Pastoral Psychology

, Volume 45, Issue 4, pp 277–299

Child sexual abuse and the Catholic church: An historical and contemporary review

  • Paul J. Isely
Article

Abstract

Although the recent revelations of clergy sexual abuse suggests an unusual and recent epidemic among the Catholic church, the historical record suggests this difficulty has plagued the church over the centuries. The recent effort of investigative reporters and adult survivors alleging sexual abuse by clergy, has led to an increased public awareness of the extent of illegal sexual activity occurring in the church. Opinion polls of Catholics in the United States have evidenced a critical view of the Church's administrative response to the crisis. Recently, criminal and civil cases have successfully challenged the negligence of the church hierarchy and the sexual misconduct by some of its members. Judicial decisions, however, tend to not hold churches liable for the sexual acts of their clergy. Despite continuing press coverage and civil/criminal litigation, research on priest offenders is virtually nonexistent The claims of unprecedented treatment success with clergy offenders has not been supported by published data. Given the high recidivism rates of sex offenders, the Catholic church should reconsider its policy of placing known sex offenders back into active ministry.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Abel, G.G., Becker, J.V., Cunningham-Rathner, J., Mittelman, M., & Rouleau, J-L. (1988). Multiple paraphilic diagnoses among sex offenders.Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatric Law, 16(2), 153–168.Google Scholar
  2. Abel, G.G., Becker, J.V., Cunningham-Rathner, J., Mittelman, M., & Rouleau, J-L. (1987). Predicting child molesters' response to treatment.Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 528, 223–234.Google Scholar
  3. American Psychiatric Association (1994).Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed.). Washington, DC: Author.Google Scholar
  4. American Psychiatric Association (1987).Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (rev. 3rd. ed.) Washington, DC: Author.Google Scholar
  5. Ames, M.A, & Houston, D.A. (1990). Legal, social, and biological definitions of pedophilia.Archives of sexual Behavior, 19(4), 333–342.Google Scholar
  6. Arnold, D. (1992, August 6). Priest who left Worcester still controversial in Canada.Boston Globe, p. 29.Google Scholar
  7. Babych, A. (1993, July 2). Price of Canada scandals hits $23 million.National Catholic Reporter, 6.Google Scholar
  8. Barbaree, H.E., & Marshall, W.L. (1988). Deviant sexual arousal, offense history, and demographic variables as predictors of reoffense among child molesters.Behavior Science and the Law, 6, 267–280.Google Scholar
  9. Bassett, W.W. (1994, June 17). Pedophilia's victims.Commonweal, 28–30.Google Scholar
  10. Benning, V. (1992, June 26). Clergy answer charges; Hingham priest pleads innocent to boy's rape.Boston Globe, p. 17.Google Scholar
  11. Berlin, F.S., Malin, H.M., & Dean, S. (1991). Effects of statutes requiring psychiatrists to report suspected sexual abuse of children.American Journal of Psychiatry, 148(4), 449–453.Google Scholar
  12. Berry, J. (1993, Dec. 3). Sudden recall: Memories delayed or imagined?National Catholic Reporter, 4.Google Scholar
  13. Berry, J. (1992).Lead us not into temptation. New York: Doubleday.Google Scholar
  14. Berry, J. (1989, September 25). Church must face the sexual crisis of its clergy.Minneapolis Star Tribune, A15.Google Scholar
  15. Berry, J. (1985, June 7). Child abuse victimizing families; bishops lack policy response.National Catholic Reporter, 4–6, 21.Google Scholar
  16. Boswell, (1980).Christianity, social tolerance, and homosexuality: Gay people in western europe from the beginning of Christian era to the fourteenth century. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  17. Burkett, E., & Bruni, F. (1993).A gospel of shame. New York: Viking.Google Scholar
  18. Callahan, S. (1993, December). Memory can play tricks and so can therapists.Commonweal, 6–7.Google Scholar
  19. Carini v. Beaven (1914).Northeastern Reporter, 106, 589.Google Scholar
  20. Chandler, R. (1990, Aug. 3). Sex abuse cases rock the clergy.Los Angeles Times, 29.Google Scholar
  21. Chopko, T. (1992). Restoring trust and faith.Human Rights, 19(4), 22–24.Google Scholar
  22. Clark, D.C. (1993, April 14). Sexual abuse in the church: The law steps in.The Christian Century, 396–398.Google Scholar
  23. Coakley, T. (1992, May 7). Rape victim speaks out as priest gets jail for crime.Boston Globe, p.1.Google Scholar
  24. Cohen, D. (1987). Law, society and homosexuality in classical athens.Past & Present, 117, 3–21.Google Scholar
  25. Commonweal (1992, November 20).Priests & Sex, 3–4.Google Scholar
  26. Connors, C. (1992). Priests and pedophilia: A silence that needs breaking.America, 166(16), 400–401.Google Scholar
  27. Costelli, J. (1993). Abuse of faith.U.S. Catholic, 58(9), 8–15.Google Scholar
  28. Cullen, K. (1991, October 24). Rain washed away clue in '72 slaying; Sources say Springfield DA believed priest killed boy.Boston Globe, p. 25.Google Scholar
  29. Curriden, M. (1992, April 2). Minister convicted of molesting 4 boys 2 brothers already in prison for abuse.Atlanta Journal and Constitution, 3.Google Scholar
  30. Davidson, J. (1993, October 8). Generational differences among catholics emerge.National Catholic Reporter, 29–30.Google Scholar
  31. Dyrud, J. (1993, June 17). On screening seminarians.Origins, 79–80.Google Scholar
  32. Edwards, R. (1993, March 5). Bishops advised on sexual abuse.National Catholic Reporter, 5.Google Scholar
  33. Emerging Trends (1993, October). Sexual abuse by priests?Emerging Trends, 15(18), 5.Google Scholar
  34. Fedje, J. (1990). Liability for sexual abuse: The anomalous immunity of churches.Law and Inequality, 9(1), 133–161.Google Scholar
  35. Fitch, J.H. (1962). Men convicted of sexual offenses against children: A descriptive follow-up study.British Journal of Criminology, 3, 18–37.Google Scholar
  36. Fitzpatrick, S. (1996). Urgent legal action alert.The Survivor Activist, 4 (1), 26.Google Scholar
  37. Fortune, M. (1990). In L. Rambo. (1991). Interview with reverend Marie Fortune, August 8, 1990.Pastoral Psychology, 39(5), 305–319.Google Scholar
  38. Fox, T.C. (1993, October 8). U.S. Catholics loyal, choose moral terms.National Catholic Reporter, 22–25.Google Scholar
  39. Fox, T.C., & Berry, J. (1993, July 2). As nation discusses pedophilia, even pope admits it's a problem.National Catholic Reporter, 2.Google Scholar
  40. Franklin, J.L. (1991, November 5). Churches change their responses to sex abuse.The Boston Globe, p. 1.Google Scholar
  41. Franklin, J.L. (1992, June 21). Catholic bishops vow to step up efforts against clergy abuse.The Boston Globe, p. 2.Google Scholar
  42. Franklin, J.L. (1992, July 12). US dioceses lack policy for cases of sex abuse.The Boston Globe, p. 1.Google Scholar
  43. Franklin, J.L. (1992, July 26). Mass. Catholics fault church on handling of sex charges.The Boston Globe, pp. 1, 8.Google Scholar
  44. Fraze, B. (1993, July 2). Canadian bishops move vigorously on sex abuse problems.National Catholic Reporter, 3.Google Scholar
  45. Freifeld, K. (1992). Acquittal brings joy to his flock.Newsday, p. 19.Google Scholar
  46. Friendly, J. (1986, Nov.). Roman catholic church discusses abuse of children by priests.New York Times, p. 4.Google Scholar
  47. Frisbie, L.V., & Dondis, E.H. (1965).Recidivism among treated sex offenders (California Mental Health Research 'Monograph No. 5). Sacramento: California Department of Mental Hygiene.Google Scholar
  48. Frisbie, L.V. (1969).Another look at sex offenders in California (California Mental Health Research Monograph No. 12). Sacramento: California Department of Mental Hygiene.Google Scholar
  49. Furby, L., Wenrott, M.R., & Blackshaw, L. (1989). Sex offender recidivism: A review.Psychological Bulletin, 105(1), 3–30.Google Scholar
  50. Geyelin, M. (1993, Nov. 24). The Catholic church struggles with suits over sexual abuse.The Wall Street Journal, pp. 1,8.Google Scholar
  51. Greely, A.M. (1992, March 13). Priestly silence on pedophilia.Chicago Tribune, p. D11.Google Scholar
  52. Greely, A.M. (1992). Foreword. In J. Berry,Lead Us Not Into Temptation. (pp. xiii-xiv). New York: Doubleday.Google Scholar
  53. Greely, A.M. (1993a). How serious is the problem of sexual abuse by clergy ?America, 168(10), 6–10.Google Scholar
  54. Greely, A.M. (1993b). But father, they're priests!The Critic, 43–51.Google Scholar
  55. Groth, A.N. (1979).Men who rape: The psychology of the offender. New York: Plenum.Google Scholar
  56. Grunfield, B., & Noreik, K. (1986). Recidivism among sex offenders.International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 9, 95–102.Google Scholar
  57. Gustafson, P. (1992). Ex-St. Paul bishop accused of abuse; Now in Iowa; 2 women sue.Star Tribune, p. 18.Google Scholar
  58. Haga, C. & McEnroe, P. (1992, July 19). Sins of the father; James Porter claims that his life as a pedophile ended when he left the priesthood. But those who he victimized cannot forgive and forget.Star Tribune, p. 1AGoogle Scholar
  59. Harvey, J.F. (1992). Priests who stray.Crisis, 10(10), 37–42.Google Scholar
  60. Hindman, J. (1988). Research disputes assumptions about child molesters.National District Attorney's Association Bulletin, 7(4), 1,3.Google Scholar
  61. Hirsley, M. (1992, March 16). Archdiocese seeking solution for sex abuse by the clergy.Chicago Tribune, p. 1.Google Scholar
  62. Hirsley, M. (1992, April 3). Northbrook priest faces sex lawsuit.Chicago Tribune, p. 4.Google Scholar
  63. Hirsley, M. (1992, June, 21). Bishops apologize for abuses.Chicago Tribune, p. 8.Google Scholar
  64. Houssaye, N. (1993). Liability of the church for the sexual misconduct of church leaders.Loyola Law Review, 39(2), 313–338.Google Scholar
  65. John Paul II (1993, July 1). Vatican-U.S. bishops committed to study applying canonical norms.Origins, 23(7), 102–103.Google Scholar
  66. Keeler, W. (1993, November 25). The media and the “American Catholic story.”Origins, 23(4), 418–421.Google Scholar
  67. Keeler, W. (1993, November 25). Statement supporting cardinal Bernardin.Origins, 23(4), 421–422.Google Scholar
  68. Kennedy, E. (1993, March 19). The see-no-problem, hear-no-problem, speak-no-problem problem.National Catholic Reporter, 5, 8.Google Scholar
  69. Kurkjian, S. (1992, Dec. 4). 68 victims settle Porter case with Catholic church.The Boston Globe, pp. 1,19.Google Scholar
  70. Lefevere, P. (1993). Racketeering statutes cited in lawsuit.National Catholic Reporter, 5.Google Scholar
  71. Lefevere, P. (1994). Clergy anger up, morale down because of sex abuser smears.National Catholic Reporter, 10.Google Scholar
  72. Lothstein, L.M. (1990). Psychological theories of pedophilia and ephebophilia. In S.J. Rossetti (ed.).Slayer of the Soul. (pp. 19–43). Mystic, CT: Twenty-Third Publications.Google Scholar
  73. Lothstein, L.M. (1993). Can a sexually addicted priest return to ministry after treatment? Psychological issues and possible forensic solutions.The Catholic Lawyer, 34(1), 89–113.Google Scholar
  74. Maida, A.J. (1992). The selection, training, and removal of diocesan clergy.The Catholic Lawyer, 33(1), 53–60.Google Scholar
  75. Malcolm, P.B., Andrews, D.A., & Quinsey, V.L. (1993). Discriminant and predictive validity of phallometrically measured sexual age and gender preference.Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 8(4), 486–501.Google Scholar
  76. Martinez, D. (1994, January 28). Santa Fe sends out sos to other dioceses.National Catholic Reporter, 5.Google Scholar
  77. Matchan, L. (1992, July 14). Ex-priest accused in Minnesota.The Boston Globe, pp. 1,6.Google Scholar
  78. Matchan, L. (1993, Aug. 29). Town SecretThe Boston Globe Magazine, pp. 10–13, 116–18, 20–22, 25–32.Google Scholar
  79. Murphy, M.B. (1993, Jan. 9th). Expelling pedophiles may not be answer, doctor says.Milwaukee Sentinel, p. 10A.Google Scholar
  80. Neuhaus, R.J. (1993). When shepherds go astray.First things, 29, 55–58.Google Scholar
  81. Neuhaus, R.J. (1994). Verdict firstFirst Things, 40, 53–54.Google Scholar
  82. O'Brien, R.C. (1988). Pedophilia: The legal predicament of clergy.Journal of Contemporary Health and Law Policy, 4, 91–154.Google Scholar
  83. O'Reilly, J.T. & Strasser, J.M. (1994). Clergy sexual misconduct: Confronting the difficult constitutional and institutional liability issues.St. Thomas Law Review, 7(1), 31–73.Google Scholar
  84. Ostling, R.N. (1991, Aug. 19). Sins of the Fathers.TIME, p. 15.Google Scholar
  85. Ostling, R.N. (1993, June 7). The secrets of St. Lawrence.TIME, p. 44.Google Scholar
  86. Paulson, J.E. (1988). The clinical and canonical considerations in cases of pedophilia: The bishop's role.Studia canonica, 22, 77–124.Google Scholar
  87. Payer, P.J. (1982).Book of Gomorrah: an eleventh-century treatise against clerical homosexual practices. Waterloo, Ontario, Canada: Wilfrid Laurier University Press.Google Scholar
  88. Poe, J. (1992, July 31). Priest is suspended.Chicago Tribune, 17–19.Google Scholar
  89. Quinn, P.A. (1989).Better than the sons of kings. New York: Peter Lang Publishing.Google Scholar
  90. Quinn, J.R. (1993). Scandals in the church: Reflections of paschaltide.America, 168(12), 4–6.Google Scholar
  91. Quinsey, V.L., Lalumiere, M.L., Rice, M.E., & Harris, G.T. (1995a). Predicting sexual offenses. In J.C. Campbell (Ed.).Assessing Dangerousness: Violence by Sexual Offenders, Batterers, and Child Abusers. (pp. 114–137). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
  92. Quinsey, V.L., Rice, M.E., & Harris, G.T. (1995b). Actuarial prediction of sexual recidivism.Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 10(1), 85–105.Google Scholar
  93. Quinsey, V.L., Harris, G.T., Rice, M.E., & Lalumiere, M. (1993). Assessing treatment efficacy in outcome studies of sex offenders.Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 8, 512–523.Google Scholar
  94. Rae-Dupree, J. (1991, December 5). Ex-pastor gets 38 years in sexual abuse of teen-ager.Los Angeles Times, p. 3.Google Scholar
  95. Rice, M.E., Quinsey, V.L., & Harris, G.T. (1990). Predicting sexual recidivism among treated and untreated extrafamilial child molesters released from a maximum security psychiatric institution.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 59, 381–386.Google Scholar
  96. Rohde, M. (1992, Dec. 20). 8 men tell of seminary sex abuse.The Milwaukee Journal, pp. 1, 14, 15.Google Scholar
  97. Rossetti, S.J. (1995). The mark of Cain: Reintegrating pedophiles.America, 173(6), 9–13.Google Scholar
  98. Rossetti, S.J. (1990)Slayer of the soul. Mystic, CT: Twenty-Third Publications.Google Scholar
  99. Rossetti, S.J., & Lothstein, L.M. (1990). Myths of the child molester. In S.J. Rossetti,(Ed.).Slayer of the soul. (pp. 9–18). Mystic, CT: Twenty-Third Publications.Google Scholar
  100. Sergent, B. (1993). Paederasty and political life in archaic greek cities.Journal of Homosexuality, 25(1/2), 147–164.Google Scholar
  101. Sheer, R. (1991). A canon, a choirboy, and homosexuality in late sixteen-century italy: A case study.Journal of Homosexuality, 121(3), 1–22Google Scholar
  102. Sipe, A.W.R. (1990).A secret world. New York: Brunner/Mazel.Google Scholar
  103. Staff. (August, 13, 1993). Former Students.National Catholic Reporter, 8.Google Scholar
  104. Staff. (August, 24, 1991). Canadian bishops seek to halt sex abuse of children by priests.Los Angeles Times, 22.Google Scholar
  105. Stahel, T.H. (1993, Dec. 4). The ‘real Catholic story’: U.S. Bishops meet.America, 169(18), 4–5.Google Scholar
  106. Sturgeon, V.H., & Taylor, J. (1980). Report of a five-year follow-up study of mentally disordered sex offenders released from Atascadero State Hospital in 1973.Criminal Justice Journal, 4, 31–63.Google Scholar
  107. Unsworth, T. (1991). Chicago faces ‘lawyer versus pastor’ sex-abuse response.National Catholic Reporter, 26.Google Scholar
  108. Wilson, T. (1992). Priest's Wisconsin bond paid.Chicago Tribune, p. 7.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Human Sciences Press, Inc. 1997

Authors and Affiliations

  • Paul J. Isely
    • 1
  1. 1.Riverside Crisis Intervention serviceRiverside Community CareNorwood

Personalised recommendations