Abstract
New theoretical approaches developed in the last years predict that macroscopic quantum gravity effects in black holes should lead to modifications of the gravitational wave signals expected in the framework of classical general relativity, with these modifications being characterized in certain scenarios by the existence of dampened rep-etitions of the primary signal. Here we use the fact that non-perturbative corrections to the near-horizon external geometry of black holes are necessary for these modifications to exist, in order to classify different proposals and paradigms with respect to this criterion and study in a neat and systematic way their phenomenology. Proposals that lead naturally to the existence of echoes in the late-time ringdown of gravitational wave signals from black hole mergers must share the replacement of black holes by horizonless configurations with a physical surface showing reflective properties in the relevant range of frequencies. On the other hand, proposals or paradigms that restrict quantum gravity effects on the external geometry to be perturbative, such as black hole complementarity or the closely related firewall proposal, do not display echoes. For the sake of completeness we exploit the interplay between the timescales associated with the formation of firewalls and the mechanism behind the existence of echoes in order to conclude that even unconventional distortions of the firewall concept (such as naked firewalls) do not lead to this phenomenon.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Virgo, LIGO Scientific collaboration, B.P. Abbott et al., Observation of gravitational waves from a binary black hole merger, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116 (2016) 061102 [arXiv:1602.03837] [INSPIRE].
Virgo, LIGO Scientific collaboration, B.P. Abbott et al., GW151226: observation of gravitational waves from a 22-solar-mass binary black hole coalescence, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116 (2016) 241103 [arXiv:1606.04855] [INSPIRE].
Virgo, LIGO Scientific collaboration, B.P. Abbott et al., Binary black hole mergers in the first advanced LIGO observing run, Phys. Rev. X 6 (2016) 041015 [arXiv:1606.04856] [INSPIRE].
M. Aparicio Resco, A. de la Cruz-Dombriz, F.J. Llanes Estrada and V. Zapatero Castrillo, On neutron stars in f (R) theories: small radii, large masses and large energy emitted in a merger, Phys. Dark Univ. 13 (2016) 147 [arXiv:1602.03880] [INSPIRE].
A. Einstein, Näherungsweise Integration der Feldgleichungen der Gravitation, Sitz. König. Preuß. Akad. Wiss. (1916) 688.
J. Stachel, The early history of quantum gravity (1916-1940), in Black holes, gravitational radiation and the universe, B.R. Iyer, Springer, Germany (1999).
S.W. Hawking, Black hole explosions, Nature 248 (1974) 30 [INSPIRE].
S.W. Hawking, Particle creation by black holes, Commun. Math. Phys. 43 (1975) 199 [Erratum ibid. 46 (1976) 206] [INSPIRE].
S.W. Hawking, Breakdown of predictability in gravitational collapse, Phys. Rev. D 14 (1976) 2460 [INSPIRE].
G.L. Landsberg, Discovering new physics in the decays of black holes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 88 (2002) 181801 [hep-ph/0112061] [INSPIRE].
P. Kanti, Black holes in theories with large extra dimensions: a review, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 19 (2004) 4899 [hep-ph/0402168] [INSPIRE].
A. Barrau, C. Feron and J. Grain, Astrophysical production of microscopic black holes in a low Planck-scale world, Astrophys. J. 630 (2005) 1015 [astro-ph/0505436] [INSPIRE].
A.M. Green, Primordial black holes: sirens of the early Universe, Fundam. Theor. Phys. 178 (2015) 129 [arXiv:1403.1198].
A. Avelino and R.P. Kirshner, The dimensionless age of the Universe: a riddle for our time, Astrophys. J. 828 (2016) 35 [arXiv:1607.00002] [INSPIRE].
C. Barcelo, L.J. Garay and G. Jannes, Quantum non-gravity and stellar collapse, Found. Phys. 41 (2011) 1532 [arXiv:1002.4651] [INSPIRE].
C. Barcelo, R. Carballo-Rubio, L.J. Garay and G. Jannes, The lifetime problem of evaporating black holes: mutiny or resignation, Class. Quant. Grav. 32 (2015) 035012 [arXiv:1409.1501] [INSPIRE].
V. Cardoso, E. Franzin and P. Pani, Is the gravitational-wave ringdown a probe of the event horizon?, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116 (2016) 171101 [arXiv:1602.07309] [INSPIRE].
V. Cardoso, S. Hopper, C.F.B. Macedo, C. Palenzuela and P. Pani, Gravitational-wave signatures of exotic compact objects and of quantum corrections at the horizon scale, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 084031 [arXiv:1608.08637] [INSPIRE].
J. Abedi, H. Dykaar and N. Afshordi, Echoes from the Abyss: Evidence for Planck-scale structure at black hole horizons, arXiv:1612.00266 [INSPIRE].
G. Ashton et al., Comments on: “Echoes from the abyss: evidence for Planck-scale structure at black hole horizons”, arXiv:1612.05625 [INSPIRE].
J. Abedi, H. Dykaar and N. Afshordi, Echoes from the abyss: the holiday edition!, arXiv:1701.03485 [INSPIRE].
A. Almheiri, D. Marolf, J. Polchinski and J. Sully, Black holes: complementarity or firewalls?, JHEP 02 (2013) 062 [arXiv:1207.3123] [INSPIRE].
A. Almheiri, D. Marolf, J. Polchinski, D. Stanford and J. Sully, An apologia for firewalls, JHEP 09 (2013) 018 [arXiv:1304.6483] [INSPIRE].
C. Barcelo, S. Liberati, S. Sonego and M. Visser, Fate of gravitational collapse in semiclassical gravity, Phys. Rev. D 77 (2008) 044032 [arXiv:0712.1130] [INSPIRE].
M. Visser, C. Barcelo, S. Liberati and S. Sonego, Small, dark and heavy: but is it a black hole?, arXiv:0902.0346 [INSPIRE].
C. Barceló, S. Liberati, S. Sonego and M. Visser, Black stars, not holes, Sci. Am. 301 (2009) 38.
P.O. Mazur and E. Mottola, Gravitational vacuum condensate stars, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 101 (2004) 9545 [gr-qc/0407075] [INSPIRE].
E. Mottola, New horizons in gravity: the trace anomaly, dark energy and condensate stars, Acta Phys. Polon. B 41 (2010) 2031 [arXiv:1008.5006] [INSPIRE].
T. Vachaspati, D. Stojkovic and L.M. Krauss, Observation of incipient black holes and the information loss problem, Phys. Rev. D 76 (2007) 024005 [gr-qc/0609024] [INSPIRE].
T. Vachaspati and D. Stojkovic, Quantum radiation from quantum gravitational collapse, Phys. Lett. B 663 (2008) 107 [gr-qc/0701096] [INSPIRE].
A. Saini and D. Stojkovic, Radiation from a collapsing object is manifestly unitary, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114 (2015) 111301 [arXiv:1503.01487] [INSPIRE].
H. Kawai, Y. Matsuo and Y. Yokokura, A self-consistent model of the black hole evaporation, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 28 (2013) 1350050 [arXiv:1302.4733] [INSPIRE].
H. Kawai and Y. Yokokura, Phenomenological description of the interior of the Schwarzschild black hole, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 30 (2015) 1550091 [arXiv:1409.5784] [INSPIRE].
H. Kawai and Y. Yokokura, A model of black hole evaporation and 4D weyl anomaly, arXiv:1701.03455 [INSPIRE].
P.-M. Ho, The absence of horizon in black-hole formation, Nucl. Phys. B 909 (2016) 394 [arXiv:1510.07157] [INSPIRE].
V. Baccetti, R.B. Mann and D.R. Terno, Role of evaporation in gravitational collapse, arXiv:1610.07839 [INSPIRE].
E. Greenwood, D.I. Podolsky and G.D. Starkman, Pre-Hawking radiation from a collapsing shell, JCAP 11 (2011) 024 [arXiv:1011.2219] [INSPIRE].
J. Bardeen, Non-singular general-relativistic gravitational collapse, in the proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Gravitation and the Theory of Relativity (GR5), Tbilisi, Georgia (1968).
S.W. Hawking, Information loss in black holes, Phys. Rev. D 72 (2005) 084013 [hep-th/0507171] [INSPIRE].
A. Ori, Firewall or smooth horizon?, Gen. Rel. Grav. 48 (2016) 9 [arXiv:1208.6480] [INSPIRE].
I. Dymnikova, Vacuum nonsingular black hole, Gen. Rel. Grav. 24 (1992) 235 [INSPIRE].
E. Ayon-Beato and A. Garcia, The Bardeen model as a nonlinear magnetic monopole, Phys. Lett. B 493 (2000) 149 [gr-qc/0009077] [INSPIRE].
C. Bambi and L. Modesto, Rotating regular black holes, Phys. Lett. B 721 (2013) 329 [arXiv:1302.6075] [INSPIRE].
T. De Lorenzo, A. Giusti and S. Speziale, Non-singular rotating black hole with a time delay in the center, Gen. Rel. Grav. 48 (2016) 31 [arXiv:1510.08828] [INSPIRE].
R. Torres and F. Fayos, On regular rotating black holes, Gen. Rel. Grav. 49 (2017) 2 [arXiv:1611.03654] [INSPIRE].
V.P. Frolov, Notes on non-singular models of black holes, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 104056 [arXiv:1609.01758] [INSPIRE].
S. Ansoldi, Spherical black holes with regular center: a review of existing models including a recent realization with Gaussian sources, talk given at the Conference on Black Holes and Naked Singularities, May 10-12, Milan, Italy (2008), arXiv:0802.0330 [INSPIRE].
C. Barceló, R. Carballo-Rubio and L.J. Garay, Where does the physics of extreme gravitational collapse reside?, Universe 2 (2016) 7 [arXiv:1510.04957] [INSPIRE].
S.A. Hayward, Formation and evaporation of regular black holes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96 (2006) 031103 [gr-qc/0506126] [INSPIRE].
V.P. Frolov, Information loss problem and a ‘black hole’ model with a closed apparent horizon, JHEP 05 (2014) 049 [arXiv:1402.5446] [INSPIRE].
L. Susskind, L. Thorlacius and J. Uglum, The stretched horizon and black hole complementarity, Phys. Rev. D 48 (1993) 3743 [hep-th/9306069] [INSPIRE].
V.P. Frolov and G.A. Vilkovisky, Spherically symmetric collapse in quantum gravity, Phys. Lett. B 106 (1981) 307 [INSPIRE].
P. Hajicek, Quantum theory of gravitational collapse: (Lecture notes on quantum conchology), Lect. Notes Phys. 631 (2003) 255 [gr-qc/0204049].
M. Ambrus and P. Hajicek, Quantum superposition principle and gravitational collapse: scattering times for spherical shells, Phys. Rev. D 72 (2005) 064025 [gr-qc/0507017] [INSPIRE].
S.B. Giddings, Nonviolent nonlocality, Phys. Rev. D 88 (2013) 064023 [arXiv:1211.7070] [INSPIRE].
S.B. Giddings and Y. Shi, Effective field theory models for nonviolent information transfer from black holes, Phys. Rev. D 89 (2014) 124032 [arXiv:1310.5700] [INSPIRE].
S.B. Giddings, Possible observational windows for quantum effects from black holes, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 124033 [arXiv:1406.7001] [INSPIRE].
S.B. Giddings, Gravitational wave tests of quantum modifications to black hole structure — With post-GW150914 update, Class. Quant. Grav. 33 (2016) 235010 [arXiv:1602.03622] [INSPIRE].
C. Rovelli and F. Vidotto, Planck stars, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 23 (2014) 1442026 [arXiv:1401.6562] [INSPIRE].
M. Christodoulou, C. Rovelli, S. Speziale and I. Vilensky, Planck star tunneling time: an astrophysically relevant observable from background-free quantum gravity, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 084035 [arXiv:1605.05268] [INSPIRE].
C. Barceló, R. Carballo-Rubio and L.J. Garay, Mutiny at the white-hole district, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 23 (2014) 1442022 [arXiv:1407.1391] [INSPIRE].
C. Barceló, R. Carballo-Rubio and L.J. Garay, Black holes turn white fast, otherwise stay black: no half measures, JHEP 01 (2016) 157 [arXiv:1511.00633] [INSPIRE].
C. Barceló, R. Carballo-Rubio and L.J. Garay, Exponential fading to white of black holes in quantum gravity, Class. Quant. Grav. 34 (2017) 105007 [arXiv:1607.03480] [INSPIRE].
A. Barrau, C. Rovelli and F. Vidotto, Fast radio bursts and white hole signals, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 127503 [arXiv:1409.4031] [INSPIRE].
S.L. Liebling and C. Palenzuela, Dynamical boson stars, Living Rev. Rel. 15 (2012) 6 [arXiv:1202.5809] [INSPIRE].
D.D. Ivanenko and D.F. Kurdgelaidze, Hypothesis concerning quark stars, Astrophys. 1 (1965) 251.
N. Itoh, Hydrostatic equilibrium of hypothetical quark stars, Prog. Theor. Phys. 44 (1970) 291 [INSPIRE].
G. Chapline, E. Hohlfeld, R.B. Laughlin and D.I. Santiago, Quantum phase transitions and the breakdown of classical general relativity, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 18 (2003) 3587 [gr-qc/0012094] [INSPIRE].
R. Konoplya and A. Zhidenko, Detection of gravitational waves from black holes: is there a window for alternative theories?, Phys. Lett. B 756 (2016) 350 [arXiv:1602.04738] [INSPIRE].
M. Visser, The Kerr spacetime: a brief introduction, talk given at Kerr Fest: Black Holes in Astrophysics, General Relativity and Quantum Gravity, August 26-28, Christchurch, New Zealand (2004), arXiv:0706.0622 [INSPIRE].
E.T. Akhmedov, D.A. Kalinov and F.K. Popov, Method for distinguishing very compact stellar objects from black holes, Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) 064006 [arXiv:1601.03894] [INSPIRE].
R. Brustein and A.J.M. Medved, Discovering the interior of black holes, arXiv:1701.07444 [INSPIRE].
H. Yang, A. Zimmerman, A. Zenginoglu, F. Zhang, E. Berti and Y. Chen, Quasinormal modes of nearly extremal Kerr spacetimes: spectrum bifurcation and power-law ringdown, Phys. Rev. D 88 (2013) 044047 [arXiv:1307.8086] [INSPIRE].
M. Visser, Black holes in general relativity, arXiv:0901.4365 [INSPIRE].
K.S. Thorne, Probing black holes and relativistic stars with gravitational waves, in the proceedings of Black holes and the structure of the Universe: 6th Conference on Quantum Mechanics of Fundamental Systems, August 18-20, Santiago, Chile (1997), gr-qc/9706079 [INSPIRE].
M. Visser and D.L. Wiltshire, Stable gravastars: an alternative to black holes?, Class. Quant. Grav. 21 (2004) 1135 [gr-qc/0310107] [INSPIRE].
C. Cattoen, T. Faber and M. Visser, Gravastars must have anisotropic pressures, Class. Quant. Grav. 22 (2005) 4189 [gr-qc/0505137] [INSPIRE].
A.E. Broderick and R. Narayan, Where are all the gravastars? Limits upon the gravastar model from accreting black holes, Class. Quant. Grav. 24 (2007) 659 [gr-qc/0701154] [INSPIRE].
P. Rocha, R. Chan, M.F.A. da Silva and A. Wang, Stable and ‘bounded excursion’ gravastars and black holes in Einstein’s theory of gravity, JCAP 11 (2008) 010 [arXiv:0809.4879] [INSPIRE].
N. Sakai, H. Saida and T. Tamaki, Gravastar shadows, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 104013 [arXiv:1408.6929] [INSPIRE].
P.O. Mazur and E. Mottola, Surface tension and negative pressure interior of a non-singular ‘black hole’, Class. Quant. Grav. 32 (2015) 215024 [arXiv:1501.03806] [INSPIRE].
C.B. M.H. Chirenti and L. Rezzolla, How to tell a gravastar from a black hole, Class. Quant. Grav. 24 (2007) 4191 [arXiv:0706.1513] [INSPIRE].
C. Chirenti and L. Rezzolla, Did GW150914 produce a rotating gravastar?, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 084016 [arXiv:1602.08759] [INSPIRE].
B. Holdom and J. Ren, Not quite a black hole, Phys. Rev. D 95 (2017) 084034 [arXiv:1612.04889] [INSPIRE].
A.E. Broderick, A. Loeb and R. Narayan, The event horizon of Sagittarius A*, Astrophys. J. 701 (2009) 1357 [arXiv:0903.1105] [INSPIRE].
A.E. Broderick et al., The event horizon of M87, Astrophys. J. 805 (2015) 179 [arXiv:1503.03873] [INSPIRE].
M.A. Abramowicz, W. Kluzniak and J.-P. Lasota, No observational proof of the black hole event-horizon, Astron. Astrophys. 396 (2002) L31 [astro-ph/0207270] [INSPIRE].
W. Lu, P. Kumar and R. Narayan, Stellar disruption events support the existence of the black hole event horizon, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 468 (2017) 910 [arXiv:1703.00023] [INSPIRE].
C. Barcelo, S. Liberati, S. Sonego and M. Visser, Hawking-like radiation does not require a trapped region, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 (2006) 171301 [gr-qc/0607008] [INSPIRE].
C. Barcelo, S. Liberati, S. Sonego and M. Visser, Minimal conditions for the existence of a Hawking-like flux, Phys. Rev. D 83 (2011) 041501 [arXiv:1011.5593] [INSPIRE].
C. Barcelo, S. Liberati, S. Sonego and M. Visser, Hawking-like radiation from evolving black holes and compact horizonless objects, JHEP 02 (2011) 003 [arXiv:1011.5911] [INSPIRE].
L.C. Barbado, C. Barcelo, L.J. Garay and G. Jannes, The trans-planckian problem as a guiding principle, JHEP 11 (2011) 112 [arXiv:1109.3593] [INSPIRE].
S.L. Braunstein, S. Pirandola and K. Życzkowski, Better late than never: information retrieval from black holes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110 (2013) 101301 [arXiv:0907.1190] [INSPIRE].
Y. Kiem, H.L. Verlinde and E.P. Verlinde, Black hole horizons and complementarity, Phys. Rev. D 52 (1995) 7053 [hep-th/9502074] [INSPIRE].
R. Brustein and A.J.M. Medved, Quantum state of the black hole interior, JHEP 08 (2015) 082 [arXiv:1505.07131] [INSPIRE].
R. Brustein and A.J.M. Medved, Falling through the black hole horizon, JHEP 06 (2015) 089 [arXiv:1503.05597] [INSPIRE].
P. Chen, Y.C. Ong, D.N. Page, M. Sasaki and D.-h. Yeom, Naked black hole firewalls, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116 (2016) 161304 [arXiv:1511.05695] [INSPIRE].
D.-I. Hwang, B.-H. Lee and D.-h. Yeom, Is the firewall consistent?: Gedanken experiments on black hole complementarity and firewall proposal, JCAP 01 (2013) 005 [arXiv:1210.6733] [INSPIRE].
W. Kim, B.-H. Lee and D.-H. Yeom, Black hole complementarity and firewall in two dimensions, JHEP 05 (2013) 060 [arXiv:1301.5138] [INSPIRE].
S.D. Mathur, The fuzzball proposal for black holes: an elementary review, Fortsch. Phys. 53 (2005) 793 [hep-th/0502050] [INSPIRE].
S.D. Mathur and C.J. Plumberg, Correlations in Hawking radiation and the infall problem, JHEP 09 (2011) 093 [arXiv:1101.4899] [INSPIRE].
S.D. Mathur, Black holes and beyond, Annals Phys. 327 (2012) 2760 [arXiv:1205.0776] [INSPIRE].
S.D. Mathur and D. Turton, Comments on black holes I: the possibility of complementarity, JHEP 01 (2014) 034 [arXiv:1208.2005] [INSPIRE].
S.D. Mathur and D. Turton, The flaw in the firewall argument, Nucl. Phys. B 884 (2014) 566 [arXiv:1306.5488] [INSPIRE].
S.G. Avery, B.D. Chowdhury and A. Puhm, Unitarity and fuzzball complementarity: ‘Alice fuzzes but may not even know it!’, JHEP 09 (2013) 012 [arXiv:1210.6996] [INSPIRE].
Open Access
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC-BY 4.0), which permits any use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
ArXiv ePrint: 1701.09156
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits use, duplication, adaptation, distribution, and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
About this article
Cite this article
Barceló, C., Carballo-Rubio, R. & Garay, L.J. Gravitational wave echoes from macroscopic quantum gravity effects. J. High Energ. Phys. 2017, 54 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/JHEP05(2017)054
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/JHEP05(2017)054