The uncertainty of certainty in clinical ethics
Physicians accept fallibility in technical matters as a condition of medical practice. When it comes to moral considerations, physicians are often loathe to act without a good deal more certitude and seem less willing to accept error. This article argues that ethics is intrinsic to medical decision making, that error is the inevitable risk of any action and that inaction (clearly action by default) carries even greater risk of error. Whether in the moral or the technical sphere, error must be accepted by physicians as part of the learning process which informs and enriches future decisions. Moral virtue, it is concluded, resides more in the making of a decision and in the agony of making it than it does in the potentially fallible decision itself.
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- 1.Dewey, J.Logic, the Theory of Inquiry. New York, Henry Holt, 1938.Google Scholar
- 5.Elstein, A.S., Shulman, L.S., Sprofka, S.A.Medical Problem Solving: An Analysis of Clinical Reasoning. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1978.Google Scholar
- 6.Gorovitz, S.A., Macintyre, A. “Towards a Theory of Medical Fallibility.”J. Med. & Phil., 1(1): 51–71, 1976.Google Scholar
- 7.Fox, R.C. “The Evolution of Medical Uncertainty.”Millbank Memorial Fund Quarterly, 58(1): 1–49, 1980.Google Scholar
- 8.Pellegrino, E.D. “Toward a Reconstruction of Medical Morality: The Act of Profession and the Fact of Illness.”J. Med. & Phil., 4(1): 32–55, 1979.Google Scholar
- 9.Loewy, E.H. “Teaching Ethics to Medical Students During the Internal Medicine Clerkship.”J. Med. Educ. (In Publication, 1986).Google Scholar
- 10.Churchill, L.R. “Bioethical Reductionism and Our Sense of the Human.”Man & Med., 5(4): 229–249, 1980.Google Scholar
- 12.Higashi, K. et al. “Five Year Follow-Up Study of Patients with Persistent Vegetative State.”J. Neuro. Neurosurg. & Psych, 44: 552–554, 1981.Google Scholar
- 13.Rosenberg, G.A., Johnson, S.F., Brenner, R.P. “Recovery of Cognition After Prolonged Vegetative State.”Ann. Neuro, 2: 167–168, 1977.Google Scholar
- 14.Wouk, H.The Caine Mutiny. New York: Mentor Books, 1975.Google Scholar
- 15.Loewy, E.H. “Physicians and Patients: Moral Agency in a Pluralist World.”Journal of Medical Humanities & Bioethics, Vol. 7, No. 1, Spring/Summer 1986.Google Scholar