Toxikologie der synthetischen Antioxidantien BHA und BHT im Vergleich mit dem natürlichen Antioxidans Vitamin E

  • Regine Kahl
  • Hermann Kappus
Übersichtsarbeit

Zusammenfassung

Die Toxikologie der Lebensmittelzusatzstoffe Butylhydroxyanisol (BHA) und Butylhydroxytoluol (BHT) sowie des natürlich vorkommenden Vitamin E (α-Tocopherol) wird beschrieben. Alle drei Verbindungen verursachen im Tierversuch bei hoher Dosierung Störungen der Blutgerinnung, die mit einem Vitamin-K-Antagonismus erklärbar sind. Spezifische toxische Effekte auf die Lunge sind nur mit BHT beobachtet worden. Die sonst beschriebenen toxischen Wirkungen von BHA und BHT sind wenig charakteristisch und treten zum Teil erst bei sehr hoher Dosierung und bei Langzeitbehandlung auf. BHA induziert jedoch bei Tieren dosisabhängig Tumoren des Vormagens, während BHT im Langzeitversuch Lebertumoren erzeugt. Da es keinen Hinweis auf eine Gentoxizität von BHA und BHT gibt, sprechen alle bisherigen Befunde dafür, daß BHA und BHT Tumorpromotoren sind. Im Gegensatz zu BHA und BHT ist Vitamin E nicht cancerogen. Andererseits besitzen alle drei Antioxidantien auch anticancerogene Eigenschaften. Die Aufnahme hoher Dosen, wie sie für diese Effekte notwendig sind, verbietet sich jedoch bei BHA und BHT wegen ihrer cancerogenen Wirkungen. Die vorliegende Übersicht kommt zu dem Schluß, daß die in Lebensmitteln, Arzneimitteln und Cosmetica zur Zeit verwendeten Konzentrationen von BHA und BHT wahrscheinlich unbedenklich sind. Vitamin E kann darüber hinaus auch in höheren Dosen eingenommen werden, ohne daß unerwünschte Wirkungen auftreten.

Toxicology of the synthetic antioxidants BHA and BHT in comparison with the natural antioxidant vitamin E

Abstract

The toxicology of the food preservatives butylhydroxyanisole (BHA) and butylhydroxytoluene (BHT) as well as the naturally occurring vitamin E (α-tocopherol) is described. In high dosages all three compounds induce in animals impairment of blood clotting, which can be explained by an antagonism with vitamin K. Specific toxic effects to the lung have only been observed with BHT. The other described toxic effects of BHA and BHT are less characteristic and often occur only after high dosage and long-term treatment. However, BHA induces in animals tumours of the forestomach, which are dose dependent, whereas BHT induces liver tumours in long-term experiments. Because there is no indication of genotoxicity of BHA and BHT, all published findings agree with the fact that BHA and BHT are tumour promoters. In contrast to BHA and BHT, vitamin E is not carcinogenic. On the other hand, all three antioxidants have also anticarcinogenic properties. The intake of the necessary high doses as for these effects are, however, contraindicated with BHA and BHT because of their carcinogenic effects. The present overview concludes that the concentrations of BHA and BHT nowadays used in food, drugs and cosmetics are probably harmless. In addition, vitamin E can also be used in higher doses without the occurrence of adverse effects.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Literatur

  1. 1.
    Kirkpatrick DC, Lauer BH (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1035–1037Google Scholar
  2. 2.
    National Academy of Sciences (1979) 1977 Survey of industry on the use of food additives, 296. NAS, Washington, D.C., Part 2, p 963; Part 3, p 127Google Scholar
  3. 3.
    Scientific Committee for Food of the Commission of the European Communities (1987) Report on antioxidants, p 6Google Scholar
  4. 4.
    Conacher HBS, Iverson F, Lau BJ, Page BD (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1159–1162Google Scholar
  5. 5.
    Kahl R (1984) Toxicology 33:185–228Google Scholar
  6. 6.
    Van der Heijden CA, Janssen PJCM, Strik JJTWA (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1067–1070Google Scholar
  7. 7.
    Suzuki H, Nakao T, Hiraga K (1979) Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 50:261–266Google Scholar
  8. 8.
    Takahashi O, Hiraga K (1978a) Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 43:399–406Google Scholar
  9. 9.
    Takahashi O, Hayashida S, Hiraga K (1980) Food Cosmet Toxicol 18:229–235Google Scholar
  10. 10.
    Takahashi O (1987) Food Chem Toxicol 25:219–224Google Scholar
  11. 11.
    Suzuki H, Nakao T, Hiraga K (1983) Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 67:152–155Google Scholar
  12. 12.
    Takahashi O, Hiraga K (1984) Food Chem Toxicol 22:97–103Google Scholar
  13. 13.
    Takahashi O (1988) Arch Toxicol 62:325–327Google Scholar
  14. 14.
    Takahashi O, Hiraga K (1978b) Food Cosmet Toxicol 16:475–477Google Scholar
  15. 15.
    Takahashi O, Sakamoto Y, Hiraga K (1985) Toxicol Lett 27:15–25Google Scholar
  16. 16.
    Wheldon GH, Bhatt A, Keller P, Hummler H (1983) Int J Vit Res 53:287–296Google Scholar
  17. 17.
    Abdo KM, Rao G, Montgomery CA, Dinowitz M, Kanagalingam K (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1043–1050Google Scholar
  18. 18.
    Kappus H, Diplock AT (1992) Free Rad Biol Med 13:55–74Google Scholar
  19. 19.
    Marino AA, Mitchell JT (1972) Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 140:122–125Google Scholar
  20. 20.
    Adamson IYR, Bowden DH, Cote MG, Witschi HP (1977) Lab Invest 36:26Google Scholar
  21. 21.
    Smith LJ (1984) Am Rev Respir Dis 130:895–904Google Scholar
  22. 22.
    Hirai KI, Witschi HP, Cote MG (1978) Exp Molec Pathol 27:285–308Google Scholar
  23. 23.
    Kawano S, Nakao T, Hiraya K (1981) Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 61:475–479Google Scholar
  24. 24.
    Mizutani T, Nomura H, Yamamoto K, Tajima K (1984) Toxicol Lett 23:327–331Google Scholar
  25. 25.
    Tajima K, Yamamoto K, Mizutani T (1985) Biochem Pharmacol 34:2109–2114Google Scholar
  26. 26.
    Yamamoto K, Tajima K, Mizutani T (1980) Toxicol Lett 6:173–175Google Scholar
  27. 27.
    Malkinson AM, Thaete LG, Blumenthal EJ, Thompson JA (1989) Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 101:196–204Google Scholar
  28. 28.
    Kahl R, Weimann A, Weinke S, Hildebrandt AG (1987) Arch Toxicol 60:158–162Google Scholar
  29. 29.
    Omaye ST, Reddy KA, Cross CE (1977) J Toxicol Environ Health 3:829–836Google Scholar
  30. 30.
    Haschek WM, Witschi HP (1979) Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 51:475–487Google Scholar
  31. 31.
    Witschi H, Malkinson AM, Thompson JA (1989) Pharmacol Therapeut 42:89–114Google Scholar
  32. 32.
    Allen JR, Engblom JF (1977) Food Cosmet Toxicol 10:769–779Google Scholar
  33. 33.
    Yang NY, Desai ID (1977) J Nutrition 107:1410–1417Google Scholar
  34. 34.
    Hansen EV, Meyer O, Olsen P (1982) Toxicology 23:79–83Google Scholar
  35. 35.
    National Institutes of Health (NIH) (1979) DHEW Publication No. 79-1706Google Scholar
  36. 36.
    Nakagawa Y, Tayama K, Nakao T, Hiraga K (1984) Biochem Pharmacol 33:2669–2674Google Scholar
  37. 37.
    Powell CJ, Connelly JC, Jones SM, Grasso P, Bridges JW (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1131–1143Google Scholar
  38. 38.
    Clapp NK, Tyndall RL, Cumming RB (1973) Food Cosmet Toxicol 11:847–849Google Scholar
  39. 39.
    Denz FA, Llaurado JG (1957) Br J Exp Pathol 38:515–524Google Scholar
  40. 40.
    Ford SM, Hook JB, Bond JT (1980) Food Cosmet Toxicol 18:15–20Google Scholar
  41. 41.
    Ford SM, Hook JB, Bond JT (1980) Food Cosmet Toxicol 18:21–26Google Scholar
  42. 42.
    Della Corte L, Sgaragli GP (1984) Pharmacol Res Commun 16:1041–1047Google Scholar
  43. 44.
    Sgaragli GP, Valoti M, Palmi M, Mantovani P (1989) Pharmacol Res 21:649–650Google Scholar
  44. 45.
    Valoti M, Delia Corte L, Tipton KF, Sgaragli G (1988) Biochem J 250:501–507Google Scholar
  45. 46.
    Stewart RM, Weir EK, Mongomery MR, Niewoehner DE (1981) Respir Physiol 45:333–342Google Scholar
  46. 47.
    Leslie SW, Gad SC, Acosta D (1978) Toxicology 10:281–289Google Scholar
  47. 48.
    Gad SC, Leslie SW, Acosta D (1979) Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 49:45–52Google Scholar
  48. 49.
    Sondergaard D, Olsen P (1982) Toxicol Lett 10:239–244Google Scholar
  49. 50.
    Hirose M, Shibata M, Hagiwara A, Imaida K, Ito N (1981) Food Cosmet Toxicol 19:147–151Google Scholar
  50. 51.
    Takahashi O, Hiraga K (1981) Toxicology 22:161–170Google Scholar
  51. 52.
    Marx W, Marx L, Meserve ER, Shimoda F, Deuel HJ (1947) Arch Pathol 47:440–445Google Scholar
  52. 53.
    Mellette SJ, Leone LA (1960) Fed Proc Fed Am Soc Exp Biol 19:1045–1049Google Scholar
  53. 54.
    Brown ND, Johnson AR, O'Halloran MW (1959) Aust J Exp Biol 37:533–548Google Scholar
  54. 55.
    Stokes JD, Scudder CL (1974) Dev Psychobiol 7:343–350Google Scholar
  55. 56.
    Vorhees CV, Butcher RE, Brunner RL, Wootten V, Sobotka TJ (1981) Neurobehav Toxicol Teratol 3:321–329Google Scholar
  56. 57.
    Vorhees CV, Butcher RE, Brunner RL, Wootten V, Sobotka TJ (1981) Food Cosmet Toxicol 19:153–162Google Scholar
  57. 58.
    Clegg DJ (1965) Food Cosmet Toxicol 3:387–403Google Scholar
  58. 59.
    Allen JR (1976) Arch Environ Health 31:47–50Google Scholar
  59. 60.
    Martin MM, Hurley LS (1977) Am J Clin Nutr 30:1629–1637Google Scholar
  60. 61.
    Hook EB, Healy KM, Niles AM, Skalko RC (1974) Lancet I:809Google Scholar
  61. 62.
    Krasavage WJ, Terhaar CJ (1977) J Agric Food Chem 25:273–278Google Scholar
  62. 63.
    Ito N, Hagiwara A, Shibata M, Ogiso T, Fukushima S (1982) Gann 73:332–334Google Scholar
  63. 64.
    Ito N, Fukushima S, Hagiwara A, Shibata M, Ogiso T (1983) J Nat Cancer Inst 70:343–352Google Scholar
  64. 65.
    Masui T, Hirose M, Imaida K, Fukushima S, Tamano S, Ito N (1986) Jpn J Cancer Res 77:1083–1090Google Scholar
  65. 66.
    Sato H, Takahashi M, Furukawa F, Miyakawa Y, Hasegawa R, Toyoda K, Hayashi Y (1987) Cancer Lett 38:49–56Google Scholar
  66. 67.
    Arno H, Kubota H, Lu J, Matsuyama M (1990) Carcinogenesis 11:151–154Google Scholar
  67. 68.
    Park EH, Chang HH, Cha YN (1990) Jpn J Cancer Res 81:738–741Google Scholar
  68. 69.
    Iverson F, Truelove J, Nera E, Wong J, Lok E, Clayson DB (1985) Cancer Lett 26:43–50Google Scholar
  69. 70.
    Altmann HJ, Grunow W, Mohr U, Richter-Reichhelm HB, Wester PW (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1183–1188Google Scholar
  70. 71.
    Clayson DB, Iverson F, Nera E, Lok E, Rogers C, Rodrigues C, Page D, Karpinski K (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1171–1182Google Scholar
  71. 72.
    Newberne PM, Charnley G, Adams K, Cantor M, Roth D, Supharkarn V (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1111–1119Google Scholar
  72. 73.
    Hirose M, Masuda A, Kurata Y, Ikawa E, Mera Y, Ito N (1986) JNCI 76:143–147Google Scholar
  73. 74.
    Ito N, Hirose M (1987) Gann 78:1011–1026Google Scholar
  74. 75.
    Ikeda GJ, Stewart JE, Sapienza PP, Peggins JO III, Michel TC, Olivito V, Alam HZ, O'Donnell WM Jr (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1201–1221Google Scholar
  75. 76.
    Tobe M, Furuya T, Kawasaki Y, Naito K, Sekita K, Matsumoto K, Ochiai T, Usui A (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1223–1228Google Scholar
  76. 77.
    Würtzen G, Olsen P (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1229–1233Google Scholar
  77. 78.
    World Health Organisation (1989) The 33rd Meeting of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee of Food Additives, Geneva 21–30 March 1989. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge NYGoogle Scholar
  78. 79.
    Williams GM (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1163–1166Google Scholar
  79. 80.
    Hageman GJ, Verhagen H, Kleinjans JC (1988) Mutat Res 208:207–211Google Scholar
  80. 81.
    Phillips BJ, Carroll PA, Tee AC, Anderson D (1989) Mutat Res 214:105–114Google Scholar
  81. 82.
    Matsuoka A, Matsui M, Miyata N, Sofuni T, Ishidate M Jr (1990) Mutat Res 24:125–132Google Scholar
  82. 83.
    Kahl R, Weinke S, Kappus H (1989) Toxicology 59:179–194Google Scholar
  83. 84.
    Sakai A, Miyata A, Takahashi A (1990) Carcinogenesis 11:1985–1988Google Scholar
  84. 85.
    Troll W, Wiesner R (1985) Annu Rev Pharmacol Toxicol 25:509–528Google Scholar
  85. 86.
    Kensler TW, Taffe BG (1986) Free Rad Biol Med 2:347–387Google Scholar
  86. 87.
    Altmann HJ, Wester PW, Matthiaschk G, Grunow W, Heijden CA van der (1985) Food Chem Toxicol 23:723–731Google Scholar
  87. 88.
    Mera EA, Iverson F, Lok E, Armstrong CL, Karpinski K, Clayson DB (1988) Toxicology 53:251–268Google Scholar
  88. 89.
    Masui T, Asamoto M, Hirose M, Fukushima S, Ito N (1987) Cancer Res 47:5171–5174Google Scholar
  89. 90.
    Hirose M, Masuda A, Hasegawa R, Wada S, Ito N (1990) Carcinogenesis 11:239–244Google Scholar
  90. 91.
    Ito N, Hirose M, Fukushima S, Tsuda H, Shirai T, Tatematsu M (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1071–1082Google Scholar
  91. 92.
    Olsen P, Meyer O, Bille N, Würtzen G (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 24:1–12Google Scholar
  92. 93.
    Inai K, Kobuke T, Nambu S, Takemoto T, Kou E, Nishina H, Fujihara M, Yonehara S, Suehiro S, Tsuya T, Horiuchi K, Tokuoka S (1988) Jpn J Cancer Res 79:49–58Google Scholar
  93. 94.
    Clapp NK, Tyndall RL, Cumming RB, Otten JA (1974) Food Chem Toxicol 12:367–371Google Scholar
  94. 95.
    Food and Drug Administration, USA (1977) Butylated hydroxytoluene. Use restrictions in: Fed Regist 42:27–603Google Scholar
  95. 96.
    Shirai T, Hagiwara A, Kurata Y, Shibata M, Fukushima S, Ito N (1982) Food Cosmet Toxicol 20:861–865Google Scholar
  96. 97.
    Sheu CW, Cain KT, Rushbrook CJ, Jorgenson TA, Generoso WM (1986) Environ Mutagen 8:357–367Google Scholar
  97. 98.
    Bruce WR, Heddle JA (1979) Can J Genet Cytol 21:319–334Google Scholar
  98. 99.
    McGregor DB, Brown A, Cattanach P, Edwards I, McBride D, Caspary WJ (1988) Environ Mol Mutagen 11:91–118Google Scholar
  99. 100.
    Taffe BG, Kensler TW (1988) Res Commun Chem Pathol Pharmacol 61:291–303Google Scholar
  100. 101.
    Thompson JA, Schullek KM, Fernandez CA, Malkinson AM (1989) Carcinogenesis 10:773–775Google Scholar
  101. 102.
    Trosko JE, Yotti LP, Warren ST, Tsushimoto G, Chang C (1982) Carcinogenesis 7:565–585Google Scholar
  102. 103.
    Masui T, Fukushima S, Katoh F, Yamasaki H, Ito N (1987) Carcinogenesis 9:1143–1146Google Scholar
  103. 104.
    Kitchin KT, Brown JL (1987) Food Chem Toxicol 25:603–607Google Scholar
  104. 105.
    Potenberg J, Schiffmann D, Kahl R, Hildebrandt AG, Henschler D (1986) Cancer Lett 33:189–198Google Scholar
  105. 106.
    Djurhuus R, Lillehaug JR (1982) Bull Environ Contam Toxicol 29:115–120Google Scholar
  106. 107.
    Fukushima S, Sakata T, Tagawa Y, Shibata MA, Hirose M, Ito N (1987a) Cancer Res 47:2113–2115Google Scholar
  107. 108.
    Shirai T, Fukushima S, Ohshima M, Masuda A, Ito N (1984) JNCI 72:1189–1198Google Scholar
  108. 109.
    Imaida K, Fukushima S, Shirai T, Masui T, Ogiso T, Ito N (1983) Gann 75:769–775Google Scholar
  109. 110.
    Shirai T, Ikawa E, Hirose M, Thamayit W, Ito N (1985) Carcinogenesis 6:637–639Google Scholar
  110. 111.
    Lindenschmidt RC, Tryka AF, Witschi H (1987) Fundam Appl Toxicol 8:474–481Google Scholar
  111. 112.
    Weisburger EK, Evarts RP, Wenk ML (1977) Food Cosmet Toxicol 15:139–142Google Scholar
  112. 113.
    Lindenschmidt RC, Tryka AF, Goad ME, Witschi HP (1986) Toxicology 38:151–160Google Scholar
  113. 114.
    Funato T, Yokota J, Sakamoto H, Kameya T, Fukushima S, Ito N, Terada M, Sugimura T (1987) Jpn J Cancer Res (Gann) 78:689–694Google Scholar
  114. 115.
    Imaida K, Fukushima S, Inoue K, Masui T, Hirose M, Ito N (1988) Cancer Lett 43:167–172Google Scholar
  115. 116.
    Peraino C, Fry RJM, Staffeldt E, Christopher JP (1977) Food Cosmet Toxicol 15:93–96Google Scholar
  116. 117.
    Maeura Y, Williams GM (1986) Food Chem Toxicol 22:191–198Google Scholar
  117. 118.
    Thornton M, Moore MA, Ito N (1989) Carcinogenesis 10:407–410Google Scholar
  118. 119.
    Sakata T, Shirai T, Fukushima S, Hasegawa R, Ito N (1984) Gann 75:950–956Google Scholar
  119. 120.
    Fukushima S, Ogiso T, Kurata Y, Hirose M, Ito N (1987b) Cancer Lett 34:83–90Google Scholar
  120. 121.
    Maeura Y, Weisburger JH, Williams GM (1984) Cancer Res 44:1604–1610Google Scholar
  121. 122.
    Imaida K, Fukushima S, Shirai T, Ohtani M, Nakanishi K, Ito N (1983) Carcinogenesis 4:895–899Google Scholar
  122. 123.
    Thamavit W, Fukushima S, Kurata Y, Asamoto M, Ito N (1989) Cancer Lett 45:93–101Google Scholar
  123. 124.
    Chung FL, Wang M, Carmella SG, Hecht SS (1986) Cancer Res 46:165–168Google Scholar
  124. 125.
    Witschi HP, Morse CC (1983) JNCI 71:859–865Google Scholar
  125. 126.
    Witschi HP, Lock S (1978) Toxicology 9:137–146Google Scholar
  126. 127.
    Witschi HP, Kehrer JP (1982) J Am Coll Toxicol 1:171–184Google Scholar
  127. 128.
    Wattenberg LW (1985) Cancer Res 45:1–8Google Scholar
  128. 129.
    Kahl R (1986) J Environ Sci Health C4:47–92Google Scholar
  129. 130.
    McCormick DL, Major N, Moon RC (1984) Cancer Res 44:2858–2863Google Scholar
  130. 131.
    Cohen LA, Polansky M, Furuya K, Reddy M, Berke B, Weisburger JH (1984) JNCI 72:165–173Google Scholar
  131. 132.
    Toth B, Patil K (1983) JNCI 70:1107–1111Google Scholar
  132. 133.
    Cook MG, McNamara P (1980) Cancer Res 40:1329–1331Google Scholar
  133. 134.
    Roed-Petersen J, Hjorth N (1976) Br J Dermatol 94:233–241Google Scholar
  134. 135.
    Bentley-Phillips B, Bayles MAH (1974) Arch Dermatol 109:216–217Google Scholar
  135. 136.
    Shlian DM, Goldstone J (1986) N Engl J Med 314:648–649Google Scholar
  136. 137.
    Grogan WA (1986) West J Med 145:245–246Google Scholar
  137. 138.
    Fisherman EW, Cohen G (1973) Ann Allerg 31:126–133Google Scholar
  138. 139.
    Cloninger P, Novey HS (1974) Ann Allerg 32:131–133Google Scholar
  139. 140.
    Verhagen H, Maas LM, Beckers RHG, Thijssen HHW, Hoor F ten, Henderson PT, Kleinjans JCS (1989) Hum Toxicol: 451–459Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag 1993

Authors and Affiliations

  • Regine Kahl
    • 1
  • Hermann Kappus
    • 2
  1. 1.Abteilung für PharmakologieUniversität HamburgHamburg 20Deutschland
  2. 2.Hautklinik, Universitäts-Klinikum Rudolf VirchowFreie Universität BerlinBerlin 65Deutschland

Personalised recommendations