Geochemical contrasts between Late Triassic ore-bearing and barren intrusions in the Weibao Cu–Pb–Zn deposit, East Kunlun Mountains, NW China: constraints from accessory minerals (zircon and apatite)
- 1.1k Downloads
The Weibao copper–lead–zinc skarn deposit is located in the northern East Kunlun terrane, NW China. Igneous intrusions in this deposit consist of barren diorite porphyry (U–Pb zircon age of 232.0 ± 2.0 Ma) and ore-bearing quartz diorite and pyroxene diorite (U–Pb zircon ages of 223.3 ± 1.5 and 224.6 ± 2.9 Ma, respectively). Whole-rock major and trace element and accessory mineral (zircon and apatite) composition from these intrusions are studied to examine the different geochemical characteristics of ore-bearing and barren intrusions. Compared to the barren diorite porphyry, the ore-bearing intrusions have higher Ce4+/Ce3+ ratios of zircon and lower Mn contents of apatite, indicating higher oxidation state. Besides, apatite from the ore-bearing intrusions shows higher Cl contents and lower F/Cl ratios. These characteristics collectively suggest the higher productivity of ore-bearing quartz diorite and pyroxene diorite. When compared with ore-bearing intrusions from global porphyry Cu deposits, those from Cu–Pb–Zn skarn deposits display lower Ce4+/Ce3+ and EuN/EuN* ratios of zircon and lower Cl and higher F/Cl ratios of apatite. We conclude that these differences reflect a general geochemical feature, and that zircon and apatite composition is a sensitive tool to infer economic potential of magmas and the resulting mineralization types in intrusion-related exploration targets.
KeywordsCe4+/Ce3 + Zircon Apatite Skarn deposits Porphyry deposits East Kunlun
Zircon and apatite are widespread accessory minerals in intermediate to felsic igneous rocks and are resistant to hydrothermal alteration and physical and chemical weathering (Uher et al. 1998; Uher and Cerny 1998; Belousova et al. 2001, 2002a, b; Ballard et al. 2002; Belousova 2006; Mao et al. 2016). During the last decade, a large number of studies have illustrated that the composition of zircon and apatite can well reflect information of their host rocks (Uher et al. 1998; Belousova et al. 2002a, b; Breiter and Skoda 2012; Burnham and Berry 2012; Cao et al. 2012; Seifert et al. 2012; Trail et al. 2012; Bruand et al. 2017) and may be effective as indicator minerals in porphyry exploration (Ballard et al. 2002; Liang et al. 2006; Li et al. 2012; Han et al. 2013; Qiu et al. 2013; Zhang et al. 2013; Zhang et al. 2017). The origin and evolution of ore-forming magmas of skarn deposits are, in many aspects, similar to those of porphyry deposits (Sillitoe and Bonham 1990; Baker et al. 2004; Meinert et al. 2005; Mao et al. 2006; Sillitoe 2010), which means that zircon and apatite may also be applied to exploration of skarn deposits.
The Weibao Cu–Pb–Zn deposit is typical of skarn exploration targets in the QMB, with the igneous intrusions occurring in this deposit being texturally and mineralogically similar to those in other skarn deposits of the QMB. In this study, the major and/or trace element composition of zircon and apatite from three Late Triassic igneous rock units in the Weibao deposit is examined using electron microprobe analysis (EMPA) and laser ablation inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS). Whole-rock geochemical and geochronological data of these intrusions are also presented. Combined with previously published data, we attempt to (1) define the temporal constraints on the sequence of Late Triassic igneous rocks in the QMB and (2) examine the different geochemical characteristics of ore-bearing and barren magmas in the Weibao deposit. Besides, by comparing zircon and apatite composition of Cu–Pb–Zn skarn deposits with that of porphyry Cu deposits, we try to evaluate the application of zircon and apatite as indicator minerals in mineral exploration.
Geology of the QMB and the Weibao deposit
The QMB in the East Kunlun Mountains, NW China, is a Phanerozoic Fe–Cu–Pb–Zn (–Ag) skarn belt that extends for about 550 km in NW–SE direction (Fig. 1a, b) (Feng et al. 2010). The major skarn deposits include Weibao, Hutouya, Galinge, Yemaquan, and Kaerqueka (Fig. 1b) (Feng et al. 2011; Gao et al. 2014a; Yu et al. 2015; Zhong et al. 2017a). Porphyry mineralization also occurs in this belt, and typical deposits and prospects include Yazigou, Wulanwuzhuer, and Mohexiala (Li et al. 2008; Xu et al. 2014). The basement of this belt is composed of the Jinshuikou, Xiaomiao, and Binggou Groups of Archean–Proterozoic age. The dominant host rocks for skarn mineralization are the Mesoproterozoic Langyashan Formation, Ordovician–Silurian Qimantagh Group, and minor Carboniferous strata, which are mainly carbonate rocks and mafic–intermediate clastic rocks in composition.
Fault systems widely occur in the QMB. The faults striking west, west–northwest, and northwest are interpreted to be produced before and/or during the skarn mineralization, therefore, usually controlling economic mineralization (Feng et al. 2010). The north- and northeast-striking fault systems are generally post-skarn and post-mineralization, but likely control the emplacement of post-skarn intrusions (Feng et al. 2010). Besides, the earlier fault systems are likely reactivated by subsequent tectonic activities.
Intermediate–felsic intrusions, including (porphyritic) syenogranite, monzogranite, granodiorite, (porphyritic) granite, quartz diorite, and pyroxene diorite, are volumetrically the most abundant igneous rocks in the QMB (Li et al. 2008; Wang et al. 2009; Feng et al. 2011, 2012; Chen et al. 2012). Besides, basalts, andesite, rhyolite, dacite, and mafic dikes also occur (Zhong et al. 2017a). Geochronological data illustrated that these igneous rocks were mainly formed in the Silurian–Devonian and Triassic (Feng et al. 2012; Gao et al. 2014a; Zhou et al. 2016), with the latter being predominant.
In spite of the spatial variations of mineralization, the orebodies in the Weibao deposit are all hosted by the Mesoproterozoic Langyashan Formation that predominantly consists of limestone, marble, skarn, schist, pyroclastic rocks, and minor siltstone (Fig. 2), although minor mineralization can also be found in Middle Devonian basaltic lavas. Spatially, these rocks are unconformably overlain by the Triassic Elashan Formation and underlain by the Paleoproterozoic Baishahe Formation (Fig. 2). The Elashan Formation is mainly composed of andesite, dacite, rhyolite, and pyroclastic rocks, whereas the Baishahe Formation dominantly consists of gneiss, marble, and amphibolite manifesting amphibolite and granulite facies metamorphism. Both the Elashan and Baishahe Formations are nonreactive and do not host significant skarn mineralization. More detailed descriptions about stratigraphy, structure, alteration, and mineralization in the Weibao deposit can be found in Fang (2015) and Zhong et al. (2017a).
Igneous rocks in the Weibao deposit
Apart from the igneous rocks mentioned above, mafic and aplite dikes are also found in the Weibao deposit (Zhong et al. 2017a). Mafic dikes are observed in the whole mine area (Fig. 2b, c), ranging from several 10 cm to several meters in width. Texturally, they are fine-grained with mafic minerals altered by chlorite, carbonate, and epidote. Aplite dikes, however, mainly crop out at Weixi and are normally fine-grained, moderately porphyritic, up to several meters in width. These rocks are as yet undated but are inferred to be post-skarn because they are observed locally cutting the skarn and orebodies in the Weibao deposit.
Sampling and analytical methods
Igneous rocks studied in this work are quartz diorite, pyroxene diorite, and diorite porphyry. The first two igneous rocks are ore-bearing, whereas the diorite porphyry is representative of the barren intrusions in this deposit. More than 50 igneous rock samples were collected. Eight least altered samples were selected for geochronological and/or geochemical analysis based on careful examination under the polarizing microscope. Detailed descriptions of these samples in terms of mineralogy and alteration are listed as an electronic supplementary material (ESM 1: Table S1).
Zircons were separated from three samples, i.e., WX51 (quartz diorite), ZK8312–7 (diorite porphyry), and WD53 (pyroxene diorite), using magnetic and heavy liquid separation. Approximately, 300 zircon grains from each sample were mounted and polished in 25-mm epoxy discs. Unlike zircon, apatite grains used in this study were not separated by standard mineral separation techniques; rather, they were selected by employing optical and back-scattered electron (BSE) microscopy in polished thin sections. This approach combines the detailed textural relationships between apatite and the host phases, allowing for a more precise interpretation for apatite composition. For whole-rock major and trace element analysis, about 1 kg of each sample was trimmed to remove weathered surfaces, cleaned with deionized water, crushed and then powdered with an agate mill.
CL images and U–Pb dating
The internal zoning patterns of the zircon crystals were observed by cathodoluminescence (CL) image analysis at the Institute of Mineral Resources, Chinese Academy of Geological Sciences (CAGS), Beijing, China. Using a combination of CL images and optical microscopy, the clearest, least fractured zircon crystals were selected as suitable targets for laser ablation.
In-situ U–Pb analysis for sample WD53 was carried out by the Cameca IMS–1280 secondary ion mass spectrometer (SIMS) at the Institute of Geology and Geophysics, Chinese Academy of Sciences (IGGCAS), Beijing, China, whereas that for samples WX51 and ZK8312–7 was carried out by laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS) at the State Key Laboratory of Continental Tectonics and Dynamics, CAGS. The beam sizes are of 30 μm diameter for SIMS dating and 35 μm diameter for LA-ICP-MS dating. Instrumental conditions and detailed measurement procedures for SIMS and LA-ICP-MS analysis are the same as those described by Li et al. (2010) and Hou et al. (2009), respectively. Data processing was carried out using the Squid and Isoplot programs of Ludwig (2001) and the measured 204Pb was used for the correction of common lead with the two methods.
Major and trace element analysis of whole-rock
Major and trace element analysis of whole-rock was done at National Research Center of Geo-analysis, CAGS. Major oxides were analyzed with a wavelength X-ray fluorescence spectrometer (3080E), with FeO and loss-on-ignition analyzed by wet chemical methods. Analytical uncertainties were better than 0.5% for all major elements. Trace elements were analyzed with an X-Series inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICP-MS; Thermo Fisher, USA). The measurement of error and drift were controlled by regular analysis of standard samples with a periodicity of 10%. Analyzed uncertainties of ICP-MS data at the ppm level were better than 10%.
BSE imaging and major element analysis of apatite
BSE imaging and major element analysis of apatite were performed using electron-probe microanalysis (EPMA) at the Electron Probe Laboratory, CAGS, using a JEOL JXA-8800 instrument with a 2- to 5-μm-diameter beam. F, Na, and Cl were analyzed with a 4-nA beam current and 10-kV accelerating voltage in the first instrumental pass; the remaining elements were measured utilizing a 20-nA beam current and 20-kV accelerating potential in the second instrumental pass. Natural minerals and synthetic oxides were used as standards, and the ZAF software provided by JEOL was used to correct matrix effects. The accuracy of the analytic results is 1–5% depending on the abundance of the element.
Trace element analysis of zircon and apatite
Trace element analysis of zircon and apatite was performed using a LA-ICP-MS at the State Key Laboratory of Ore Deposit Geochemistry, Institute of Geochemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences (IGCAS), Guiyang, China. Laser sampling was accomplished employing a 193-nm ArF excimer laser connected to an Agilent 7700× quadruple ICP-MS. Laser ablation was operated at a relatively constant frequency of 6 Hz, with the spot diameter of 44 μm for zircons from samples WX51 and ZK8312–7 and of 32 μm for zircons from sample WD53 and apatite from three samples. Each analysis incorporated a background acquisition of approximately 20 s (gas blank) followed by 60 s data acquisition from the sample. The Agilent Chemstation was utilized for the acquisition of each individual analysis. Corrections of zircon data were made for mass bias drift which was evaluated by reference to standard glass NIST 610, and trace-element concentrations were obtained by normalizing count rates for each analyzed element to those for Si, and assuming SiO2 to be stoichiometric in zircon with a concentration of about 32.8 wt% (Ballard et al. 2002). P and Ca, and K and Th were used in this study to evaluate the possible involvements of mineral inclusions (apatite, K-feldspsar and monazite, respectively); when spiders of these elements are encountered, the analysis was discarded. Besides, the analysis spots showing high P contents (> 1000 ppm) were also discarded even though spiders of P were not observed, since they might be contaminated by even-distributed, micro-metric apatite inclusions.
Trace element contents of apatite were obtained through calibration of relative element sensitivities using the NIST-610, NIST-612, and NIST-614 glass as the external standard, and normalization of each analysis to the electron microprobe data for 43Ca as an internal standard. Where direct electron microprobe data were not available, the median Ca content from other apatite crystals within the same sample was used in the calculation. The preferred values of element concentrations for the USGS reference glasses are from the GeoReM database (http://georem.mpch-mainz.gwdg.de/). Off-line selection and integration of background and analyte signals, and time-drift correction and quantitative calibration were performed by ICPMSDataCal (Liu et al. 2008).
Zircon U–Pb age
Zircon crystals from three igneous rock samples display a variety of sizes, morphology, and colors ranging from clear to pale yellow. Typical CL images of zircon are shown in ESM 2; U–Pb dating data are summarized in ESM 1 (Table S2).
Diorite porphyry: Sample ZK8312–7 contains clear to pale, euhedral to subhedral, nearly granular (normally 200 to 400 μm in size) zircons which display concentric zonation patterns under CL (ESM 2). These zircons contain many mineral inclusions, which are predominantly composed of apatite, and to a lesser extent K-feldspar, as indicated by the energy dispersive spectrum analysis. Twenty single grains of zircon were analyzed by LA-ICP-MS, giving a wide range in uranium (147–571 ppm) and thorium (90–778 ppm) contents, as well as Th/U ratios ranging from 0.50 to 1.36 (ESM 1: Table S2). They define a linear array on the concordia diagram (ESM 2) and are anchored by a cluster of concordant analyses, yielding a weighted mean 206Pb/238U age of 232.0 ± 2.0 Ma (MSWD = 0.81) (ESM 2). This age likely represents the time of emplacement of diorite porphyry.
Quartz diorite: Most zircons in sample WX51 are pale yellow to light brown, elongated and tabular (150 × 50 to 300 × 150 μm in size); some zircons are granular with a size of < 200 μm (ESM 2). In spite of these discrepancies, they both display systematic zircon growth patterns. The energy-dispersive spectrum analysis manifests that minor apatite and K-feldspar inclusions occur within the studied zircons. Similar to sample ZK8312–7, 20 zircon grains from sample WX51 were analyzed by LA-ICP-MS. These zircon grains display relative uniform U and Th contents, ranging from 215 to 491 ppm and 86 to 283 ppm, respectively (ESM 1: Table S2). Th/U ratios range from 0.39 to 0.62. These zircon grains give a weighted mean 206Pb/238U age of 223.3 ± 1.5 Ma with an MSWD = 0.67 (ESM 2). This age is interpreted to be the age of crystallization of quartz diorite. However, this age is slightly younger than the previously reported SIMS zircon U–Pb age of 227.7 ± 3.1 Ma (MSWD = 2.8) (Zhou et al. 2015). It is possible that the observed age range in this unit reflects a long-lived magma system, rather than only differences in dating methods considering that sampling sites were different in each case (Zhou et al. 2015), and taking into account the batholithic size of the quartz diorite at Weixi. Another interpretation is that the previously obtained age is overestimated considering the probable influence of an older zircon core (ESM 2) and the large MSWD value.
Pyroxene diorite: Zircons from sample WD53 are primarily light brown, subhedral, smaller in size (mostly < 200 μm) and less abundant compared to those from the other two samples (ESM 2). Besides, few mineral inclusions (e.g., apatite and K-feldspar) are observed within the studied zircons. Nevertheless, they also exhibit well-developed concentric growth bands. Ten zircon grains were analyzed by SIMS. For seven zircon grains used for the age calculation, U and Th contents range from 127 to 736 ppm and 65 to 444 ppm, respectively (ESM 1: Table S2). Their Th/U ratios range from 0.44 to 0.76 and the 206Pb/238U ages for individual crystals range over 7 m.y. with a calculated mean age of 224.6 ± 2.9 Ma (MSWD = 0.76) (ESM 2). This age represents the best age estimate of pyroxene diorite emplacement. Two grains (spots WD53–2 and WD53–6) with 206Pb/238U ages of 403.3 Ma and 392.5 Ma, respectively, and one grain (spot WD53–4) with the Paleoproterozoic 206Pb/238U age of 1723.9 Ma are not included in the age calculation. These zircons are interpreted to be xenocrysts, with the former reflecting incorporation of either Devonian volcanic rocks in the Weibao district (Zhong et al. 2017a) or intrusions associated with that magmatic episode, and the latter probably reflecting incorporation of wall rocks (e.g., the Baishahe Formation) in the Weibao district.
Overall, U–Pb ages reported herein demonstrate Late Triassic magmatism in the Weibao deposit, with igneous rock ages broadly ranging from 232 to 224 Ma.
Whole-rock major and trace elements
Zircon trace elements
Analytical data of trace elements for zircons from the Weibao intrusions are summarized in ESM 3.
ZrO2 contents in zircons of diorite porphyry (sample ZK8312–7; 58.87 to 66.01 wt%) are lower than the stoichiometric ZrO2 concentration of ~67.22 wt% in zircons, which might indicate strong cation substitution. In contrast, ZrO2 contents in zircons of quartz diorite (sample WX51) and pyroxene diorite (sample WD53) are relatively high and can exceed the maximum ZrO2 concentration of zircon, with ranges from 63.64 to 68.22 wt% and 60.93 to 69.90 wt%, respectively.
Rb and Sr contents of zircons from three samples are similar and typically less than 10 ppm. Other trace elements in the studied zircons, however, may vary over several orders of magnitude. Th and U contents range from tens of ppm to thousands of ppm, with the highest values in quartz diorite. Hf concentrations are at thousands of ppm, with average values of 7532 ppm for diorite porphyry, 9434 ppm for quartz diorite, and 7523 ppm for pyroxene diorite.
Apatite major and trace elements
Most apatite grains from the three intrusions in the Weibao deposit are euhedral, and no prominent zonation is observed (Fig. 7). Apatite grains from quartz diorite (sample WX51) and pyroxene diorite (sample WD53) are generally elongated, tabular, 120 × 40 μm to 360 × 50 μm in size (Fig. 7b, c), whereas those from diorite porphyry (sample ZK8312–7) are normally granular and smaller in size (mostly < 40 μm) (Fig. 7). Apatite CaO contents show little variation with increasing whole-rock SiO2 concentrations (Fig. 8a), whereas P2O5 is higher in the mafic end-members (Fig. 8b). Fluorine contents are relatively high (ranging from 1.4 to 2.6 wt%) but indistinguishable between ore-forming and barren intrusions (ESM 3; Fig. 8c). In contrast, chlorine contents are lower and are well distinguished between ore-forming and barren intrusions, with the former displaying higher Cl contents (0.4 to 1.0 wt%) (ESM 3; Fig. 8d). Assuming that F−, Cl−, and OH− fill the anion site, the studied apatite indicates mainly F–OH exchange. Other major elements (Na2O, MgO, SiO2 , and FeO) in apatite rarely exceed 1 wt% (ESM 3) and are commonly below their detection limits.
Zircons from three intrusions in the Weibao Cu–Pb–Zn skarn deposit are predominantly euhedral and display clearly concentric zonation patterns under CL. The U–Pb dates for individual grains are concordant and the Th/U ratios are high (ranging from 0.40 to 1.36 with one exception). All these characteristics advocate that the studied zircons are of magmatic origin and their ages therefore can represent the time of magma emplacement.
The obtained U–Pb ages document multiple magmatic activities in the Weibao deposit. It extends back to ~ 400 Ma, as evidenced by two concordant zircon grains of this age (spot WD53–2, 403.3 Ma; spot WD53–6, 392.5 Ma). This is consistent with our previous study that demonstrated the existence of Devonian magmatic activity in the Weibao deposit (Zhong et al. 2017a). After a very long magmatic lull (~ 160 Ma), igneous activity in the Weibao deposit resumed at about 232 Ma with the emplacement of barren diorite porphyry (232.0 ± 2.0 Ma) at Weixi. The next stage of igneous activity is indicated by ~ 224 Ma zircon U–Pb dates. During this new magmatic cycle, the ore-bearing intrusions were emplaced, which are characterized by quartz diorite at Weixi with the age of 223.3 ± 1.5 Ma and pyroxene diorite at Weidong with the age of 224.6 ± 2.9 Ma. These two ages are indistinguishable when errors are considered, indicating that the ore-bearing magmas were emplaced simultaneously or during a very short time span. As hydrothermal activity and mineralization in porphyry–skarn systems are intimately tied to emplacement of ore-forming intrusions (Razique et al. 2014), the associated hydrothermal and mineralization events in the Weibao deposit probably have similar short durations of just a few million years or less.
At the regional scale, magmatism in the Weibao deposit coincides with that in other porphyry and skarn deposits/prospects in the QMB. For instance, in the Yemaquan Fe skarn deposit the early stage of magmatic activity is characterized by Early to Middle Devonian monzogranite (393 ± 2 Ma; Gao et al. 2014a) and granodiorite (400.8 ± 1.4 Ma to 386 ± 1 Ma; Gao et al. 2014a; Qiao et al. 2016), and the late stage of magmatic activity is characterized by porphyritic quartz monzodiorite (219 ± 1 Ma; Gao et al. 2014a), syenogranite (213 ± 1 Ma; Gao et al. 2014a), and granodiorite (220.53 ± 0.69 Ma; Qiao et al. 2016). Similarly, in the Kaerqueka Cu–Pb–Zn skarn deposit, two distinct igneous events were also demonstrated (Wang et al. 2009; Chen et al. 2012; Feng et al. 2012). It should be noted that although Middle to Late Triassic igneous rocks in the QMB are volumetrically comparable to Paleozoic (mainly Early to Middle Devonian) igneous rocks at the regional scale, at the district and deposit scale, however, the former are volumetrically more predominant. Moreover, published molybdenite Re–Os and muscovite 40Ar/39Ar dates in these skarn and porphyry deposits gave a similar time span ranging from 224 to 239 Ma (Li et al. 2008; Feng et al. 2011; Yu et al. 2015; and references therein), therefore also indicating that hydrothermal events in the QMB resulted from Triassic magmatic activity. It should be noted that Gao et al. (2014a) argued that both Middle Devonian magmatic activity and Late Triassic magmatic activity were closely related to ore-forming processes in the Hutouya deposit, which might mean two, rather than only one, mineralization events existed in the QMB. However, currently, this assumption still cannot be reliably determined due to lack of direct dating of sulfides and/or hydrothermal minerals in most deposits of the QMB.
Contrasts between ore-bearing and barren intrusions in the Weibao deposit
Magmatic oxygen fugacity
The magmatic oxygen fugacity is a key factor in controlling the magmatic fertility of porphyry deposits (Lehmann 1990; Wittenbrink et al. 2009; Sun et al. 2013, 2015; Zhang et al. 2017; Zhong et al. 2017b). There is a consensus that oxidized magmas are more favorable than reduced magmas in generating porphyry Cu deposits (Imai 2002; Liang et al. 2006; Lu et al. 2016; Li et al. 2017a), considering that at higher oxygen fugacity, magmatic sulfur exists mainly as sulfate (SO4 2−) which has a much higher solubility in silicate melts than sulfide and will tend to delay or even prevent saturation of a magmatic sulfide phase (Ballard et al. 2002; Richards 2003). When it comes to Cu (–Pb–Zn) skarn deposits, this is also applicable because of the similar magmatic origins and evolutions of porphyry and skarn deposits (Li et al. 2017b).
The zircon EuN/EuN* and especially Ce4+/Ce3+ ratios have been firmly demonstrated to be an effective proxy of the magmatic oxygen fugacity (e.g., Ballard et al. 2002; Liang et al. 2006; Li et al. 2012; Trail et al. 2012; Qiu et al. 2013; Xu et al. 2016; Gardiner et al. 2017). In the Weibao Cu–Pb–Zn skarn deposit, the ore-bearing intrusions display higher zircon Ce4+/Ce3+ values (> 12) than those of barren intrusions, although their EuN/EuN* ratios are indistinguishable. This indicates that compared to the barren diorite porphyry, the ore-bearing intrusions are much more oxidized and thus more productive for Cu mineralization. Unlike Cu, Pb and Zn can behave as incompatible elements regardless of the redox state, which means that Pb–Zn mineralization can occur either at high oxygen fugacity or at relatively low oxygen fugacity. This is evidenced by many findings that both S-type (and thus low oxidation state) or I-type (and thus higher oxidation state) granitoids can form Pb–Zn deposits (e.g., Fu et al. 2017; Niu et al. 2017). In other words, the oxidation state is not a controlling factor for Pb–Zn mineralization within the Weibao deposit.
Different from the Eu and Ce anomalies in zircon, the amplitude of these anomalies in apatite is probably more strongly controlled by other factors such as the crystallization of feldspars, and the presence of other accessory phases such as monazite and fluorite (Piccoli and Candela 2002). Feldspar crystallization can concentrate Eu2+ from the melt (Philpotts 1970; Pun et al. 1997), whereas monazite and fluorite can concentrate Ce (Chesley et al. 1991). Therefore, it was found that the correlation between the degree of the Eu and Ce anomalies of apatite and the oxidation state of the whole rock was rather weak (Piccoli and Candela 2002). This study is such a case where apatite within barren and ore-bearing intrusions in the Weibao deposit shares similar ranges in EuN/EuN* (0.12 to 0.26) and CeN/CeN* ratios (1.01 to 1.12). All these observations indicate that Eu and Ce anomalies in apatite are not a good proxy of the oxidation state of magmas. Nevertheless, previous studies found that Mn concentrations in apatite appeared to be affected by the oxidation state, with high apatite Mn contents normally found in reduced magmas and lower Mn contents found in more oxidized magmas. This can be explained by the substitution of Mn2+ for Ca2+. Apatite incorporates Mn2+ in preference to Mn3+ or Mn4+, because the ionic radius and valence of Mn2+ are closer to Ca2+ than those of Mn3+ and Mn4+ (Belousova et al. 2001, 2002b; and references therein). Therefore, apatite will have elevated Mn content at low oxygen fugacity in which manganese exists principally as a divalent anion (Mn2+). In the Weibao deposit, apatite within two ore-forming intrusions exhibits much lower Mn concentrations than within the barren diorite porphyry (Fig. 8e), which therefore further demonstrates the higher oxidized state (and thus higher productivity) of ore-bearing magmas in the Weibao deposit.
Halogen contents of magmas
Apart from the oxidation state, sthe abundance of halogens, especially fluorine and chlorine, is also of great importance for productive magmas since halogens can effectively complex and transport metals (e.g., gold, copper) (Piccoli and Candela 1994; Coulson et al. 2001; Webster et al. 2004, 2009; Mathez and Webster 2005; Pan et al. 2016). Numerous studies advocate that Cl-rich systems are more prospective for base and precious metal mineralization than Cl-barren ones, indicating that Cl contents might be a potential proxy of the fertility of magmas (e.g., Roegge et al. 1974; Piccoli and Candela 2002; Mathez and Webster 2005). Previous works demonstrated that halogen contents could be evaluated using the composition of apatite in igneous rocks (Mathez and Webster 2005; Webster et al. 2009). For mafic silicate melt containing less than ~ 3.8 wt% Cl (1066 to 1150 °C, 199 to 205 MPa), experiments showed that DCl apatite/melt (wt. fraction of Cl in apatite/Cl in melt) ≈ 0.8 and DF apatite/melt ≈ 3.4 (Mathez and Webster 2005). The calculated Cl concentrations of the barren magma in the Weibao deposit range from 0.09 to 0.15 wt%, much lower than those of the ore-bearing magmas (ranging from 0.50 to 1.18 wt%), therefore further indicating that the two ore-bearing intrusions are more productive. In contrast, the calculated F contents of the barren and ore-bearing magmas are almost identical, ranging from 0.42 to 0.77 wt% and 0.41 to 0.72 wt%, respectively. This suggests that unlike Cl, F may not effectively control the extraction and transport of Cu, Pb, and Zn during the magmatic evolution, although it has a greater influence on the extraction and transport of Nb, Ta, Sn, and W (Thomas et al. 2004; Simons et al. 2017).
Copper productivity of magmas: Cu–Pb–Zn skarn deposits vs. porphyry Cu deposits
Contrasts in magmatic oxygen fugacity
In Fig. 6, we compare the intrusions in the Weibao deposit with those in typical porphyry Cu deposits from the literature (Ballard et al. 2002; Wang et al. 2013; Zhang et al. 2013; Wang et al. 2017; Zhao et al. 2017). It is clearly shown that the two ore-bearing intrusions in the Weibao deposit have much lower Ce4+/Ce3+ ratios (mostly < 200) and EuN/EuN* ratios (< 0.3) than those from porphyry copper deposits (Fig. 6), indicating that the Weibao Cu–Pb–Zn skarn deposit has much lower oxygen fugacity than porphyry Cu deposits. By examining the relationships between the oxygen fugacity and mineralization associated with Yanshanian granites in South China, Li et al. (2017b) also found that the granites related to Cu–Pb–Zn mineralization had distinctly lower oxygen fugacity than those related to porphyry Cu–(Au)–Mo mineralization. Li et al. (2008) proposed that the lower oxygen fugacity of magmas in Cu–Pb–Zn skarn deposits might result from assimilation of crustal materials. They argued that magmas generating the Cu–Pb–Zn mineralization were initially depleted in sulfur and acquired their sulfur through assimilation of crustal material, and so a relatively low oxygen fugacity could not cause significant precipitation of sulfides in the early stages of the magmatic evolution. We do not know whether this explanation is correct, and additional data are needed to demonstrate it. Nevertheless, it is apparent that low oxygen fugacity of ore-bearing magmas for Cu–Pb–Zn skarn deposits is less favorable for Cu mineralization and, therefore, makes them less economic than porphyry Cu deposits when only copper resources are considered.
Contrasts in halogen contents of magmas
Implications for regional mineral exploration
Previous geological studies in the Weibao deposit revealed that it was comparable to other skarn deposits in the QMB in terms of host rocks, alteration, mineralization, and igneous rock types (Gao et al. 2014b; Fang 2015; Zhou et al. 2015; Zhong et al. 2017a). In this study, we further confirm that magmatism in the Weibao deposit is similar to other skarn deposits in the QMB. This work shows that ore-bearing and barren intrusions in the Weibao deposit can be well distinguished by zircon Ce4+/Ce3+ ratios and apatite Cl contents, with the former displaying higher zircon Ce4+/Ce3+ ratios and apatite Cl contents. This might be a general feature of mineralized igneous rocks in the QMB, but it still awaits confirmation from data on deposits such as Kaerqueka, Hutouya in the QMB, which are in a similar geological setting. Besides, by comparing Cu–Pb–Zn skarn deposits with porphyry Cu deposits worldwide, our study shows that porphyry Cu deposits have much higher Ce4+/Ce3+ (> 200) and EuN/EuN* ratios (> 0.3) of zircon and higher Cl contents of apatite (> 0.9 wt%) than Cu–Pb–Zn skarn deposits. If these results are confirmed by further works, then the measurement of Ce4+/Ce3+ and EuN/EuN* ratios of zircon and Cl contents of apatite may provide a useful tool not only in discriminating between ore-bearing and barren intrusions at an early stage of exploration as previously suggested (e.g., Ballard et al. 2002), but also in evaluating the potential mineralization types for a certain intrusion.
The barren diorite porphyry and ore-bearing quartz diorite and pyroxene diorite in the Weibao deposit can be well distinguished by zircon U–Pb ages and major and/or trace element composition of zircon and apatite. The ore-bearing intrusions were emplaced in a narrow time span from 224.6 ± 2.9 to 223.3 ± 1.5 Ma which is ~ 8 m.y. later than that of the barren diorite porphyry (232.0 ± 2.0 Ma). They show much higher zircon Ce4+/Ce3+ ratios and lower apatite Mn contents than the barren intrusion, indicating a much higher oxygen fugacity. Besides, they also display higher Cl contents and lower F/Cl ratios than the barren intrusion. Since both the oxidation state and halogen contents of magmas are closely related to their metal productivity, this study advocates that the quartz diorite and pyroxene diorite intrusions in the Weibao deposit were more productive than the diorite porphyry intrusion. Moreover, combined with published data, it is shown that ore-bearing intrusions of Cu–Pb–Zn skarn deposits can be distinguished from those of porphyry Cu deposits by zircon Ce4+/Ce3+ and EuN/EuN* ratios and apatite halogen contents. In summary, this study indicates two important applications of apatite and zircon as indicator minerals: (1) discrimination between ore-bearing and barren intrusions at an early stage of exploration and (2) evaluation of the potential mineralization types for a certain intrusion.
This study was financially supported by the Geological Survey Program (Grant 1212011085528) of the China Geological Survey; the Program of High-level Geological Talents (201309) and Youth Geological Talents (201112) of the China Geological Survey; and the IGCP–592 project sponsored by IUGS–UNESCO. SZ appreciates the cooperation with the Natural History Museum (RS, AD) and the Camborne School of Mines, University of Exeter (JA) for hosting his skarn research. This is a contribution to their research on mineralized skarn systems funded by the EU Horizon 2020 project “FAME” (grant # 641650) and the Chinese Scholarship Council (fellowship to SZ). Dr. Hongying Qu, Jiannan Liu, Miao Yu, Hui Wang, and Jianhou Zhou from the CAGS are acknowledged for their assistance during the fieldwork. Special thanks are given to the Editor-in-Chief Prof. Bernd Lehmann, Associate Editor Prof. Ruizhong Hu, and anonymous reviewers for their critical and constructive reviews.
- Chen B, Zhang ZY, Geng JZ, Jian QZ, Song ZB, Zhao XF, Chen AY, Quan SC, Zhang YL, Fu YZ (2012) Zircon LA-ICP-MS U-Pb age of monzogranites in the Kaerqueka copper-polymetallic deposit of Qimantag, western Qinghai province. Geol Bull China 31:463–468 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Fang J. (2015) Ore genesis of Weibao banded skarn lead-zinc deposit, Qimantagh area, Xinjiang, China. Dissertation, Chinese Academy of SciencesGoogle Scholar
- Feng CY, Li DS, Wu ZS, Li HJ, Zhang ZY, Zhang AK, Shu XF, Su SS (2010) Major types, time-space distribution and metallogeneses of polymetallic deposits in the Qimangtage metallogenic belt, Eastern Kunlun area. Northwest Geol 43:10–17 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Feng CY, Wang XP, Shu XF, Zhang AK, Xiao Y, Liu JN, Ma SC, Li GC, Li DX (2011) Isotopic chronology of the Hutouya skarn lead-zinc polymetallic ore district in Qimantage area of Qinghai province and its geological significance. J Jilin Univ (Earth Sci Ed) 41:1806–1817 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Feng CY, Wang S, Li GC, Ma SC, Li DS (2012) Middle to Late Triassic granitoids in the Qimantage area, Qinghai Province, China: chronology, geochemistry and metallogenic significances. Acta Petrol Sin 28:665–678 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Fu Q, Xu B, Zheng Y, Yang Z, Hou Z, Huang K, Liu Y, Zhang C, Zhao L (2017) Two episodes of mineralization in the Mengya’a deposit and implications for the evolution and intensity of Pb–Zn–(Ag) mineralization in the Lhasa terrane, Tibet. Ore Geol Rev 90:877–896. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oregeorev.2017.01.008 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Gao YB, Li WY, Qian B, Li K, Li DS, He SY, Zhang ZW, Zhang JW (2014a) Geochronology, geochemistry and Hf isotopic compositions of the granitic rocks related with iron mineralization in Yemaquan deposit, East Kunlun, NW China. Acta Petrol Sin 30:1647–1665 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Gao YB, Li WY, Qian B, Li K, Zhang ZW, Jiang ZX, Shen DL, Wang ZH, Ye MF (2014b) Geology, fluid incluisions and S, Pb isotopic geochemistry of the Weibao Zn-Pb deposit in Qimantage, Xinjiang. J Jilin Univ (Earth Sci Ed) 44:1153–1165 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Han Y, Zhang S, Pirajno F, Zhou X, Zhao G, Qü W, Liu S, Zhang J, Liang H, Yang K (2013) U–Pb and Re–Os isotopic systematics and zircon Ce4+/Ce3+ ratios in the Shiyaogou Mo deposit in eastern Qinling, central China: insights into the oxidation state of granitoids and Mo (Au) mineralization. Ore Geol Rev 55:29–47. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oregeorev.2013.04.006 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Hou KJ, Li YH, Tian YR (2009) In situ U-Pb zircon dating using laser ablation-multi ion counting-ICP-MS. Mineral Deposits 28:481–492 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Imai A (2002) Metallogenesis of porphyry Cu deposits of the western Luzon arc, Philippines: K-Ar ages, SO3 contents of microphenocrystic apatite and significance of intrusive rocks. Resour Geol 52(2):147–161. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1751-3928.2002.tb00127.x CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lehmann B (1990) Metallogeny of tin. Lecture Notes in Earth Sciences. Springer Verlag, Berlin, p 32Google Scholar
- Li SJ, Sun FY, Feng CY, Liu ZY, Zhao JW, Li YC, Wang S (2008) Geochronological study on Yazigou polymetallic deposit in Eastern Kunlun, Qinhai province. Acta Geol Sin 82:949–955 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Lu YJ, Loucks RR, Fiorentini M, McCuaig TC, Evans NJ, Yang Z-M, Hou Z-Q, Kirkland CL, Parra-Avila LA, Kobussen A (2016) Zircon compositions as a pathfinder for porphyry Cu±Mo±Au deposits. Econ Geol Spec Pub 19:329–347Google Scholar
- Ludwig K (2001) Squid 1.02: a user’s manual. Berkeley Geochronol Cent Spec Pub 2:15–35Google Scholar
- Mao JW, Wang YT, Lehmann B, Yu JJ, Du AD, Mei YX, Li YT, Zang WS, Stein HJ, Zhou TF (2006) Molybdenite Re–Os and albite 40Ar/39Ar dating of Cu–Au–Mo and magnetite porphyry systems in the Yangtze River valley and metallogenic implications. Ore Geol Rev 29(3-4):307–324. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oregeorev.2005.11.001 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Meinert LD, Dipple GM, Nicolescu S (2005) World skarn deposits. Econ Geol 100th Anniversary Volume 100:299–336Google Scholar
- Nash WP (1984) Phosphate minerals in terrestrial igneous and metamorphic rocks. In: Nriagu JO, Moore PB (eds) Phosphate minerals, 6th edn. Springer, Verlag, pp 215–241Google Scholar
- Niu SD, Li SR, Huizenga JM, Santosh M, Zhang DH, Zeng YJ, Li ZD, Zhao WB (2017) Zircon U-Pb geochronology and geochemistry of the intrusions associated with the Jiawula Ag-Pb-Zn deposit in the Great Xing’an Range, NE China and their implications for mineralization. Ore Geol Rev 86:35–54. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oregeorev.2017.02.007 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Patiño DAE, Roden MF, Chaumba J, Fleisher C, Yogodzinski Y (2011) Compositional variability of terrestrial mantle apatites, thermodynamic modeling of apatite volatile contents, and the halogen and water budgets of planetary mantles. Chem Geol 288:14–31. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemgeo.2011.05.018
- Qiao B, Pan T, Chen J (2016) Geochronology, geochemical characteristic and geological significance of granodiorite in Yemaquan iron polymetallic deposit of the East Kunlun. J Qinghai Univ (Nat Sci Ed) 34:63–73 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Qu HY, Feng CY, Pei RF, He SY, Li DX, Liu JN, Wang H, Zhou JH (2015) Thermochronology of Hutouya skarn-type copper-lead-zinc polymetallic ore district in the Qimantage area, Qinghai province. Acta Geol Sin 89:498–509 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Sillitoe RH, Bonham HF (1990) Sediment-hosted gold deposits: distal products of magmatic-hydrothermal systems. Geology 18(2):157–161. https://doi.org/10.1130/0091-7613(1990)018<0157:SHGDDP>2.3.CO;2 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Simons B, Andersen JCØ, Shail RK, Jenner FE (2017) Fractionation of Li, Be, Ga, Nb, Ta, In, Sn, Sb, W and Bi in the peraluminous Early Permian Variscan granites of the Cornubian Batholith: precursor processes to magmatic-hydrothermal mineralisation. Lithos 278-281:491–512. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lithos.2017.02.007 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Uher P, Cerny P (1998) Zircon in hercynian granitic pegmatites of the Western Carpathians, Slovakia. Geol Carpath 49:261–270Google Scholar
- Uher P, Breiter K, Klecka M, Pivec E (1998) Zircon in highly evolved hercynian Homolka granite, Moldanubian zone, Czech Republic: indicator of magma source and petrogenesis. Geol Carpath 49:151–160Google Scholar
- Wang S, Feng CY, Li SJ, Jiang JH, Li DS, Su BS (2009) Zircon SHRIMP U-Pb dating of granodiorite in the Kaerqueka polymetallic ore deposit, Qimantage Mountain, Qinghai Province, and its geological implications. Geol China 36:74–84 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Wang Y, Chen H, Han J, Chen S, Huang B, Li C, Tian Q, Wang C, Wu J, Chen M (2017) Paleozoic tectonic evolution of the Dananhu-Tousuquan island arc belt, Eastern Tianshan: constraints from the magmatism of the Yuhai porphyry Cu deposit, Xinjiang, NW China. J Asian Earth Sci. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jseaes.2017.05.022
- Xu QL, Sun FY, Li BL, Qian Y, Li L, Yang YQ (2014) Geochronological dating, geochemical characteristics and tectonic setting of the granite-porphyry in the Mohexiala silver polymetallic deposit, eastern Kunlun orogenic belt. Geotecton Metallog 38:421–433 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Xu L, Bi X, Hu R, Qi Y, Tang Y, Wang X, Zhu J (2016) Redox states and genesis of magmas associated with intra-continental porphyry Cu–Au mineralization within the Jinshajiang–Red River alkaline igneous belt, SW China. Ore Geol Rev 73:330–345. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oregeorev.2015.05.007 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Zhang H, Ling MX, Liu YL, Tu XL, Wang FY, Li CY, Liang HY, Yang XY, Arndt NT, Sun WD (2013) High oxygen fugacity and slab melting linked to Cu mineralization: evidence from Dexing porphyry copper deposits, southeastern China. J Geol 121(3):289–305. https://doi.org/10.1086/669975 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Zhao YM, Feng CY, Li DX, Liu JN, Xiao Y, Yu M, Ma SC (2013) Metallogenic setting and mineralization-alteration characteristics of major skarn Fe-polymetallic deposits in Qimantag area, western Qinghai Province. Mineral Deposits 32:1–19 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
- Zhao XB, Xue CJ, Chi GX, Mo XX, Nurtaev B, Zhang GZ (2017) Zircon and molybdenite geochronology and geochemistry of the Kalmakyr porphyry Cu–Au deposit, Almalyk district, Uzbekistan: implications for mineralization processes. Ore Geol Rev 86:807–824. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oregeorev.2017.04.008 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Zhou JH, Feng CY, Shen DL, Li DX, Wang H, Zhang MY, Ma SC (2015) Geochronology, geochemistry and tectonic implications of granodiorite in the northwest of Weibao deposit, Xinjiang Qimantage. Acta Geol Sin 89:473–486 (in Chinese with English abstract)Google Scholar
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.