Taxes and giving: new findings

  • Richard Steinberg


This paper surveys 24 studies, appearing since Clotfelter's (1985) book, which estimate the influence of tax incentives on personal donations in three countries. Studies employ new surveys, experimental data, and data corrected for tax evasion. Newly available panel data sets obtain conclusions which strongly challenge the traditional consensus that tax incentives are a powerful stimulus to giving. The paper also surveys theoretical developments. In particular, the traditional test for efficiency (price elasticity exceeding unity) is not generally appropriate.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Adams, Burton and Mark Schmitz (1984) The crowding out effect of governmental transfers on private charitable contributions: cross-section evidence,National Tax Journal, 36, December, 563–7.Google Scholar
  2. Auten, Gerald and Gabriel Rudney (1984) Charitable deductions and tax reform: new evidence on giving behaviour, in NTA/TIAProceedings of 77th Annual Conference, 73–81.Google Scholar
  3. Auten, Gerald and Gabriel Rudney (1986) Tax reform and individual giving to higher education,Economics of Higher Education Review, 5, 167–78.Google Scholar
  4. Broman, Amy (1989) Statutory tax rate reform and charitable contributions: evidence from a recent period of reform,Journal of the American Taxation Association, 10, Fall, 7–20.Google Scholar
  5. Brown, Eleanor (1987) Tax incentives and charitable giving: evidence from new survey data,Public Finance Quarterly, 15, 386–96.Google Scholar
  6. Christian, Charles and James Boatsman (1990) Cross-sectional price elasticity estimates of the charitable contributions deduction, in Sally M. Jones (ed.)Advances in Taxation, 3, JAI Press, Greenwich, Conn.Google Scholar
  7. Christian, Charles, James Boatsman and J. Hal Reneau (1990) The interpretation of econometric estimates of the tax incentive to engage in philanthropy,Journal of the American Taxation Association, 11, Spring, 7–16.Google Scholar
  8. Clotfelter, Charles (1985)Federal Tax Policy and Charitable Giving, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, Ill.Google Scholar
  9. Clotfelter, Charles (1989) Federal tax policy and charitable giving, in Richard Magat (ed.)Philanthropic Giving: Studies in Varieties and Goals, Oxford University Press, New York.Google Scholar
  10. Daniel, Joseph (1989) Price and income elasticities of charitable giving: new evidence from a panel of taxpayers, draft, Department of Economics, University of Minnesota.Google Scholar
  11. Feenberg, Daniel (1987) Are tax price models really identified: the case of charitable giving,National Tax Journal, 42, December, 620–33.Google Scholar
  12. Feigenbaum, Susan (1980) The case of income redistribution: a theory of government and private provision of collective goods,Public Finance Quarterly, 8, 3–22.Google Scholar
  13. Feldstein, Martin and Lawrence Lindsey (1983) Simulating nonlinear tax rules and nonstrandard behavior: an application to the tax treatment of charitable contributions, in Martin Feldstein (ed.)Behavioral Simulation Methods in Tax Policy Analysis, National Bureau of Economics Research, Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
  14. Glenday, Graham, Anil K. Gupta and Henry Pawluk (1986) Tax incentives for personal charitable contributions,The Review of Economics and Statistics, 68, November, 668–93.Google Scholar
  15. Greenwood, Daphne T. (1988) Price and income elasticities of charitable giving: the effects of specification, Working Paper No. 134, Program on Nonprofit Organizations, Yale University, New Haven, Conn.Google Scholar
  16. Hood, R.S., S.A. Martin and L.S. Osberg (1977) Economic determinants of individual charitable donations in Canada,Canadian Journal of Economics, 10, 653–69.Google Scholar
  17. Hsiao, C. (1986)Analysis of Panel Data, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
  18. Jencks, Christopher (1987) Who gives to what?, in Walter W. Powell (ed.)The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook, Yale University Press, New Haven, Conn.Google Scholar
  19. Jones, Andrew and John Posnett (1990a) Charitable donations by UK households: evidence from the Family Expenditure Survey,Applied Economics (forthcoming).Google Scholar
  20. Jones, Andrew and John Posnett (1990b) The impact of tax deductibility on charitable giving by covenant in the UK, draft, Department of Economics and Related Studies, University of York, York.Google Scholar
  21. Jones, P.R. (1983) Aid to charities,International Journal of Social Economics, 10, 4–11.Google Scholar
  22. Kingma, Bruce R. (1989) An accurate measurement of the crowd-out effect, income effect, and price effect for charitable contributions,Journal of Political Economy, 97, 1197–1205.Google Scholar
  23. Lawrence, D.B. and M.M. Saghafi (1984) The flat-rate income tax, tax burden, and charitable contributions,National Tax Journal, 37, December, 569–74.Google Scholar
  24. Lindsey, Lawrence and Richard Steinberg (1989) Joint crowdout: an empirical study of the effects of federal grants on state government expenditures and local donations, working paper, Department of Economics, Virginia Polytechnic Institute.Google Scholar
  25. O'Neil, Cherie J. and G. Rodney Thompson (1989) An examination of the impact of the Tax Reform Act of 1986 on charitable contributions of appreciated property, draft, Department of Accounting, Virginia Polytechnic Institute.Google Scholar
  26. O'Neil, Cherie J., Richard Steinberg and G. Rodney Thompson (1990) Cash vs property contributions, draft, Department of Accounting, Virginia Polytechnic Institute.Google Scholar
  27. Pacque, Karl-Heinz (1982) The efficiency of public support to private charity: an econometric analysis of the income tax treatment of charitable contributions in the Federal Republic of Germany, Working Paper No. 152, Institute für Weltwirtschaft an der Universität Kiel, Kiel.Google Scholar
  28. Pindyck, Robert and Daniel Rubinfeld (1976)Econometric Models and Economic Forecasts, McGraw Hill, New York.Google Scholar
  29. Reece, William S. and Kimberly D. Zieschang (1989) Evidence on taxation and charitable giving from the 1983 US Treasury Tax Model File,Economic Letters, 31, 49–53.Google Scholar
  30. Roberts, Russell D. (1987) Financing public goods,Journal of Political Economy, 92, 420–37.Google Scholar
  31. Schiff, Jerald (1985) Does government spending crowd out charitable contributions?,National Tax Journal, 38, December, 535–46.Google Scholar
  32. Schiff, Jerald (1989) Tax policy, charitable giving, and the nonprofit sector: what do we really know?, in Richard Magat (ed.)Philanthropic Giving: Studies in Varieties and Goals, Oxford University Press, New York.Google Scholar
  33. Schiff, Jerald (1990)Charitable Giving and Government Policy: An Economic Analysis, Greenwood Press, Westwood, Conn.Google Scholar
  34. Schuster, J. Mark Davidson (1989) The British deed of covenant as a tax incentive for charitable donations: vestige or viable alternative?, in Estelle James (ed.)The Nonprofit Sector in International Perspective: Studies in Comparative Culture and Poverty, Oxford University Press, Oxford and New York.Google Scholar
  35. Simon, John G. (1987) The tax treatment of nonprofit organizations: a review of federal and state policies, in Walter W. Powell (ed.)The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook, Yale University Press, New Haven, Conn.Google Scholar
  36. Slemrod, Joel (1989) Are estimated tax elasticities really just tax evasion elasticities? The case of charitable contributions,Review of Economics and Statistics, 71, August, 517–22.Google Scholar
  37. Slemrod, Joel and William Shobe (1988) The use of panel data in the analysis of the behavioral response to taxation, working paper, School of Business Administration, University of Michigan.Google Scholar
  38. Smith, Elizabeth J. (1989) An empirical study of the effect of the changes in the marginal tax rates in the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981 upon charitable contributions, unpublished manuscript.Google Scholar
  39. Steinberg, Richard (1985) Empirical relations between government spending and charitable donations,Journal of Voluntary Action Research, 14, September, 54–64.Google Scholar
  40. Steinberg, Richard (1986) Charitable giving as a mixed public/private good: implications for tax policy,Public Finance Quarterly, 14, October, 415–31.Google Scholar
  41. Toolson, Richard B. (1990) The charitable contribution deduction: new evidence of a strong incentive effect, in Sally M. Jones (ed.)Advances in Taxation, 2, JAI Press, Greenwich, Conn.Google Scholar
  42. Watson, Harry (1984) A note on the effects of taxation on charitable giving over the life-cycle and beyond,Quarterly Journal of Economics, 99, August, 639–47Google Scholar
  43. Weisbrod, Burton (with the assitance of Eliabeth Mauser) (1990) Tax policy toward nonprofit organizations: an eleven country survey, in Russy D. Sumariwalla and Kathleen D. McCarthy (eds)The Nonprofit Sector (NGOs) in the United States and Abroad: Cross-Cultural Perspectives (working title), Jossey Bass, San Francisco.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Charities Aid Foundation 1990

Authors and Affiliations

  • Richard Steinberg
    • 1
  1. 1.Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State UniversityUSA

Personalised recommendations