Virchows Archiv A

, Volume 368, Issue 3, pp 229–241

An introduction to diagnostic criteria of syphilis, treponarid and Yaws (treponematoses) in dry bones, and some implications

  • C. J. Hackett
Article

Summary

Diagnostic criteria of syphilis and some other diseases are proposed from a study of 424 crania and calvariae and 250 long bones in 22 medical museums in Europe. Yaws bone lesions in Uganda and changes in Australian aboriginal bones also contributed to the establishment of these criteria. Any deductions about disease in the past or isolated populations must depend upon acceptable diagnostic criteria; post mortem damage must be recognised. In crania and calvariae the sequence of changes of Virchow's caries sicca, and in long bones nodes/expansions with superficial cavitation are sound indicators of syphilis, and of yaws and treponarid in relevant geographical areas.

Attention is called to the cause of sequestra in European calvariae labelled syphilis, the absence of sequestra due to haematogenous pyogenic osteomyelitis in Australian and other aboriginal bones and possibly in Europe before the Middle Ages. The number of bones with diagnostic criteria needed to demonstrate the endemicity of a particular infection in a past community is discussed. There is also need for an extensive application of diagnostic criteria of syphilis to pre-Columbian or pre-European bones everywhere. The uncertain future of old dry diseased bones in medical museums, and the need for reference centres to provide sound advice and guidance in palaeopathology are stressed.

Key words

Diagnostic criteria Syphilis Dry bones 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Andersen, J. G.: Studies in the mediaeval diagnosis of leprosy in Denmark, Copenhagen: Costers Bogtrykkeri 1969Google Scholar
  2. Beitzke, J.: Erworbene Syphilis der Knochen. In: Handb. Spez. path. Anat. Hist. (Hrsg. Lubarsch, O., Henke, F., Rössle, R.), Bd. IX/2, S. 469–538. Berlin: Julius Springer 1934Google Scholar
  3. Bullin, A. K.: Paleoepidemiology and distribution of prehistoric treponemaisis [sic] (syphilis) in Florida. Fla. Anthrop. 25, 133–175 (1972)Google Scholar
  4. Burkhardt, L.: Pathologische Anatomie des Schädels in seiner Beziehung zum Inhalt spezielle Pathologie des Schädelskelets. In: Handb. Spez. path. Anat. Hist. (Hrsg. Lubarsch, O., Henke, F., Uehlinger, E.), Bd. IX/7, S. 212–234, S. 229–234, Berlin: Julius Springer 1970Google Scholar
  5. Erdheim, J.: Über Tuberkulose des Knochens im allgemeinen und die des Schädeldaches. Virchows Arch. path. Anat. 238, 368–376 (1932)Google Scholar
  6. Fribourg-Blanc, A.: Treponema. In: Pathology of Simian Primates (Feinnes, R. N. T. -W. ed.), Part II, p. 255–262. Basel: Karger 1972Google Scholar
  7. Garner, H. F., Backhouse, J. L., Moodie, P. M., Tibbs, G. J.: Treponemal infections in the Australian Northern Territory aborigines. Bull. Wld Hlth Org. 46, 285–293 (1972)Google Scholar
  8. Hackett, C. J.: Bone lesions of yaws in Uganda, Oxford: Blackwell Scientific Publications Ltd. 1951Google Scholar
  9. Hackett, C. J.: On the origin of the human treponematoses. Bull. Wld Hlth Org. 29, 7–41 (1963)Google Scholar
  10. Hackett, C. J.: Some aspects of treponematoses in past populations. J. Anthrop. Soc. S. Aust., 6, 5–14 (1968)Google Scholar
  11. Hudson, E. H.: Treponematosis in perspective. Bull. Wld Hlth Org. 32, 735–748 (1965)Google Scholar
  12. Jarcho, S.: Human Palaeopathology, 175, London: Yale University Press 1966Google Scholar
  13. Jones, J.: Exploration of the aboriginal remains of Tennessee. Smithson. Contr. to Knowl. 22, 65–73 (1876)Google Scholar
  14. Lisowski, F. P.: Prehistoric and early historic trepanation. In: Diseases in Antiquity (Brothwell, D., Sandison, A. T., eds.), p. 651–672. Springfield, Ill.: Charles C. Turner 1967Google Scholar
  15. Møller-Christensen, V.: Bone lesions in leprosy, Copenhagen: Munksgaard 1961Google Scholar
  16. Morse, D.: Ancient disease in the Mid-West USA, Reports of Investigations, No. 15. Illinois State Museum, Springfield, Ill., Plate 13A and B (1969)Google Scholar
  17. Murray, J. F., Merriweather, A. M., Friedman, M. J.: Endemic syphilis in the Bakwena Reserve of the Bechunaland Protectorate. Bull. Wld Hlth Org. 15, 975–1039 (1956)Google Scholar
  18. Ouchinnikov, N. M., Delekorskij, V. V.: Treponema pertenue under the electron microscope. Brit. J. vener. Dis. 46, 349–379 (1970)Google Scholar
  19. Pales, L.: Paléopathologie et Pathologie Comparative, 192–225, Paris: Masson et Cie 1930Google Scholar
  20. Reynolds, J.: The roentgenological features of the sickle-cell disease and related haemoglobinopathies, Springfield, Ill.: Charles, C. Turner 1965Google Scholar
  21. Rost, W.: Roentgen manifestations of Bejel (“Endemic syphilis”) as observed in the Euphrates River valley. Radiology 38, 320–325 (1942)Google Scholar
  22. Sandison, A. T.: Disease changes in Australian skeletons. Newsletter 3, 20–22, Canberra: Australian Institute of Aboriginal Study 1973Google Scholar
  23. Satinoff, M. T.: The origins and geographical spread of the thalassaemias and abnormal haemoglobins. J. Human Evolution 1, 79–82 (1972)Google Scholar
  24. Stewart, T. D.: Some historical implications of physical anthropology in North America. In: Essays in historical anthropology in North America. Smithson. Misc. Colins. 100, 15–50 (1940)Google Scholar
  25. Stewart, T. D.: The People of America, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson 1973Google Scholar
  26. Turner, T. B., Hollander, E. R.: Biology of the Treponematoses. Geneva, World Health Organization, Monograph Series No. 35, 1957Google Scholar
  27. Virchow, R. L. K.: Beitrag zur Geschichte der Lues. Derm. Z. 3, 1–9 (1896)Google Scholar
  28. Wells, C.: Bones, bodies and disease, 100–105, London: Thames & Hudson, 1964Google Scholar
  29. Wells, C.: Pseudopathology. In: Diseases in Antiquity (Brothwell, D., Sandison, A. T., eds.), p. 5–19, Springfield, Ill.: Charles C. Turner, 1967Google Scholar
  30. Wells, C.: The palaeopathology of bone disease. Practitioner, 210, 384–391 (1973)Google Scholar
  31. Williams, H. U.: The origin and antiquity of syphilis; the evidence from diseased bones. A review with some new material from America. Archs. Path. 13, 779–814, 931–983 (1932)Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag 1975

Authors and Affiliations

  • C. J. Hackett
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Morbid AnatomyInstitute of OrthopaediesLondon

Personalised recommendations