Higher Education

, Volume 20, Issue 4, pp 411–442 | Cite as

Essay-writing: what really counts?

  • Linda S. Norton


This study uses objective measures from essay scripts to report on the interaction between students' strategies in essay writing and tutors' strategies in marking. 98 1st year psychology students completed questionnaires on their essay writing strategies and submitted their essays for analysis. Six tutors who marked the essays were subsequently interviewed. The results indicate that the amount of time spent on the essay, the number of books used, the number of references cited and proportion of research based content actually found in the essays were all strategies that led to higher essay marks. However, there was clear evidence of a mismatch between students and tutors on their perceptions of the most important criteria - students were more concerned with content, whereas tutors were more concerned with argument.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Bizzell, P. and Singleton, R. (1988). ‘What can we do about essay exams?’, Teaching Sociology 16, 177–179.Google Scholar
  2. Blackey, R. (1988). ‘Bull's-eye: a teacher's guide for developing student skill in responding to essay questions’, Social Education 52 (6), 464–466.Google Scholar
  3. Branthwaite, A., Trueman, M. and Hartley, J. (1980). ‘Writing essays: the actions and strategies of students’, in Hartley, J. (ed.), The Psychology of Written Communication: Selected Readings. London: Kogan Page.Google Scholar
  4. Cirino-Gerena, S. (1981). ‘Strategies in answering essay tests’, Teaching of Psychology 8, 53–54.Google Scholar
  5. Clanchy, J. and Ballard, B. (1983). How to Write Essays. A Practical Guide for Students. Melbourne: Longman Cheshire.Google Scholar
  6. Daly, J. A. and Dickson-Markman, F. (1982). ‘Contrast effects in evaluating essays’, Journal of Educational Measurement 19 (4), 309–316.Google Scholar
  7. Fox, H. W. (1977). ‘Helping students write good essay examinations’, Journal of Business Education 52 (7), 305–306.Google Scholar
  8. Freedman, S. W. (1979). ‘How characteristics of student essays influence teachers' evaluations’, Journal of Educational Psychology 71 (3), 328–338.Google Scholar
  9. Freeman, R. (1982). Mastering Study Skills. London: Macmillan Press.Google Scholar
  10. Gibbs, G. (1981). Teaching Students to Learn. A Student-Centred Approach. Milton Keynes: The Open University Press.Google Scholar
  11. Hall, C. G. W. and Daglish, N. D. (1982). ‘Length and quality: an exploratory study of writer-marker reliability’, Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education 7 (2), 186–191.Google Scholar
  12. Hall, J. (1989). Essays and Exams: A Practical Approach for Students. Cambridge: University of Cambridge Local Examinations Syndicate.Google Scholar
  13. Hartley, J. (1984). ‘How can tutors help students to write essays?’, in Shaw, K. E. (ed.), Aspects of Educational Technology, Vol. XVII. London: Kogan Page, pp. 74–79.Google Scholar
  14. Hartley, J. (1987). Unpublished questionnaire on students' essay-writing strategies: University of Keele.Google Scholar
  15. Hartley, J. and Branthwaite, A. (1976). ‘All this for two percent: the contribution of course-work assessment to the final grade’, Durham Research Review VIII (37), 14–20.Google Scholar
  16. Hartley, J. and Davies, I. K. (1978). ‘Note taking: a critical review’, Programmed Learning and Educational Technology 15, 207–224.Google Scholar
  17. Hounsell, D. (1984). ‘Learning and essay writing’, in Marton, F., Hounsell, D. and Entwistle, N. (eds.), The Experience of Learning. Edinburgh: Scottish Academic Press.Google Scholar
  18. Hughes, D. C., Keeling, B. and Tuck, B. F. (1983). ‘Effects of achievement expectations and handwriting quality on scoring essays’, Journal of Educational Measurement 20 (1), 65–70.Google Scholar
  19. Kegley, P. H. (1986). ‘The effect of mode discourse on student writing performance: implications for policy’, Educational Evaluation & Policy Analysis 8 (2), 147–154.Google Scholar
  20. Lewis, R. (1979). How to Write Essays. Oxford: Heinemann Educational.Google Scholar
  21. Martin, N. (1979). ‘Essay assignments and their grades’, Teaching at a Distance 15, 50–56.Google Scholar
  22. McLaughlin Cook, N. (1984). ‘What is the value of planning essays in psychology examinations?’, Psychology Teaching, December, 21–26.Google Scholar
  23. Miller, C. M. L. and Parlett, M. (1974). Up to the Mark. A Study of the Examination Game. London: Society for Research into Higher Education.Google Scholar
  24. Norton, L. S. (1980). ‘Study skills: can they be taught? Some approaches to student learning’, Psyklops 3 (2), 19–23. (Journal of Psychology Department, University of Keele).Google Scholar
  25. Norton, L. S. (1981). ‘The effects of notetaking and subsequent use on long-term recall’, Programmed Learning and Educational Technology 18 (1), 16–22.Google Scholar
  26. Norton, L. S. and Hartley, J. (1986). ‘What factors contribute to good examination marks? The role of notetaking in subsequent examination performance’, Higher Education 15, 355–371.Google Scholar
  27. Reed, W. M. and Burton, J. K. (1985). ‘Effective and ineffective evaluation of essays: perceptions of college freshmen, Journal of Teaching Writing 4 (2), 270–283.Google Scholar
  28. Siann, G. and French, K. (1975). ‘Edinburgh University students' views on continuous assessment’, Durham Research Review II (35), 1064–1070.Google Scholar
  29. Wheeler, M. (1983). Counselling in Study Methods. Exeter: Exeter University Teaching Services.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1990

Authors and Affiliations

  • Linda S. Norton
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of PsychologyLiverpool Institute of Higher EducationLiverpoolUK

Personalised recommendations