Springer Nature is making Coronavirus research free. View research | View latest news | Sign up for updates

Methodological bases of a progressive mentalism

  • 97 Accesses

  • 23 Citations

This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.


  1. Achinstein, Peter, and Stephen F. Barker (eds.): 1969, The legacy of logical positivism, The Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore.

  2. Anderson, Stephen, and Paul Kiparsky (eds.): 1973, A Festschrift for Morris Halle, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.

  3. Austerlitz, Robert (ed.): 1975, The scope of American linguistics (= Papers of The First Golden Anniversary Symposium of the Linguistic Society of America, Held at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst, on July 24 and 25, 1974), The Peter de Ridder Press, Lisse.

  4. Bach, Emmon, and Robert T. Harms (eds.): 1968, Universals in linguistic theory, Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Inc., New York, etc.

  5. Bahcall, John N. and Raymond Davis, Jr.: 1976, ‘Solar neutrinos: a scientific puzzle’, Science 191, 264–267.

  6. Bar-Hillel, Yehoshua: 1964, ‘Neorealism vs. neopositivism: A neo-pseudo issue’, Proceedings of the Israeli Academy of Science and Humanities, Vol. II, No. 3, 29–37.

  7. Bar-Hillel, Yehoshua: 1966, ‘On a misapprehension of the status of the status of theories in linguistics’, Foundations of Language 2, 394–399.

  8. Bartley, W.: 1968, ‘Theories of demarcation between science and metaphysics’, in Lakatos and Musgrave (eds.), pp. 46–64.

  9. Bever, Thomas G.: 1974, ‘The ascent of the specious or there's a lot we don't know about mirrors’ in Cohen (ed.), pp. 173–200.

  10. Bever, Thomas G., Jerrold J. Katz and D. Terence Langendoen: 1977, Introduction to Bever, Katz and Langendoen (eds.), pp. 1–9.

  11. Bever, Thomas G., Jerrold J. Katz and D. Terence Langendoen (eds.): 1977, An integrated theory of linguistic ability, The Harvester Press, Hassocks, Sussex.

  12. Botha, Rudolf P.: 1968, The function of the lexicon in transformational generative grammar (= Janua Linguarum, Series Maior, No. 38), Mouton Publishing Company, The Hague and Paris.

  13. Botha, Rudolf P.: Methodological aspects of transformational generative phonology (= Janua Linguarum, Series Minor, No. 112), Mouton Publishing Company, The Hague and Paris.

  14. Botha, Rudolf P.: 1973, The justification of linguistic hypotheses. A study of non-demonstrative inference in transformational grammar. (= Janua Linguarum, Series Maior, No. 84), Mouton Publishing Company, The Hague and Paris.

  15. Botha, Rudolf P.: On the logic of linguistic research (= Utrecht Working Papers in Linguistics, No. 2), RUU Instituut voor Algemene Taalwetenschap, Utrecht.

  16. Botha, Rudolf P.: 1978a, On the method of mentalism: I. Professor Chomsky's thermonuclear analogy, mimeographed.

  17. Botha, Rudolf P.: 1978b, On the method of mentalism: II. Professor Chomsky's position on the status of external evidence, mimeographed.

  18. Botha, Rudolf P.: 1978c, On the method of mentalism: III. The bases of a progressive mentalism, mimeographed.

  19. Botha, Rudolf P.: 1978d, ‘Protecting general-linguistic hypotheses from refutation’, Stellenbosch Papers in Linguistics, 1, 1–38.

  20. Botha, Rudolf P.: 1979, ‘External evidence in the validation of mentalistic theories: A Chomskyan paradox’, Stellenbosch Papers in Linguistics 2, 1–38. (Published in Lingua 48, 299–328 as well.)

  21. Botha, Rudolf P.: to appear, The conduct of linguistic inquiry: A systematic introduction to the methodology of generative grammar (= Janua Linguarum, Series Practica). Mouton Publishers, The Hague, Paris, New York.

  22. Bresnan, Joan: 1977, ‘Variables in the theory of transformations’, in Culicover, Wasow, and Akmajian (eds.), pp. 157–196.

  23. Bresnan, Joan: 1978, ‘A realistic transformational grammar’, in Halle et al., pp. 1–59.

  24. Buck, Roger C., and Robert S. Cohen: 1971, PSA 1970. In memory of Rudolf Carnap (= Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science, Vol. VIII), D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht.

  25. Chomsky, Noam: 1965, Aspects of the theory of syntax, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.

  26. Chomsky, Noam: 1973, ‘Conditions on transformations’, in Anderson and Kiparsky (eds.), pp. 232–286.

  27. Chomsky, Noam: 1975a, ‘Questions of form and interpretation’, in Austerlitz (ed.), pp. 159–196.

  28. Chomsky, Noam: 1975b, Reflections on language, Pantheon Books, New York.

  29. Chomsky, Noam: 1976, ‘On the biological basis of language capacities’, in Rieber (ed.), pp. 1–24.

  30. Chomsky, Noam: 1976a, ‘On the nature of language’, in Harnad, Steklis and Lancaster (eds.), pp. 46–55.

  31. Chomsky, Noam: 1977a, Essays on form and interpretation, North-Holland Publishing Company, New York, etc.

  32. Chomsky, Noam: 1977b, Introduction to Chomsky 1977a, pp. 1–21.

  33. Chomsky, Noam: 1977c, ‘Conditions on rules of grammar’, in Cole (ed.), pp. 3–50.

  34. Chomsky, Noam: 1978a, On binding, mimeographed.

  35. Chomsky, Noam: 1978b, ‘A theory of core grammar’, Glot. 1, 7–26.

  36. Chomsky, Noam, and Jerrold J. Katz: 1974, ‘What the linguist is talking about’, The Journal of Philosophy 71, 347–367.

  37. Chomsky, Noam, and Howard Lasnik: 1977, ‘Filters and control’, Linguistic Inquiry 8, 425–504.

  38. Cohen, David (ed.): 1974, Explaining linguistic phenomena, Hemisphere Publishing Corporation, Washington, D.C.

  39. Cohen, David, and Jessica R. Wirth (eds.): 1975, Testing linguistic hypotheses. Hemisphere Publishing Corporation, Washington, D.C.

  40. Cole, Roger W. (ed.): 1977, Current issues in linguistic theory, Indiana University Press, Bloomington and London.

  41. Cooper, David E.: 1975, Knowledge of language, Prism Press, London.

  42. Culicover, Peter W., Thomas Wasow, and Adrian Akmajian (eds.): 1977, Formal syntax, Academic Press, New York, etc.

  43. Derwing, Bruce L.: 1973, Transformational grammar as a theory of language acquisition. A study in the empirical, conceptual, and methodological foundations of contemporary linguistics, at the University Press, Cambridge.

  44. Derwing, Bruce L., and Peter S. Harris: 1975, ‘what is a generative grammar?’, in Koerner (ed.), pp. 297–314.

  45. Dougherty, Ray C.: 1975: The logic of linguistic research, mimeographed.

  46. Edmonds, Joseph E.: 1976, A transformational approach to English syntax. Root, structure-preserving and local transformations, Academic Press, New York, etc.

  47. Flege, James E.: 1977, ‘Psychological reality and generative phonology’, Language Sciences 48, 17–22.

  48. Fodor, J.A., T.G. Bever, and M.F. Garrett: 1974, The psychology of language. An introduction to psycholinguistics and generative grammar, McGraw Hill Book Company, New York, etc.

  49. Fodor, J.D., J.A. Fodor, and M.F. Garrett: 1975, ‘the psychological unreality of semantic representations’, Linguistic Inquiry 6, 515–532.

  50. Grobstein, Paul, and Kao Liang Chow: 1975, ‘Receptive field development and individual experience’, Science 191, 352–358.

  51. Grünbaum, Adolf: 1976a, ‘Can a theory answer more questions than one of its rivals?’, The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 27, 1–23.

  52. Grünbaum, Adolf: 1976b, Is the method of bold conjectures and attempted refutations justifiably the method of science?’, The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 27, 105–136.

  53. Grünbaum, Adolf: 1976c, ‘Ad hoc auxiliary hypotheses and falsification’, The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 27, 329–362.

  54. Grünbaum, Adolf: 1976d, ‘Is falsifiability the touchstone of scientific rationality? Karl Popper versus inductivism’, The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 27, 329–362.

  55. Halle, Morris, Joan Bresnan, and George A. Miller (eds.): 1978, Linguistic theory and psychological reality, The MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass. and London.

  56. Harnad, Stevan R., Horst D. Steklis, and Jane Lancaster (eds.): 1976, Origins and evolution of language and speech (=Annals of The New York Academy of Sciences, Vol. 280), The New York Academy of Sciences, New York.

  57. Harré, R.: 1961, Theories and things. A brief study in prescriptive metaphysics, Sheed and Ward, London and New York.

  58. Hiż, Henry: 1967, ‘Methodological aspects of the theory of syntax’, The Journal of Philosophy 64, 67–74.

  59. Hook, Sidney (ed.): 1969, Language and philosophy, New University Press, New York.

  60. Itkonen, Esa: 1976, Linguistics and empiricalness: answers to criticisms (=Publication No. 4 of the Department of General Linguistics, University of Helsinki), Helsinki.

  61. Katz, Jerrold J.: 1977, ‘The real status of semantic representations’, Linguistic Inquiry 8, 559–584.

  62. Katz, Jerrold J., and Thomas G. Bever: 1977, ‘the fall and rise of empiricism’, in Bever, Katz and Langendoen (eds.), pp. 11–64.

  63. Kiparsky, Paul: 1968a, ‘Linguistic universals and linguistic change’, in Bach and Harms (eds.), pp. 171–202.

  64. Kiparsky, Paul: 1968b, How abstract is phonology? Reproduced by the Indiana University Linguistics Club.

  65. Koerner, E.F.K. (ed.): 1975, The transformational-generative paradigm in modern linguistic theory, John Benjamins B.V., Amsterdam.

  66. Koningsveld, Herman: 1977, Het verschijnsel wetenschap. Een inleiding tot de wetenschapsfilosofie, Second impression, Boom, Meppel en Amsterdam.

  67. Labov, W.: 1972, ‘Some principles of linguistic methodology’, Language in Society 1, 97–120.

  68. Lakatos, Imre: 1971, ‘History of science and its rational reconstructions’, in Buck and Cohen (eds.), 1971, 91–136.

  69. Lakatos, Imre, and Alan Musgrave (eds.): 1968. Problems in the philosophy of science, North-Holland Publishing Company, Amsterdam.

  70. Laudan, Larry: 1977, Progress and its problems. Towards a theory of scientific growth, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London and Henley.

  71. Lenneberg, Eric H.: Biological foundations of language (with appendices by Noam Chomsky and Otto Marx), John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, etc.

  72. Levelt, W.J.M.: 1974, Formal grammars in linguistics and psycholinguistics, Vol. III, Mouton, The Hague.

  73. Lightfoot, David L.: in press, Principles of diachronic syntax, to be published by CUP (page references are to the manuscript of the first draft.)

  74. Lightfoot, David L.: to appear, Explaining syntactic change, mimeographed.

  75. Ney, J.W.: 1975, ‘The decade of private knowledge: Linguistics from the early 70's’, Historiographia Linguistica 11, 143–156.

  76. Popper, Karl R.: 1974, ‘Replies to my critics’, in Schilpp (ed.), pp. 961–1197.

  77. Postal, Paul M.: 1968, Aspects of phonological theory, Harper and Row Publishers, New York, etc.

  78. Rieber, R.W. (ed.): 1976, The neuropsychology of language. Essays in honor of Eric Lenneberg, Plenum Press, New York and London.

  79. Ringen, Jon D.: to appear a, ‘Transformational generative grammars as descriptions of idiolects’, Paper presented at the LSA Summer Meeting, Amherst, Mass., July 28, 1974, mimeographed.

  80. Ringen, Jon D.: to appear b, ‘On evaluating data concerning linguistic intuition,’ Paper presented at The Fifth Annual UWM Linguistic Symposium, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, March 28, 1976, mimeographed.

  81. Sampson, Geoffrey: 1975, The form of language, Weidenfeld, London.

  82. Schilpp, Paul Arthur (ed.): 1974, The philosophy of Karl Popper, Open Court, La Salle, Ill.

  83. Schwartz, Robert: 1969, ‘On knowing a grammar’, in Hook (ed.), pp. 183–190.

  84. Shaphere, Dudley: 1969, ‘Notes toward a post-positivistic interpretation of science’, in Achinstein and Barker (eds.), pp. 115–160.

  85. Sinclair, Melinda: 1977, The refutability of Edmonds's structure-preserving constraint, M.A. Thesis, University of Stellenbosch.

  86. Skousen, Royal: 1975, Substantive evidence in phonology. The evidence from Finnish and French, Mouton, The Hague and Paris.

  87. Steinberg, Danny D.: 1975, ‘Chomsky: from formalism to mentalism and psychological invalidity’, Glossa 9, 218–252.

  88. Stich, Stephen P.: 1972, ‘Grammar, psychology and indeterminacy’, The Journal of Philosophy 69, 799–818.

  89. Stich, Stephen P.: 1975, ‘Competence and indeterminacy’, in Cohen and Wirth (eds.), pp. 93–109.

  90. Wanner, Eric, and Michael Maratos: 1978, ‘An ATN approach to comprehension’, in Halle et al. (eds.), pp. 119–161.

Download references

Author information

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Botha, R.P. Methodological bases of a progressive mentalism. Synthese 44, 1–112 (1980).

Download citation


  • Methodological Basis