Advertisement

Cooperation between humans and machines: First results of an experiment with a multi-level cooperative organisation in air traffic control

  • M. P. Lemoine
  • S. Debernard
  • I. Crevits
  • P. Millot
Article

Abstract

The increasing air traffic and the ensuing increasing burden on air traffic controllers suggest to attempt to provide enhanced assistance to air traffic controllers. As it is difficult to reduce the number of primary tasks, a solution is to give active assistance to controllers by means of computer tools that allow for optimal control in order to maintain the level of safety and at the same time regulate the air traffic controllers' workload.

The objective of our research is to propose and validate a new organisation of air traffic control. It aims at integrating both levels of the organisation of air traffic control: a tactical level managed by a radar controller and a strategic level managed by a organic controller. Our study at first addresses the tactical level, aiming at ‘horizontal cooperation’ consisting in dynamic allocation of control tasks between a human air traffic controller and an assistance tool. The results of this first approach has oriented the study toward the implementation of a scheduling module for the tactical level.

This paper reports the functionalities of air-traffic control and the results of few preceding experiments. A description of the new multi-level organisation is given, to conduce to the presentation of experimental platform, experimental protocol and the first results of experiments.

Key words

air traffic control human-machine cooperation dynamic task allocation load evaluation tasks allocation criterion 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Angerand, L. and H. Le Jeannie (1992): Bilan du projet SAINTEX, Note R92009, Centre d'Etude de la Navigation Aérienne. CENA-DGAC: Paris.Google Scholar
  2. Crévits, I., M.-P. Lemoine, S. Debernard, and P. Millot (1993): Etude d'un système de partage dynamique de tâches entre contrôleurs du trafic aérien et système automatisé; Evaluation d'une aide multiniveau, Rapport final de contrat. Convention LAIH/CENA 91/00008. Université de Valenciennes: Valenciennes, France.Google Scholar
  3. Debernard, S., F. Vanderhaegen, and P. Millot (1992): An Experimental Investigation of Dynamic Allocation of Task between Air Traffic Controller and A.I. System. In MMS'92. 5th IFAC/IFIP/IFORS/IEA, Symposium on Analysis, Design and Evaluation of Man-Machine Systems. The Hague, The Netherlands, June 9–11 1992, pp. 95–100.Google Scholar
  4. Debernard, S., F. Vanderhaegen, N. Debbache, and P. Millot (1990): Dynamic Task Allocation between Controller and A.I. systems in Air Traffic Control. In Proceedings of the 9th European Annual Conference on Human Decision Making and Manual Control, Ispra, Italy, pp. 183–192.Google Scholar
  5. Gondran and M. Minoux (1985): Graphes et algorithmes. Collection de la direction des études et recherches d'Electricité De France. Editions Eyrolles: France.Google Scholar
  6. Greenstein, J.S. and S.T. Lam (1985):An Experimental Study of Dialogue-Based Communication for Dynamic Human-Computer Task Allocation. International Journal of Man-Machine Studies, vol. 23, no. 6, pp. 605–621.Google Scholar
  7. Kamoun, A. (1989): Contribution à la Répartition Dynamique des Tâches entre Opérateur et Calculateur pour la Supervision des Procédés Automatisés. Thèse de Doctoral. Université de Valenciennes: Valenciennes, France.Google Scholar
  8. Kamoun, A., S. Debernard, and P. Millot (1989): Comparison between Two Dynamic Task Allocations. Proceedings of the 2nd European Meeting on Cognitive Science Approaches to Process Control, Siena, Italy. In Proceedings of the 9th European Annual Conference on Human Decision Making and Manual Control, Ispra, Italy, October 2–7 1989.Google Scholar
  9. Lemoine, M.-P., J.-M. Hoc, and S. Debernard (1994a): Etude d'un système de partage dynamique de tâches entre contrôleurs du trafic aérien et système automatisé; Présentation des expérimentations sur SPECTRA V2, Second rapport intermédiaire de contrat. Convention LAIH/CENA 91/00008. Université de Valenciennes: Valenciennes, France.Google Scholar
  10. Millot, P. (1988): Supervision des procédés automatisés et ergonomie. Hermes: France.Google Scholar
  11. Mordchelles, P., H. Angebault, and L. Angerand (1989): Système expert pour le contrôle automatique de nuit, Rapport fin d'étude. CENA-DGAC: Paris.Google Scholar
  12. Millot, P. and A. Kamoun (1988): An Implicit Method for Dynamic Task Allocation between Man and Computer in Supervion Posts of Automated Processes. In Proceedings of the 3rd IFAC Congress, Analysis Design and Evaluation of Man-Machine Systems, OULU, Finland. 14–16 June 1988, pp.135–140.Google Scholar
  13. Revesman, M.E. and J.S. Greenstein (1986):Application of a Mathematical Model of Human Decision Making for a Human-Computer Communication. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics, vol. 16, no. 1, pp. 142–147.Google Scholar
  14. Taborin, V. (1989): Coopération entre opérateur et système d'aide à la décision pour la conduite des procédés continus: Application à l'interface opérateur-système expert du projet Alliance. Thèse de Doctorat, Université de Valenciennes: Valenciennes, France.Google Scholar
  15. Taborin, V. and P. Millot (1989): Cooperation between Man and Decision Aid System in Supervisory Loop of Continuous Processes. Proceedings of the 8th European Annual Conference on Decision Making and Manual Control, Copenhagen, Denmark, June 12–14 1989, pp. 188–207.Google Scholar
  16. Vanderhaegen, F., S. Debernard, and P. Millot (1991): Man-Machine Cooperation in Air Traffic Control. In Proceedings of the 10th European Annual Conference on Decision Making and Manual Control, Liège, Belgium, November 11–13 1991, pp. 212–227.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1996

Authors and Affiliations

  • M. P. Lemoine
    • 1
  • S. Debernard
    • 1
  • I. Crevits
    • 1
  • P. Millot
    • 1
  1. 1.Laboratoire d'Automatique et de Mécanique Industrielle et Humaine, URA CNRS 1775Université de Valenciennes et du Hainaut CambrésisValenciennes CédexFrance

Personalised recommendations