Estimation of waterborne selenium concentrations that are toxicity thresholds for wildlife

  • Jeffrey A. Peterson
  • Alan V. Nebeker
Article

Abstract

Contamination of freshwater systems can lead to mortality and impaired reproduction in wildlife. There is a growing need for methods to estimate waterborne contaminant concentrations that pose an unacceptable risk to semi-aquatic and terrestrial vertebrates that use aquatic habitats. Single-species toxicity data, information on contaminant bioaccumulation in aquatic food webs, and energy-based estimates of contaminant exposure to sensitive birds and mammals were used to estimate waterborne selenium levels that are toxicity thresholds for wildlife. Threshold estimates for birds and mammals with food habits that likely lead to high exposure to bioaccumulative contaminants in aquatic systems (e.g., piscivorous birds and mammals) were about 1 μg/L (ppb) waterborne selenium (dissolved selenium). The estimates are near the low end of toxicity thresholds developed by other investigators using different methods. The model may be a useful tool for estimating risks waterborne environmental contaminants pose to aquatic wildlife.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Adams WJ, Johnson HE (1981) Selenium: A hazard assessment and a water quality criterion calculation. In: Branson DR, Dickson KL (eds) Aquatic toxicology and hazard assessment: Fourth conference. ASTM STP 737, American Society for Testing Materials, pp 124–137Google Scholar
  2. Alexander G (1977) Food of vertebrate predators of trout waters in north central lower Michigan. Michigan Academician 10:181–195Google Scholar
  3. Anthony ELP, Kunz TH (1977) Feeding strategies of the little brown bat, Myotis lucifugus, in southern New Hampshire. Ecology 58:775–786Google Scholar
  4. Arnold RL, Olson OE, Carlson CW (1973) Dietary selenium and arsenic additions and their effects on tissue and egg selenium. Poultry Sci 52:847–854Google Scholar
  5. Barr JF (1986) Population dynamics of the common loon (Gavia immer) associated with mercury-contaminated waters in northwestern Ontario. Occasional Paper, Number 56, Canadian Wildlife Service, Cat No CW69-1/56EGoogle Scholar
  6. Baumann PC, Gillespie RB (1986) Selenium bioaccumulation in gonads of largemouth bass and bluegill from three power plant cooling reservoris. Environ Toxicol Chem 5:695–701Google Scholar
  7. Bertram PE, Brooks AS (1986) Kinetics of accumulation of selenium from food and water by fathead minnows. Water Res 20:877–884Google Scholar
  8. Birge WJ (1978) Aquatic toxicology of trace elements of coal fly ash. In: Thorp JH, Gibbons JW (eds) Energy and environmental stress in aquatic systems. CONF-771114, National Technical Information Service, Springfield, VA, pp 219–240Google Scholar
  9. Birge WJ, Black JA, Westerman AG (1979) Evaluation of aquatic pollutants using fish and amphibian eggs as bioassay organisms. In: Nielson SW, Migaki G, Scarelli DG (eds) Animals as monitors of environmental pollutants. National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, pp 108–118Google Scholar
  10. Browne CL, Dumont JN (1979) Toxicity of selenium to developing Xenopus laevis embryos. J Toxicol Environ Health 5:699–709Google Scholar
  11. —, — (1980) Cytotoxic effects of sodium selenite on tadpoles (Xenopus laevis). Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 9:181–191Google Scholar
  12. Burmaster DE, Menzie CA, Freshman JS, Burris JA, Maxwell NI, Drew SR (1991) Assessment of methods for estimating aquatic hazards at Superfund-type sites: A cautionary tale. Environ Toxicol Chem 10:827–842Google Scholar
  13. Calder WA, Braun EJ (1983) Scaling of osmotic regulation in mammals and birds. Am J Physiol 244:R601-R606Google Scholar
  14. Chanin P (1985) The natural history of otters. Facts on File Publications, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  15. Cherry DS, Guthrie RK, Sherberger FF, Larrick SR (1979) The influence of coal ash and thermal discharges upon the distribution and bioaccumulation of aquatic invertebrates. Hydrobiologia 62:257–267Google Scholar
  16. Cherry DS, Guthrie RK, Davis EM, Harvey RS (1984) Coal ash basin effects (particulates, metals, acidic pH) upon aquatic biota: an eight-year evaluation. Water Resour Bull 20:535–544Google Scholar
  17. Clark DR Jr (1987) Selenium accumulation in mammals exposed to contaminated California irrigation drainwater. Sci Total Environ 66:147–168Google Scholar
  18. Clark DR Jr, Ogasawara PA, Smith GJ, Ohlendorf HM (1989) Selenium accumulation by raccoons exposed to irrigation drainwater at Kesterson National Wildlife Refuge, California, 1986. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 18:787–794Google Scholar
  19. Combs GF Jr, Combs SB (1986) The role of selenium in nutrition. Academic Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  20. Conaway CH (1952) Life history of the water shrew (Sorex palustris navigator). Am Midl Nat 48:219–248Google Scholar
  21. Cumbie PM, VanHorn SL (1978) Selenium accumulation associated with fish mortality and reproductive failure. Proc Annu Conf SE Assoc Fish Wildl Agencies 32:612–624Google Scholar
  22. Delnicki D, Reinecke KJ (1986) Mid-winter food use and body weights of mallards and wood ducks. J Wildl Manage 50:43–51Google Scholar
  23. Dourson ML, Stara JF (1983) Regulatory history and experimental support of uncertainty (safety) factors. Reg Toxicol Pharmacol 3:224–238Google Scholar
  24. DuBowy PJ (1989) Effect of diet on selenium bioaccumulation in marsh birds. J Wildl Manage 53:776–781Google Scholar
  25. Dunning JB Jr (1984) Body weights of 686 species of North American birds. Monograph No 1, Western Bird Banding AssociationGoogle Scholar
  26. Eisler R (1985) Selenium hazards to fish, wildlife, and invertebrates: A synoptic review. Biological Report 85 (1.5), Contaminant Hazard Reviews, Report No 5, US Fish and Wildl Serv, Laurel, MDGoogle Scholar
  27. El-Begearmi MM, Sunde ML, Ganther HE (1977) A mutual protective effect of mercury and selenium in Japanese quail. Poultry Sci 56:313–322Google Scholar
  28. El-Begearmi MM, Ganther HE, Sunde ML (1982) Dietary interaction between methylmercury, selenium, arsenic, and sulfur amino acids in Japanese quail. Poultry Sci 61:272–279Google Scholar
  29. Frost DV (1972) The two faces of selenium—can selenophobia be cured? CRC Crit Rev Toxicol 1:467–514Google Scholar
  30. Gillespie RB, Baumann PC (1986) Effects of high tissue concentrations of selenium on reproduction by bluegills. Trans Am Fish Soc 115:208–213Google Scholar
  31. Guthrie RK, Cherry DS (1979) Trophic level accumulation of heavy metals in a coal ash basin drainage system. Water Resour Bull 15:244–248Google Scholar
  32. Gutzwiller KJ, Anderson SH (1987) Habitat Suitability Index Models: Marsh Wren. US Fish Wildl Serv Biol Rep 82(10.139)Google Scholar
  33. Halverson AW, Palmer IS, Guss PL (1966) Toxicity of selenium to post-weaning rats. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 9:477–484Google Scholar
  34. Hamilton SJ, Wiedmeyer RH (1990) Concentrations of boron, molybdenum, and selenium in chinook salmon. Trans Am Fish Soc 119:500–510Google Scholar
  35. Hamilton SJ, Buhl KJ, Faerber NL, Wiedmeyer RH, Bullard FA (1990) Toxicity of organic selenium in the diet to Chinook salmon. Environ Toxicol Chem 9:347–358Google Scholar
  36. Harr JR, Muth OH (1972) Selenium poisoning in domestic animals and its relationship to man. Clin Toxicol 5:175–186Google Scholar
  37. Heinz GH, Sanderson CJ (1990) Avoidance of selenium-treated food by mallards. Environ Toxicol Chem 9:1155–1158Google Scholar
  38. Heinz GH, Hoffman DJ, Gold LG (1988) Toxicity of organic and inorganic selenium to mallard ducklings. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 17:561–568Google Scholar
  39. —, —, — (1989) Impaired reproduction of mallards fed an organic form of selenium. J Wildl Manage 53:418–428Google Scholar
  40. Heinz GH, Hoffman DJ, Krynitsky AJ, Weller DMG (1987) Reproduction in mallards fed selenium. Environ Toxicol Chem 6:423–433Google Scholar
  41. Heinz GH, Pendleton GW, Krynitsky AJ, Gold LG (1990) Selenium accumulation and elimination in mallards. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 19:374–379Google Scholar
  42. Hoffman DJ, Heinz GH (1988) Embryotoxic and teratogenic effects of selenium in the diet of mallards. J Toxicol Environ Health 24:477–490Google Scholar
  43. Hoffman DJ, Ohlendorf HM, Aldrich TW (1988) Selenium teratogenesis in natural populations of aquatic birds in Central California. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 17:519–525Google Scholar
  44. Hoffman RD, Bookhout TA (1985) Metabolizable energy of seeds consumed by ducks in Lake Erie marshes. Trans North Am Wildl Natur Resour Conf 50:557–565Google Scholar
  45. Hothem RL, Ohlendorf HM (1989) Contaminants in foods of aquatic birds at Kesterson Reservoir, California, 1985. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 18:773–786Google Scholar
  46. Humphrey SR (1982) Bats. In: Chapman JA, Feldhamer GA (eds) Wild mammals of North America, biology, management, and economics. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD, pp 52–70Google Scholar
  47. Jensen LS (1975) Modification of a selenium toxicity in chicks by dietary silver and copper. J Nutr 105:769–775Google Scholar
  48. Koller LD, Exon JH (1986) The two faces of selenium—deficiency and toxicity—are similar in animals and man. Can J Vet Res 50:297–306Google Scholar
  49. Latshaw JD, Osman M (1975) Distribution of selenium in egg white and yolk after feeding natural and synthetic selenium compounds. Poultry Sci 54:1244–1252Google Scholar
  50. Leisenring W, Ryan LM (in press) Statistical properties of the NOAEL. Reg Toxicol PharmacolGoogle Scholar
  51. Lemly AD (1985a) Toxicology of selenium in a freshwater reservoir: implications for environmental hazard evaluation and safety. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 10:314–318Google Scholar
  52. — (1985b) Ecological basis for regulating aquatic emissions from the power industry: the case with selenium. Reg Toxicol Pharmacol 5:465–486Google Scholar
  53. Lemly AD, Smith GJ (1987) Aquatic cycling of selenium: Implications for fish and wildlife. US Fish Wildl Serv, Fish Wildl Leafl #12 10 ppGoogle Scholar
  54. Linscombe G, Kinler N, Aulerich RJ (1982) Mink. In: Chapman JA, Feldhamer GA (eds) Wild mammals of North America, biology, management, and economics. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD, pp 629–643Google Scholar
  55. Maier KJ, Foe C, Ogle RS, Williams MJ, Knight AW, Kiffney P, Melton LA (1987) The dynamics of selenium in aquatic ecosystems. In: Hemphill DD (ed) Trace substances in environmental health. University of Missouri, Columbia, MO, pp 361–408Google Scholar
  56. Maser C, Mate BR, Franklin JF, Dyrness CT (1984) Natural history of Oregon coast mammals. Museum of Natural History, University of Oregon, EugeneGoogle Scholar
  57. Mason CF, Macdonald SM (1986) Otters: Ecology and conservation. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  58. Moxon AL, Rhian MA (1943) Selenium poisoning. Physiol Rev 23:305–337Google Scholar
  59. Muth OH, Binns W (1964) Selenium toxicity in domestic animals. Ann NY Acad Sci 111:583–590Google Scholar
  60. Muth OH (ed) (1967) Selenium in biomedicine. First International Symposium, Oregon State University, 1966. AVI Publishing Company, Westport, CTGoogle Scholar
  61. Nagy KA (1987) Field metabolic rate and food requirement scaling in mammals and birds. Ecol Monogr 57:111–128Google Scholar
  62. National Academy of Science-National Research Council (1976) Selenium. Comm on medical and biological effects of environmental pollutants. NAS-NRC, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  63. — (1980) Mineral tolerance of domestic animals. Subcomm on mineral toxicity in animals, Comm on animal nutrition. NAS-NRC, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  64. — (1983) Selenium in Nutrition. Subcomm on mineral toxicity in animals, Comm on animal nutrition. NAS-NRC, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  65. Neve J, Favier A (eds) (1988) Selenium in medicine and biology. Walter de Gruyter & Co, Berlin, Germany, 197 ppGoogle Scholar
  66. Newell AJ, Johnson DW, Allen LK (1987) Niagara River biota contamination project: Fish flesh criteria for piscivorous wildlife. Technical Report 87-3, Division of Fish and Wildlife, Bureau of Environmental Protection, New York State Department of Environmental ConservationGoogle Scholar
  67. Norton S, McVey M, Colt J, Durda J, Hegner R (1988) Review of ecological risk assessment methods. US Environmental Protection Agency, EPA/230-10-88-041, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  68. Oehme FW (ed) (1978) Toxicity of heavy metals in the environment, Part I. Marcel Dekker, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  69. Ohlendorf HM (1989) Bioaccumulation and effects of selenium in wildlife. In: Jacobs LW (ed) Selenium in agriculture and the environment. SSSA Spec Publ No 23, American Society of Agronomy and Soil Science Society of America, Madison, WI pp 314–338Google Scholar
  70. Ohlendorf HM, Skorupa JP (1989) Selenium in relation to wildlife and agricultural drainage water. In: Carapella SC Jr (ed) Proceedings of the Fourth International Symposium on Uses of Selenium and Tellurium. Selenium-Tellurium Development Association, Inc, Darien, CNGoogle Scholar
  71. Ohlendorf HM, Hoffman DJ, Saiki MK, Aldrich TW (1986a) Embryonic mortality and abnormalities of aquatic birds: Apparent impacts of selenium from irrigation drainwater. Sci Total Environ 52:49–63Google Scholar
  72. Ohlendorf HM, Hothem RL, Aldrich TW (1988a) Bioaccumulation of selenium by snakes and frogs in the San Joaquin Valley, California. Copeia 1988:704–710Google Scholar
  73. Ohlendorf HM, Hothem RL, Aldrich TW, Krynitsky AJ (1987) Selenium contamination of the Grasslands, a major California waterfowl area. Sci Total Environ 66:169–183Google Scholar
  74. Ohlendorf HM, Hothem RL, Bunck CM, Aldrich TW, Moore JF (1986b) Relationships between selenium concentrations and avian reproduction. Trans North Am Wildl Natur Resour Conf 51:330–342Google Scholar
  75. Ohlendorf HM, Hothem RL, Bunck CM, Marois KC (1990) Bioaccumulation of selenium in birds at Kesterson Reservoir, California. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 19:495–507Google Scholar
  76. Ohlendorf HM, Hothem RL, Welsh D (1989) Nest Success, cause-specific nest failure, and hatchability of aquatic birds at selenium-contaminated Kesterson Reservoir and a reference site. Condor 91:787–796Google Scholar
  77. Ohlendorf HM, Kilness AW, Simmons JL, Stroud RK, Hoffman DJ, Moore JF (1988b) Selenium toxicosis in wild aquatic birds. J Toxicol Environ Health 24:67–92Google Scholar
  78. Olson OE (1986) Selenium toxicity in animals with emphasis on man. J Amer Coll Toxicol 5(1):45–70Google Scholar
  79. Ort JF, Latshaw JD (1978) The toxic level of sodium selenite in the diet of laying chickens. J Nutr 108:1114–1120Google Scholar
  80. Owen M, Black JM (1990) Waterfowl Ecology. Chapman and Hall, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  81. Owen RB Jr, Reinecke KJ (1979) Bioenergetics of breeding dabbling ducks. In: Bookhout TA (ed) Waterfowl and wetlands—An integrated review. North Cent Sect Wildl Soc, Madison, WI, pp 71–93Google Scholar
  82. Palmer RS (ed) (1988) Handbook of North American Birds, Volume 4. Yale University Press, New Haven, CTGoogle Scholar
  83. Peakall DB (1988) Known effects of pollutants on fish-eating birds in the Great Lakes of North America. In: Schmidtke NW (ed) Toxic Contamination in large lakes, volume 1, Chronic effects of toxic contaminants in large lakes. Lewis Publishers, Chelsea, MI, pp 39–54Google Scholar
  84. Poley WE, Moxon AL (1938) Tolerance levels of seleniferous grains in laying rations. Poultry Sci 17:72–76PubMedGoogle Scholar
  85. Poole AF (1989) Ospreys: A natural and unnatural history. Cambridge University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  86. Presser TS, Ohlendorf HM (1987) Biogeochemical cycling of selenium in the San Joaquin Valley, California, USA. Environ Manage 11:805–821Google Scholar
  87. Prince HH (1979) Bioenergetics of postbreeding dabbling ducks. In: Bookhout TA (ed) Waterfowl and wetlands—An integrated review. North Cent Sect Wildl Soc, Madison, WI, pp 103–117Google Scholar
  88. Prose BL (1985) Habitat suitability index models: Belted kingfisher. US Fish and Wildl Serv Biol Rep 82(10.87)Google Scholar
  89. Roelke ME, Schultz DP, Facemire CF, Sundlof SF (1991) Mercury contamination in the free-ranging endangered Florida panther (Felis concolor coryi). Proceedings American Association of Zoo Veterinarians, pp 277–283Google Scholar
  90. Romijn CAFM, Luttik R, Meent DVD, Slooff W, Canton JH (1991) Presentation and analysis of a general algorithm for risk-assessment on secondary poisoning. National Institute of Public Health and Environmental Protection, Report no 679102002. Bilthoven, The NetherlandsGoogle Scholar
  91. Rosenfeld I, Beath OA (1964) Selenium: Geobotany, biochemistry, toxicity, and nutrition. Academic Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  92. Sager DR, Cofield CR (1984) Differential accumulation of selenium among axial muscles, reproductive and liver tissues of four warm-water fish species. Water Resour Bull 20:359–363CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. Saiki MK (1986a) A field example of selenium contamination in an aquatic food chain. In: Proceedings of the First Annual Environmental Symposium: Selenium in the environment. California Agricultural Technology Institute, Fresno, CA, pp 67–76Google Scholar
  94. --(1986b) Concentrations of selenium in aquatic food-chain organisms and fish exposed to agricultural tile drainage water. In: Howard AQ (ed) Selenium and agricultural drainage: implications for San Francisco Bay and the California environment. Proc Second Selenium Symposium, Berkeley, CA, pp 25–33Google Scholar
  95. Saiki MK, Lowe TP (1987) Selenium in aquatic organisms from subsurface agricultural drainage water, San Joaquin Valley, California. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 16:657–670Google Scholar
  96. Schmitt CJ, Brumbaugh WG (1990) National contaminant biomonitoring program: Concentrations of arsenic, cadmium, copper, lead, mercury, selenium, and zinc in U.S. freshwater fish, 1976–1984. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 19:731–747Google Scholar
  97. Schuler CA, Anthony RG, Ohlendorf HM (1990) Selenium in wetlands and waterfowl foods at Kesterson Reservoir, California, 1984. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 19:845–853Google Scholar
  98. Skorupa JP, Ohlendorf HM (1991) Contaminants in drainage water and avian risk thresholds. In: Dinar A, Zilberman D (eds) The economy and management of water and drainage in agriculture. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Norwell, MA, pp 345–368Google Scholar
  99. Smith GJ, Heinz GH, Hoffman DJ, Spann JW, Krynitsky AJ (1988) Reproduction in black-crowned night-herons fed selenium. Lake Reservoir Manage 4:175–180Google Scholar
  100. Stalmaster MV, Gessaman JA (1984) Ecological energetics and foraging behavior of overwintering bald eagles. Ecol Monogr 54:407–428Google Scholar
  101. Stephan CE, Mount DI, Hansen DJ, Gentile JH, Chapman GA, Brungs WA (1985) Guidelines for deriving numerical national water quality criteria for the protection of aquatic organisms and their uses. National Technical Information Service, PB85–227049, Springfield, VAGoogle Scholar
  102. Swanson GA, Krapu GL, Serie JR (1979) Foods of laying female dabbling ducks on the breeding grounds. In: Bookhout TA (ed) Waterfowl and wetlands—An integrated review. North Cent Sect Wildl Soc, Madison, WI pp 47–57Google Scholar
  103. Swanson GA, Meyer MI, Adomaitis VA (1985) Foods consumed by breeding mallards on wetlands of south-central North Dakota. J Wildl Manage 49:197–203Google Scholar
  104. Toweill DE, Tabor JE (1982) River otter. In: Chapman JA, Feldhamer GA (eds) Wild mammals of North America, biology, management, and economics. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD, pp 688–703Google Scholar
  105. US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) (1980) Ambient water quality criteria for selenium. Office of Water Regulations and Standards, EPA/5-80-070, NTIS PB81-117814 Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  106. --(1984) Health effects assessment for selenium (and compounds). Environmental Criteria and Assessment Office, EPA/540/1-86/058, NTIS PB86-134699, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  107. --(1987) Ambient water quality criteria for selenium-1987. Office of Water Regulations and Standards, EPA-440/5-87-006, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  108. US General Accounting Office (1987) National refuge contamination is difficult to clean up. Resources, Community, and Economic Development Division, GAO/RCED-87-128, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  109. Weseloh DV, Teeple SM, Gilbertson M (1983) Double-crested cormorants of the Great Lakes: egg-laying parameters, reproductive failure, and contaminant residues in eggs, Lake Huron 1972–1973. Can J Zool 61:427–436Google Scholar
  110. World Health Organization (1987) Selenium: Environmental health criteria 58. World Health Organization, GenevaGoogle Scholar
  111. Wilber CG (1980) Toxicology of selenium: A review. Clin Toxicol 17:171–230Google Scholar
  112. — (1983) Selenium: A potential poison and a necessary food constituent. Charles C. Thomas, Springfield, ILGoogle Scholar
  113. Williams B, Marcy S, Gerould S (1989a) Water quality criteria to protect wildlife resources. Environmental Research Laboratory, Corvallis, OR, EPA/600/3–89/067, NTIS PB 89 220 016Google Scholar
  114. Williams ML, Hothem RL, Ohlendorf HM (1989b) Recruitment failure in American avocets and black-necked stilts nesting at Kesterson Reservoir, California, 1984–1985. Condor 91:797–802PubMedGoogle Scholar
  115. Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (WDNR) (1990) Technical Support Document for Chapters NR102 & NR105 of the Wisconsin Administrative Code. Madison, WIGoogle Scholar
  116. Zingaro RA, Cooper WC (eds) (1974) Selenium. Van Nostrand Reinhold Co, New YorkGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag New York Inc 1992

Authors and Affiliations

  • Jeffrey A. Peterson
    • 1
  • Alan V. Nebeker
    • 2
  1. 1.USEPA Environmental Research LaboratoryManTech Environmental Technology, Inc.CorvallisUSA
  2. 2.USEPA Environmental Research LaboratoryCorvallisUSA
  3. 3.Department of Integrative BiologyUniversity of CaliforniaBerkeleyUSA

Personalised recommendations