Environmental Management

, Volume 15, Issue 1, pp 1–14

Review and appraisal of concept of sustainable food production systems

  • Michael Brklacich
  • Christopher R. Bryant
  • Barry Smit

Abstract

Environmental degradation, competition for resources, increasing food demands, and the integration of agriculture into the international economy threaten the sustainability of many food production systems. Despite these concerns, the concept of sustainable food production systems remains unclear, and recent attempts to appraise sustainability have been hampered by conceptual inconsistencies and the absence of workable definitions. Six perspectives are shown to underpin the concept. Environmental accounting identifies biophysical limits for agriculture. Sustained yield refers to output levels that can be maintained continuously. Carrying capacity defines maximum population levels that can be supported in perpetuity. Production unit viability refers to the capacity of primary producers to remain in agriculture. Product supply and security focuses on the adequacy of food supplies. Equity is concerned with the spatial and temporal distribution of products dervied from resource use. Many studies into sustainable agriculture cover more than one of these perspectives, indicating the concept is complex and embraces issues relating to the biophysical, social, and economic environments. Clarification of the concept would facilitate the development of frameworks and analytical systems for appraising the sustainability of food production systems.

Key words

Sustainable food production systems Environmental accounting Sustained yield Carrying capacity Viability Food supply and security Equity 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Literature Cited

  1. AFT (American Farmland Trust). 1988. Eroding choices emerging issues: the condition of California's agricultural land resources. Executive summary. AFT, California Field Office, San Francisco.Google Scholar
  2. Agriculture Canada. 1985. Agricultural soil and water resources in Canada: situation and outlook. Regional Development Branch, Ottawa, Ontario.Google Scholar
  3. Alauddin, M., and C. Tisdell. 1987. Trends and projections for Bangladeshi food production: an alternative viewpoint.Food Policy 11(2):318–331.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Altieri, M. 1987. Agroecology: the scientific basis for alternative agriculture. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado.Google Scholar
  5. Ashmead, R. 1985. Economic structure and capital requirements for agriculture.Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics 32:24–37.Google Scholar
  6. Ashmead, R. 1986. The myth and reality of the farm finance crisis.Canadian Journal of Agriculture Economics 33:63–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Avery, D. 1985. Us farin dilemma: The global bad news is wrong.Science 230(4724):408–412.Google Scholar
  8. Bale, M., and M. Duncan. 1983. Prospects for food production and consumption in developing countries. World Bank Staff Working Paper Number 596. The World Bank, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
  9. Barbier, E. 1987. The concept of sustainable economic development.Environmental Conservation 14(2):101–110.Google Scholar
  10. Battiston, L., M. Miller, and I. Shelton. 1987. Soil erosion and corn yield in Ontario. I. Field evaluation.Canadian Journal of Soil Science 67(4):731–745.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Baumel, C., and M. Hayenga. 1984. Domestic food security: transportation and marketing. Pages 255–271in L. Busch and W. Lacy (eds.), Food security in the United States. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado.Google Scholar
  12. Beanlands, G., and P. Duinker. 1984. An ecological framework for environmental impact assessment.Journal of Environmental Management 18(3):267–277.Google Scholar
  13. Bentley, C. 1981. Agricultural land and Canada's future. 1981–1982 Klinck Lecture. Agricultural Institute of Canada, Ottawa, Ontario.Google Scholar
  14. Bentley, C. 1987. Population, environmental and food propects for Africa. Presented to the Annual Meeting of the Canadian Association of African Studies, 7–9 May, 1987, Edmonton, Alberta.Google Scholar
  15. Bentley, C., and L. Leskiw. 1984. Sustainability of farmed lands: current trends and thinking. Report No. 15. Canadian Environmental Advisory Council, Ottawa, Ontario.Google Scholar
  16. Berry, W. 1984. The agricultural crisis as a crisis of culture. Pages 219–225in D. Douglass (ed.), Agricultural sustainability in a changing world order. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado.Google Scholar
  17. Biswas, M. 1984. Agricultural production and environment: a review.Environmental Conservation 11(3):253–259.Google Scholar
  18. Blobaum, R. 1987. Farming on the urban fringe: the economic potential of the rural-urban connection. Pages 3–8in W. Lockeretz (ed.), Sustaining agriculture near cities. Soil and Water Conservation Society, Ankeny, Iowa.Google Scholar
  19. Bowers, J. 1988. Farm incomes and the benefits of environmental protection. Pages 161–171in D. Collard, D. Pearce, and D. Ulph (eds.), Economics, growth and sustainable development. St. Martins Press, New York.Google Scholar
  20. Brown, B., M. Hanson, D. Liverman, and R. Merideth. 1987. Global sustainability: toward definition.Environmental Management 11(6):713–719.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Brown, L. 1984. State of the world 1984. W.W. Norton, New York.Google Scholar
  22. Budowski, G. 1984. Sustainable use of species and ecosystems. Pages 56–65in F. Thibodeau and H. Field (eds.), Sustaining tomorrow: a strategy for world conservation and development. University Press of New England, Hanover, New Hampshire.Google Scholar
  23. Busch, L., and W. Lacy. 1984. What does food security mean? Pages 1–10in L. Busch and W. Lacy (eds.), Food security in the United States. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado.Google Scholar
  24. Buttel, F., G. Gillespie, R. Janke, B. Caldwell, and M. Sarrantonio. 1987. Reduced-input agricultural systems: rationale and prospects.American Journal of Alternative Agriculture 1(2):58–64.Google Scholar
  25. Caldwell, L. 1984. Political aspects of ecologically sustainable development.Environmental Conservation 11(4):299–308.Google Scholar
  26. CAST (Council for Agricultural Science and Technology). 1981. Preserving agricultural land: Issues and policy alternatives. Report No. 90. CAST, Ames, Iowa.Google Scholar
  27. CELA (Canadian Environmental Law Association). 1988. Selling Canada's environment short: the environmental case against the trade deal. CELA, Toronto, Ontario.Google Scholar
  28. Clark, W. 1986. Sustainable development of the biosphere: themes for research. Pages 5–48in W. Clark and R. Munn (eds.), Sustainable development of the biosphere. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.Google Scholar
  29. Cloudsley-Thompson, J. 1988. Desertification or sustainable yields from arid environments.Environmental Conservation 15(3):197–204.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Conway, G. 1985. Agroecosystem analysis.Agricultural Administration 20:31–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Crosson, P. 1983. A schematic view of resources, technology and environment in agricultural development.Agriculture, Ecosystems, and Environment 9(4):339–357.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Crosson, P. 1986. Sustainable food production: interactions among natural resources, technology and institutions.Food Policy 11(2):143–156.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Dasmann, R. 1984. An introduction to world conservation. Pages 16–24in F. Thibodeau and H. Field (eds.), Sustaining tomorrow: a strategy for world conservation and development. University Press of New England, Hanover, New Hampshire.Google Scholar
  34. Dasmann, W. 1945. A method for estimating carrying capacity of range lands.Journal of Forestry 43:400–402.Google Scholar
  35. Domanico, J., P. Madden, and E. Partenheimer. 1987. Income effects of limiting soil erosion under organic, conventional, and no-till systems in Eastern Pennsylvania.American Journal of Alternative Agriculture 1(2):75–82.Google Scholar
  36. Douglass, G. 1984. The meanings of agricultural sustainability. Pages 3–29in G. Douglass (ed.), Agricultural sustainability in a changing world order. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado.Google Scholar
  37. Dumanski, J., D. Coote, G. Luciuk, and C. Lok. 1986. Soil conservation in Canada.Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 41(4):204–210.Google Scholar
  38. Dyer, J. 1982. Sustainability in the Canadian agri-food system.Canadian Farm Economics 17(3):23–28.Google Scholar
  39. Edens, T. 1985. Toward a sustainable agriculture. Pages 2–5in T. Edens, C. Fridgen, and S. Battenfield (eds.), Sustainable agriculture and integrated farming systems. Michigan State University Press, East Lansing.Google Scholar
  40. Elkin, T. 1987. State of the environment report: regional municipality of Waterloo. School of Urban and Regional Planning, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada.Google Scholar
  41. Falcon, W., C. Kurien, F. Monckeberg, A. Okeyo, S. Olayide, F. Rabar, and W. Tims. 1987. The world food and hunger problem: Changing perspectives and possibilities, 1974–1984. Pages 15–38in J. Gittinger, J. Leslie, and C. Hoisington (eds.), Food policy: integrating supply, distribution, and consumption. John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, Maryland.Google Scholar
  42. Farrell, K. 1988. Agricultural development and international trade. 1987–1988 Klinck Lecture. Agricultural Institute of Canada, Ottawa.Google Scholar
  43. Finsterbusch, K. 1985. State of the art in social impact assessment.Environment and Behavior 17(2):193–221.Google Scholar
  44. Firey, W. 1960. Man, mind and land. Free Press, Glencoe, Illinois.Google Scholar
  45. Francis, C., R. Harwood, and J. Parr. 1987. The potential for regenerative agriculture in the developing world.American Journal of Alternative Agriculture 1(2):65–74.Google Scholar
  46. Friend, G. 1983. The potential for a sustainable agriculture. Pages 28–47in D. Knorr (ed.), Sustainable food systems. AVI, Westport, Connecticut.Google Scholar
  47. Gale, R. 1985. Federal management of forests and marine fisheries: a comparative analysis of renewable resource management.Natural Resources Journal 25(2):275–315.Google Scholar
  48. Gale, R. 1988. Ec(onomic)ological policy.Policy Options April: 15–17.Google Scholar
  49. Goodland, R. 1988. Environmental sustainability in economic development: with emphasis on Amazonia. Mimeo. The World Bank, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
  50. Grigg, D. 1986. The world food problem. Pages 239–263in M. Pacione (ed.), Progress in agricultural geography. Croom Helm, London, U.K.Google Scholar
  51. Hansen, J. 1984. Canada's potential cropland margin.Canadian Journal of Regional Science 7(1):95–114.Google Scholar
  52. Hansen, J., G. Russel, P. Stone, A. Lacis, S. Lebedeff, R. Ruedy, and L. Travis. 1983. Efficient three-dimensional global models for climate studies. Models I and II.Monthly Weather Review 111:609–662.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Hedley, D. 1985. Agricultural development in Canada: some issues. J. S. McLean Memorial Lecture. Ontario Agricultural College, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario.Google Scholar
  54. Heffernan, W., and S. Elder. 1987. Quality of life for farm families in metropolitan and nonmetropolitan counties. Pages 91–101in W. Lockeretz (ed.), Sustaining agriculture near cities. Soil and Water Conservation Society, Ankeny, Iowa.Google Scholar
  55. Hekstra, G., and D. Liverman. 1986. Global food futures and desertification.Climatic Change 9(1,2):59–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Higgins, G., A. Kassam, L. Naiken, G. Fischer, and M. Shah. 1982. Potential population supporting capacities of lands in the developing world. The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome.Google Scholar
  57. Hileman, B. 1990. Alternative agriculture.Chemical and Engineering News 5 March, 1990, pp 26–40.Google Scholar
  58. Irving, P. 1983. Acid precipitation effects on crops: a review and analysis of research.Journal of Environmental Quality 12:442–453.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. IUCN (International Union for the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources). 1980. World conservation strategy. IUCN, Gland, Switzerland.Google Scholar
  60. Jackson, W. 1984. A search for a unifying concept for sustainable agriculture. Pages 208–229in W. Jackson, W. Berry, and B. Colman (eds.), Meeting the expectations of the land: essays in sustainable agriculture and stewardship. North Point Press, San Francisco.Google Scholar
  61. Johnston, T., and C. Bryant. 1987. Agricultural adaptation: the prospects for sustaining agriculture near cities. Pages 9–21in W. Lockeretz (ed.), Sustaining agriculture near cities. Soil and Water Conservation Society, Ankeny, Iowa.Google Scholar
  62. Kates, R. 1987. The human environment: the road not taken, the road still beckoning.Annals of the Association of American Geographers 77(4):525–534.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Lapping, M., and J. FitzSimons. 1982. Beyond the land issue: farm viability strategies.Geojournal 6(6):519–524.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Laszlo, P. 1986. Environmentally sound management of freshwater resources.Resources Policy 12(4):306–316.Google Scholar
  65. Lecuyer, G. (Task Force Chairman). 1987. Report of the national task force on environment and economy. Submitted to the Canadian Council of Resource and Environment Ministers.Google Scholar
  66. Lee, J. 1980. A framework for food and agricultural policy in the 1980s.Southern Journal of Agricultural Economics 12(1):1–10.Google Scholar
  67. Lewis, P. 1986. Europe's farm folly.Report on Business Magazine 1986:48–52.Google Scholar
  68. Liverman, D., M. Hanson, B. Brown, and R. Merideth. 1988. Global sustainability: toward measurement.Environmental Management 12(2):133–143.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Lockeretz, W. 1986. Trends in farming near cities.Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 41(4):256–262.Google Scholar
  70. MacNeill, J., J. Cox and D. Runnalls. 1989. CIDA and sustainable development: how Canada's aid policies can support sustainable development in the third world more effectively. The Institute for Research on Public Policy, Halifax, Nova Scotia.Google Scholar
  71. Manning, E. 1986. Towards sustainable land use: A strategy. Working Paper No. 47. Lands Directorate, Environment Canada, Ottawa, Ontario.Google Scholar
  72. Manning, E. 1988. The analysis of land use determinants in support of sustainable development. Lands, Environment Canada, Ottawa, Ontario.Google Scholar
  73. Marten, G. 1988. Productivity, stability, sustainability: equitability and autonomy as properties for agroecosystem assessment.Agricultural Systems 26:291–316.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Marten, G., and L. Sancholuz. 1982. Ecological land-use planning and carrying capacity evaluation in the Jalapa Region (Veracruz, Mexico).Agro-Ecosystems 8:83–124.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. McEwen, F. (Task Force Chairman). 1986. Directions for sustainable agriculture. Ontario Institute of Agrologists, Guelph, Ontario.Google Scholar
  76. Milbrath, L. 1984. A proposed value structure for a sustainable society.The Environmentalist 4(2):113–124.Google Scholar
  77. Mitchell, B. 1979. Geography and resource analysis. Longman, New York.Google Scholar
  78. Myers, N. 1987. The environmental basis of sustainable development.The Annals of Regional Science 21(3):33–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. NALS (National Agricultural Lands Study). 1981. National agricultural lands study: Final report. US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
  80. Nepal. 1983. National conservation strategy for Nepal. Government of Nepal in conjunction with the IUCN.Google Scholar
  81. Nielsen, E., and L. Lee. 1987. The magnitude and costs of groundwater contamination from agricultural chemicals: a national perspective. Natural Resource Economics Division, Economic Research Service, US Department of Agriculture, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
  82. NSE-SPRPC (National Soil Erosion—Soil Productivity Research Planning Committee). 1981. Soil erosion effects on soil productivity: a research perspective.Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 36(2):82–90.Google Scholar
  83. O'Riordan, T. 1983. Putting trust in the countryside. Pages 171–260in I. Pollard (Chairman), The conservation and development programme for the UK: A response to the world conservation strategy. Kogan Page, London, UK.Google Scholar
  84. O'Riordan, T. 1985. Research policy and review 6. Future directions for environmental policy.Environment and Planning A 17(11):1431–1446.Google Scholar
  85. Owens, P. L., and S. Owens. 1989. Resource management.Progress in Human Geography 31(1):107–117.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. PAC (Public Advisory Committees). 1986. Prospectus for an Alberta conservation strategy. ECA86-PA/CS. PAC to the Environment Council of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta.Google Scholar
  87. Parikh, K., and F. Rabar. 1981. Food problems and policies: present and future, local and global. Pages 1–23in K. Parikh and F. Rabar (eds.), Food for all in a sustainable world: the IIASA food and agriculture program. International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, Laxenburg, Austria.Google Scholar
  88. Parry, B., H. Vaux, and N. Dennis. 1983. Changing conception of sustained yield policy on the national forests.Journal of Forestry 81(3):150–154.Google Scholar
  89. Pearce, D. 1988. Optimal prices for sustainable development. Pages 57–66in D. Collard, D. Pearce, and D. Ulph (eds.), Economics, growth and sustainable development. St. Martins Press, New York.Google Scholar
  90. PFRA (Prairie Farm Rehabilitation Administration). 1983. Land degradation and soil conservation issues of the Canadian prairies: An overview. PFRA, Regina, Saskatchewan.Google Scholar
  91. Pierce, J., and O. Furuseth. 1983. Assessing the adequacy of North American agricultural land resources.Geoforum 14(4):413–425.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  92. Pierce, J., and O. Furuseth. 1986. Constraints to expanded food production: a North American perspective.Natural Resources Journal 26(1):15–39.Google Scholar
  93. Poincelot, R. 1986. Toward a more sustainable agriculture. AVI, Westport, Connecticut.Google Scholar
  94. Pollard, D., and M. McKechnie. 1986. World conservation strategy—Canada: a report on achievements in conservation. Conservation and Protection, Environment Canada, Ottawa, Ontario.Google Scholar
  95. Postel, S. 1986. Altering the earth's chemistry: Assessing the risks. Worldwatch Paper 71. Worldwatch Institute, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
  96. Repetto, R. 1987. Economic incentives for sustainable production.The Annals of Regional Science 21(3):44–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  97. Ritter, W. 1988. Reducing impacts of nonpoint source pollution from agriculture: a review.Journal of Environmental Science and Health A 23(7):645–667.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  98. Ruddle, K., and D. Rondinelli. 1983. Resources, environment, and development policy: a resource systems framework.Resources Management and Optimization 3(1):1–22.Google Scholar
  99. SCC (Science Council of Canada). 1979. Canadian food and agriculture sustainability and self-reliance. SCC, Ottawa, Ontario.Google Scholar
  100. Schaeffer, D., E. Herricks, and H. Kerster. 1988. Ecosystem health: I. Measuring ecosystem health.Environmental Management 12(4):445–455.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  101. Shafi, M. 1984. Food production and consumption in developed and developing countries.Rural Systems 2(4):191–197.Google Scholar
  102. Siddiqi, M. 1983. Population growth and food supply margin in Pakistan.Geojournal 10(1):83–89.Google Scholar
  103. Sinha, S., N. Rao, and M. Swaminathan. 1988. Food security in the changing global climate. Presented to the World Conference on the Changing Atmospheres: Implications for Global Security, Toronto, Ontario, Canada, 27–30 June 1988.Google Scholar
  104. Smit, B., M. Brklacich, R. McBride, Y. Yin, and D. Bond. 1988. Assessing implications of soil erosion for future food production: a Canadian example.Geoforum 19(2):245–259.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  105. Stankey, G. 1982. Recreational carrying capacity research review.Ontario Geography 19:57–72.Google Scholar
  106. Strange, M. 1984. The economic structure of a sustainable agriculture. Pages 116–125in W. Jackson, W. Berry, and B. Colman (eds.), Meeting the expectations of the land: essays in sustainable agriculture and stewardship. North Point Press, San Francisco.Google Scholar
  107. Streeten, P. 1986. What do we owe the future.Resources Policy 12(1):4–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  108. Swader, F. 1980. Soil productivity and the future of American agriculture. Pages 79–116in S. Batie and R. Healy (eds.), The future of American agriculture as a strategic resource. The Conservation Foundation, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
  109. Talbot, L. 1984. The world conservation strategy. Pages 3–15in F. Thibodeau and H. Field (eds.), Sustaining tomorrow: a strategy for world conservation and development. University Press of New England, Hanover, New Hampshire.Google Scholar
  110. Thomas, W. (ed.). 1956. Man's role in changing the face of the earth. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
  111. Tisdell, C. 1988. Sustainable development: Differing perspectives of ecologists and economists, and relevance to LDCs.World Development 16(3):373–384.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  112. Vanegas, M. 1986. Meeting world food objectives: Towards an improved trade environment in agriculture.Food Policy 11(3):205–215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  113. Wall, G. 1982. Cycles and capacity: incipient theory or conceptual contradiction.Tourism Management 3(3):188–192.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  114. WCED (World Commission on Environment and Development). 1987. Our common future. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag New York Inc. 1991

Authors and Affiliations

  • Michael Brklacich
    • 1
  • Christopher R. Bryant
    • 2
  • Barry Smit
    • 3
  1. 1.Land Resource Research Centre Research BranchAgriculture CanadaOttawaCanada
  2. 2.Department de GéographieUniversité de MontréalMontréalCanada
  3. 3.Department of GeographyUniversity of GuelphGuelphCanada

Personalised recommendations