Social Indicators Research

, Volume 32, Issue 2, pp 101–160 | Cite as

Is happiness a trait?

Tests of the theory that a better society does not make people any happier
  • Ruut Veenhoven
Article

Abstract

One of the ideological foundations of the modern welfare states is the belief that people can be made happier by providing them with better living conditions. This belief is challenged by the theory that happiness is a fixed ‘trait’, rather than a variable ‘state’. This theory figures both at the individual level and at the societal level. The individual level variant depicts happiness as an aspect of personal character; rooted in inborn temperament or acquired disposition. The societal variant sees happiness as a matter of national character; embedded in shared values and beliefs. Both variants imply that a better society makes no happier people.

Happiness can be regarded as a trait if it meets three criteria: (1) temporal stability, (2) cross-situational consistency, and (3) inner causation. This paper checks whether that is, indeed, the case.

The theory that happiness is a personal-character-trait is tested in a (meta) analysis of longitudinal studies. The results are: (1) Happiness is quite stable on the short term, but not in the long run, neither relatively nor absoloutely. (2) Happiness is not insensitive to fortune or adversity. (3) Happiness is not entirely built-in: its genetic basis is at best modest and psychological factors explain only part of its variance.

The theory that happiness is a national-character-trait is tested in an analysis of differences in average happiness between nations. The results point in the same direction: (1) Though generally fairly stable over the last decades, nation-happiness has changed profoundly in some cases, both absolutely and relatively. (2) Average happiness in nations is clearly not independant of living conditions. The better the conditions in a country, the happier its citizens. (3) The differences cannot be explained by a collective outlook on life.

It is concluded that happiness is no immutable trait. There is thus still sense in striving for greater happiness for a greater number.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Adams, R. G.: 1988, ‘Which comes first: poor psychological well-being or decreased friendship activity?’ Activities, Adaptation and Aging 12, pp. 27–41.Google Scholar
  2. Andrews, F. M. and Withey, S. B.: 1976, Social indicators of Well-Being (Plenum Press, New York).Google Scholar
  3. Bahr, H. M. and Harvey, C. D.: 1980, ‘Correlates of Morale among the newly widowed’, Journal of Psychology 110, pp. 219–233.Google Scholar
  4. Block, J.: 1971, Lives Through Time (Bancroft, Berkely, California), pp. 293–307.Google Scholar
  5. Brachtel, W. and Zapf, W.: 1984, ‘Stabilität und Wandel individueller Wohlfahrt: Panel Ergebnisse’, in: Glatzer, W. and Zapf, W. (eds), Lebensqualität in der Bundesrepublik’ Campus (Frankfurt/Main), pp. 323–342.Google Scholar
  6. Bradburn, N. M.: 1969, The Structure of Psychological Well-Being (Aldine, Chicago).Google Scholar
  7. Brickman, P. Coates, D. and Janoff-Bullman, R.: 1978, ‘Lottery winners and accident victims: Is happiness relative?’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 36, pp. 917–927.Google Scholar
  8. Brim, O. G. jr.: 1970, ‘Personalty development as role-learning’, in: Scott, W. R. (ed), Social Process and Social Structure (Holt, New York), pp. 158–169.Google Scholar
  9. Buchanan, W. and Cantril, H.: 1953, How Nations See Each Other. A Study in Public Opinion (University of Illinois Press, Urbana, USA).Google Scholar
  10. Buss, A. H. and Plomin, R.: 1975, A Temperament Theory of Personality Development (Wiley, New York).Google Scholar
  11. Cameron, P.et al.: 1973, ‘The life satisfaction of non-normal persons’, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 41, pp. 207–214.Google Scholar
  12. Cantril, H.: 1965, The Pattern of Human Concern (Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ).Google Scholar
  13. Chamberlain, K. and Zika, S.: 1972, ‘Stability and Change, in subjective well-being over short time periods’, Social Indicator Research 26, pp. 101–117.Google Scholar
  14. Chaplin, W. T. John O. P. and Goldberg L. R.: 1988, ‘Conceptions of states and traits’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 54, pp. 541–557.Google Scholar
  15. Chin Hon Foei, S.: 1989, ‘Life-satisfaction in the EC countries 1975–1984’, in: Veenhoven, R. (ed), Did the Crisis Really Hurt? Effects of the 1980–1982 Economic Recession on Satisfaction, Mental Health and Mortality (Universitaire Pers Rotterdam, Den Haag).Google Scholar
  16. Chiriboga, D. A.: 1982, ‘Concistency in adult functioning: the influence of social stress’, Aging and Society 2, pp. 7–29.Google Scholar
  17. Chiriboga, D. A.: 1984, ‘Social stressors as antecedents of change’, Journal of Gerontology 39, pp. 468–477.Google Scholar
  18. Chiriboga, D. A.: 1989, ‘Stress and loss in middle age’, in: Kalish, R. E. (ed), Midlife Loss: Coping Strategies (Sage, London).Google Scholar
  19. Costa, P. T.et al.: 1987, ‘Longitudinal analysis of psychological well-being in national sample: stability of mean levels’, Journal of Gerontology 42, pp. 50–55.Google Scholar
  20. Costa, P. T., McCrae, R. R. and Norris, A. H.: 1981, ‘Personal Adjustment to aging: longitudinal prediction from neuroticism and extraversion’, Journal of Gerontology 36, pp. 78–85.Google Scholar
  21. Costa, P. T. and McCrae, R. R.: 1984, ‘Concurrent validation after 20 years: the implications of personality stability for its assessment’, in: Butcher, J. N. and Spielberger, C. D. (eds), Advances in Personality Assessment (Erlbaum, Hillsdale, New York), pp. 31–54.Google Scholar
  22. Costa, P. T. and McCrae, R. R.: 1988, ‘Personality in adulthood’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 54, pp. 853–863.Google Scholar
  23. Costa, P. T., McCrae, R. R. and Zonderman, A. B.: 1987, ‘Environmental and dispositional influences on well-being longitudinal follow-up of an American national sample’, British Journal of Psychology 78, pp. 299–306.Google Scholar
  24. Dam van, M. Puyenbroek van, R. and Verschuren, P.: 1989, ‘De centrum-periferie theorie, Intra — versus internationale determinanten van inkomensongelijkheid’, Mens en Maatschappij 2, pp. 5–21.Google Scholar
  25. Davis, J. A.: 1984, ‘New money, an old man, lady and two's company: Subjective welfare in the NORC general Social Surveys 1972–1982’, Social Indicators Research 15, pp. 319–356.Google Scholar
  26. DeFrain, J. D. and Ernst, L.: 1978, ‘The psychological effect of sudden infant death syndrome on surviving family members’, Journal of Family Practice 6, pp. 985–989.Google Scholar
  27. Diener, E., Larsen, R. J. and Emmons, R. A.: 1984, ‘Bias in mood recall in happy and unhappy persons’, Paper (American Psychological Association, Toronto).Google Scholar
  28. Dobson, C.: 1985, ‘Attitudes and Perceptions’, in: Powers, E. A., Goudy, W. J. and Keith, P. M. (eds), Late Life Transitions (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht), pp. 123–136.Google Scholar
  29. Easterlin, R. A.: 1974, ‘Does economic growth improve the human lot? Some empirical evidence’, in: David P. A. and Melvin, W. R. (eds), Nations and Households in Economic Growth (Stanford University Press, Palo Alto, California, USA).Google Scholar
  30. Eels, L. W.: 1985, The Effect of Role Change on Psysical Health, Mental Health and General Life-Satisfaction: A Panel Analysis [Dissertation] (University of Nebraska, Michigan).Google Scholar
  31. Estes, R. J.: 1984, The Social Progress of Nations (Praeger, New York).Google Scholar
  32. Feather, N. T. and O'Brien, G. E.: 1986, ‘A longitudinal study of the effects of employment on schoolleavers’, Journal of Occupational Psychology 59, pp. 121–144.Google Scholar
  33. Friedrich, W. N. and Friedrich, W. L.: 1981, ‘Psychological assets of parents of handicapped and non-handicapped children’, American Journal of Mental Deficiency 85, pp. 551–553.Google Scholar
  34. Gallup, G. H. and Kettering, C. F.: 1976, Human Needs and Satisfactions a Global Survey [Research Report] (C.F. Kettering Foundation and Gallup International Research Institutes).Google Scholar
  35. George, V. and Lawson, R.: 1980, Poverty and Inequality in Common Market Countries (London: Routlegde and Kegan Paul, London).Google Scholar
  36. Gergen, K. J.: 1972, ‘Multiple identity: the happy healthy human being wears many masks’, Psychology Today.Google Scholar
  37. Glenn, N. D.: 1975, ‘The contribution of marriage to the psychological well-being of males and females’, Journal of Marriage and the Family 37, pp. 594–601.Google Scholar
  38. Halman, L.: 1991, Waarden in de Westerse Wereld (Tilburg University Press, Tilburg).Google Scholar
  39. Halman, L., Heunks, F., Moor, R. de and Zanders, H.: 1987, Traditie, Secularisatie en Individualisering (Tilburg University Press, Tilburg).Google Scholar
  40. Harding, S.: 1985, ‘Values and the nature of psychological well-being’, in: Abrams, M. Gerard, D. and Timms, N. (eds), Values and Social Change in Britain (McMillan, London).Google Scholar
  41. Harley, J. and Lavery, J. J.: 1991, ‘The stability and sensitivity of subjective well-being measures’. Social Indicators Research 24, pp. 113–122.Google Scholar
  42. Heady, B. and Veenhoven, R.: 1989, ‘Does happiness induce a rosy outlook?’, in: Veenhoven, R. (ed), How Harmful Is Happiness? (Universitaire Pers Rotterdam, The Netherlands).Google Scholar
  43. Heady, B. and Wearing, A.: 1989, ‘Personality: Life-events and subjective well-being: towards a dynamic equilibrium model’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 57, pp. 731–734.Google Scholar
  44. Heady B. and Wearing, A.: 1992, Understanding Happiness: A Theory of Subjective Well-Being (Longman Cheshire, Sydney, Australia).Google Scholar
  45. Hornstra, R. K. and Klassen, D.: 1977, ‘The course of depression’, Comprehensive Psychiatry 18, pp. 119–125.Google Scholar
  46. IMF: 1987, Government Finance Statistics Yearbook, vol. XI (Washington).Google Scholar
  47. Inglehart, R.: 1977, The Silent Revolution (Princeton University Press, New Yersey, USA).Google Scholar
  48. Inglehart, R.: 1990, Culture Shift in Advanced Industrial Society (Princeton University Press, New Yersey, USA).Google Scholar
  49. Inkeles, A.: 1960, ‘Industrial man: the relation of status of experience perception, and value’, American Journal of Sociology 66, pp. 1–31.Google Scholar
  50. Inkeles, A.: 1990/91, ‘National character revisited’, The Tocqueville Review 12, pp. 83–117.Google Scholar
  51. Kirchler, E.: 1985, ‘Jobloss and mood’, Journal of Economic Psychology 6, pp. 9–25.Google Scholar
  52. Kozma, A.et al.: 1990, ‘Long- and short-term affective states in happiness’, Social Indicators Research 22, pp. 119–138.Google Scholar
  53. Kuhlen, R. G.: 1948, ‘Age trends in adjustment during the adult years as reflected in happiness ratings’, American Psychologist 3, p. 307.Google Scholar
  54. Kurian, G. T.: 1979, The Book of World Rankings (McMillam Reference Books, London).Google Scholar
  55. Landua, D.: 1992, ‘Satisfaction changes’, Social Indicators Research 26, pp. 221–241.Google Scholar
  56. Lieberman, L. R.: 1970, ‘Life satisfaction in the young and the old’, Psychological Reports 27, pp. 75–79.Google Scholar
  57. Matlin, M. W. and Gawron, V. J.: 1979, ‘Individual differences in Polyannaisn’, Journal of Personality Assesment 43, pp. 411–412.Google Scholar
  58. McCrae, R. R.: 1984, ‘Personality as a lifelong determinant of well-being’, in: Malatesta, C. Z. and Izard, C. E. (eds), Emotioning Adult Development (Sage, Beverly Hills, California), pp. 143–153.Google Scholar
  59. McCrae, R. R. and Costa, P. T.: 1990, ‘Adding Liebe und Arbeit: the full five-factor model and well-being’, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 17, pp. 227–232.Google Scholar
  60. McKinley Runyan, W.: 1979, ‘Perceived determinants of highs and lows in life-satisfaction’, Developmental Psychology 15, pp. 331–333.Google Scholar
  61. McNeil, J. K. Stones, M. J. and Kozma, A.: 1986, ‘Subjective well-being in late life; issues concerning measurement and prediction’, Social Indicators Research 18, pp. 35–70.Google Scholar
  62. Meneghan, E. G. and Lieberman, M. A.: 1986, ‘Changes in depression following divorces: a panel study’, Journal of Marriage and the Family 48, pp. 319–328.Google Scholar
  63. Michalos, A.: 1991, ‘Global Report on Student Well-Being’, Vol. I, ‘Life satisfaction and Happiness’ (Springer Verlag, New York).Google Scholar
  64. Mohr, H. M.: 1986, Subjektives Wohlbefinden (Subjective well-being) [Paper] Presented at the Conference of the German Sociological Association, Hamburg.Google Scholar
  65. Moller, V.: 1988, ‘The relevance of personal domain satisfaction’, South-Africa Tydskrif Sielkunde (S-Afr. Journal of Psychiatry), p. 74.Google Scholar
  66. Mortimer, J. T. and Lorence, J.: 1981, ‘Self-concept Stability and change from late adolescence to early adulthood’, Research in Community and Mental Health 2, pp. 5–42.Google Scholar
  67. Mussen, P., Honzik and Eichorn: 1982, ‘Early adult antecedents of life satisfaction at age 70’, Journal of Gerontology 37, pp. 316–322.Google Scholar
  68. Mussen, P. Eichhorn, D. H. Honzik, M. P. Biebe, S. L. and Meredith, W.: 1980, ‘Continuity and change in women's characteristics over four decades’, International Journal of Behavioral Development 3, pp. 331–347.Google Scholar
  69. Moum, T.: 1988, Yeah saying and mood-of-the-day effects in self reported quality of life, Social Indicators Research 20, pp. 117–139.Google Scholar
  70. Naroll, R.: 1982, The Moral Order (London, Sage).Google Scholar
  71. Neugarten, B. L. Hovinghurst, R. J. and Tobin, S. S.: 1961, ‘The measurement of life-satisfaction’, Journal of Gerontology 16, pp. 134–143.Google Scholar
  72. Ormel, J.: 1980, Moeite met Leven of een Moeilijk Leven (Difficulty with Living or a Difficult Life) (Konstapel, Groningen, Holland).Google Scholar
  73. Ostroot, N. and Snyder, W.: 1985, ‘Measuring cultural bias in a cross-national study’, Social Indicators Research 17, pp. 243–251.Google Scholar
  74. Ouweneel, P. and Veenhoven, R.: 1991, ‘Cross national differences in happiness: Cultural bias or societal quality’, in: Bleichrodt, N. and Drenth, P. J. (eds), Contemporary Issues in Cross Cultural Psychology (Swets and Zeitlinger, Amsterdam/Lisse, The Netherlands), pp. 168–184.Google Scholar
  75. Palmore, E. and Kivett, V.: 1977, ‘Change in life-satisfaction: a longitudinal study of persons aged 46–70’, Journal of Gerontology 32, pp. 311–316.Google Scholar
  76. Prime Minister Office: 1987, Public Opinion Survey on the Life of the Nation (Foreign press Center, Tokyo, Japan).Google Scholar
  77. Rosenberg, M.: 1962, ‘The dissonant religious context and emotional disturbance’, American Journal of Sociology 68, pp. 1–10.Google Scholar
  78. Schaefer, E. S. and Bayley, N.: 1963, ‘Maternal behavior, child behavior, and their intercorrelations’, Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 28(3).Google Scholar
  79. Schulz, B. and Decker, S.: 1985, ‘Long term adjustment to physical disability’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 48, pp. 1162–72.Google Scholar
  80. Simmons, R. G., Klein, S. D. and Simmons, R. C.: 1977, Gift of Life (Wiley, London).Google Scholar
  81. Simmons, R. G. and Blyth, D. A.: 1987, Moving into Adolescence (Aldine de Gruyter, New York).Google Scholar
  82. Stacey, A. and Gatz, M.: 1991, ‘Cross-sectional agedifferences and longitudinal change on the Bradburn Affect Balance Scale’, Journal of Gerontology 46, pp. 76–78.Google Scholar
  83. Stones, M. J. and Kozma, A.: 1989, ‘Happiness and activities in late life: a propensity formulation’, Canadian Psychology 30, pp. 526, 537.Google Scholar
  84. Stones, M. J., Kozma, A. Hannak, I. E. and Mc Kim, W. A.: 1991, ‘The correlation coefficient and models of Subjective Well-Being’, Social Indicators Research 24, pp. 317–327.Google Scholar
  85. Summers, R. and Heston, A.: 1988, ‘A new set of international comparisons of real product and price level estimates for 130 countries, 1950–1985’, National Income and Wealth 34, pp. 1–25.Google Scholar
  86. Tellegen, A.et al.: 1988, ‘Personality similarity in twins reared apart and together’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 54, pp. 1031–1037.Google Scholar
  87. Tuddenham, R. D.: 1959, ‘Constancy of personality ratings over two decades’, Genetic Psychology Monographs 60, pp. 3–29.Google Scholar
  88. Tuddenham, R. D.: 1962, ‘Constancy of personal morale over a fifteen year interval’: Child Devellopment 33, pp. 663–673.Google Scholar
  89. United Nations: 1986, 1983/84 Statistical Yearbook (United Nations, New York).Google Scholar
  90. Veenhoven, R.: 1984, Conditions of Happiness (Reidel, Dordrecht, Holland).Google Scholar
  91. Veenhoven, R.: 1987, ‘Cultural Bias in ratings of perceived life quality: a comment on Ostroot and Snyder’, Social Indicators Research 19, pp. 329–334.Google Scholar
  92. Veenhoven, R.: 1988, ‘The utility of happiness’, Social Indicators Research 20, pp. 33–354.Google Scholar
  93. Veenhoven, R. (ed.): 1989, ‘Did the crisis really hurt? Effects of the 1980–82 economic recession on satisfaction, mental health and mortality’, (Universitaire Pers Rotterdam, Rotterdam,)Google Scholar
  94. Veenhoven, R. (ed.): 1989, How Harmfull is Happiness?: Consequences of Enjoying Life or Not (Universitaire Pers Rotterdam, Rotterdam).Google Scholar
  95. Veenhoven, R.: 1991, ‘Is happiness relative?’, Social Indicators Research 24, pp. 1–34.Google Scholar
  96. Veenhoven, R.: 1991, ‘Questions on happiness, classical topics, modern answers, blind spots’, in: Strack, F., Argyle, M. and Schwarz, N. (eds), Subjective Well-Being: In Interdisciplinary Perspective (London), pp. 7–26.Google Scholar
  97. Veenhoven, R.: 1992, World Database of Happiness. Ongoing catalogue of research on subjective appreciation of life. Catalogue of correlates. Printout September 1992 (Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands). Electronically published on ftp.eur.nl (pub\database.happiness\correlat).Google Scholar
  98. Veenhoven, R.: 1993, Happiness in Nations (RISBO, Rotterdam). Electronically published on ftp.eur.nl (pub\database.happiness\nations).Google Scholar
  99. Verkley, H. and Stolk, J.: 1989, ‘Does happiness lead into idleness?’, in: Veenhoven (ed), How Harmful is Happiness (Univ. Pers Rotterdam, Holland), pp. 79–93.Google Scholar
  100. Verkuyten, M.: 1986, ‘Opgroeien in den vreemde’, Gezondheid en Samenleving 7, pp. 1–6.Google Scholar
  101. Verkuyten, M. and Veenhoven, R.: 1988, ‘Welbevinden van kinderen na echtscheding: een onderzoek onder adolescenten’ (‘Wellbeing of children after divorce: a study of adolescents’), Tijdschrift voor Sociale Gezondheidszorg 66, pp. 128–133.Google Scholar
  102. Waltz, M.: 1986, ‘A longitudinal study on environment and dispositional determinants of life quality: social support and coping with physical illness’, Social Indicators Research 18, pp. 71–93.Google Scholar
  103. Wierzbicki, M.: 1986, ‘Similarity of monozygotic and dizigotic twins in level and lability of subclinically depresses mood’, Journal of Clinical Psychology 42, 577–585.Google Scholar
  104. Yardley, J. K. and Rice, R. W.: 1991, ‘The relationship between mood and subjective well-being’, Social Indicators Research 24, pp. 101–111.Google Scholar
  105. Yeo, G. Ingram, L. Skunnic, J. and Crapo, L.: 1987, ‘Effects of a geriatric clinic on functional health and well-being of elders’, Journal of Gerontology 42, pp. 252–258.Google Scholar
  106. Young, P. T.: 1937, ‘Is cheerfullness-depression a general temperamental trait?: A study of moods in college students’, Psychological Review 44, pp. 313–319.Google Scholar
  107. Zapf, W. and Brachtel, W.: 1984, ‘Gastarbeiter und Deutsche Bevolkerung’, in: Glatzer, W. and Zapf, W. (eds), Lebensqualität in der Bundesrepublik (Campus, Frankfurt/Main), pp. 286–306.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1994

Authors and Affiliations

  • Ruut Veenhoven
    • 1
  1. 1.Erasmus University of RotterdamRotterdamThe Netherlands

Personalised recommendations