Studies in Philosophy and Education

, Volume 19, Issue 1–2, pp 109–131

John Dewey and the development of education in russia before 1930 — report on a forgotten reception

Dewey and European Education-General Problems and Case Studies 2. Case Studies

Abstract

This article explores the kinds of response John Dewey (1859–1952) received in Russia between 1900 and 1930, and the impact he had on the educational debate there. The study’s main findings are: Both before and after the Socialist October Revolution of 1917, Dewey had a significant impact on the development of the Russian school system. The ultimate rejection of Dewey’s pedagogy towards the end of the 20s was not due to educational but to political and ideological reasons.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Bibliography

I. Materials from the Scientific Archive of the Russian Academy of Education (sarae) Moskow

  1. F. (Fond [achival fund]) 23, op. (opis [file]) 1, ed. khr. (edinitsa khranenia [depository]) 13: The personal archive of K. N. Ventsel, including the memoirs of his work of 1912–1915.Google Scholar

II. Printed sources: Journals of educational congresses, PROTOCOLS, RESOLUTIONS, ANNUAL REPORTS, OFFICIAL BULLETINS AND OTHER DOCUMENTS

  1. Dnevnik pervogo Vserossyskogo syezda po voprosam narodnogo obrazovania [Journal of the First All-Russian Congress on National Education], 1913, Ulei, St. Peterburg.Google Scholar
  2. Doklady, prenia i postanovlenia vtoroi sektsii Pervogo Vserossyskogo syezda po voprosam narodnogo obrazovania [Lectures, discussions and resolutions of the Second Section of the First All-Russian Congress on National Education], 1915, n.publ., Petrograd.Google Scholar
  3. KPSS v rezoliutsiakh syezdov, konferentsy i plenumov TsK [The Communist Party of the USSR in congresses, conferences, and plenary sessions of the Central Comittee], 1954, Vol. 2, Moskva.Google Scholar
  4. Pervyi Vserossysky syezd po Prosvescheniyu. Zasedanie 26-go avgusta 1918 g. [The First All-Russian Congress on Education. Session of August 26, 1918] n.d., n.publ., n.p.Google Scholar
  5. Otchyot o deyatelnosti pedagogicheskogo obschestva [Report on the Activities of the Pedagogical Society], 1899, n.publ., Moskva.Google Scholar
  6. Polozhenie o edinoi trudovoi shkole Rossyskoi Sotsialisticheskoi Federativnoi Sovetskoi Respubliki [Decree on the Unified Production school of the Russian Socialist Federal Soviet Republic], 1918, Vserossysky Tsentralnyi Ispolnitelnyi komitet, Narkompros po prosvescheniyu, Moskva.Google Scholar
  7. Rezoliutsia Pervogo Vserossyskogo syezda po voprosam narodnogo obrazovania s 22 dekabria 1913 po 3 yanvaria 1914 goda [Resolution of the First All-Russian Congress on National Education from December 22, 1913 through January 3, 1914], 1914, Kommercheskaya skoropechatnia, St. Peterburg.Google Scholar

III. References

  1. Anweiler, O.: 1978,Geschichte der Schule und PÄdagogik in Ru\land vom Ende des Zarenreiches bis zum Beginn der Stalin-Ära [History of Education and School in Russia from the End of the Zarist Empire to the Beginning of the Stalin Era]. Osteuropa-Institut, Berlin.Google Scholar
  2. Blonsky, P.P.: 1924,Pedagogika [Pedagogy], Rabotnik Prosveschenia, Moskva.Google Scholar
  3. Blonsky, P.P.: 1925,Novye programmy GUS’a i uchitel [New Programs of the National Counsel of Scholars, and the Teachers], Rabotnik Prosveschenia, Moskva.Google Scholar
  4. Blonsky, P.P.: 1973,Die Arbeitsschule [The Production School], Schöningh, Paderborn.Google Scholar
  5. Bohnsack, F.: 1976,Erziehung zur Demokratie. John Deweys PÄdagogik und ihre Bedeutung für die Reform unserer Schule [Education for Democracy. John Deweys Pedagogy and Its Relevance for the Reform of Our Schools], Otto Maier, Ravensburg.Google Scholar
  6. Chekhov, N.V.: 1906, ‘Die Volksbildung [National Education]’, in J. Melnik (ed.),Russen über Ru\land, Rütten & Loening, Frankfurt a.M.Google Scholar
  7. Chekhov, N.V.: 1907,Svobodnaya shkola. Opyt organizatsii shkoly novogo tipa [A Free School: The Experience of Organizing a New Type of High School], I.D. Sytin, Moskva.Google Scholar
  8. Dewey, E.: 1923,Daltonsky laboratornyi plan [The Dalton Laboratory Plan], trans. R. Langsberg, preface N. K. Krupskaya, Novaya Moskva, Moskva.Google Scholar
  9. Dewey, J.: 1907,Skola i obschestvo [The School and Society], I.D. Sytin, Moskva.Google Scholar
  10. Dewey, J.: 1915,Psikhologia ipedagogika myshlenia [How We Think], Mir, Moskva.Google Scholar
  11. Dewey, J. and Dewey, E.: 1916/1917, ‘Shkoly buduschego [Schools of Tomorrow]’, trans. R. Langsberg,Svobodnoe vospitanie [Free Education] 1, 21–48;2, 55–74; 3,21-42; 4/5, 17–40;6, 19–34; 7/8, 25–40;9/10, 67–94;11/12, 21–40.Google Scholar
  12. Dewey, J.: 1921,Vvedenie vfilosofiyu vospitania [Democracy and Education: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Education], preface by S. T. Shatsky, Rabotnik Prosveschenia, Moskva.Google Scholar
  13. Dewey, J.: 1922a,Psikhologia i pedagogika myshlenia [How We Think], trans. N. M. Nikolskaya, Red. N. D. Vinogradov, Gosizdat RSFSR, Berlin.Google Scholar
  14. Dewey, J.: 1922b,Shkola i obschestvo [The School and Society], Rabotnik Prosveschenia, Moskva.Google Scholar
  15. Dewey, J.: 1922c,Shkola i rebyonok [The Child and the Curriculum], trans. L. Azarevich, Gosizdat, Moskva.Google Scholar
  16. Dewey, J. and Dewey, E.: 1922d,Shkoly buduschego [Schools of Tomorrow], trans. R. Langsberg, Rabotnik Prosveschenia, Moskva.Google Scholar
  17. Dewey, J.: 1923,Shkola i rebyonok [The Child and the Curriculum], trans. L. Azarevic, Gosizdat, Moskva/Petrograd.Google Scholar
  18. Dewey, J.: 1924,Shkola i obschestvo [The School and Society], Gosizdat, Moskva.Google Scholar
  19. Dewey, J.: 1925,Shkola i obschestvo [The School and Society], trans. G.A. Luchinsky, Rabotnik Prosveschenia, Moskva.Google Scholar
  20. Dewey, J.: 1993,Demokratie und Erziehung. Eine Einleitung in die philosophische PÄdagogik [Democracy and Education: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Education], Beltz, Weinheim/ Basel.Google Scholar
  21. Finkel, I.: 1925,Daltonplan v shkole fabzavucha: Sbornik statei i materialov [The Dalton Plan in Factory Schools. A Collection of Articles and Materials], Novaya Moskva, Moskva.Google Scholar
  22. Fortunatov, A.: 1926,Teoria trudovoi shkoly v eyo istoricheskom razvitii [The Theory of the Production School in its Historical Development], Part 1, Mir, Moskva.Google Scholar
  23. Froese, L.: 1963,Ideengeschichtliche TriebkrÄfte der russischen und sowjetischen PÄdagogik [Intellectual springs of Russian and Soviet Pedagogy], Quelle & Meyer, Heidelberg.Google Scholar
  24. Gansberg, F.: 1907/1908, ‘Nauka v narodnoi shkole [Science in Elementary School]’, trans. V. Koshevich,Svobodnoe vospitanie [Free Education] 8, 73–92.Google Scholar
  25. Gansberg, F.: 1915/1916, ‘Shkola buduschego [School of Tomorrow]’, trans. V. Koshevich,Svobodnoe vospitanie [Free Education] 1, 21–36.Google Scholar
  26. Gentsov, I.A., Dzens-Litovsky, A.I. and Kazmin, N.V.: 1925,Daltonplan na rabfake [The Dalton Plan at Workers’ Faculties], Priboi, Leningrad.Google Scholar
  27. Gerit, A. and Gotalov-Gottlieb, A.: 1925,Sovremennye pedagogicheskie techenia [Current Trends in Education], Gosudarstvennoe izdatelstvo Ukrainy, Cherson.Google Scholar
  28. Ignatiev, B.V.: 1925,Daltonplan i noveishie techenia russkoi pedagogicheskoi mysli [The Dalton Plan and the Newest Educational Trends in Russia], Mir, Moskva.Google Scholar
  29. Ignatiev, P.N., Odinetz, D.M. and Novgorotsev, P.J.: 1929,Russian Schools and Universities in the World War, Yale University Press, New Haven.Google Scholar
  30. Johnson, W.H.E.: 1969,Russia’s Educational Heritage, Ostagon Books, New York.Google Scholar
  31. Kamenev, S.A.: 1925,Sovetskaya trudovaya shkola [The Soviet Production School], Sevkavkniga, Rostov-na-Donu.Google Scholar
  32. Kapterev, P.F.: 1918, ‘Organizatsia avtonomnoi shkoly [Organization of the Autonomous School]’,Pedagogicheskaya mysl [Pedagogical Thought] 9-12, 147–149.Google Scholar
  33. Klafki, W.: 1978, ‘Die AktualitÄt der PÄdagogik von John Dewey’, [The Continuing Relevance of Dewey’s Education] Zeitschrift für PÄdagogik 24, 781–793.Google Scholar
  34. Komarovsky, B.B.: 1926,Pedagogika Dewey [Dewey’s Education], T. 1, n.publ., Baku.Google Scholar
  35. Konstantinov, N.A.: 1947,Ocherki po istorii srednei shkoly [Sketches on the History of the High School], Uchpedgiz, Moskva.Google Scholar
  36. Krupskaya, N.K.: 1922, ‘Evelyn Dewey. Daltonsky plan laboratornoi raboty v shkole. Helen Parkhurst. Vospitanie pri pomoschi Daltonskogo plana [Evelyne Dewey. The Dalton Laboratory Plan. Helen Parkhurst. Education on the Dalton Plan]’,Na putiakh k novoi shkole [Towards the New School] 2-3, 163–168.Google Scholar
  37. Krupskaya, N.K.: 1923, ‘Metod proektov v politprosvetrabote [The Project Method in Political Education]’,Kommunisticheskoe Prosveschenie [Communist Education] 3(9), 25–31.Google Scholar
  38. Krupskaya, N.K.: 1972,Sozialistische PÄdagogik [Socialist Education], Vol. 1, Volk und Wissen, Berlin.Google Scholar
  39. Levin, L.: 1925,Novyeputi shkolnoi raboty (metod proektov) [New Ways in School Work (The Project Method)], Rabotnik Prosveschenia, Moskva.Google Scholar
  40. Levitin, S.A.: 1912/1913, ‘Trudovaya shkola — shkola buduschego [The Production School — School of the Future]’,Svobodnoe vospitanie [Free Education] 4, 23–32.Google Scholar
  41. Levitin, S.A.: 1914/1915, ‘Trudovoi prinzip vospitania. Doklady, chitannye na Vserossyskom syezde po narodnomu obrazovaniyu [The Work Principle. Lectures Held at the First Congress on National Education]’,Svobodnoe vospitanie [Free Education] 3, 25–40.Google Scholar
  42. Levitin, S.A.: 1915, ‘Trudovaya shkola i professionalizm [Production school and Professionalism]’,Russkaya shkola [Russian School] 4, 71–89.Google Scholar
  43. Levitin, S.A.: 1916,Trudovaya shkola — shkola buduschego [The Production School — School of the Future], Prakticheskie znania, Moskva.Google Scholar
  44. Lunacharsky, A.V.: 1924,Na novykh putiakh [Breaking New Ground], Gubizdat, Samara.Google Scholar
  45. Lunacharsky, A.V.: 1984, ‘Die Ziele der Sowjetschule [Goals of the Soviet School]’, in Kommission für deutsche Erziehungs — und nSchulgeschichte der Akademie der PÄdagogischen Wissenschaften der DDR (eds.),Monumenta Paedagogica. Dokumente und Materialien zu den deutschsowjetischen Beziehungen auf bildungspolitischem und pÄdagogischem Gebiet 1917–1933, Vol. XXII, Volk und Wissen, Berlin, pp. 210–215.Google Scholar
  46. Mamontov, J.: 1924,Khrestomatia sovremennykh pedagogicheskikh techeny [Chrestomathy of Current Educational Trends], preface V. Arnautov, Gosudarstvennoe Izdatelstvo Ukrainy, Ekaterinoslav.Google Scholar
  47. Mchitarjan, I.: 1998,Der russische Blickauf die deutsche ReformpÄdagogik. Zur Rezeption deutscher Schulreformideen in Ru\land zwischen 1900 und 1917 [The Russian view of German Progressive Education. The Reception of German Ideas on Progressive Education in Russia between 1900 and 1917], Kovac, Hamburg.Google Scholar
  48. Medynsky, E.D.: 1927, ‘Pedagogicheskie techenia v Rossii kontsa 19 — nachala 20 veka [The Educational Trends in Russia at the End of the 19th and the Beginning of the 20th Century]’, in A.G. Kalashnikov (ed.),Pedagogicheskaya entsiklopedia [Pedagogical Enzyklopaedia], vol. 1, Rabotnik Prosveschenia, Moskva, pp. 392–395.Google Scholar
  49. Medynsky, E.D.: 1929,Istoria pedagogiki v sviazi s ekonomicheskim razyitiem obschestva [History of Pedagogy in Relation to Economic Social Development], Vol. 2, Rabotnik Prosveschenia, Moskva.Google Scholar
  50. Medynsky, E.D.: 1938,Istoria russkoi pedagogiki do Velikoi Oktiabrskoi sotsialisticheskoi revoliutsii [History of Russian Education up to the Great Socialist October Revolution], Gosuchpedgiz Narkomprosa RSFSR, Moskva.Google Scholar
  51. Merzon: 1925, ‘Opyt primenenia Dalton-plana v trudovoi shkole [Using the Dalton Plan in the Production School]’,Narodnoe Prosveschenie [National Education] 10/11, 128–132.Google Scholar
  52. Moiseev, L.V. and Beskin, M.A.: 1927,Daltonplan vshkolach uchenichestva. Opyt raboty Moskovskoi shkoly uchenichestva [The Dalton Plan in Apprentice Schools. Work Experience in the Moscow Apprentice School], Transpechat NKPS, Moskva.Google Scholar
  53. Oelkers, J.: 1993, ‘Dewey in Deutschland — ein Mi\verstÄndnis [Dewey in Germany — a Misunderstanding]’, in J. Dewey (ed.),Demokratie und Erziehung. Eine Einleitung in die philosophische PÄdagogik, Beltz, Weinheim/Basel, pp. 497–517.Google Scholar
  54. Pabst, A.: 1909/1910, ‘Prakticheskoe vospitanie [Practical Education]’, trans. V. Koshevich,Svobodnoe vospitanie [Free Education] 1, 63–88.Google Scholar
  55. Palchinsky, V.O.: 1928,Protiv komplexnoi sistemy i o metodach prepodavania voobsche [Against the Complex System and on Instructional Methods in General], Kabinet NOT pri sektsii gigieny Odesskoi nauchno-issledovatelskoi kafedry profelakticheskoi meditsiny, Odessa.Google Scholar
  56. Pinkevich, A.P.: 1925,Pedagogika. Trudovaya shkola [Pedagogy. The Production School], Part 2, Rabotnik Prosveschenia, Moskva.Google Scholar
  57. Pinkevich, A.P.: 1930,Kratky ocherk istorii pedagogiki [A Short Sketch of the History of Pedagogy], Proletary, Charkov.Google Scholar
  58. ‘Reforma srednei shkoly [The Reform of the High School] (author unknown)’: 1915,Russkaya shkola [Russisan School] 5/6, 78–85.Google Scholar
  59. Rubinstein, M.M.: 1925,Trudovaya shkola v svete istorii i sovremennosti [The Production school in the Past and in the Present], Seyatel, Leningrad.Google Scholar
  60. Riittenauer, I. and Schiff, B.: 1970,S.T. Shatsky: AusgewÄhlte pÄdagogische Schriften [S.T. Shatsky: Selected Educational Writings], Quelle & Meyer, Heidelberg.Google Scholar
  61. Shatsky, S.T: 1907/1908, ‘Detsky trud i novye puti [Child Labor and new Approaches]’,Svobodnoe vospitanie [Free Education] 6, 47–56.Google Scholar
  62. Shatsky, S.T.: 1925, ‘Opyt primenenia programm GUS v shkolach pervoi stupeni [The Application of the GUS-Programs in Primary Schools]’,Narodnoe Prosveschenie [National Education] 10/11, 121–123.Google Scholar
  63. Shatsky, S.T., Zelenko, A.U. and Kazimirov, N.J.: 1908,Deti — rabotniki buduschego [Children — Working People of Tomorrow], n.publ., Moskva.Google Scholar
  64. Shulgin, V.N.: 1918a, ‘Detskaya Kommuna [The Children’s Commune]’,Narodnoe Prosveschenie [National Education] 23-25, 6.Google Scholar
  65. Shulgin, V.N.: 1918b, ‘Shkoly buduschego [Schools of Tomorrow]’, by J. Dewey & E. Dewey,Svobodnoe vospitanie [Free Education] 19, 15–16.Google Scholar
  66. Shulgin, V.N.: 1925a, ‘Obschestvennaya rabota v shkole [Public Work in School]’,Narodnoe Prosveschenie [National Education] 10/11, 125–127.Google Scholar
  67. Shulgin, V.N.: 1925b,Osnovnye voprosy sotsialnogo vospitania [The Main Questions of Social Education], Rabotnik Prosveschenia, Moskva.Google Scholar
  68. Simonov, I.S. and Chekhov, N.V.: 1924,Daltonplan v russkoi shkole [The Daltan Plan in the Russian School], Brockhaus-Ethron, Leningrad.Google Scholar
  69. Sokolov, P.: 1913,Istoria pedagogicheskikh sistem [History of Pedagogical Systems], O.V. Bogdanova, St. Peterburg.Google Scholar
  70. Ventsel, K.N.: 1906,Borba za svobodnuyu shkolu [The Struggle for a Free School], A.P. Pechkovskogo, Moskva.Google Scholar
  71. Ventsel, K.N.: 1907/1908, ‘Rol truda v shkole buduschego [The Function of Work in the School of the Future]’,Svobodnoe vospitanie [Free Education] 1, 44–52.Google Scholar
  72. Ventsel, K.N.: 1908,Kak sozdat’ svobodnuyu shkolu (Dom svobodnogo rebyonka) [How to Found a Free School (House of the Free Child)], I.N. Kushnerev i Kℴ, Moskva.Google Scholar
  73. Ventsel, K.N.: 1908/1909, ‘Idealnaya shkola buduschego i sposoby eyo osuschestvlenia [The Ideal School of the Future and the Means for Its Realization]’,Svobodnoe vospitanie [Free Education]8, 1–28;9, 19–44.Google Scholar
  74. Ventsel, K.N.: 1916/1917, ‘Otdelenie shkoly ot gosudarstva [The Separation of School and State]’,Svobodnoe vospitanie [Free Education] 6, 1–18.Google Scholar
  75. Ventsel, K.N.: 1918, ‘Sovremennyi moment i svobodnoe vospitanie [The Current Moment and Free Education]’,Svobodnoe vospitanie [Free Education] 1-3, 13–18.Google Scholar
  76. Zolotarev, S.A., Golubev, A.V. and Shatsky, S.T.: 1918,Trudovaya shkola [The Production School], K.L. Menschova, Moskva.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2000

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Ernst-Moritz-Arndt University GreifswaldGermany
  2. 2.Institut für Erziehungswissenschaft, Lehrstuhl Allgemeine PÄdagogikErnst-Moritz-Arndt UniversitÄt GreifswaldGreifswaldGermany

Personalised recommendations