Oecologia

, Volume 52, Issue 1, pp 64–74

Examination of the “null” model of connor and simberloff for species co-occurrences on Islands

  • Jared M. Diamond
  • Michael E. Gilpin
Article

Summary

Among birds of the Bismarck Archipelago, only certain combinations of the species in a guild coexist on islands, and some species that are very similar ecologically have mutually exclusive distributions. Diamond (1975) interpreted these patterns as biologically significant, involving effects such as competition. Connor and Simberloff (1979) claimed such patterns to be not recognizably different from random, because they were scarcely distinguishable from those generated by a “null” distribution supposedly not incorporating competition.

On examining the analysis by Connor and Simberloff, we find that it actually yields the opposite conclusion: three faunas tested have grossly non-random structures, while their test is unworkable for the fourth fauna. The method of Connor and Simberloff for generating a null distribution has many fatal weaknesses: dilution of relevant data from guilds with irrelevant data from the whole species pool; hidden incorporation of effects of competition into the constraints; inability to recognize a checkerboard, the extreme example of a distribution produced by competition; reliance on inefficient Monte Carlo simulations; severe constraints that sometimes make generation of a null distribution impossible; failure to weight species combinations; and failure to identify the direction of non-randomness or the species combinations most responsible.

Finally, we use other recent studies by Simberloff and coleagues to examine the value of constructing null hypotheses in community ecology.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Beckner M (1959) The biological way of thought. Columbia Univ Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  2. Case TJ (1982) Non-null models of community-wide character displacement. In press, EvolutionGoogle Scholar
  3. Cody ML (1978) Habitat selection and interspecific territoriality among the sylviid warblers of England and Sweden. Ecol Monogr 48:351–396Google Scholar
  4. Connor EF, McCoy ED (1979) The statistics and biology of the species-area relationship. Amer Naturalist 113:791–833Google Scholar
  5. Connor EF, Simberloff DS (1978) Species number and compositional similarity of the Galapagos flora and avifauna. Ecol Monogr 48:219–248Google Scholar
  6. Connor EF, Simberloff DS (1979) The assembly of species communities: chance or competition? Ecology 60:1132–1140Google Scholar
  7. Diamond JM (1970) Ecological consequences of island colonization by southwest Pacific birds. II. The effect of species diversity on total population density. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 67:1715–1721Google Scholar
  8. Diamond JM (1972) Biogeographic kinetics: estimation of relaxation times for avifaunas of southwest Pacific islands. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 69:3199–3203Google Scholar
  9. Diamond JM (1975) Assembly of species communities. In: Cody ML, Diamond JM (eds) Ecology and evolution of communities. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard Univ Press, p 342–444Google Scholar
  10. Diamond JM (1982) Effect of species pool size on species occurrence frequencies: musical chairs on islands. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA in pressGoogle Scholar
  11. Diamond JM, Marshall AG (1977) Distributional ecology of New Hebridean birds: a species kaleidoscope. J Anim Ecol 46:703–727Google Scholar
  12. Diamond JM, Mayr E (1976) Species-area relation for birds of the Solomon Archipelago. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 73:262–266Google Scholar
  13. Feinsinger P, Whelan RJ, Kiltie RA (1981) Some notes on community composition: assembly by rules or by dartboards? Bull Ecol Soc Amer 62:19–23Google Scholar
  14. Gilpin ME, Diamond JM (1982) Factors contributing to non-randomness in species co-occurrences on islands. Oecologia (Berl) in pressGoogle Scholar
  15. Grant PR (1966) Ecological compatibility of bird species on islands. Amer Naturalist 100:451–462Google Scholar
  16. Grant PR, Abbott I (1980) Interspecific competition, island biogeography and null hypotheses. Evolution 34:332–341Google Scholar
  17. Haffer J (1969) Speciation in Amazonian forest birds. Science 165:131–137Google Scholar
  18. Heatwole H, Levins R (1972) Trophic structure stability and faunal change during recolonization. Ecology 53:531–534Google Scholar
  19. Hempel CG (1965) Aspects of scientific explanation. New York: Free PressGoogle Scholar
  20. Hempel CG (1966) Philosophy of natural science. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-HallGoogle Scholar
  21. Hull D (1974) Philosophy of biological science. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-HallGoogle Scholar
  22. Koopman KF (1968) Taxonomic and distributional notes on Lesser Antillean bats. Amer Mus Novitates no 2333Google Scholar
  23. Kuhn TS (1970) The structure of scientific revolutions. 2nd ed. Chicago: Univ of Chicago PressGoogle Scholar
  24. MacArthur RH (1972) Geographical ecology. Harper and Row New YorkGoogle Scholar
  25. Mayr E, Short LL (1970) Species taxa of North American birds. Cambridge, Mass: Nuttall Ornithological ClubGoogle Scholar
  26. Moreau RE (1966) The bird faunas of Africa and its islands. Academic Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  27. Popper KR (1963) Conjectures and refutations: the growth of scientific knowledge. Harper and Row New YorkGoogle Scholar
  28. Root R (1967) The niche exploitation pattern of the Blue-grey Gnatcatcher. Ecol Monogr 37:317–350Google Scholar
  29. Roughgarden J (1982) Competition and theory in community ecology. Submitted to Amer NaturalistGoogle Scholar
  30. Schoener TW (1976) The species-area relation within archipelagoes: models and evidence from island land birds. In: HJ Frith, JH Calaby (eds), Proceedings of the 16th International Ornithological Congress. Canberra: Australian Academy of SciencesGoogle Scholar
  31. Simberloff DS (1970) Taxonomic diversity of island biotas. Evolution 24:23–47Google Scholar
  32. Simberloff DS (1976) Trophic structure determination and equilibrium in an arthropod community. Ecology 57:395–398Google Scholar
  33. Simbeloff DS (1978) Using island biogeographic distributions to determine if colonization is stochastic. Amer Naturalist 112:713–726Google Scholar
  34. Strong DR Jr, Szyska LA, Simberloff DS (1979) Tests of community-wide character displacement against null hypotheses. Evolution 33:897–913Google Scholar
  35. Sugihara G (1981) S-CAz, z∼1/4: a reply to Connor and McCoy. Amer Naturalist 117:790–793Google Scholar
  36. Suppe F (1977) The structure of scientific theories. University of Illinois Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
  37. Terborgh J (1981) Discussion of a paper by Simberloff et al. In: Nelson G, Rosen DE (eds), Vicariance Biogeography. Columbia Univ Press New York p 64–68Google Scholar
  38. Terborgh J, Faaborg J (1980) Saturation of bird communities in the West Indies. Amer Naturalist 116:178–195Google Scholar
  39. Wilcox BA (1980) Insular ecology and conservation. In: Soulé ME, Wilcox BA (eds), Conservation Biology. Sunderland, Mass: Sinauer, p 95–117Google Scholar
  40. Williams CB (1964) Patterns in the balance of nature and related problems in quantitative ecology. Academic Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  41. Wright SJ, Biehl CC (1981) Insular distributions: testing for chance and competition. Submitted to Amer NaturalistGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag 1982

Authors and Affiliations

  • Jared M. Diamond
    • 1
  • Michael E. Gilpin
    • 2
  1. 1.Physiology DepartmentUniversity of California Medical SchoolLos AngelesUSA
  2. 2.Biology DepartmentUniversity of California at San DiegoLa JollaUSA

Personalised recommendations