Environmental Monitoring and Assessment

, Volume 40, Issue 1, pp 11–40 | Cite as

Temporal and spatial variability in water quality of wetlands in the Minneapolis/St. Paul, MN metropolitan area: Implications for monitoring strategies and designs

  • Naomi E. Detenbeck
  • Debra L. Taylor
  • Ann Lima
  • Cynthia Hagley


Temporal and spatial variability in wetland water-quality variables were examined for twenty-one wetlands in the Minneapolis/St. Paul metropolitan area and eighteen wetlands in adjacent Wright County. Wetland water quality was significantly affected by contact with the sediment (surface water vs. groundwater), season, degree of hydrologic isolation, wetland class, and predominant land-use in the surrounding watershed (p<0.05). Between years, only nitrate and particulate nitrogen concentrations varied significantly in Wright County wetland surface waters. For eight water-quality variables, the power of a paired before-and-after comparison design was greater than the power of a completely randomized design. The reverse was true for four other water-quality variables. The power of statistical tests for different classes of water-quality variables could be ranked according to the predominant factors influencing these: climate factors>edaphic factors>detritivory>land-use factors>biotic-redox or other multiple factors.

For two wetlands sampled intensively, soluble reactive phosphate and total dissolved phosphorus were the most spatially variable (c.v.=76–249%), while temperature, color, dissolved organic carbon, and DO were least variable (c.v.=6–43%). Geostatistical analyses demonstrated that the average distance across which water-quality variables were spatially correlated (variogram range) was 61–112% of the mean radius of each wetland. Within the shallower of the two wetlands, nitrogen speciation was explained as a function of dissolved oxygen, while deeper marsh water-quality variables were explained as a function of water depth or distance from the wetland edge. Compositing water-quality samples produced unbiased estimates of individual sample means for all water quality variables examined except for ammonium.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. APHA: 1985, Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater, 16th edition, American Public Health Association, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
  2. Ayers, M. A., Brown, R. G. and Oberts, G. L.: 1985, Runoff and Chemical Loading in Small Watersheds in the Twin Cities Metropolitan Area, Minnesota, U.S.G.S. Water-Resources Investigations Report 85-4122, St. Paul, MN.Google Scholar
  3. Ayers, M. A., Payne, G. A. and Have, M. R.: 1980, Effects of Urbanization on the Water Quality of Lakes in Eagan, Minnesota, Water-Resources Investigations 80-71, U.S. Geological Survey.Google Scholar
  4. Bowden, W. B.: 1987, ‘The Biogeochemistry of Nitrogen in Freshwater Wetlands’, Biogeochemistry 4, 313–348.Google Scholar
  5. Brinson, M. M., Lugo, A. E. and Brown, S.: 1981, ‘Primary Productivity, Decomposition and Consumer Activity in Freshwater Wetlands’, Ann. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 12, 123–161.Google Scholar
  6. Brown, R. G.: 1984, Atmospheric Deposition of Selected Chemicals and their Effect on Nonpoint-Source Pollution in the Twin Cities Metropolitan Area, Minnesota, U.S.G.S. Water Resources Investigations Report 83-4195, St. Paul, MN.Google Scholar
  7. Brown, R. G.: 1985a, ‘Effects of an Urban Wetland on Sediment and Nutrient Loads in Runoff’, Wetlands 4, 147–158.Google Scholar
  8. Brown, R. G.: 1985b, Effects of Wetlands on Quality of Runoff entering Lakes in the Twin Cities Metropolitan Area, Minnesota, U.S. Geological Survey, Water-Resources Investigations Report 85-4170.Google Scholar
  9. Buffle, J., Deladoey, P., Zumstein, J. and Haerdi, W.: 1982, ‘Analysis and Characterization of Natural Organic Matters in Freshwaters. I. Study of Analytical Techniques’, Schiez. Z. Hydrol. 44(2), 325–366.Google Scholar
  10. Carter, V. and Novitzki, R. P.: 1988, ‘Some Comments on the Relation Between Ground Water and Wetlands’, pp. 68–86, Hook, D. D., McKeeJr., W. H., Smith, H. K., Greogory, J., BurrellJr., V. G., DeVoe, M. R., Sojka, R. E., Gilbert, S., Banks, R., Stolzy, L. H., Brooks, C., Matthews, T. D. and Shear, T. H., (Eds.), The Ecology and Management of Wetlands. Volume 1: Ecology of Wetlands, Timber Press, Portland, OR.Google Scholar
  11. Cook, A. H. and Powers, C. F.: 1958, ‘Early Biochemical Changes in the Soils and Waters of Artificially Created Marshes in New York’, N. Y. Fish and Game Journal 5, 9–65.Google Scholar
  12. de LaCruz, A. A., Hackney, C. T. and Bhardwaj, N.: 1989, ‘Temporal and Spatial Patterns of Redox Potential (Eh) in three Tidal Marsh communities’, Wetlands 9, 181–190.Google Scholar
  13. Detenbeck, N. E., Taylor, D. L., Lima, A.: 1992, Assessing Recovery of Freshwater Wetland Water-quality from Disturbance, Final report to U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Environmental Research Laboratory-Duluth, MN.Google Scholar
  14. Detenbeck, N. E., Johnston, C. A. and Niemi, G. J.: 1993, ‘Wetland Effects on Lake Water Quality in the Minneapolis/St. Paul Metropolitan Area’, Landscape Ecology 8(1), 39–61.Google Scholar
  15. Edwards, R. J.: 1968, Soil survey of Wright County, U.S. Soil Conservation Service, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
  16. Englund, E. and Sparks, A.: 1988, GEO-EAS (Geostatistical Environmental Assessment Software) User's Guide, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Las Vegas, NV. EPA 600/4-88/033.Google Scholar
  17. Ernst, W. H. O.: 1990, ‘Ecophysiology of Plants in Waterlogged and Flooded Environments’, Aquatic Botany 38, 73–90.Google Scholar
  18. Fetter, C. W.: 1988, Applied Hydrogeology, 2 edn, Merrill Publishing Company, 592 pp.Google Scholar
  19. Forman, R. T. T. and Godron, M.: 1986, Landscape Ecology. John Wiley & Sons, New York, pp. 216–217.Google Scholar
  20. Gehrels, J. and Mulamoottil, G.: 1989, ‘The Transformation and Export of Phosphorus from Wetlands’, Hydrological Processes 3, 365–370.Google Scholar
  21. Gilbert, R. O.: 1987, Statistical Methods for Environmental Pollution Monitoring, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York.Google Scholar
  22. Gilman, L. B.: 1988, Microwave sample preparation, CEM Corporation, Matthews, N.C., U.S.A.Google Scholar
  23. Hilton, J., Carrick, T., Rigg, K. and Lishman, J. P.: 1989, ‘Sampling Strategies for Water Quality Monitoring in Lakes: The Effect of Sampling Method’, Environmental Pollution 57, 223–234.Google Scholar
  24. Hodges, J. L. and Lehman, E. L.: 1968, ‘A Compact Table for Power of the t-Test’, The Annals of Mathematical Statistics. 39(5), 1629–1637.Google Scholar
  25. Holland, M. M., Whigham, D. F. and Gopal, B.: 1990, ‘The Characteristics of Wetland Ecotones’, pp. 171–198, in: Naiman, R. J. and Dècamps, H. (Eds.), The Ecology and Management of Aquatic-Terrestrial Ecotones, UNESCO, Paris, and the Parthenon Publishing Group.Google Scholar
  26. Hook, D. D., Murray, M. D., DeBell, D. S. and Wilson, B. C.: 1987, ‘Variation in the Growth of Red Alder Families in Relation to Shallow Water Table Levels’, Forest Sci. 33(1), 224–229.Google Scholar
  27. Hossner, L. R. and Baker, W. H.: 1988, ‘Phosphorus Transformations in Flooded Soils’, pp. 293–306, in: Hook, D. D., McKeeJr., W. H., Smith, H. K., Gregory, J., BurrellJr., V. G., DeVoe, M. R., Gilbert, S., Banks, R., Stolzy, L. H., Matthews, T. D. and Shear, T. H., (Eds.), The Ecology and Management of Wetlands. Volume 1: Ecology of Wetlands, Timber Press, Portland, OR.Google Scholar
  28. Johnston, C. A., Detenbeck, N. E. and Niemi, G. J.: 1990, ‘The Cumulative Effect of Wetlands on Stream Water Quality and Quantity: A Landscape Approach’, Biogeochemistry 10, 105–41.Google Scholar
  29. Kadlec, R. H.: 1988, ‘Monitoring Wetland Responses’, pp. 114–120, in: Zelazny, J. and Feierabend, J. S. (Eds.) Proceedings, Wetlands: Increasing our wetland resources, National Wildlife Federation, Washington, D.C., Oct. 4–7, 1987.Google Scholar
  30. Kadlec, J. A.: 1986, ‘Effects of Flooding on Dissolved and Suspended Nutrients in Small Diked Marshes’, Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 43, 1999–2008.Google Scholar
  31. Kadlec, J. A.: 1979, ‘Nitrogen and Phosphorus Dynamics in Inland Freshwater Wetlands’, pp. 17–41, in: Bookhout, T. A., (Ed.), Waterfowl and Wetlands — An Integrated Review, Proceedings of a symposium held at the 39th Midwest Fish and Wildlife Conference, Madison, WI, 5 December 1977.Google Scholar
  32. Keith, L. H. (ed.): 1988, Principles of Environmental Sampling, American Chemical Society.Google Scholar
  33. Knudsen, H. P.: 1988, A Short Course on Geostastical Ore Reserve Estimation, Division of Mining and Minerals Engineering, Montana Tech, Butte, MT.Google Scholar
  34. Latchet: 1989, QuikChem Automated Ion Analyzer Methods Manual, Latchet Instruments. Milwaukee, WI.Google Scholar
  35. Legendre, P. and Troussellier, M.: 1988, ‘Aquatic Heterotrophic Bacteria: Modelling in the Presence of Spatial Autocorrelation’, Limnol. Oceanogr. 33, 1055–1067.Google Scholar
  36. Magnuson, J. J., Benson, B. J. and Kratz, T. K.: 1990, ‘Temporal Coherence in the Limnology of a Suite of Lakes in Wisconsin, U.S.A.’, Freshwater Biology. 23, 145–159.Google Scholar
  37. Mantel, N.: 1967, ‘The Detection of Disease Clustering and a Generalized Regression Approach’, Cancer Res. 27, 209–220.Google Scholar
  38. Millard, S. P., Yeasley, J. R. and Lettenmaier, D. P.: 1985, ‘Space-Time Correlation and its Effects on Methods for Detecting Aquatic Ecological Change’, Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 42, 1391–1400.Google Scholar
  39. Oberts, G. L. and Jousseau, M.: 1979, Water Pollution from Nonpoint Sources: An Assessment and Recommendations, Metropolitan Council of the Twin Cities Area Publication No. 62-72-008, 194 pp.Google Scholar
  40. Osgood, R.: 1988, ‘Lake Mixis and Internal Phosphorus Dynamics’, Arch. Hydrobiol. 113, 629–638.Google Scholar
  41. Pinay, G., Dècamps, H., Arles, C. and Lacassin-Seres, M.: 1989, ‘Topographic Influence on Carbon and Nitrogen Dynamics in Riverine Woods’, Arch. Hydrobiol. 114, 401–414.Google Scholar
  42. Reddy, K. R. and Graetz, D. A.: 1988, ‘Carbon and Nitrogen Dynamics in Wetland Soils’, pp. 307–318, in: Hook, D. D., McKeeJr., W. H., Smith, H. K., Gregory, J., BurrelJr., V. G., DeVoe, M. R., Sojka, R. E., Gilbert, S. Banks, R., Stolzy, L. H., Brooks, C., Matthews, T. D. and Shear, T. H., (Eds.), The Ecology and Management of Wetlands. Volume 1: Ecology of Wetlands, Timber Press, Portland, OR.Google Scholar
  43. Reddy, K. R. and PatrickJr., W. H.: 1975, ‘Effects of Alternate and Anaerobic Conditions on Redox Potential, Organic Matter Decomposition and Nitrogen Loss in a Flooded Soil’, Soil Biol. Biochem. 7, 87–94.Google Scholar
  44. SAS: 1988, SAS/STAT User's quide, Release 6.03 Edition, SAS Institute, Inc. Cary, NC.Google Scholar
  45. Schoenberg, S. A. and Oliver, J. D.: 1988, ‘Temporal Dynamics and Spatial Variation of Algae in Relation to Hydrology and Sediment Chracteristics in the Okefenokee Swamp, Georgia’, Hydrobiologia 162, 123–133.Google Scholar
  46. Shaw, S. P. and Fredine, C. G.: 1956, Wetlands of the United States, Circular 39, U.S. Dept. of the Interior, Fish and Widlife Service, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. 1971 (reissue).Google Scholar
  47. Siegel, D. I.: 1988, ‘A Review of the Recharge-Discharge Function of Wetlands’, pp. 59–67, in: Hook, D. D., McKeeJr., W. H., Smith, H. K., Gregory, J., BurrellJr., V. G., DeVoe, M. R., Sojka, R. E., Gilbert, S., Banks, R., Stolzy, L. H., Brooks, C., Matthews, T. D. and Shear, T. H. (Eds.), The Ecology and Management of Wetlands. Volume 1: Ecology of Wetlands, Timber Press, Portland, OR.Google Scholar
  48. Snedecor, G. W. and Cochran, W. G.: 1980, Statistical methods, 7th edn. Iowa State University Press, Ames, Iowa.Google Scholar
  49. Sokal, R. R. and Rohlf, F. J.: 1981, Biometry: The Principles and Practice of Statistics in Biological Research, 2nd. edn. W. H. Freeman and Company, New York, 859 pp.Google Scholar
  50. Solorzano, L. and Sharp, J. H.: 1980, ‘Determination of Total Dissolved Nitrogen in Natural Waters’, Limnol. Oceanogr. 25(4), 751–754.Google Scholar
  51. U.S. EPA: 1983, Methods for Chemical Analyses of Water and Wastes, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Cincinnati, OH, EPA-600/4-79-020.Google Scholar
  52. U.S. EPA: 1991, Water Pollution Quality Control Samples: Instructions for Nutrient Quality Control Samples, U.S. EPA Environmental Monitoring and Support Laboratory-Cincinnati, OH.Google Scholar
  53. Vanamburg, H. L.: 1982, ‘Effects of Agricultural Runoff upon Natural Wetland Ecosystems: Completion report’, University of Minnesota Water Resources Research Center, NTIS PB88-4-111905.Google Scholar
  54. van derValk, A.: 1989, Northern Prairie Wetlands, Iowa State University Press: Ames, Iowa, 400 pp.Google Scholar
  55. Walker, W.: 1987, ‘Phosphorus Removal by Urban Runoff Detention Basins’, Lake and Reservoir Management. 3, 314–326.Google Scholar
  56. Westermann, P. and Ahring, B. K.: 1987, ‘Dynamics of Methane Production, Sulfate Reduction, and Denitrification in a Permanently Waterlogged Alder Swamp’, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 53, 2554–2559.Google Scholar
  57. Whitehead, A. J., Lo, K. V. and Bulley, N. R.: 1987, ‘The Effect of Hydraulic Retention Time and Duckweed Cropping Rate on Nutrient Removal from Dairy Barn Wastewater’, pp. 697–703, In: Reddy, K. R. and Smith, W. H. (Eds.), Aquatic Plants for Water Treatment and Resource Recovery, Magnolia Publishing Inc., Orlando, Fl.Google Scholar
  58. Winter, T. C.: 1989, ‘Hydrologic Studies of Wetlands in the Northern Prairies’, in: van derValk, A. (Ed.), Northern Prairie Wetlands, Iowa State University Press: Ames, Iowa, 473 pp.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1996

Authors and Affiliations

  • Naomi E. Detenbeck
    • 1
  • Debra L. Taylor
    • 2
  • Ann Lima
    • 3
  • Cynthia Hagley
    • 4
  1. 1.U.S. E.P.A. Environmental Research Laboratory-DuluthDuluthUSA
  2. 2.SAIC Corporation-DuluthDuluthUSA
  3. 3.Natural Resources Research InstituteUniversity of Minnesota-DuluthDuluthUSA
  4. 4.MN Sea Grant-DuluthDuluthUSA

Personalised recommendations