The mechanism of ageing: primary role of transposable elements in genome disintegration
- 3k Downloads
Understanding the molecular basis of ageing remains a fundamental problem in biology. In multicellular organisms, while the soma undergoes a progressive deterioration over the lifespan, the germ line is essentially immortal as it interconnects the subsequent generations. Genomic instability in somatic cells increases with age, and accumulating evidence indicates that the disintegration of somatic genomes is accompanied by the mobilisation of transposable elements (TEs) that, when mobilised, can be mutagenic by disrupting coding or regulatory sequences. In contrast, TEs are effectively silenced in the germ line by the Piwi-piRNA system. Here, we propose that TE repression transmits the persistent proliferation capacity and the non-ageing phenotype (e.g., preservation of genomic integrity) of the germ line. The Piwi-piRNA pathway also operates in tumorous cells and in somatic cells of certain organisms, including hydras, which likewise exhibit immortality. However, in somatic cells lacking the Piwi-piRNA pathway, gradual chromatin decondensation increasingly allows the mobilisation of TEs as the organism ages. This can explain why the mortality rate rises exponentially throughout the adult life in most animal species, including humans.
KeywordsLifespan determination Age-related diseases Retroelements Repetitive sequences Chromatin relaxation Non-coding small RNAs Methylation Cancer
Understanding what actually causes ageing remains admittedly a fundamental and fascinating problem in biology . Experimental data accumulated in the last three decades have led to the identification of various environmental and genetic factors, as well as chemical substances that influence lifespan in divergent eukaryotic species [1, 2]. Organisms normally age faster and hence live shorter under stress conditions that can lead to the generation of DNA mutations and, often as a consequence of mutations, damaged cytoplasmic constituents (including injured proteins, lipids, carbohydrates and organelles). Such types of damage can interfere with cellular functioning; thereby, they should be eliminated by effective repair and self-cleaning mechanisms to maintain cellular homeostasis. These mechanisms include DNA repair pathways, molecular chaperons, as well as the proteasome–ubiquitin system and lysosome-mediated autophagy, the main forms of cellular self-degradation . This has led to the attractive model that the gradual, lifelong accumulation of unrepaired cellular damage drives the ageing process and determines the incidence of age-related fatal diseases [4, 5].
However, some observations contradict certain aspects of this damage-driven model of ageing. First, mutations should appear exponentially during the lifespan if they are to explain mortality patterns apparent at advanced ages (mortality rates often rise exponentially throughout adult life) . Environmental and metabolic stress factors causing mutations, however, appear to be nearly constant during lifespan in any species examined. Thus, the causal role of mutations in the ageing process remains largely unclear . Second, in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans lowering mitochondrial respiration during adulthood only does not affect lifespan, even though it lowers the amount of cellular damage that are caused by reactive oxygen species generated during respiration . Third, mice defective for Pms2, a DNA mismatch repair gene, display a 100-fold elevation in mutation frequency and a dramatically increased cancer rate, while not exhibiting an accelerated ageing phenotype . One can argue that the early death stemming from the increased prevalence of cancer in Pms2 mutant animals may be masking the signs of accelerated ageing . However, C. elegans strains deficient in msh-2, another mismatch repair gene, have a lifespan identical to that of the wild type , and the soma of this organism is known to be devoid of cancer. It is also possible that many ageing phenotypes could be caused by genome rearrangements and not by point mutations . Nevertheless, these examples show that the rate of ageing cannot be lowered by merely increasing the effectiveness of cellular repair mechanisms or diminishing the severity of factors responsible for damage. It may, therefore, be inferred that ageing is primarily caused by factors that are beyond the capabilities of cellular repair mechanisms.
Another attractive model of ageing is formulated by the “telomere shortening theory” . The activity of the telomerase enzyme complex responsible for maintaining the structure of the chromosome ends (telomeres) at each round of cell division likewise affects lifespan in a number of model organisms [11, 12]. Still, the ageing process of postmitotic cells (like neurons) contradicts the theory. Furthermore, the somatic cells of adult C. elegans do not divide, meaning that the shortening of telomeric regions is not an issue even in the case of a complete absence of telomerase activity . Regardless, the adult nematode ages and dies in about 2 weeks. Thus, the effect of telomere length on ageing appears to be rather complex.
Unlike the soma, the germ line shows no sign of ageing. What is it that renders the germ line potentially immortal? The question is relevant as its cells also display metabolism and respond to diverse molecular and environmental stress factors. And how can certain organisms (such as certain hydras and the jellyfish Turritopsis nutricula) be immortal, when the above features define their somatic cells as well?
Age-related differences in genomic integrity between somatic and germ line cells
In most eukaryotic organisms, the genome of somatic cells progressively accumulates mutations, mostly genomic rearrangements, as the individual ages [14, 15, 16]; whereas the integrity of genetic material in germ line cells remains largely stable (the latter could result from either selection against mutations—damaged embryos just die at early stages—or a decreased mutation rate [14, 15, 16]). This suggests that uncovering the causes of this difference between the stability of the genetic information of these two cell types may help to understand the mechanisms that are actually responsible for ageing. This view is supported by a recent discovery of ectopic expression of germ line-specific genes in the soma of long-lived insulin/IGF-1 signalling-defective nematodes . The longer lifespan can thus be characterised by soma-to-germ line transformation of cell fate.
The eukaryotic genome is organised into a highly ordered chromatin structure composed of DNA and histone proteins. Different regions of the genome exist in either the relatively loose euchromatin or tightly packaged heterochromatin state. The former represents transcriptionally active domains, while the latter represents transcriptionally silent chromosomal regions. Histone proteins can be covalently modified at specific amino acid side chains to modify gene expression. Hallmark features of heterochromatin formation include, for example, histone hypoacetylation, H3K9 (histone protein H3 lysine-9) hypermethylation, and recruitment of heterochromatin protein 1 (HP1) . In the soma, heterochromatin domains established early in embryogenesis are progressively broken down during ageing [18, 19]. This age-associated gradual loss of heterochromatin contributes to the derepression of silenced genes at the affected loci. Although heterochromatization at specific loci can also occur, ageing is associated with an overall net decrease in heterochromatin state in somatic cells [18, 19]. Indeed, overexpression of HP1 that promotes chromatin condensation extends lifespan in the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster . Genetic data indicate that longevity response triggered by caloric restriction is tightly coupled to the modification of heterochromatic domains in the somatic genome . Furthermore, DNA methylation at the 5 position of cytosine (5-methylcytosine) also leads to epigenetic repression of gene expression, and markedly decreases as the organism ages (with an overall decrease in methylcytosine content, but with local increases in some cytosine guanine dinucleotide—CpG—islands) . This phenomenon cannot be observed in immortal cell lines [23, 24]. Hence, another common molecular feature associated with ageing is the global hypomethylation of genomic DNA .
Loss of heterochromatin structure and hypomethylation allow for the activation and relocation of transposable elements (TEs) that constitute a significant part of eukaryotic genomes (>45 % of the human genome consist of TEs [26, 27, 28]. For example, a progressive decline in DNA methylation during ageing preferentially takes place in TE-derived repetitive elements dispersed throughout the genome . Mobilisation of TEs can lead to genomic instability: if a TE jumps into a functional (coding or regulatory) region of the genome, the insertion often results in loss of function, thereby, facilitating the death of the affected cell. The mass occurrence of transposition events can lead to various degenerative processes .
TEs, their mobilisation and silencing
TEs can be divided into two main groups, DNA transposons and retrotransposons . DNA transposons are DNA stretches that encode an enzyme called transposase. In a so-called cut-and-paste transposition mechanism, the transposase binds to the inverted repeat sequences found at the ends of the transposon, and slices the DNA at these sites. The sliced DNA fragment is then integrated into a new genomic locus by the transposase.
Retrotransposons can be subdivided into two subgroups, retrotransposons with long terminal repeats (LTR retrotransposons) and without LTR (non-LTR retrotransposons). LTR retrotransposons are widely distributed in eukaryotes, and make up nearly 8 % of the human genome . Non-LTR retrotransposons are the most abundant TEs in mammals, represented by the long and short interspersed nuclear elements (LINEs and SINEs). Retrotransposons can mobilise themselves through an element-derived RNA intermediate, which is converted into a complementary DNA (cDNA) by reverse transcription, followed by integration into a new genomic locus, thereby generating a second copy of the TE (copy-and-paste mechanism).
The piRNA pathways can also repress TE activity at the transcriptional level through RNA-mediated chromatin modification collectively called RNA-mediated epigenetic silencing. piRNAs not only promote degradation of TE mRNA, but also they can direct the recruitment of chromatin modifying factors to specific loci [35, 36].
Changes in chromatin structure and TE activity during ageing
Epigenetic changes influencing TE activity can be uniformly observed during ageing. For example, the murine intracisternal A-particle (IAP) retrotransposon has been found to become active upon ageing, and this change is associated with a progressive demethylation of the IAP promoter during the lifespan . DNA methylation in humans also decreases as the individual ages . A significant decline in average Alu (the most common SINE in primates) methylation over the lifespan was detected; age is thus negatively associated with methylation levels of Alu sequences . Furthermore, whole-genome bisulfite sequencing in humans revealed that the centenarian DNA has significantly lower methylation content, as compared with the newborn DNA . Together, these observations may reveal a general epigenetic process that could account for a series of events associated with ageing. Indeed, genome-wide methylation profiles were recently used to quantify individual ageing rates in humans .
There are several examples establishing a relationship between TE activity and ageing in different eukaryotic organisms ranging from fungi to humans. In yeast, retrotransposition of Ty1 (an LTR-retrotransposon) is associated with genomic instability during chronological ageing; Ty1 mobility occurs at elevated rates in old populations . Transposition in mitochondrial DNA also causes senescence in Neurospora . Thus, a correlation between retrotransposition and genome instability exists during fungal ageing. Furthermore, transcriptional profiling of ageing in C. elegans revealed that only less than 1 % of the genome shows significant changes in transcript levels as the organism ages . Among these genes, expression of certain transposases markedly increases in older worms. In addition, somatic excision of Tc1, a DNA transposon in C. elegans, increases by more than 14-fold during the organism’s lifespan . In an inbred D. melanogaster line, a significant age dependence of the transposition rate of the retrotransposon copia was documented . Consistent with these findings, reverse transcriptase inhibitors caused retardation of ageing in this species . In addition, it was recently found that several TEs were highly active in the Drosophila brain during normal ageing, suggesting that TE activation with age contributes to neuronal decline . In humans, somatic expression of LINE1 elements has also been widely detected, and associated with the induction of DNA damage . In the adult human brain, somatic retrotransposition reshapes the genetic circuitry in an individual pattern, underlying various pathological processes at advanced ages . Senescence-associated somatic expression of LINE1 elements has also been widely detected . Moreover, repression of LINE1 by SIRT6 into transcriptionally inactive heterochromatin fails to occur during the course of ageing . Together, these data show that genetic damage generated by TE mobilisation in somatic cells may be a characteristic feature of ageing. Thus, TEs may have an important, suicidal role in age-related genomic instability [51, 52, 53].
Somatic activity of the Piwi-piRNA pathway and its potential role in extreme longevity
The Piwi-piRNA pathway effectively silences TE activity in the germ line, contributing considerably to genome integrity and immortality of this tissue. Here, we hypothesise that somatic expression of the pathway is responsible for the absence of the ageing phenotype in certain organisms, particularly lower eukaryotes. A Cnidarian, the freshwater hydra Hydra vulgaris, exhibits an almost unlimited regeneration capacity and immortality . Its adult body largely consists of populations of stem cells with an unlimited proliferating and self-renewal capacity. These types of hydrozoan somatic cells are characterised by the abundant expression of Piwi proteins and Piwi-interacting RNAs [55, 56], suggesting low levels of TE activity in their genome. Another Cnidarian, the jellyfish T. nutricula, is also regarded as an immortal organism, as the sexually mature adult is able to transform itself back into a post-larval polyp stage, and repeat this cycle indefinitely . Somatic cells of the closely related hydrozoan Podocoryne carnea, which can also alternate between the mature medusa and post-larval polyp stages, accumulate Piwi-like proteins (Cniwi) in somatic cells during all developmental stages . This organism is likewise capable of continuously renewing its tissues. Considering that these Cnidarians are subjected to the same external DNA damaging factors as all other eukaryotic organisms, and that their DNA repair systems are not known to exhibit extraordinary effectiveness, we suggest that the activity of the Piwi-piRNA system is the cause of the non-ageing phenotype of their soma. In addition, some planarians (flatworms) display an extraordinary ability to regenerate lost body parts . This phenomenon is used in asexual reproduction: the animal detaches its tail ends and each half regrows the lost parts by regeneration. During the process, adult stem cells divide and differentiate, and their activities are functionally associated with Piwi-like proteins . As they have an apparently limitless regenerative capacity, planarians are considered to be effectively immortal. The amphibian Mexican axolotl also represents an animal species that lives unusually long (up to 25 years). In this organism, abundant activation of germ line-specific Piwi genes in the soma, especially in the wound epidermis, is required for injury-induced effective regeneration of limbs . Thus, somatic activity of Piwi proteins and piRNAs is likely to contribute to increased longevity and regeneration capacity in these organisms.
TE activity and the mechanism of ageing
It has been widely accepted that ageing is associated with the progressive, lifelong accumulation of unrepaired cellular damage [1, 2]. Cells respond to molecular stress by activating various defence mechanisms and eventually by dying. Massive levels of cell loss then lead to tissue deterioration and, eventually, to organismal death .
Mutations induced by physical and chemical mutagens occur independently from TEs (biological mutagens) in both germ line and somatic cells, but the majority of these are repaired by effective molecular mechanisms, which include DNA repair pathways, molecular chaperones, autophagy and the ubiquitin–proteasome system (Fig. 2a–c). These cell repair mechanisms are likely to be equally effective in the soma and germ line, but they do operate with some imperfection. This imperfection, however, is inconsequential, as the damaged cells are eliminated at the population level (microevolution) . The primary difference is that in the germ line, the TEs are largely silenced by the Piwi-piRNA pathway; while in the soma, TEs become progressively active during the lifespan. Replicative transposition is self-duplicating, enabling the number of retrotransposon-induced mutations to grow exponentially in the somatic genome over time, and explaining why the mortality rate rises exponentially throughout adult life in most animal species (Fig. 2c). Since TEs constitute a significant portion of eukaryotic genomes, the mutagenic effect of their activity may be considerable [46, 50, 63], thereby providing a plausible explanation for the difference in mutation rates between somatic and germ line genomes. Thus, TE activity may be the main factor in ageing. In the germ line, the mutation rate is constant due to the silenced TEs, in contrast to the exponential rate of TE-derived mutagenesis in the soma. As a result of the exponential mutation rate, damaged somatic cells cannot be eliminated after a while, since the rate of mutation surpasses the rate of elimination, a process that manifests in ageing (Fig. 2b, c). Note that factors modulating the accumulation of cellular damage generally affect transposition as well. For instance, caloric restriction leads to attenuation of metabolism (including respiration) and, through reduced transcription and cell proliferation rate, lowered transposition activity . The constant mutation rate of the germ line does not exceed the elimination rate, allowing all damaged cells to be eliminated from the population through cell loss or early embryo death (Fig. 2c) (in C. elegans, for example, nearly half of the germ cells undergo apoptosis ). This is why mutant or damaged cells cannot accumulate in the germ line, allowing it to attain the quality of immortality.
This work was supported by the grants OTKA (Hungarian Scientific Research Fund) NK78012 and MEDinPROT Protein Science Research Synergy Program (provided by the Hungarian Academy of Sciences) to T. V. The authors are grateful to Daniel Sturm for his proofreading and translation assistance.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no competing financial interest.
- 10.Degtyareva NP, Greenwell P, Hofmann ER, Hengartner MO, Zhang L, Culotti JG, Petes TD (2002) Caenorhabditis elegans DNA mismatch repair gene msh-2 is required for microsatellite stability and maintenance of genome integrity. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99(4):2158–2163. doi: 10.1073/pnas.032671599 CrossRefPubMedCentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 12.Tomas-Loba A, Flores I, Fernandez-Marcos PJ, Cayuela ML, Maraver A, Tejera A, Borras C, Matheu A, Klatt P, Flores JM, Vina J, Serrano M, Blasco MA (2008) Telomerase reverse transcriptase delays aging in cancer-resistant mice. Cell 135(4):609–622. doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2008.09.034 CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 22.Hannum G, Guinney J, Zhao L, Zhang L, Hughes G, Sadda S, Klotzle B, Bibikova M, Fan JB, Gao Y, Deconde R, Chen M, Rajapakse I, Friend S, Ideker T, Zhang K (2012) Genome-wide methylation profiles reveal quantitative views of human aging rates. Mol Cell 49(2):359–367. doi: 10.1016/j.molcel.2012.10.016 CrossRefPubMedCentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 39.Heyn H, Li N, Ferreira HJ, Moran S, Pisano DG, Gomez A, Diez J, Sanchez-Mut JV, Setien F, Carmona FJ, Puca AA, Sayols S, Pujana MA, Serra-Musach J, Iglesias-Platas I, Formiga F, Fernandez AF, Fraga MF, Heath SC, Valencia A, Gut IG, Wang J, Esteller M (2012) Distinct DNA methylomes of newborns and centenarians. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 109(26):10522–10527. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1120658109 CrossRefPubMedCentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 48.Baillie JK, Barnett MW, Upton KR, Gerhardt DJ, Richmond TA, De Sapio F, Brennan PM, Rizzu P, Smith S, Fell M, Talbot RT, Gustincich S, Freeman TC, Mattick JS, Hume DA, Heutink P, Carninci P, Jeddeloh JA, Faulkner GJ (2011) Somatic retrotransposition alters the genetic landscape of the human brain. Nature 479(7374):534–537. doi: 10.1038/nature10531 CrossRefPubMedCentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 49.De Cecco M, Criscione SW, Peckham EJ, Hillenmeyer S, Hamm EA, Manivannan J, Peterson AL, Kreiling JA, Neretti N, Sedivy JM (2013) Genomes of replicatively senescent cells undergo global epigenetic changes leading to gene silencing and activation of transposable elements. Aging Cell 12(2):247–256. doi: 10.1111/acel.12047 CrossRefPubMedCentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 61.Zhu W, Pao GM, Satoh A, Cummings G, Monaghan JR, Harkins TT, Bryant SV, Randal Voss S, Gardiner DM, Hunter T (2012) Activation of germ line-specific genes is required for limb regeneration in the Mexican axolotl. Dev Biol 370(1):42–51. doi: 10.1016/j.ydbio.2012.07.021 CrossRefPubMedCentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 63.Wang J, Geesman GJ, Hostikka SL, Atallah M, Blackwell B, Lee E, Cook PJ, Pasaniuc B, Shariat G, Halperin E, Dobke M, Rosenfeld MG, Jordan IK, Lunyak VV (2011) Inhibition of activated pericentromeric SINE/Alu repeat transcription in senescent human adult stem cells reinstates self-renewal. Cell Cycle 10(17):3016–3030CrossRefPubMedCentralPubMedGoogle Scholar