Environmentalist

, Volume 7, Issue 1, pp 43–53

Gordon below Franklin dam, Tasmania, Australia: Environmental factors in a decision of national significance

  • H. Bandler
Special Report

Summary

In Tasmania's rugged south-west, the Gordon River Power Development, Stage 1, with several dams and one power station has been in operation since 1978. A Committee of Enquiry severely criticised environmental aspects of the scheme. The Gordon River Power Development, Stage II, with the construction of another dam and power station on the Gordon River, was put forward by the Hydro Electric Commission of Tasmania to satisfy the electricity demand growth rate expected. Many objections were raised.

A Senate Select Committee on South-west Tasmania received many submissions disputing the need for the dam, objecting to its intrusion into the World Heritage Wilderness area and disagreeing on several scientific aspects. Simultaneously, extensive debate was carried on in the media and in technical and scientific journals. A popular protest movement against building the dam grew throughout Australia and a blockade against the work of the Hydro Electric Commission was successfully maintained. Elections, influenced by the popular movement against the dam, changed the Government of Australia in March 1983. In July 1983, the High Court of Australia determined that construction of the Gordon below Franklin Dam was illegal and work by the Hydro Electric Commission in the area had to be terminated.

This case illustrates that the importance of environmental implications of water structures must never be under-estimated. In special cases, popular support can be gained, to bring about political and legal action to counteract transgression of environmental principles. It is to be hoped that in future the kind of situation which developed in this case will not recur.

“We will be judged, not by what we built, but by what we destroyed.”

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. ANCOLD (1982)Register of Large Dams in Australia. Australian National Committee on Large Dams, December.Google Scholar
  2. Ashton, J. R. (1983) On the Shelf? Letter to the Editor,World Water, April, p. 7.Google Scholar
  3. Bandler, H. (1983) Voice from the Wilderness Letter to the Editor,World Water, June, p. 5.Google Scholar
  4. Burton, B. (1984)Overpowering Tasmania. The Wilderness Society, Australia.Google Scholar
  5. Cooper, M. (1983)The Franklin Dam Case. Butterworths, Australia.Google Scholar
  6. Engineers Australia (1983) Tasmanian Coal could Fuel Power-station.J1., Institution of Engineers, Australia, 21 January, p. 6.Google Scholar
  7. Frost, A. C. H. (1983) Hydro-electricity in AustraliaWater 2000: Consultants Report No. 6. Australian Government Publishing Service.Google Scholar
  8. Hungerford, H. B. (1983)I will not say the day is done. Alternative Publishing Cooperative Limited, Sydney.Google Scholar
  9. HECT (1979)Report on Gordon River Power Development, Stage 2. Report to the Premier, October, Hydro-electric Commission, Tasmania, Holbart, Tasmania.Google Scholar
  10. HECT (1982)Annual Report 1981–82. Hydro-electric Commission, Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania.Google Scholar
  11. HECT (1984)Annual Report 1983–84. Hydro-electric Commission, Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania.Google Scholar
  12. HECT (1985)Annual Report 1984–85. Hydro-electric Commission, Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania.Google Scholar
  13. HECT (1986)Annual Report 1985–86. Hydro-electric Commission, Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania.Google Scholar
  14. ICOLD (1980)Dams and the Environment. International Commission on Large Dams, Bulletin 35, p. 47.Google Scholar
  15. Jones, N., and Outhred, H. S. (1983/84) Energy and CSIRO.Search 14 (11–12), Dec. 1983/Jan. 1984.Google Scholar
  16. Jones, R. (1983) Franklin Valley sites.Nature 306, p. 726.Google Scholar
  17. Kellow, A. J. (1982) An Economical Evaluation of Hydro-Electric and Coalfired Thermal Power. Development programme for Tasmanian Environmental Studies Working Paper 14, University of Tasmania.Google Scholar
  18. Kellow, A. J. (1983/84) A Neglected Option in Tasmania's Power Debate.Search 14 (11–12) 306–308.Google Scholar
  19. Kiernan, K., Jones, R., and Ranson, D. (1983) New Evidence from Fraser Cave for Glacial Age Man in South-west Tasmania.Nature 301 (5895) 28–32.Google Scholar
  20. LPCE (1974)The Flooding of Lake Pedder. Final Report, Lake Pedder Committee of Enquiry, April, Australian Government Publishing Service.Google Scholar
  21. Mulvaney, J. (1983) Towards a New National Consciousness.Australian Natural History 21(3) 88–89.Google Scholar
  22. Mulvaney, D. J. (1983) Franklin Valley Defended.Nature 306, p. 636.Google Scholar
  23. Paterson, S. J. (1983) Franklin Valley not so Special?Nature 303, p. 354.Google Scholar
  24. Saddler, H., Bennet, J., Reynolds, I., and Smith, B. (1980)Public Choice in Tasmania. Aspects of the lower Gordon River hydro-electric development proposal, Centre of Resources and Environmental Studies, Australian National University.Google Scholar
  25. Sarma, V. (1982) Dam Threatens Wilderness.Nature 300, p. 3.Google Scholar
  26. SMH (1984) Mr Hawke Insists on an Observer.Sydney Morning Herald, 25th February, p. 3.Google Scholar
  27. SSCSWT (1982)Report on Demand and Supply of Electricity for Tasmania and Other Matters. Senate Select Committee on South-west Tasmania, Australian Government Publishing Service.Google Scholar
  28. State Library (1984)Research No. 387. Gordon below Franklin Dam, Overseas References. Research Service State Library of N.S.W.Google Scholar
  29. Tasmanian Government (1981)Nomination of Western Tasmania Wilderness National Parks, by the Commonwealth of Australia for inclusion in the World Heritage List, prepared by Tasmanian Government, Australian Heritage Commission, November.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Science and Technology Letters 1987

Authors and Affiliations

  • H. Bandler
    • 1
  1. 1.TurramurraAustralia

Personalised recommendations