Advertisement

Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory

, Volume 4, Issue 3–4, pp 239–263 | Cite as

Historians, prehistorians, and the tyranny of the historical record: Danish state formation through documents and archaeological data

  • Tina L. Thurston
Article

Abstract

Historians traditionally have viewed the emergence of Denmark as a nation-state through western European primary sources, inferring a fragmented, politically divided region between AD 800 and AD 1050. Conversely, archaeologists using local-scale, single-site data argue for unification by ca. AD 800. An alternative is offered, combiningregional-scale archaeological methods (rank-size analyses) and consideration of westernand northern European texts. This approach reveals that as disparate polities unified, the “homelands” of ruling dynasties came under control quickly, while peripheral areas remained largely autonomous. To incorporate peripheral areas, rulers manipulated the location and function of political and economic centers. Local resistance to change is reflected in slow, uneven unification, interregional elite competition, and eventually, armed rebellion. The apparent discrepancies between historic and prehistoric data are no error; in fact, they mirror the inherent conflicts of this profound social transformation.

Key Words

state formation Viking Age Denmark regional analysis 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References Cited

  1. Adams, R. McC. (1966).The Evolution of Urban Society, Aldine, Chicago.Google Scholar
  2. Andersson, I. (1947).Skånes Historia, Norstedt & Sons, Stockholm.Google Scholar
  3. Andrén, A. (1983). Städer och kungmakt—en studie i Danmarks politiska geografi före 1230 (Towns and Royal Power—A study in Denmark's political geography before 1230).Scandia 49: 31–71.Google Scholar
  4. Andrén, A. (1985).Den Urbana Scenen (The Urban Scene), Acta Archaeologica, Lundensia Series 8, No. 13, CWK Gleerup, Malmö.Google Scholar
  5. Barley, M. W. (1977).European Towns. Their Archaeology and Early History, Academic Press, New York.Google Scholar
  6. Becker, C. J. (1980). Viking Age settlements in western and central Jutland. Recent excavations.Acta Archaeologica 50: 89–94.Google Scholar
  7. Bencard, M. (ed.) (1981)Ribe Excavations 1970–76, Vol. 1, Sudjysk Universitetsforlag, Esbjerg.Google Scholar
  8. Berglund, B. E. (1991).The Cultural Landscape During 6000 Years in Southern Sweden—The Ystad Project, Munksgaard International, Copenhagen.Google Scholar
  9. Binford, L. (1962). Archaeology as anthropology.American Antiquity 28: 217–225.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Binford, L. (1968). Archaeological perspectives. In Binford, S. R., and Binford, L. R. (eds.),New Perspectives in Archaeology, Aldine, Chicago.Google Scholar
  11. Bolin, S. (1930).Skånelands Historia I (History of Scania I), Malmö.Google Scholar
  12. Brattberg, S. (1983). Studier Kring Skånes Köpinger—Vikingatida Marknadsplatser (Studies on Skånes Köpinges—Viking Age marketplaces).Limnhamnia 1983: 83–102.Google Scholar
  13. Braudel, F. (1980).On History, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
  14. Callmer, J. (1986) To stay or to move: Some aspects of settlement dynamics in southern Sweden.Meddelanden från Lunds Universitets Historiska Museum 1985–1986: 167–208.Google Scholar
  15. Callmer, J. (1987) Iron Age and early Medieval settlement development in southern Scandinavia: Some contemporary and future research perspectives. In Burenhult, G. (ed.),Theoretical Approaches to Artifacts, Settlement and Society, BAR International Series 366(ii), Oxford, pp. 429–443.Google Scholar
  16. Callmer, J. (1991). Territory and dominion in the Late Iron Age in southern Scandinavia. In Jennbert, K., Larsson, L., Petré, R. and Wyszomirska-Werbart, B. (eds.),Regions and Reflections. InHonour of Märta Strömberg, Series 80, No. 20, Almqvist & Wiksell International, Lund, pp. 257–273.Google Scholar
  17. Champion, T. (1990). Medieval archaeology and the tyranny of the historical record. In Austin, D., and Alcock, L. (eds.),From the Baltic to the Black Sea, Studies in Medieval Archaeology, Unwin Hyman, London, pp. 79–95.Google Scholar
  18. Clark, D. L. (1973). Archaeology: The loss of innocence.Antiquity 47: 6–18.Google Scholar
  19. Clarke, H., and Ambrosiani, B. (1991).Towns in the Viking Age, Leicester University Press, London.Google Scholar
  20. Cohen, S. (1977). The earliest Scandinavian towns. In Miskimin, H. A., Herlihy, D., and Udovitch, A. L. (eds.)The Medieval City, Yale University Press, New Haven, CT, pp. 313–335.Google Scholar
  21. Daltroy, T. (1994). Factionalism and political development in the central Andes. In Brumfiel, D., and Fox, J. W. (eds.),Factional Competition and Political Development in the New World, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 171–187.Google Scholar
  22. Earle, T. K. (1977). A reappraisal of redistribution: Complex Hawaiian chiefdoms. In Earle, T., and Ericson, J. (eds.),Exchange Systems in Prehistory, Academic Press, New York, pp. 213–232.Google Scholar
  23. Earle, T. K. (1991). Property rights and the evolution of chiefdoms. In Earle, T. (ed.),Chiefdoms: Power, Economy and Ideology, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 70–99.Google Scholar
  24. Emanuelsson, U. (1985).Det Skånska Kulturlandskap (The Scanian Cultural Landscape). Bokförlaget Signum, Lund.Google Scholar
  25. Falconer, S. E., and Savage, S. H. (1995). Heartlands and hinterlands: Alternative trajectories of early urbanization in Mesopotamia and the southern Levant.American Antiquity 60: 37–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Feinman, G. M. (1995). Scale and social organization: Perspectives on the archaic state. In Feinman, G. M., and Marcus, J. (eds.),The Archaic State, School of American Research, Santa Fe, NM.Google Scholar
  27. Fell, C. (1984). Some questions of language. In Lund, N. (ed.),Two Voyagers, Ohthere and Wulfstan, at the Court of King Alfred, William Sessions, York, pp. 56–69.Google Scholar
  28. Foucault, M. (1972).The Archaeology of Knowledge, Tavistock, London.Google Scholar
  29. Frandsen, L., and Jensen S. (1987). Pre-Viking and Early Viking Age ribe.Journal of Danish Archaeology 6.Google Scholar
  30. Hedeager, L. (1992).Iron Age Societies. From Tribe to State in Northern Europe, 500 BC to AD 700, Blackwell, Oxford.Google Scholar
  31. Jacobsson, B., Arén, E., Arén, E., and Blom, K. A. (1995).Trelleborgen. En av Harald Blåtands Dansk Ringborgar, Wallin and Dalholm, Lund.Google Scholar
  32. Jansen, H. (1985). Early urbanization in Denmark. In Clarke, H., and Simms, A. (eds.),The Comparative History of Urban Origins in Non-Roman Europe: Ireland, Wales, Denmark, Germany, Poland and Russia from the Ninth to the Thirteenth Century, BAR International Series 255(i), Oxford, pp. 183–216.Google Scholar
  33. Johnson, G. A. (1980). Spatial organization of early Uruk settlement systems. InColloque L'Arqeologie de l'Iraq du Debut de l'Epoque Neolithique, CNRS, Paris, pp. 233–263.Google Scholar
  34. Johnson, G. A. (1981). Monitoring complex system integration and boundary phenomenon with settlement size data. In Leeuw, S. E. V. D. (ed.),Archaeological Approaches to the Study of Complexity, University of Amsterdam Albert Egges van Giffen Insitiuut voor Prae- un Protohistorie, Amsterdam, CINGVLA VI, pp. 143–188.Google Scholar
  35. Johnson, G. A. (1982) Organizational structure and scalar stress. In Renfrew, A. C., Rowlands, M. J., and Segraves, B. A. (eds.),Theory and Explanation in Archaeology, the Southhampton Conference, Academic Press, New York, pp. 389–421.Google Scholar
  36. Johnson, G. A. (1987). The changing organization of Uruk administration on the Susiana Plain. In Hole, F. (ed.),Archaeological Perspectives on Western Iran: From Prehistory to the Islamic Conquest, Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, DC, pp. 107–140.Google Scholar
  37. Knapp, A. B. (ed.) (1992).Archaeology, Annales, and Ethnohistory, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
  38. Kosse, K. (1990). Group size and societal complexity: Thresholds in the long-term memory.Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 9: 275–303.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Kousgård-Sorensen, J. (1979). Place names and settlement history. In Sawyer, P. (ed.),Names, Words, and Graves: Early Medieval Settlement.Google Scholar
  40. Kristiansen, K. (1991). Chiefdoms, states, and systems of social evolution. In Earle, T. (ed.),Chiefdoms: Power, Economy, and Ideology, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 16–43.Google Scholar
  41. Kroman, E. (1976).Det Danske Rige i Den Aeldre Vikingtid (The Danish State in the Older Viking Age), Roskilde og Bagger, Copenhagen.Google Scholar
  42. Leone, M. (1978). Time in American archaeology. In Redman, C. (ed.),Social Archaeology, Academic Press, New York, pp. 25–36.Google Scholar
  43. Lindow, J. (1976).Comitatus, Individual and Honor: Studies in Northern Germanic Institutional Vocabulary, University of California Publications in Linguistics, Berkeley, Vol. 33.Google Scholar
  44. Lund, N. (1981). Viking Age society in Denmark—Evidence and theories. In Skyum-Nielsen, N., and Lund, N. (eds.),Danish Medieval History. New Currents, Museum Tusculanum Press, Copenhagen, pp. 22–35.Google Scholar
  45. Lund, N. (1984).Two Voyagers to the Court of King Alfred: The Ventures of Ohthere and Wulfstan, Together with the Descriptions of Northern Europe from the Old English Orosius, William Sessions, York.Google Scholar
  46. Nielsen, I., and Schiørring, O. (1982). Medieval Roskilde—An urban-archaeological survey.Journal of Danish Archaeology 1: 133–144.Google Scholar
  47. Norborg, L.-A. (1990).Lunds ålder och Uppkomst (Lund's origins and development), Kulturen, Lund.Google Scholar
  48. Palsson, H., and Edwards, P. (1986).Knytlinga Saga, Odense University Press, Odense.Google Scholar
  49. Randsborg, K. (1980).The Viking Age in Denmark: The Formation of a State, Duckworth, London.Google Scholar
  50. Rausing, G. (1990). Löddeköpinge, Lund and Lödde Kar.Meddelanden från Lunds Universitets Historiska Museum 1989–1990: 143–148.Google Scholar
  51. Redin, L. (1972). Tommarp. In Thun, E. (ed.),Nytt om Fornt i Skåne, Skånes Hembygdsförbund Årsbok, pp. 61–80.Google Scholar
  52. Ridderspore, M. (1991). Landscape and land use in the Köpinge area around 1300. A hypothetical reconstruction based on land survey documents from around 1700. In Berglund, B. (ed.),The Cultural Landscape During 6000 Years in Southern Sweden: The Ystad Project, Munksgaard International, Copenhagen, pp. 143–144.Google Scholar
  53. Roesdahl, E. (1982).Viking Age Denmark, Colonnade, London.Google Scholar
  54. Sawyer, P. H. (1984). Ohthere and Viking Age trade. In Lund, N. (ed.),Two Voyagers to the Court of King Alfred: The Ventures of Ohthere and Wulfstan, Together with the Descriptions of Northern Europe from the Old English Orosius, William Sessions, York, pp. 43–55.Google Scholar
  55. Sawyer, B., and Sawyer, P. (1993).Medieval Scandinavia. From Conversion to Reformation Circa 800–1500, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.Google Scholar
  56. Scholz, B. W. (1972).Carolingian Chronicles, University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
  57. Skinner, W. (1977). Regional urbanization in nineteenth century China. In Skinner, W. (ed.),The City in Late Imperial China, Standford University Press, Stanford, CA.Google Scholar
  58. Skovgaard-Petersen (1981) The written sources. In Bencard, M. (ed.),Ribe Excavations, 1970–76, Vol. 1, Sudjysk Universitetsforlag, Esbjerg.Google Scholar
  59. Smith, M. (1992). Braudel's temporal rhythms and chronology theory in archaeology. In Knapp, A. B. (ed.),Archaeology, Annales, and Ethnohistory, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 23–34.Google Scholar
  60. Tesch, S. (1991). A central settlement region on the coastal plain in the Early Iron Age, the Late Iron Age, and the Early Middle Ages. From habitation site to village site in the Köpinge area. In Berglund, B. (ed.),The Cultural Landscape During 6000 Years in Southern Sweden: The Ystad Project, Munksgaard International, Copenhagen, pp. 132–140.Google Scholar
  61. Tesch, S. (1992). The long-term development of a settlement region on the coastal plain—the Köpinge area. In Larsson, L., Callmer, J., and Stjernquist, B. (eds),The Archaeology of the Cultural Landscape. Field Work and Research in a South Swedish Rural Region, Almqvist & Wiksell International, Series 40. No. 19, Stockholm, pp. 161–250.Google Scholar
  62. Tesch, S. (1993).Houses, Farmsteads, and Long-Term Change. A Regional Study of Prehistoric Settlements in the Köpinge Area, in Scania, Southern Sweden, Institute of Archaeology, Uppsala.Google Scholar
  63. Thun, E. (1960).Medieval Tommarp: Archaeological Investigations 1959–60, Acta Archaeologica Lundensia Series 8, No. 5, Lund.Google Scholar
  64. Thun, E., and Anglart, M. (1984)., Meddeltidstaden No. 57, RAÄ, Stockholm.Google Scholar
  65. Thurston, T. (1996).The Development and Transformation of a Prehistoric Cultural Landscape: Boundaries, Integration, and Political Economy in the South Scandinavian Iron Age, Ph.D. dissertation, University of Wisconsin, Madison.Google Scholar
  66. Tschan, F. (1959)The History of the Archbishops of Hamburg-Bremen, Columbia University Press, New York.Google Scholar
  67. Vestergaard, T. (1979). Class and state development in Scandinavia: Necessary and voluntary relations.Kontaktstencil 16: 25–52.Google Scholar
  68. Whitelock, D., and Douglas, D. (1961).The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ.Google Scholar
  69. Wihlborg, A. (1981).Helsingborg, Medeltidstaden 32, RAÄ, Stockholm.Google Scholar
  70. Wright, H. T., and Johnson, G. A. (1975). Population, exchange, and early state formation in southwestern Iran.American Anthropologist 77: 267–289.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Plenum Publishing Corporation 1997

Authors and Affiliations

  • Tina L. Thurston
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of AnthropologyUniversity of Wisconsin-MadisonMadison

Personalised recommendations