Social Indicators Research

, Volume 24, Issue 1, pp 1–34 | Cite as

Is happiness relative?

  • Ruut Veenhoven
Article

Abstract

The theory that happiness is relative is based on three postulates: (1) happiness results from comparison, (2) standards of comparison adjust, (3) standards of comparison are arbitrary constructs. On the basis of these postulates the theory predicts: (a) happiness does not depend on real quality of life, (b) changes in living-conditions to the good or the bad have only a shortlived effect on happiness, (c) people are happier after hard times, (d) people are typically neutral about their life. Together these inferences imply that happiness is both an evasive and an inconsequential matter, which is at odds with corebeliefs in present-day welfare society.

Recent investigations on happiness (in the sense of life-satisfaction) claim support for this old theory. Happiness is reported to be as high in poor countries as it is in rich countries (Easterlin), no less among paralyzed accident victims than it is among lottery winners (Brickman) and unrelated to stable livingconditions (Inglehart and Rabier). These sensational claims are inspected but found to be untrue. It is shown that: (a) people tend to be unhappy under adverse conditions such as poverty, war and isolation, (b) improvement or deterioration of at least some conditions does effect happiness lastingly, (c) earlier hardship does not favour later happiness, (d) people are typically positive about their life rather than neutral.

It is argued that the theory happiness-is-relative mixes up ‘overall happiness’ with contentment’. Contentment is indeed largely a matter of comparing life-as-it-is to standards of how-life-should-be. Yet overall hapiness does not entirely depend on comparison. The overall evaluation of life depends also on how one feels affectively and hedonic level of affect draws on its turn on the gratification of basic bio-psychological needs. Contrary to acquired ‘standards’ of comparison these innate ‘needs’ do not adjust to any and all conditions: they mark in fact the limits of human adaptability. To the extend that it depends on need-gratification, happiness is not relative.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Andrews, F. M.: 1981, Subjective Social Indicators, Objective Social Indicators and Social Accounting Systems (Academic Press, New York).Google Scholar
  2. Antonovsky, A., Maoz, B., Dowty, N. and Wijsenbeck, H.: 1971, ‘Twenty-five years later: A limited study of sequelae of the concentration camp experience’, Social Psychiatry, vol. 6, p. 186–93.Google Scholar
  3. Arnold, M. B.: 1960, Emotion and Personality (Columbia, New York).Google Scholar
  4. Barrow, R.: 1980, Happiness (Robertson, Oxford U.K.).Google Scholar
  5. Barschak, E.: 1951, ‘A study of happiness and unhappiness in the childhood and adolescense of girls in different cultures’, Journal of Psychology vol. 32, p. 173–215.Google Scholar
  6. Bless, Herbert and Schwarz, Norbert: 1984, Ist schlechte Stimmung die Ausnahme? ((unpublished paper) Universität Heidelberg).Google Scholar
  7. Brickman, P. and Campbell, D. T.: 1971, Hedonic Relativism and Planning in the Good Society (Academic Press, London), p. 287–302.Google Scholar
  8. Brickman, P., Coates, D. and Janoff-Bulman: 1978, ‘Lottery winners and accident victims: Is happiness relative?’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, vol. 36, p. 917–27.Google Scholar
  9. Cameron, P., Van Hoeck, D., Weiss, N. and Kostin, M.: 1971, Happiness or lifesatisfaction of the malformed’, Proceedings of the 79th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association, vol. 6, nr. 2, p. 641–2.Google Scholar
  10. Cantril, H.: 1965, The Pattern of Human Concern (Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick (NJ)).Google Scholar
  11. Chiriboga, D. A.: 1984, ‘Social stressors as antecedents of change’, Journal of Gerontology, Vol. 39, nr. 4, p. 468–77.Google Scholar
  12. Davies, J.: 1979, ‘The J-curve of rising and declining satisfaction as a cause of some great revolutions and a contained rebellion’, in: Graham, H. D. and Gurr, T. R., eds., The History of Violence in America (Bantam, New York), p. 690–739.Google Scholar
  13. Diener, Ed., Horwitz, J. and Emmons, R. A.: 1985, ‘Happiness of the very wealthy’, Social Indicators Research, vol. 16, p. 263–74.Google Scholar
  14. Easterlin, R. A.: 1974, ‘Does economic growth improve the human lot? Some empirical evidence’, in: David, P. A. and Melvin, W. R. (eds.) Nations and Households in Economic Growth (Stanford University Press, Palo Alto, Ca.), p. 98–125.Google Scholar
  15. Elder, G. H.jr.: 1974, Children of the Great Depression (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).Google Scholar
  16. Feierabend, I. K. and Feierabend, R. L.: 1966, ‘Aggressive behaviors in politics 1948–1966’, Journal of Conflict Resolution, Vol. 10, p. 249–72.Google Scholar
  17. Fordyce, M. W.: 1972, Happiness, Its Daily Variation and Its Relation to Values ((Unpublished Ph.D-thesis) US International University).Google Scholar
  18. Gallup, G. H.: 1976/77, ‘Human Needs and Satisfaction: A global survey’, Public Opinion Quaterly, p. 459–69.Google Scholar
  19. Geschwender, J. A.: 1964, ‘Social Structure and the negro revolt: an examination of some hypotheses’, Social Forces, vol. 43, p. 248–65.Google Scholar
  20. Gurr, T. R.: 1970, Why Men Cebel (Princeton University Press, Princeton).Google Scholar
  21. Heady, B., Holstrom, E. and Wearing, A.: 1984, ‘The impact of life events and changes in domain satisfactions on well-being’, Social Indicators Research, vol. 15, nr. 3, p. 203–27.Google Scholar
  22. Heady, B., Glowacki, T., Holstrom, E. and Wearing, A.: 1985, ‘Modelling change in perceived quality of life’, Social Indicators Research, vol. 17, p. 267–98.Google Scholar
  23. Hersey, R. B.: 1932, Workers' Emotion in Shop and Home (University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, USA).Google Scholar
  24. Inglehart, R. and Rabier J. R.: September 1984, ‘Du Bonheur ... Les Aspirations s'adaptent aux situations’, Futurible, p. 29–58.Google Scholar
  25. Ipsen, Detlev: 1978, Das Konstrukt Zufriedenheit. Soziale Welt, vol. 29, nr. 1, p. 44–53.Google Scholar
  26. Kirchler, E.: 1985, ‘Jobloss and mood’, Journal of Economic Psychology, vol. 6, p. 9–25.Google Scholar
  27. Lewin, K., Dembo, T., Festinger, L. and Sears, P.: 1944, Level of Aspirations (Ronald Press, New York).Google Scholar
  28. Manning Gibbs, R. A.: 1972, Relative Deprivation and Self-reported Happiness of Blacks: 1946–1966 (Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, University of Texas at Austin, USA).Google Scholar
  29. Maslow, A. H.: 1954, Motivation and Personality (Harper, New York).Google Scholar
  30. Mason, R. and Faulkenberry, G. D.: 1978, ‘Aspirations, achievement and life satisfaction’, Social Indicators Research, vol. 5, p. 133–50.Google Scholar
  31. Maxwell, N. L.: 1985, ‘The retirement experience psychological and financial linkages to the labormarket’, Social Science Quarterly, vol. 66, p. 22–3.Google Scholar
  32. McDougall, W.: 1908, An Introduction into Social Psychology (Methuen, London).Google Scholar
  33. Michalos, A. C.: 1985, ‘Multiple discrepancies theory (MDT)’, Social Indicators Research, vol. 16, p. 347–413.Google Scholar
  34. Morgan, A. E.: 1934, ‘An attempt to measure happiness’, International Journal of Ethics, vol. 44, p. 271–4.Google Scholar
  35. Nock, S. L.: 1981, ‘Family life-cycle transitions: Longitudinal effects on family members’, Journal of Marriage and the Family, Vol. 43, nr. 3, p. 703–14.Google Scholar
  36. Parducci, A.: 1984, ‘Value judgment: toward a relational theory of happiness’, in: Eiser, J. B., ed., Attitudinal Judgement (Springer, New York).Google Scholar
  37. Parducci A.: ‘The relativism of absolute judgments’, Scientific American, vol. 219, p. 84–90.Google Scholar
  38. Praag, B. M. S. van, Kapteyn, D. and Herwaarden, F. G. van: 1979, ‘The definition and measurement of Social Reference Spaces’, The Netherlands Journal of Sociology, Vol. 15, p. 13–25.Google Scholar
  39. Runciman, W. G.: 1966, Relative Deprivation and Social Justice (University of California Press, Berkeley).Google Scholar
  40. Schulz, R. and Decker, S.: 1985, ‘Long-term adjustment to physical disability’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, vol. 48, p. 1162–72.Google Scholar
  41. Smith, T. W.: 1979, ‘Happiness: Time Trends, Seasonal Variation, intersurvey differences and other mysteries’, Social Psychology Quarterly, vol. 42, p. 18–30.Google Scholar
  42. Solomon, R. L.: 1980, ‘The Opponent-Process theory of acquired motivation: the cost of pleasure and the benefit of pain’, American Psychologist, vol. 35, p. 691–712.Google Scholar
  43. Stones, M. J. and Kozma, A.: 1986, ‘Happy are they who are happy’, Experimental Ageing Research, vol. 12, p. 23–9.Google Scholar
  44. Suchman, S.: 1967, ‘Reducing the cost of surveys’, NORC Monographs in Social Research (Aldine, Chicago).Google Scholar
  45. Tatarkiewicz, W.: 1975, Analysis of Happiness (Nyhoff, The Hague).Google Scholar
  46. Thibaut, J. W. and Kelly, H. H.: 1959, The Social Psychology of Groups (Wiley, New York).Google Scholar
  47. Unger, H. E.: 1970, ‘The feeling of happiness’, Psychology, vol. 7, p. 27–33.Google Scholar
  48. Veenhoven, R.: 1984a, Conditions of Happiness (Reidel, Dordrecht/Boston).Google Scholar
  49. Veenhoven, R.: 1984b, Databook of Happiness (Reidel, Dordrecht/Boston).Google Scholar
  50. Veenhoven, R.: 1988, ‘The utility of happiness’, Social Indicators Research, vol. 20, p. 333–54.Google Scholar
  51. Veenhoven, R.: 1989, National Economic Prosperity and Individual Happiness, in: Grunert K. G. and Olander T., Understanding Economic Behavior (Kluwer Academic, London), p. 9–32.Google Scholar
  52. Veenhoven, R.: World Database of Happiness, Catalogue of Correlates. Printout 10-1-1990. Ongoing register held at Erasmus University Rotterdam, the Netherlands.Google Scholar
  53. Wentholt, R.: 1975, Map motivatieleer (Erasmus University Rotterdam, Department of Social Sciences).Google Scholar
  54. Wessmann, A. E. and Ricks, D. T.: 1966, Mood and Personality (Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York).Google Scholar
  55. Zajonc, R. B.: 1980, ‘Feeling and thinking, Preference need no inference’, American Psychologist, vol. 35, p. 151–75.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1991

Authors and Affiliations

  • Ruut Veenhoven
    • 1
  1. 1.Erasmus UniversityRotterdamThe Netherlands

Personalised recommendations