://library.wur.nl./ejae/
  73. VCMC (Victorian Catchment Management Council). 2003. Victoria’s Catchment Management Framework. Available at http://www.vcmc.vic.gov.au/Web/CatchmentManagementFramework.htm
  74. VCMC/DSE (Victorian Catchment Management Council/Department of Sustainability and Environment). 2003. Ecosystem services through land stewardship practices: issues and options. Department of Sustainability and Environment, Victoria, AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  75. White, M. E. 1997Listen our land is crying: Australia’s environment: problems and solutionsKangaroo Press Pty LtdKenthurst, NSW, AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  76. Wild River, S. 2003. Pages 338–362 in S. Dovers and S. Wild River (eds.) Managing Australia’s environment. The Federation Press, Annandale, NSW, AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  77. Williams, J., and H. Gascoigne. 2003. Redesign of plant production systems for Australian landscapes. In Proceedings of 11th Australian Agronomy Conference “Solutions for a better environment.” Geelong, Victoria, 2–6 FebruaryGoogle Scholar
  78. WorkCover Authority of NSW1998Code of Practice for the safe use and storage of chemicals in agricultureWorkCover Authority of NSWSydney, NSW, AustraliaGoogle Scholar
  79. Yencken, D. G., Wilkinson, D. 2000Resetting the compass: Australia’s journey towards sustainabilityCSIRO PublishingVictoria, AustraliaGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Primary IndustriesPrimary Industries Research VictoriaVictoriaAustralia

Personalised recommendations