Does extending health insurance coverage to the uninsured improve population health outcomes?
An ongoing debate exists about whether the US should adopt a universal health insurance programme. Much of the debate has focused on programme implementation and cost, with relatively little attention to benefits for social welfare.
To estimate the effect on US population health outcomes, measured by mortality, of extending private health insurance to the uninsured, and to obtain a rough estimate of the aggregate economic benefits of extending insurance coverage to the uninsured.
We use state-level panel data for all 50 states for the period 1990–2000 to estimate a health insurance augmented, aggregate health production function for the US. An instrumental variables fixed-effects estimator is used to account for confounding variables and reverse causation from health status to insurance coverage. Several observed factors, such as income, education, unemployment, cigarette and alcohol consumption and population demographic characteristics are included to control for potential confounding variables that vary across both states and time.
The results indicate a negative relationship between private insurance and mortality, thus suggesting that extending insurance to the uninsured population would result in an improvement in population health outcomes. The estimate of the marginal effect of insurance coverage indicates that a 10% increase in the population-insured rate of a state reduces mortality by 1.69–1.92%. Using data for the year 2003, we calculate that extending private insurance coverage to the entire uninsured population in the US would save over 75 000 lives annually and may yield annual net benefits to the nation in excess of $US400 billion.
This analysis suggests that extending health insurance coverage through the private market to the 46 million Americans without health insurance may well produce large social economic benefits for the nation as a whole.
- 1.Hadley J, Holahan J. Covering the uninsured: how much would it cost? Health Aff 2003; Web Exclusive, W3–251Google Scholar
- 2.US Census Bureau. Current population survey, 1990–2000: annual social and economic supplements [online]. Available from URL: http://www.census.gov [Accessed 2006 Feb 21]
- 3.Henderson J. Health economics and policy. Florence (KY): South-Western Educational Publishing, 2005Google Scholar
- 13.Newhouse JP. Free for all? Lessons from the Rand health insurance experiment. Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press, 1993Google Scholar
- 19.Hadley J. More medical care better health? An economic analysis of mortality rates. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute Press, 1982Google Scholar
- 20.Lichtenberg F. Sources of US longevity increase, 1960-1997 [NBER working paper 8755]. Cambridge (MA): National Bureau of Economic Research, 2002Google Scholar
- 22.Cutler D, McClellan M, Newhouse J. The costs and benefits of intensive treatment for cardiovascular disease. In: Triplett J, editor. Measuring the prices of medical treatments. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press, 1999: 34–71Google Scholar
- 24.Cutler D, Kadiyala S. The return to biomedical research: treatment and behavioral effects. In: Murphy K, Topel R, editors. Measuring the gains from medical research. Chicago (IL): The University of Chicago Press, 2003; 110–62Google Scholar
- 27.Hadley J. Sicker and poorer: the consequences of being uninsured. A review of the research on the relationship between health insurance, medical care use, health, work, and income. Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured, 2002 [online]. Available from URL: http://www.kff.org [Accessed 2006 Feb 15]
- 28.Levy H, Meltzer D. What do we really know about whether health insurance affects health? In: McLaughlin C, editor. Health policy and the uninsured: setting the agenda. Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press, 2004Google Scholar
- 30.Fihn S, Wicher J. Withdrawing routine outpatient medical services: effects on access and health. J Gen Int Med 1988; Jul-Aug: 356–62Google Scholar
- 34.Lichtenberg F. The effects of Medicare on health care utilization and outcomes. Forum Health Econ Policy 2002; 5(1): 1028Google Scholar
- 35.Perry C, Rosen H. The self-employed are less likely to have health insurance than wage earners: so what? [NBER working paper 8316]. Cambridge (MA): NBER, 2001Google Scholar
- 37.Ackerman F, Heinzerling L. If it exists, it’s getting bigger: revising the value of a statistical life [working paper no. 01-06]. Medford (MA): Global Development and Environment Institute, 2001Google Scholar