Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 9, Issue 6, pp 457–471 | Cite as

Methodology in business ethics research: A review and critical assessment

  • D. M. Randall
  • A. M. Gibson
Article

Abstract

Using 94 published empirical articles in academic journals as a data base, this paper provides a critical review of the methodology employed in the study of ethical beliefs and behavior of organizational members. The review revealed that full methodological detail was provided in less than one half of the articles. Further, the majority of empirical research articles expressed no concern for the reliability or validity of measures, were characterized by low response rates, used convenience samples, and did not offer a theoretic framework, hypotheses, or a definition of ethics. Several recommendations, including a reviewer rating form addressing methodological decisions and inclusion of methodologists on the review panel, are offered to improve methodological rigor in published ethics research.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Allen, R. F.: 1980, ‘IK in the Office’, Organizational Dynamics 8, 26–41.Google Scholar
  2. Armstrong, J. S. and T. S. Overton: 1977, ‘Estimating Nonresponse Bias in Mail Surveys”, Journal of Marketing Research 14, 396–402.Google Scholar
  3. Ashton, R. H. and S. S. Kramer, ‘Students as Surrogates in Behavioral Accounting Research: Some Evidence’, Journal of Accounting Research 18, 1–15.Google Scholar
  4. Babbie, E.: 1986, The Practice of Social Research, 4th ed. (Wadsworth Publishing Co., Belmont, CA).Google Scholar
  5. Bailey, K. D.: 1982, Methods of Social Research, 2nd ed. (Free Press, New York).Google Scholar
  6. Barnett, J. H. and M. J. Karson: 1987, ‘Personal Values and Business Decisions — An Exploratory Investigation’, Journal of Business Ethics 6(5), 371–382.Google Scholar
  7. Baumhart, R. C.: 1961, ‘How Ethical are Businessmen?’, Harvard Business Review 39(4), 6–8.Google Scholar
  8. Becker, H. and D. J. Fritzsche: 1987, ‘Business Ethics: A Cross-Cultural Comparison of Managers' Attitudes’, Journal of Business Ethics 6, 289–95.Google Scholar
  9. Bezilla, R, J. B. Haynes and C. Elliott: 1976, ‘Ethics in Marketing Research’, Business Horizons 19, 83–6.Google Scholar
  10. Bird, F. and J. A. Waters: 1987, ‘The Nature of Managerial Moral Standards’, Journal of Business Ethics 6, 1–13.Google Scholar
  11. Bommer, M., C. Gratta, J. Gravendu and M. Tuttle: 1987, ‘A Behavioral Model of Ethical and Unethical Decision-Making’, Journal of Business Ethics 6, 265–80.Google Scholar
  12. Bowman, J. S.: 1976, ‘Managerial Ethics in Business and Government’, Business Horizons 19, 48–54.Google Scholar
  13. Brenner, S. N. and A. Molander: 1977, ‘Is the Ethics of Business Changing?’ Harvard Business Review 55, 57–71.Google Scholar
  14. Brown, D. J. and J. B. King: 1982, ‘Small Business Ethics: Influences and Perceptions [Survey]’, Journal of Small Business Management 20, 11–8.Google Scholar
  15. Browning, J. and N. B. Zabriskie: 1983, ‘How Ethical are Industry Buyers?’ Industrial Marketing Management 12 219–24.Google Scholar
  16. Campbell, D. T. and D. W. Fiske: 1959, ‘Convergent and Discriminant Validation by the Multi-trait Multi-method Matrix’, Psychological Bulletin 56(2), 81–105.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  17. Carroll, A. B.: 1975, ‘Managerial Ethics: A Post-Watergate View’, Business Horizons 18, 75–80.Google Scholar
  18. Chonko, L. B. and S. D. Hunt: 1985, ‘Ethics and Marketing Management: An Empirical Examination’, Journal of Business Research 13, 339–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Churchill, G. A.: 1979, ‘A Paradigm for Developing Better Measures of Marketing Constructs’, Journal of Marketing Research 16, 64–73.Google Scholar
  20. Cronbach, L. J. and P. E. Meehl: 1955, ‘Construct Validity in Psychological Tests’, Psychological Bulletin 52(4), 281–302.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  21. Crowne, D. P. and D. Marlowe: 1964, The Approval Motive (Wiley, New York).Google Scholar
  22. Dillman, D.: Mail and Telephone Surveys: The Total Design Method (John Wiley, New York).Google Scholar
  23. Dubinsky, A. J. and J. M. Gwin: 1981, ‘Business Ethics: Buyers and Sellers’, Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management 17, 9–16.Google Scholar
  24. Dubinsky, A. J. and T. N. Ingram: 1984, ‘Correlates of Salespeople's Ethical Conflict: An Exploratory Investigation’, Journal of Business Ethics 3, 343–53.Google Scholar
  25. Dubinsky, A. J. and M. Levy: 1985, ‘Ethics in Retailing: Perceptions of Retail Salespeople’, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 13(1), 1–16.Google Scholar
  26. Ferrell, O. C. and L. G. Gresham: 1985, ‘A Contingency Framework for Understanding Ethical Decision Making in Marketing’, Journal of Marketing 49 (Summer), 87–96.Google Scholar
  27. Fleming, J. E.: 1987, ‘Authorities in Business Ethics’, Journal of Business Ethics 6(3), 213–17.Google Scholar
  28. Forsyth, D. R.: 1980, ‘A Taxonomy of Ethical Ideologies’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 39(1), 175–84Google Scholar
  29. Frederiksen, N., O. Jensen and A. Beaton: 1972, Prediction of Organizational Behavior (Pergamon, New York).Google Scholar
  30. Fredrickson, J. W.: 1986, ‘An Exploratory Approach to Measuring Perceptions of Strategic Decision Process Constructs’, Strategic Management Journal 7, 473–83.Google Scholar
  31. Fritzsche, D. J. and H. Becker: 1984, ‘Linking Management Behavior in Ethical Philosophy — An Investigation’, Academy of Management Journal 27, 166–75.Google Scholar
  32. Fulmer, R. M.: 1971, ‘Business Ethics: Present and Future’, Personnel Administration 34, 48–55.Google Scholar
  33. Gordon, M. E., L. A. Slade and N. Schmitt: 1987, ‘Student Guinea Pigs: Porcine Predictors and Particularistic Phenomena’, Academy of Management Review 12, 160–63.Google Scholar
  34. Greenberg, J.: 1987, ‘The College Sophomore as Guinea Pig: Setting the Record Straight’, Academy of Management Review 12, 157–9.Google Scholar
  35. Hawkins, D. I. and A. B. Cocanougher: 1972, ‘Student Evaluations of the Ethics of Marketing Practices: The Role of Marketing Education’, Journal of Marketing 36(2), 61–4.Google Scholar
  36. Hegarty, W. H. and H. P. Sims Jr.: 1978, ‘Some Determinants of Unethical Decision Behavior’, Journal of Applied Psychology 63(4), 451–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Hegarty, W. H. and H. P. Sims: 1979, ‘Organizational Philosophy, Policies and Objective Related to Unethical Decision Behavior: A Laboratory Experiment’, Journal of Applied Psychology 64, 331–8.Google Scholar
  38. Hogarth, R. M.: 1978, ‘A Note on Aggregating Opinions,’ Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 21, 40–6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Krugman, D. M. and O. C. Ferrell: 1981, ‘The Organizational Ethics of Advertising: Corporate and Agency Views’, Journal of Advertising 10, 21–30.Google Scholar
  40. Laczniak, G.: 1983, ‘Business Ethics: A Manager's Primer’, Business 3(1). 23–9.Google Scholar
  41. Laczniak, G. and E. J. Inderrieden: 1987, ‘The Influence of Stated Organizational Concerns Upon Ethical Decision-Making’, Journal of Business Ethics 6(4), 297–307.Google Scholar
  42. Lazernitz, B.: 1968, ‘Sampling Theory and Procedures’. In Methodology in Social Research, H. A. Blalock and A. B. Blalock, eds., pp. 278–328, NY: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
  43. Levy, M. and A. J. Dubinsky: 1983, ‘Identifying and Addressing Retail Salespeople's Ethical Problems: A Method of Application’, Journal of Retailing 59, 46–66.Google Scholar
  44. Lewis, P. V.: 1985, ‘Defining ‘Business Ethics’: Like Nailing Jello to a Wall’, Journal of Business Ethics 4, 377–83.Google Scholar
  45. Lincoln, D. J., M. M. Pressley and T. Little: 1982. ‘Ethical Beliefs and Personal Values of Top Level Executives’, Journal of Business Research 10, 475–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. McNichols, L. W. and T. W. Zimmer: 1985, ‘Situational Ethics: An Empirical Study of Differentiators of Student Attitudes’, Journal of Business Ethics 4, 175–80.Google Scholar
  47. Nederhof, A. J.: 1985, ‘Methods of Coping with Social Desirability Bias: A Review’, European Journal of Social Psychology 15, 263–80.Google Scholar
  48. Phillips, D. L. and K. J. Clancy: 1970, ‘Some Effects of “Social Desirability” in Survey Studies’, American Journal of Sociology 77(5), 921–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Posner, B. Z. and W. H. Schmidt: 1987, ‘Ethics in American Companies: A Managerial Perspective’, Journal of Business Ethics 6, 383–91.Google Scholar
  50. Remus, W.: 1986, ‘Graduate Students as Surrogates for Managers in Experiments on Business Decision Making’, Journal of Business Research 14, 19–25.Google Scholar
  51. Rizzo, A. and T. J. Patka: 1981, ‘Organizational Imperative and Supervisory Control: Their Effects on Managerial Ethics’, Public Personnel Management 10, 103–9.Google Scholar
  52. Rosenthal, R. and R. L. Rosnow: 1975, The Volunteer Subject, (New York: Wiley).Google Scholar
  53. Rudelius, W. and R. Buchholz: 1979, ‘What Industrial Purchasers See as Key Ethical Dilemmas’, Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management 15, 2–10.Google Scholar
  54. Runes, D. D. (Ed.): 1964, Dictionary of Philosophy, Peterson: Littlefield, Adams & Company.Google Scholar
  55. Schutte, T. F.: 1965, ‘Executives’ Perceptions of Business Ethics’, Journal of Purchasing, 38–52.Google Scholar
  56. Simon, J. L. and P. Burstein: 1985, Basic Research Methods in Social Science, 3rd Ed., (New York: Random House).Google Scholar
  57. Stevens, G. E.: 1984, ‘Business Ethics and Social Responsibility: The Responses of Present and Future Managers’, Akron Business and Economic Review 15(3), 6–11.Google Scholar
  58. Trawick, F. and W. R. Darden: 1980, ‘Marketer's Perception of Ethical Standards in the Marketing Profession: Educators and Practitioners’, Review of Business and Economic Research 16, 1–17.Google Scholar
  59. Trevino, L. K.: 1986, ‘Ethical Decision Making in Organizations: A Person-Situation Interactionist Model’, Academy of Management Review 11(3), 601–17.Google Scholar
  60. Vitell, S. J. and T. A. Festervand: 1987, ‘Business Ethics: Conflicts, Practices and Beliefs of Industrial Executives’, Journal of Business Ethics 6, 111–22.Google Scholar
  61. Waters, J. A. and F. Bird: 1987, ‘The Moral Dimension of Organizational Culture’, Journal of Business Ethics 6, 15–22.Google Scholar
  62. Waters, J. A., F. Bird and P. D. Chant: 1986, ‘Everyday Moral Issues Experienced by Managers’, Journal of Business Ethics 5, 373–84.Google Scholar
  63. Zey-Ferrell, M. and O. C. Ferrell: 1982, ‘Role-set Configuration and Opportunity as Predictors of Unethical Behavior in Organizations’, Human Relations 35(7), 587–604.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1990

Authors and Affiliations

  • D. M. Randall
    • 1
  • A. M. Gibson
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Management and SystemsWashington State UniversityPullmanUSA

Personalised recommendations