Age-related islet autoantibody incidence in offspring of patients with type 1 diabetes
Seroconversion to islet autoantibodies precedes type 1 diabetes. This study aimed to identify periods of high seroconversion incidence, which could be targeted for mechanistic and therapeutic studies.
Incidence of islet autoantibodies was calculated in 1,650 genetically at-risk children followed with measurements of islet autoantibodies and thyroid autoantibodies at age 9 months and 2, 5, 8, 11, 14 and 17 years. Peak incidence periods were confirmed in a second cohort of 150 children followed until age 6 years with three-monthly samples up to age 3 years.
Islet autoantibody incidence (per 1,000 person-years) was 18.5 until age 9 months, 21 from 9 months to 2 years and <10 for intervals after age 2 years. The second cohort confirmed peak incidence around age 9 months and demonstrated an absence of seroconversion before this age. Seroconversion to insulin autoantibodies occurred earlier than other autoantibodies (p < 0.01 against glutamic acid decarboxylase [GAD]-, insulinoma-associated protein 2 [IA-2]- and zinc transporter 8 [ZnT8]-autoantibodies). Early peak seroconversion incidence was most evident in children with high-risk HLA DR3/4-DQ8 or DR4/4-DQ8 genotypes.
The age period 9 months to 2 years is associated with a high incidence of activation of type 1 diabetes-associated autoimmunity in genetically at-risk children and should be targeted for effective primary prevention strategies.
KeywordsIncidence Islet autoantibody Type 1 diabetes
Glutamic acid decarboxylase
Glutamic acid decarboxylase autoantibodies
Insulinoma-associated protein 2
Insulinoma-associated protein 2 autoantibodies
Zinc transporter 8
Zinc transporter 8 autoantibodies
Type 1 diabetes is an autoimmune disorder in which disease onset is preceded by a pre-clinical period of islet autoimmunity . The initiation of islet autoimmunity is heralded by seroconversion for islet autoantibodies directed against insulin, glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD), insulinoma-associated protein 2 (IA-2) and zinc transporter 8 (ZnT8) [2, 3, 4, 5]. Progression to clinical disease after seroconversion is variable and associated with the diversity and specificity of islet autoantibodies [6, 7] as well as genetic determinants of type 1 diabetes [8, 9]. While much is known with respect to the incidence of type 1 diabetes with the notable rise over recent decades and a peak age of incidence around puberty , little is known about the incidence of islet autoimmunity and its relationship to age. Understanding periods of high and low incidence of seroconversion and their relationships with demographics and genes will provide insights into potential pathogenetic mechanisms and environmental triggers, and identify ages at which prevention strategies are most likely to be needed. We have prospectively followed from birth children who are genetically at risk for type 1 diabetes for more than 20 years, providing the opportunity to examine the incidence of seroconversion during childhood and adolescence. Here we show that seroconversion is greatest in the age period 9 months to 2 years, is rare at ages 6 months or younger, occurs earlier in boys and occurs earliest for insulin autoantibodies. These data emphasise the importance of developing immune therapies that can be safely used in neonates and infants.
Study cohort, participants and samples
The study was performed in children from the BABYDIAB Study, a longitudinal study examining the natural history of islet autoimmunity and type 1 diabetes in 1,650 children born to a mother or father with type 1 diabetes . Recruitment began in 1989 and ended in 2000. All children (840 boys, 810 girls) were recruited from Germany. The cohort is not population based and 97% of families are German and of European descent. Venous blood samples were obtained from children at study visits scheduled at 9 months and at 2, 5, 8, 11, 14 and 17 years of age. Islet autoantibodies (insulin autoantibodies [IAA], GAD autoantibodies [GADA], IA-2 autoantibodies [IA-2A] and ZnT8 autoantibodies [ZnT8-A]) were measured in samples taken at all scheduled visits, and every 6 months in children positive for islet autoantibodies. The median follow-up time from birth to last sample was 11.1 years (interquartile range, 5.7–14.0 years) and from birth to last contact was 13.9 years (interquartile range, 11.9–15.6 years).
As a confirmatory cohort, islet autoantibody incidence was examined in 150 children who participated in the BABYDIET Study . These children were selected for having both a first-degree relative with type 1 diabetes and type 1 diabetes risk HLA genotypes. Children were recruited between 2000 and 2004 and followed from the age of 3 months with three-monthly blood samples until age 3 years and subsequently with yearly blood samples. The median follow-up time from birth to last sample was 5.2 years (interquartile range, 3.2–6.6 years). The BABYDIET Study was a dietary intervention study in which children were randomised to be first exposed to gluten-containing foods at age 6 or 12 months (ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01115621). No difference in islet autoantibody development was observed with respect to randomisation group .
The BABYDIAB and BABYDIET studies were approved by the ethical committee of Bavaria, Germany (Bayerische Landesärztekammer No. 95357 and Ludwig-Maximilians University No. 329/00, respectively). All families gave written informed consent to participate in the studies. Investigations were carried out in accordance with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki, as revised in 2000.
IAA, GADA, IA-2A and ZnT8-A were determined centrally by the Institute of Diabetes Research Munich using radiobinding assays as previously described [11, 14]. Briefly, IAA were measured by protein A/G radiobinding assays using [125I]-recombinant human insulin labelled at A-14 tyrosine, and GADA, IA-2A and ZnT8-A were measured separately by protein A radiobinding assays using [35S]methionine in vitro transcribed/translated recombinant human GAD65, IA-2ic and the carboxy terminal portion of ZnT8 for the two major variants at amino acid 325 (arginine and tryptophan), respectively. The upper limit of normal for each assay was determined using Q–Q plots and corresponded to the 99th percentile of 836 control children. Islet autoantibody assays were evaluated by the Diabetes Autoantibody Standardization Program (laboratory 121) [15, 16]. Thyroid peroxidase (TPO) autoantibodies were measured using a direct radiobinding assay according to the manufacturer’s instructions (CentAK anti-TPO, Medipan, Dahlewitz/Berlin, Germany) as previously described .
HLA-DRB1, HLA-DQA1 and HLA-DQB1 alleles were typed using PCR-amplified DNA and non-radioactive sequence-specific oligonucleotide probes as described previously . Children with the high-risk HLA genotypes DR4-DQA1*030X-DQB1*0302/DR3-DQA1*0501-DQB1*0201 or DR4-DQA1*030X-DQB1*0302/DR4-DQA1*030X-DQB1*0302 were compared with children with other HLA genotypes.
Children were classified as islet autoantibody positive if they were positive for one or more islet autoantibodies in at least two consecutive samples. The age of the first autoantibody-positive sample was considered the seroconversion age in children. If a child was positive in the first sample measured, autoantibodies in the child’s mother were compared and, if positive, the child sample was classified as negative on the basis that the positive result was likely to be due to placental transfer of maternal autoantibodies. For some analyses, children were also classified as multiple islet autoantibody positive if they were positive for more than one of the antibodies measured on at least one occasion, or as single islet autoantibody positive if they were not. For these subanalyses, bias due to different follow-up times in children who seroconverted at different ages was reduced by excluding single islet autoantibody-positive children who had not been followed for at least 3 years after seroconversion (n = 19), and children who converted to multiple islet autoantibodies after 3 years of initial seroconversion (n = 8).
Islet autoantibody incidence and TPO autoantibody incidence in the BABYDIAB cohort was calculated from the number of children who newly seroconverted to islet autoantibody positivity in samples obtained at 9 months (mean age of sample, 0.85 years), 2 years (mean age of sample, 2.0 years), 5 years (mean age of sample, 5.0 years), 8 years (mean age of sample, 8.0 years), 11 years (mean age of sample, 11.0 years) and 14 years (mean age of sample, 14.0 years) and the number of children followed at each time point, and by subsequently calculating incidence as cases per 1,000 per year (per 1,000 person-years) for each time interval. As an example, if 1,500 children remained negative at their 9 month visit (median age at 9 month visit was 0.85 years) and reached their 2 year follow-up (median age at 2 year visit was 2.0 years), and 25 of these children became positive at age 2 years, the incidence for the period 9 months to 2 years would be 25/1,500/(2–0.85) × 1,000 = 14.5 per 1,000 person-years. Intervals used for the BABYDIET cohort were 0 to 6, 6.1 to 12, 12.1 to 18, 18.1 to 24, 24.1 to 36, and 36.1 to 60 months. The 95% CIs are provided around the antibody incidences.
Comparisons of islet autoantibody incidence between groups were performed using Fisher’s exact test using the actual number of cases. Time to event analyses (Kaplan–Meier) were used to examine progression from first islet autoantibody to diabetes. Kaplan–Meier analysis was used to calculate risk and to compare probabilities of type 1 diabetes in children stratified for age of seroconversion. The time from the age of seroconversion to the age at diagnosis of diabetes or the age at last follow-up was used as the event time. The logrank test was used to compare categories in the Kaplan–Meier analysis. All statistical analyses were performed using the Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS 17.0; Chicago, IL, USA).
In order to confirm the findings from the BABYDIAB cohort and to refine incidence from birth to age 3 years, islet autoantibody incidence was determined in the BABYDIET cohort (Fig. 3b). These children had a higher overall increased risk of developing islet autoantibodies than BABYDIAB children and had samples collected at 3 month intervals until age 3 years. No child seroconverted to islet autoantibody positivity at age 3 or 6 months. Peak incidence was observed in the 6.1 to 12 months age period (97 [95% CI 46, 186] per 1,000 person-years; p = 0.006 vs 0 to 6 months). Incidences for each 12 month period after age 12 months were less than 50 per 100 person-years (p = 0.02; 6.1 to 12 months vs 12.1 to 72 months). Similarly to observations in the BABYDIAB cohort, the incidence in the 6 to 12 month age period (95% CI) tended to be higher in boys than in girls (159 [66, 326] vs 48 [15, 166] per 1,000 person-years; p = 0.2).
The incidence of type 1 diabetes has its peak around puberty. Here, we show that, in genetically at-risk individuals, the incidence of islet autoantibody seroconversion has a peak at 9 months to 2 years of age. This peak incidence period is preceded by a period during which islet autoantibody seroconversion is rare, and is followed by a relatively low incidence period in which seroconversion is often characterised by single islet autoantibodies. The findings imply a heightened propensity to activate type 1 diabetes relevant autoimmunity between the ages of 9 months and 2 years, and suggest an increased susceptibility of the immune system to autoimmunity and/or increased exposure to factors that trigger autoimmunity in this period.
These are the first data providing the incidence of seroconversion to autoimmunity during childhood and adolescence. While the incidence estimates are approximate, as evidenced by relatively wide confidence intervals, there are some important and consistent messages in the data. The early peak incidence of islet autoantibody seroconversion seen at 9 months to 2 years was consistently observed in two time periods and was confirmed in a second cohort. Seroconversion at this early age was associated with a high rate of progression to diabetes and accounted for the large majority of children who developed type 1 diabetes by age 10 years, indicating that the increased seroconversion was disease relevant. The findings apply to genetically at-risk children and were pronounced in those children with both a first-degree family history of type 1 diabetes and high type 1 diabetes risk HLA class II genotypes, and thus may not be representative of all children. Nevertheless, these genetically at-risk children are those in whom first prevention therapies are tested and therefore the findings are highly relevant to prevention.
The BABYDIET cohort was informative as to when seroconversion starts to occur. No seroconversion occurred at 3 and 6 months in these children. Because there were relatively few children in this cohort, we cannot conclude that seroconversion does not occur in this period. Nevertheless, the observed lack of seroconversion is intriguing with respect to pathogenesis. Several scenarios could explain the finding. It is possible that triggers relevant for activating islet autoreactive cells are infrequent in this period. Alternatively, they may be present but there is protection against activation of autoreactive cells. Such protection could be in the form of other environmental factors or by an immune system that is downregulated or incomplete in its antigen presentation capacity, as has been suggested to be the case at birth [19, 20, 21].
In contrast to the period up to age 6 months, the subsequent period up to age 2 years presented the highest risk of developing islet autoimmunity. This was particularly evident for autoimmunity that was associated with multiple islet autoantibodies, and in children with HLA genotypes conferring high type 1 diabetes risk. The high incidence at this age may reflect exposure to environmental factors relevant to type 1 diabetes and/or susceptibility of the immune system to activation against self. It is, however, interesting to note that another type of autoimmunity has high incidence periods at a later age; seroconversion to TPO autoantibodies was frequent in this cohort, but did not reach high levels until puberty and appeared to peak in adolescence. The thyroid organ undergoes remodelling around this age as a result of increased activity [22, 23, 24], potentially explaining the increased rate of TPO autoimmunity. Interestingly, neonatal remodelling of the pancreas has been suggested to be involved in the pathogenesis of diabetes in the NOD mouse . While in humans beta cell apoptosis appears to be restricted to the first months of life , it is conceivable that beta cell growth or insulin demands after weaning could contribute to the high incidence of islet autoimmunity after age 6 months.
Of further interest with respect to pathogenesis, we found that boys tended to have an earlier peak incidence of islet autoantibody seroconversion than girls. The reason for this sex-based effect is unclear. There are several differences in hormones between boys and girls in the first years of life, including markedly increased oestradiol concentrations in girls . These differences could play a role in immune response per se  or affect beta cell remodelling or function.
Finally, the incidence data have implications for prevention in genetically at-risk children. A substantial proportion of children who develop type 1 diabetes will have seroconverted between 9 months and 2 years of age. Thus, if we are to prevent type 1 diabetes, primary prevention will be most needed in the first months of life. Of potential benefit, this period may be associated with protection against autoimmunity and may be ideal for therapies aiming to induce autoantigen-specific immune tolerance. The earlier seroconversion of IAA suggests that (pro)insulin is an important antigen to target in this early period. An alternative to inducing early immune tolerance could be to protect high-risk children during the high incidence period with treatments that inhibit T cell activation or protect beta cells from apoptosis. If successful, such short-term treatments could reduce the incidence of childhood autoimmune diabetes.
We thank A. Knopff and J. Stock (Forschergruppe Diabetes e.V. at Helmholtz Center Munich, Neuherberg, Germany) and M. Zwilling (Forschergruppe Diabetes, Klinikum Rechts der Isar, University of Technology, Munich) for data collection and expert technical assistance, and K. Adler (Forschergruppe Diabetes, Klinikum Rechts der Isar, University of Technology, Munich) for laboratory management. We also thank all paediatricians and family doctors in Germany for participating in the BABYDIAB Study.
The work was supported by grants from the Helmholtz Zentrum München, the Competence Network for Diabetes Mellitus funded by the Federal Ministry of Education and Research (FKZ 01GI0805-07), the European Union (EP7-HEALTH-2007, DIAPREPP N202013), the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG ZI-310/14-1 to 14-4) and the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation (JDRF; no 1-2006-665). E. Bonifacio is supported by the DFG Research Center and Cluster of Excellence–Center for Regenerative Therapies, Dresden (FZ 111).
Duality of interest
The authors declare that there is no duality of interest associated with this manuscript.
A-GZ is the principal investigator of the BABYDIAB and BABYDIET studies, designed the studies and concept, undertook statistical analyses, interpreted the results, wrote the manuscript and critically reviewed it for intellectual content. EB performed the statistical analysis, interpreted the results, wrote the manuscript, and critically reviewed it for intellectual content. The BABYDIAB-BABYDIET Study group members contributed to cohort contact and follow-up (MP, CW, EG, MH, SH), autoantibody measurements (PA, SK), data preparation, assembly and quality check (MP, CW, SH) and manuscript writing (MP, CW, EG). All the authors have read and edited the manuscript and approved the version to be published.