Do prices reflect market fundamentals in real estate markets?

  • Louis O. Scott
Article

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to examine prices on land and REIT shares for possible evidence of deviations from market fundamentals, the underlying economic forces. Models of market fundamentals are developed from the intertemporal capital asset pricing model so that risk aversion and a stochastic investment opportunity set can be incorporated in the analysis. The approach in this article is to compare ex post values of actual discounted cash flows with prices and to test whether the price series are unbiased predictors of the future discounted cash flows. Several tests of the relationship are presented, and the results suggest that prices of real estate investment trusts and prices of farm land do not always reflect fundamental value.

Key words

valuation land REIT prices 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Campbell, John Y. and Shiller, Robert J. “Cointegration and Tests of Present Value Models”. Journal of Political Economy 95 (October 1987), 1062–1088.Google Scholar
  2. Chamberlain, Gary. “Funds, Factors, and Diversification in Arbitrage Pricing Models”. Econometrica 51 (September 1983), 1305–1324.Google Scholar
  3. — and Rothschild, Michael. “Arbitrage, Factor Structure, and Mean-Variance Analysis on Large Asset Markets.” Econometrica 51 (September 1983, 1281–1304.Google Scholar
  4. Durlauf, Steven N. and Hall Robert E. “Bounds on the Variances of Specification Errors in Models with Expectations.” Stanford University, November 1988.Google Scholar
  5. -Durlauf, Steven N. and Hall Robert E. “Measuring Noise in Stock Prices.” Stanford University, January 1989.Google Scholar
  6. Flood, Robert P. and Hodrick, Robert J. “Asset Price Volatility, Bubbles and Process Switching.” Journal of Finance 41 (September 1986), 831–842.Google Scholar
  7. Grebler, Leo and Mittelbach, Frank G. The Inflation of House Prices: Its Extent, Causes and Consequences. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1979.Google Scholar
  8. Grossman, Sanford and Shiller, Robert J. “The Determinants of the Variability of Stock Market Prices.” American Economic Review 71 (May 1981), 222–227.Google Scholar
  9. Hannan, E.J. Multiple Time Series. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1970.Google Scholar
  10. Hoyt, Homer. One Hundred Years of Land Values in Chicago: The Relationship of the Growth of Chicago to the Rise in its Land Values, 1830–1933. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1933).Google Scholar
  11. Johnson, Brace B. “An Active Land Market in Perspective.” Farm Real Estate Market Developments CD-71 (December 1986), 27–33.Google Scholar
  12. Kau, James B. and Sirmans, C.F. “Changes in Urban Land Values: 1836–1970.” Journal of Urban Economics15 (January 1984), 18–25.Google Scholar
  13. Kleidon, Allan W. “Variance Bounds Tests and Stock Price Valuation Models.” Journal of Political Economy 94 (October 1986), 953–1001.Google Scholar
  14. Kost, Willaim F. “Rates of Return for Farm Real Estate and Common Stock.” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 50 (May 1968), 213–224.Google Scholar
  15. LeRoy, Stephen F. and Porter, Richard D. “The Present-Value Relation: Tests Based on Implied Variance Bounds.” Econometrica 49 (May 1981), 555–574.Google Scholar
  16. — and LaCivita, C.J. “Risk Aversion and the Dispersions of Asset Prices.” Journal of Business 54 (October 1981), 535–547.Google Scholar
  17. —, “Expectations Models of Asset Prices: A Survey of Theory.” Journal of Finance 37 (March 1982), 185–218.Google Scholar
  18. Lucas, Robert. “Asset Prices in an Exchange Economy.” Econometrica 46 (November 1978), 1429–1445.Google Scholar
  19. Malkiel, Burton G. A Random Walk Down Wall Street, 4th ed. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1985.Google Scholar
  20. Mankiw, N. Gregory; Romer, David; and Shapiro, Matthew D. “An Unbiased Reexamination of Stock Market Volatility.” Journal of Finance 40 (July 1985), 677–687.Google Scholar
  21. Marsh, Terry A. and Merton, Robert C. “Dividend Volatility and Variance Bounds Tests for Rationality of Stock Market Prices.” American Economic Review 76 (June 1986), 485–498.Google Scholar
  22. Nerlove, Marc; Grether, David M. and Carvolho, Jose L. Analysis of Economic Time Series: A Synthesis. New York: Academic Press, 1979.Google Scholar
  23. Scofield, William H. “Land Prices and Farm Earnings.” Farm Real Estate Market Developments CD-66 (October 1964), 39–47.Google Scholar
  24. —,“Land Returns and Farm Income.” Farm Real Estate Market Developments CD-67 (August 1965), 44–54.Google Scholar
  25. Scott, Louis O. “The Present Value Model of Stock Prices: Regression Tests and Monte Carlo Results.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 67 (November 1985), 599–605.Google Scholar
  26. -Scott, Louis O., “Estimating the Marginal Rate of Substitution in the Intertemporal Capital Asset Pricing Model and Testing Stock Market Rationality.” The Review of Economics and Statistics, forthcoming (1989).Google Scholar
  27. Shiller, Robert J. “Do Stock Prices Move Too Much to be Justified by Subsequent Changes in Dividends?” American Economic Review 71 (June 1981), 421–436.Google Scholar
  28. -Shiller, Robert J., “Consumption, Asset Markets and Macroeconomic Fluctuations.” National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 838, January 1982, and Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series, 1982.Google Scholar
  29. Summers, Lawrence H. “Does the Stock Market Rationally Reflect Fundamental Value?” Journal of Finance 41 (July 1986), 591–600.Google Scholar
  30. Williams, John B. The Theory of Investment Value. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1938.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1990

Authors and Affiliations

  • Louis O. Scott
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Banking and Finance, Brooks HallUniversity of GeorgiaAthensUSA

Personalised recommendations