Consideration of religious sentiments while selecting a biological product for knee arthroscopy
There is an increasing use of various synthetic and biological products in orthopaedics. The use of a biological product can be a major area of concern for patients of various cultures/religions. The purpose of this work is to study various restrictions in different faiths and their compatibility with available products focused on cartilage repair.
A systematic search in several databases, CINAHL, EMBASE, Global health, PubMed, MEDLINE and the Cochrane collaboration, was performed to find out various religious beliefs of some major religions regarding the use of animal products. Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Jewish and Buddhist faiths were studied to find out whether animal-derived surgical implants are permitted. Major religious scholars were asked about their opinions, and guidelines related to human/religious ethics were evaluated. A market survey was carried out to find out biological contents of various products and their compatibility.
Jews and Muslims have religious restrictions for porcine products, while Hindus reject bovine products. Vegetarian Hindus reject usage of any animal product. Most Christians do not have any restrictions except those who follow vegetarian dietary regulations. Though there is no prohibition for the use of animal products in Buddhism, a code of non-violence to animals is being followed. However, difference of opinion exists about interpretation of these dietary guidelines for surgical usage amongst various scholars.
Products of biological origin have a definite restriction for various religions, with few exceptions. Surgeons should know the source of the product and should be aware of the basic requirements of the patient’s faith. Patient should be informed about the source of the product and alternative if available, and an informed consent may be considered.
Level of evidence
Type of study, Level V.
KeywordsAnimal origin Cartilage products Meniscus implants Religion Restriction Culture Hindu Jews Muslim Christian Human ethics Xenografts
We are thankful to Mr. A I Saiyad, Chairman, Wakf Board, Government of Gujarat, India for providing us the religious viewpoints of Muslim community. We are also thankful to Shashtri Jnanprakash Swami, MA (Indian Philosophy & World Religion), Vedantacharya (Sanskrut University—Varanasi), Trustee, Satsang Shiksha Parishad, Swaminarayan Gurukul, Gandhinagar, India for providing us analysis of Hindu beliefs.
Conflict of interest
Authors declare that there is no conflict of interests. No financial support or grant was obtained in preparation of this manuscript. Third author is a consultant for Sanofi Genzyme and Piramal Healthcare.
(1) The chapter is written with a purpose of informing clinicians and industry about various religious sentiments and possible restrictions. (2) This information may help clinicians and industry to avoid any complication arising after use of a particular product in a strict religious patient. (3) Basic religious guidelines have been drawn from various sources, as complete guidelines for each religion are out of scope of this study. (4) Utmost care has been taken to ascertain the correct source of each product. But still product tables are for reference purpose only. There may be a case where modification of the source has been done by a particular company. (5) In no way, the list is complete for all the products. There might be instances when some of the products have been missed. (6) Even though authors tried to study all products available in market, there were instances when details of some of the products could not be found. (7) In no way, it is intended to harm or disrespect any product or religion. (8) Clinicians and Industry are advised to study each case individually and use best practice.
- 2.Agar. In: Wikipedia, the free encyclopaedia. Available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agar
- 4.Alginic Acid. In: Wikipedia, the free encyclopaedia. Available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alginic_acid. Accessed 15 Nov 2011
- 5.BIOSEED-C (2011) In: Guidelines, BioTissue Technologies GmbH. http://www.biotissue.de/documents/BC%20Guidelines%20EN_Nov11.pdf
- 6.BIOSEED-C- Treatment with BIOSEED-C. In: Products, BioTissue AG. Available at http://www.biotissue.de/en-ProductsPatientsBioSeedCTreatment.html
- 7.Biphasic Support Material (2012) In: Company, Research and Development, TETEC Tissue Engineering Technologies AG. Available at http://www.tetec-ag.com/cps/rde/xchg/cw-tetec-en-int/hs.xsl/index.html. Accessed 23 Sep 12
- 8.Chitosan. In: Wikipedia, the free encyclopaedia. Available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chitosan. Accessed 15 Nov 2011
- 9.Chondrocelect. In: Product Information, European Medical Agency. Available at http://www.ema.europa.eu/docs/en_GB/document_library/EPAR_Product_Information/human/000878/WC500026031.pdf. Accessed 15 Nov 2011
- 10.Chondrotissue- Introduction. In: Products, BioTissue AG. Available at http://www.biotissue.de/en-ProductsPatientsChondrotissueIntroduction.html. Accessed 23 Nov 2011
- 11.Collagen. In: Wikipedia, the free encyclopaedia. Available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collagen. Accessed 15 Nov 2011
- 12.Consent to treatment. The Medical Defence Union 3, 1996Google Scholar
- 13.Consent: patients and doctors making decisions together. In: Guidance for Doctor, General Medical Council. Available at http://www.gmc-uk.org. Accessed 4 Apr 2012
- 15.Declaration regarding vegetarian and non-vegetarian food (2011) In: Food safety and standards (packaging and labelling) regulations, ministry of health and family welfare, the Gazette of India: extraordinary. PART III—SEC. 4, Chapter 2, regulation 4, p 35Google Scholar
- 20.Fibrin Glue. In: Wikipedia, the free encyclopaedia. Available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fibrin_glue
- 21.Food regulations from the time of the Garden of Eden to the time of Moses (2011) In: Bible Q&A, World Mission Society Church of God. Available at http://text.watv.org/english/qna/view.html?idx=1656
- 22.Gandhi MK (1927) Faith on its trial. In: Desai M (Translator) An autobiography or the story of my experiments with truth, reprint 2009. Navjivan publishing house, Ahmedabad, pp 226–227Google Scholar
- 24.General Assembly of United Nations (1948) In: The Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Available at http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/index.shtml. Accessed 4 Apr 2012
- 29.Harris M (1985) The riddle of the sacred cow. In: Simon, Schuster (eds) Good to eat: riddles of food and culture. Waveland Press Inc., Long Grove, pp 47–66Google Scholar
- 32.Herbert P (1996) Due care and informed consent: doing right. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
- 33.Highlights of prescribing information. In: product information, Genzyme Biosurgery. Available at http://www.carticel.com/~/media/Files/Carticel/Carticel-PI.PDF
- 34.Holy Quran. 5:3, 6:145Google Scholar
- 35.Holy Quran. 5:3, also in 2:173, 6:145, 16:115Google Scholar
- 36.Hyaluronan. In: Wikipedia, the free encyclopaedia. Available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyaluronan. Accessed 15 Nov 2011
- 37.IslamSet (2006) The use of unlawful or juridically unclean substances in food and medicine. Islamic Organization for Medical Sciences, SulaibekhatGoogle Scholar
- 40.Leviticus 11:7–8 (King James Version)Google Scholar
- 41.MACI: Process, Quality and Validation (2012) In: Health Care Professionals, Genzyme Europe BV. Available at http://www.maci.com/healthcare/process-quality-validation.aspx. Accessed 23.11.2011
- 42.MaioRegen Biojoint System. In: Osteochondral regeneration. Getting to the core of the problem, Finceramica Regenerative Surgery. Available at http://www.jri-ltd.co.uk/pdf/MaioRegen.pdf. Accessed 11 May 2012
- 43.Major Religions of the World Ranked by Number of Adherents. In: World Religion Statistics. Available at http://www.adherents.com/Religions_By_Adherents.html. Accessed 16 Sept 2012
- 44.Matricel. In: Product description, Matricel GmbH. Available at http://www.matricel.net/en/products/remaix/product-description.html. Accessed 11 May 2012
- 45.Megumi Hirota. Faithandfood fact files—Buddhism. In: Faith and food. Available at http://www.faithandfood.com/Buddhism.php. Accessed 15 April 2012
- 48.Pavesio A (2007) Hyalograft-C- a hyaluronan based tissue engineered cartilage graft- a review of preclinical and clinical findings. In: Workshop, stem cell research for regenerative medicine and tissue engineering. Available at http://wtec.org/stem_cell_workshop/presentations/15-Pavesio.pdf. Accessed 30 Apr 12
- 56.Stepaniak J (2000) The vegan sourcebook. Lowell House, Los AngelesGoogle Scholar
- 57.Tissel Kit Version 4 (2005) In: Product information, Baxter AG, Vienna, Austria. Available at http://www.baxterbiosurgery.com/en_EU/downloads/ifu_tisseel_kit_and_duo.pdf. Accessed 30 Apr 12
- 60.Veganism. In: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veganism#cite_note-ethicaldietary-0. Accessed 15 Apr 2012
- 61.Verdonk P, Beaufils P, Bellemans J, Djian P, Heinrichs E-L, Huysse W, Laprell H, Siebold R, Verdonk R (2012) Successful treatment of painful irreparable partial meniscal defects with a polyurethane scaffold: two-year safety and clinical outcomes. Am J Sports Med 40:844–853PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar