# The conceptual import of Carnot's theorem to the discovery of the entropy

- 158 Downloads
- 4 Citations

## Summary

Among many other things, Carnot stated a principle and proved a theorem. In 1850, Clausius corrected Carnot's theory, modifying it according to Joule's principle. He might have considered a corollary of the theorem as the mathematical formulation of Carnot's principle. We challenge the corollary: it is based on hidden assumptions, nor is it true for all cycles. Clausius realized the corollary's lack of generality, but on different grounds. In 1854, he generalized the theorem, and gave an (other) expression to Carnot's principle. We analyze Clapeyron's account of Carnot's theory, Thomson's account of 1849 and some of Clausius belated comments on his 1850 paper, as well Clausius' paper of 1854. We hope that they shed light on the corollary's tacit hypotheses and on the meaning of Carnot's principle. It is our contention: Clausius took seriously a contemporary meaning of the principle, and looked for a condition of integrability that could express recovery of the initial conditions of the reservoirs. Furthermore, he seems to have had some prior knowledge of the form the expression of the principle should take. Actually, this was the theory's natural candidate.

### Keywords

Entropy Prior Knowledge Mathematical Formulation Conceptual Import Natural Candidate## Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

### References

- Brush, S. G. (1976)
*The Kind of Motion We Call Heat*, 2 vols., North-Holland, Amsterdam.Google Scholar - Cardwell, D. S. L. (1967) “Early Development of the Concepts of Power, Work and Energy,”
*The British Journal for the History of Science***3**, 209–224.Google Scholar - Cardwell, D. S. L. (1971)
*From Watt to Clausius (The Rise of Thermodynamics in the Early Industrial Age)*, Cornell University Press, Ithaca.Google Scholar - Carnot, S. (1824)
*Réflexions sur la Puissance Motrice du Feu et Sur les Machines propres a Développer cette Puissance*, Bachelier, Paris, translated by R. H. Thurston (1890), republished in E. Mendoza (ed) (1960), pp. 1–59. Also in R. Fox (ed) (1976), pp. 55–179.Google Scholar - Clapeyron, E. (1834)
*Journal de l'École Polytechnique*,**14**, 153, translated by E. Mendoza, in E. Mendoza (1960), pp. 71–105.Google Scholar - Clausius, R. J. E. (1850), “On the Motive Power of Fire and the Laws of the Theory of Heat, Which are Deduced from It,”
*Annalen der Physik und Chemie*,**79**, 368, 500, translated in*Philosophical Magazine*[4],**2**, 1, 102 (1851). English translation by W. F. Magie (1899) republished in E. Mendoza (1960), pp. 107–152. French version by F. folie in Clausius (1868), vol. 1, pp. 17–84.Google Scholar - Clausius, R. J. E. (1854) “On Another Form of the Second Principle of the Mechanical Theory of Heat,”
*Annalen der Physik und Chemie*,**93**, 481–506, translated in*Philosophical Magazine*[4],**12**, p. 81 (1856). French version of F. Folie in Clausius (1868), vol. 1, pp. 131–160.Google Scholar - Clausius, R. J. E. (1865) “On Different Forms of the Fundamental Equations of the Mechanical Theory of Heat and their Convenience for Application,”
*Annalen der Physik und Chemie*,**124**, 353–399, translation by R. B. Llndsay in J. Kestin (ed) (1976), pp. 162–193.Google Scholar - Clausius, R. J. E. (1868)
*Théorie Méchanique de La Chaleur*, 2 vols., French version by F. Folie, Eugene Lacroix, Paris.Google Scholar - Clausius, R. J. E. (1879)
*The Mechanical Theory of Heat*, translated by Walter R. Browne, Macmillan and Co.Google Scholar - Dias, P. M. C. (1994) “A Path From Watt's Engine to the Principle of Heat Transfer,” in Dag Prawitz & Dag Werterstahl (eds),
*Logic and Philosophy of Science in Uppsala*, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp. 425–438.Google Scholar - Fox, R. (1978)
*Sadi Carnot: Réflexions sur la Puissance Motrice du Feu. Edition critique avec introduction et commentaire, augmenté de documents d'archives et de divers manuscripts de Carnot, par Robert Fox*, Vrin, Paris. English translation and edition by Robert Fox (1986)*Reflexions on the Motive Power of Fire (A critical edition with the Surviving Scientific Manuscripts)*Manchester University Press, Lilian Barber Press, Inc, New York.Google Scholar - Fox, R. (1989) “Les Réflexions sur la puissance motrice du feu de Sadi Carnot et la leçon de leur édition critique,”
*Comptes Rendus*, série générale,**5**, 283–301.Google Scholar - Gillispie, C. G. (1960)
*The Edge of Objectivity. An Essay in the History of Scientific Ideas*, Princeton.Google Scholar - Harman, P. M. (1982)
*Energy, Force and Matter: The Conceptual Development of Nineteenth-Century Physics*, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar - Kestin, J. (ed) (1976) “The Second Law of Thermodynamics,”
*Benchmark Papers on Energy*, Dowden, Hutchinson & Ross, New York, vol. 5.Google Scholar - Klein, M. J. (1974) “Carnot's Contribution to Thermodynamics,”
*Physics Today*,**27**, 23–28.Google Scholar - Lervig, P. (1972) “On the Structure of Carnot's Theory of Heat,”
*Archive for History of Exact Sciences*,**9**, 222–239.Google Scholar - Lervig, P. (1976) “The Existence of a Work Function in Carnot's Theory,” in René Taton (ed), pp. 199–212.Google Scholar
- Mendoza, E. (ed) (1960)
*Reflections on the Motive Power of Fire by Sadi Carnot and Other Papers on the Second Law of Thermodynamics by E. Clapeyron and R. Clausius*, Dover, New York.Google Scholar - Taton, R. (ed) (1976),
*Sadi Carnot et l'Essor de la Themodynamique*Éditions du CNRS, Paris.Google Scholar - Thomson, W. (1848) “On an Absolute Thermometric Scale Founded on Carnot's Theory of the Motive Power of Heat, and Calculated from Regnault's Observations,”
*Philosophical Magazine*, republished in J. Kestin (ed) (1976), pp. 52–58.Google Scholar - Thomson, W. (1849) “An Account of Carnot's Theory of the Motive Power of Heat; With Numerical Results Deduced from Regnault's Experiments on Steam,”
*Edinburgh Transactions*,**16**, 541, republished in J. Kestin (ed) (1976), pp. 59–86.Google Scholar - Thomson, W. (1851) “On the Dynamical Theory of Heat, With Numerical Results Deduced from Mr. Joule's Equivalent of a Thermal Unit, and M. Regnault's Observation,”
*Edinburgh Transactions*,**20**, 261–289, republished in J. Kestin (ed) (1976), pp. 106–132.Google Scholar - Truesdell C. A. (1980)
*The Tragicomical History of Thermodynamics, 1822–1854*, Springer-Verlag, New York, Heidelberg, Berlin.Google Scholar