Polymicrogyria is one of the most common malformations of cortical development. It has been known for many years and its clinical and MRI manifestations are well described. Recent advances in imaging, however, have revealed that polymicrogyria has many different appearances on MR imaging, suggesting that is may be a more heterogeneous malformation than previously suspected. The clinical and imaging heterogeneity of polymicrogyria is explored in this review.
Polymicrogyria Epilepsy Malformations of cortical development Magnetic resonance imaging
Polymicrogyria is a malformation of cortical development in which the process of normal cerebral cortical development is disturbed late in the stage of neuronal migration or early in the stage of cortical organization; thus, it is considered a disorder of neuronal organization . As a result of these disturbances to the developmental process, the deeper layers of the cerebral cortex develop abnormally and multiple small gyri form within the cortex . Polymicrogyria has a range of histologic appearances, all having in common a derangement of the normal six-layered lamination of the cortex, an associated derangement of sulcation, and fusion of the molecular layer across sulci [3, 4, 5]. In areas of polymicrogyria, no normal sulci are seen. Causes of polymicrogyria include congenital infection (particularly cytomegalovirus infection [6, 7]), localized or diffuse in utero ischemia [8, 9], or mutations (Table 1) [10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23].
Genes associated with polymicrogyria.
Patients with polymicrogyria may have a wide variety of clinical presentations, ranging from hemiparesis or partial epilepsy to developmental delay, quadriparesis, and medically refractory, intractable epilepsy; the neurologic disability appears to depend upon the portion[s] of brain involved, but may also depend upon the type of polymicrogyria and the presence or absence of associated anomalies. Neurologic manifestations are similar among patients who have polymicrogyria due to different causes [6, 22, 24, 25]. The severity of the clinical presentation and age at presentation depend mostly upon the extent of cortical involvement; bilateral involvement and involvement of more than half of a single hemisphere are poor prognostic indicators, portending moderate to severe developmental delay and significant motor dysfunction .
Polymicrogyria affects variable portions of the cerebral cortex: it may be focal, multifocal, or diffuse; it may be unilateral, bilateral, and asymmetrical; or bilateral and symmetrical. The most common location (in 60–70% of cases ) is around the sylvian fissure, particularly the posterior aspect of the fissure; however, any part of the cerebral cortex, including the frontal, occipital, and temporal lobes, can be affected [3, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28]. Polymicrogyria may be an isolated malformation or it may be associated with other brain malformations; when other malformations are identified, the most common are corpus callosum agenesis and hypogenesis, cerebellar hypoplasia , periventricular nodular heterotopia , and subcortical heterotopia . Affected patients may be microcephalic, normocephalic, or macrocephalic .
Several specific syndromes are associated with cerebral polymicrogyria (Table 2). Some of the best known of these are Aicardi syndrome (OMIM 304050 [32, 33]), Delleman syndrome (oculo-cerebral-cutaneous syndrome, OMIM 164180 [34, 35]), DiGeorge syndrome (OMIM 188400, also called the 22q11.2 deletion syndrome in which several genes are deleted ), Warburg Micro syndrome (OMIM 600118 [36, 37, 38]), and D-bifunctional protein deficiency (OMIM 261515) . Many others will likely be found.
Multiple congenital anomaly syndromes with polymicrogyria.
Heterotopia [periventricular and subcortical]
Large, dysplastic tectum
Absent Cb vermis
Polymicrogyria [perisylvian, right hemisphere preferred]
Warburg Micro syndrome
Hypogenitalism with hypotonia
Callosal hypo- or agenesis
D-bifunctional protein deficiency
Bilateral perisylvian polymicrogyria
Large anterior fontanelle
Up-slanting palpebral fissures
The imaging appearance of polymicrogyria is variable. This variability is most likely a result of three factors: imaging factors (amount of gray matter–white matter contrast, thickness of the slices); the stage of maturity/myelination of the brain at the time of the imaging study; and, in all likelihood, the type of PMG. In a previous analysis of PMG, I noted that it can have a coarse appearance or a delicate appearance and that the appearance seen in the so-called cobblestone malformations differs from that seen in most bilateral polymicrogyria syndromes . The precise reasons for these differing appearances are not known, but the development of the cerebral cortex is so complex that it is not surprising that disruptions of the processes of late cortical migration and cortical organization at different stages might result in slightly different malformations. The cortical surface can have multiple small, delicate gyri (Fig. 1) or appear thick and irregularly bumpy (Fig. 2) or be paradoxically smooth (Fig. 3) because the outer cortical (molecular) layer fuses over the microsulci. Sometimes the cortex appears thick and coarse (with an appearance of “palisades” of cortex , (Fig. 4)), while other times the microgyri appear fine and delicate (Fig. 1), even when the brains are similarly myelinated. However, these variations in appearance may not be detectable on routine, 5-mm thick images. Therefore, images with thin sections and optimal gray matter–white matter contrast [we acquire volume 3DFT spoiled gradient acquisition (T1 weighted) and volume 3DFT fast spin echo (T2 weighted) images, both in the sagittal plane with ≤1.5 mm partition size] should always be acquired. Evaluation in three planes is often necessary to detect irregularities of the gray matter–white matter junction, which are often the most convincing evidence of dysplastic brain (Fig. 3) ; this is most easily accomplished via volumetric acquisition with display in all three orthogonal planes (sagittal, axial, and coronal). The volume acquisitions can be displayed as three-dimensional surface images (Fig. 5) and can be utilized for stereotactic localization, aiding in surgical therapy, if appropriate. The degree of myelination affects the appearance. In unmyelinated regions, the inner surface of the polymicrogyric cortex looks thin [2–3 mm] and bumpy, while in myelinated areas it looks thicker (5–8 mm) and relatively smooth . The reason proposed for this is that a 4–5 mm layer of gliotic white matter runs through the polymicrogyric cortex, blending in with white matter in the unmyelinated brain and blending in with cortex after myelination . Finally, as stated earlier, polymicrogyria is almost certainly a heterogeneous malformation that can have many different appearances: thick and coarse, fine and delicate, with shallow or deep sulci. Whatever the reason, it is important to realize that a spectrum of cortical appearances, all having some sort of small gyri, can be seen in patients with polymicrogyria.
In addition to the variability of the appearance of polymicrogyria, the location of polymicrogyria is extremely variable. It may be superficial, with the cortex appearing flat and congruent to the arc of normal cortex, or may course radially inward, as if it were buckled or folded toward the ventricle. This infolding of cortex may be small or large, but close examination will show that the cortical features are similar [bumpy, irregular inner and outer cortical surfaces] in both the superficial and radially folded types. Polymicrogyria may be unilateral (∼40%) or bilateral (∼60%). The cortex surrounding the sylvian fissures is involved in ∼80% of cases, with the frontal lobe being most commonly involved (∼70%), followed by parietal (63%), temporal (38%), and occipital (7%) lobes . The striate cortex, cingulate gyrus, hippocampus, and gyrus rectus are typically spared . Polymicrogyria is sometimes calcified, but it is difficult to know the frequency because few patients are studied with CT. It is not clear if the calcification is of any significance. Finally, it is important to recognize that anomalous venous drainage is common in areas of dysplastic cortex , seen in up to 51% of patients with polymicrogyria . Large vessels are especially common in regions where there is a large infolding of thickened cortex. Such large vessels, when seen in association with abnormal, thickened cortex, should not be mistaken for vascular malformations. Angiography is not indicated.
Several syndromes of bilateral symmetrical polymicrogyria have been described; these should be recognized by neuroimagers. The best known and most common of these is bilateral perisylvian polymicrogyria (also called congenital bilateral perisylvian syndrome ). This syndrome may be sporadic or familial [15, 45]. The heterogeneous inheritance patterns suggest that mutations of several different genes can cause this malformation ; three locations (Xq21.33-q23 (SRPX2), 22q11.2, and Xq28) have been identified [13, 19, 20, 22]. Sporadic cases tend to present with more severe neurologic manifestations. A syndrome of developmental pseudobulbar palsy (oropharyngeal dysfunction and dysarthria, 100%), epilepsy (80–90%), mental retardation (50–80%), and, sometimes, congenital arthrogryposis has been described [44, 46, 47, 48]. Other patients are brought to attention in infancy or early childhood because of delayed development (60%), palatal dysfunction (40%), hypotonia (30%), arthrogryposis (30%), or motor deficits (25%) [47, 49]. Seizures are present in 40–60% and may be of many clinical types [47, 49]. Studies of familial cases of congenital bilateral perisylvian polymicrogyria show a lower incidence of these clinical manifestations [45, 50], possibly because patients with minimal symptoms are more readily identified and examined. A developmental reading disorder and reading impairment without severe motor or cognitive handicap may be the cause of seeking medical attention in this group . Bilateral perisylvian polymicrogyria can be graded according to severity on MRI (with grade 1 the most severe and grade 4 the mildest) : Grade 1, with perisylvian polymicrogyria extending to the frontal or occipital pole (Fig. 6); Grade 2, with polymicrogyria extending beyond the perisylvian region but not to either pole (most common, Fig. 7); Grade 3, with polymicrogyria of the perisylvian region only (Fig. 8); and Grade 4, with polymicrogyria restricted to the posterior perisylvian regions.
Bilateral frontoparietal polymicrogyria is another well-defined syndrome [12, 52]. Affected patients are characterized by global developmental delay of at least moderate severity, seizures, disconjugate gaze, and bilateral pyramidal and cerebellar signs . MR demonstrates symmetric cortical dysgenesis affecting the frontoparietal regions most severely, as well as ventriculomegaly, bilateral white matter signal changes, and small brainstem and cerebellar structures with dysmorphic cerebellar cortex (Fig. 9). The presence of the white matter changes and the posterior fossa anomalies is very uncommon for polymicrogyria syndromes. In addition, the cortical malformation itself has a slightly different appearance than that of most polymicrogyria. Indeed, the overall appearance of the brain is more similar to that of the so-called cobblestone malformations, associated with congenital muscular dystrophies and resulting from abnormalities of linkage of radial glial cells to the pial basement membrane overlying the developing cortex [53, 54]. Further research has shown that the pial basement membrane is regulated by GPR56, the gene that causes BFPP when mutated , and that mutations of GPR56 cause gaps in the pial basement membrane and abnormal linkage of radial glial cells to that membrane . Therefore, this disorder may fit better into the cobblestone malformations. Moreover, this observation raises the question of what precisely defines polymicrogyria and whether the different types of polymicrogyria should be analyzed and distinguished.
Other syndromes of bilateral symmetrical polymicrogyria have been described . Several groups have described patients with spastic quadriparesis and epilepsy, on whom imaging shows bilateral symmetrical frontal polymicrogyria (Fig. 10) . Guerrini et al. have described patients with bilateral medial parietal-occipital polymicrogyria (Fig. 11) [27, 58]. Other patients have combinations of the above-mentioned patterns (Fig. 2); thus, it appears that any region of cortex may be involved by bilateral, symmetrical polymicrogyria . A syndrome of congenital hemiplegia and epilepsy has been described in patients with large areas of unilateral polymicrogyria . These patients typically present in infancy with delayed motor development. A familial syndrome of unilateral polymicrogyria has also been described .
A syndrome of megalencephaly with polymicrogyria and hydrocephalus has been described. Affected children present at birth or in early infancy with macrocephaly and hypotonia; delayed motor and cognitive development become evident as they grow. Epilepsy, postaxial polydactyly, cutis marmorata, midface capillary malformation, and coarse facial features are frequently present [61, 62, 63, 64, 65]. Imaging reveals ventriculomegaly (from hydrocephalus) and polymicrogyria, which is most severe in the perisylvian region (typically Grade 1 or 2). This disorder is now thought to include those previously called megalencephaly–polymicrogyria–polydactyly–hydrocephalus syndrome and macrocephaly capillary malformation syndromes [63, 64, 65].
In summary, polymicrogyria is not a single entity, but a group of disorders that has many causes and many clinical and radiological phenotypes. Imaging characteristics may be useful in helping to differentiate the different types of polymicrogyria, which may appear as one component of multiple congenital anomaly syndromes or as isolated CNS malformation. It is important for neuroimagers to acquire high-quality images in affected patients and carefully analyze the images to help to optimize the diagnosis and treatment.
A.J. Barkovich is funded by NIH R01 NS058721, R01 NS46432, and R37 NS35129.
Conflict of interest statement
I declare that I have no conflict of interest.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.