Advertisement

Biology and Philosophy

, Volume 1, Issue 1, pp 53–87 | Cite as

Colleagues in conflict: An ‘in vivo’ analysis of the sociobiology controversy

  • Ullica Segerstrale
Article

Abstract

Edward O. Wilson's forays into human sociobiology have been the target of persistent, vehement attack by his Harvard colleague in evolutionary biology, Richard C. Lewontin. Through examination of existing “documents in the case”, together with in-depth personal interviews of Wilson, Lewontin, and other biologists, the reasons for Wilson's stance and Lewontin's criticisms are uncovered. It is argued that the dispute is not primarily personally or politically motivated, but involves a conflict between long-term scientific-cum-moral agendas, with the “reductionist program” as a key issue. It is concluded that it is in the interest of both disputants to keep the controversy alive.

Keywords

E. O. Wilson R. C. Lewontin sociobiology 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Albury, W. R.: 1980., ‘Politics and Rhetoric in the Sociobiology Debate’, Social Studies of Science 10, 519–536.Google Scholar
  2. Bouchier, D.: 1977, ‘Radical Ideologies and the Sociology of Knowledge’, Sociology 11, 29–46.Google Scholar
  3. Allen, E. et al.: 1975, ‘Against Sociobiology’, The New York Review of Books, November 13.Google Scholar
  4. Caplan, A. (ed.): 1978. The Sociobiology Debate, Harper and Row, New York.Google Scholar
  5. Cavalli-Sforza, L. L. and M. W. Feldman: 1981, Cultural Transmission and Evolution, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.Google Scholar
  6. Davis, B. D.: 1975, ‘Social Determinism and Behavioral Genetics’, Science 189, 1049.Google Scholar
  7. Davis, B. D.: 1976, ‘Letter to The Harvard Crimson’, The Harvard Crimson, May 19.Google Scholar
  8. Davis, B. D.: 1978, ‘The Moralistic Fallacy’, Nature 272, 390.Google Scholar
  9. Davis, B. D. 1980, ‘The Importance of Human Individuality for Sociobiology’, Zygon 15, 275–293.Google Scholar
  10. Dawkins, R.: 1976, The Selfish Gene, Oxford University Press, New York.Google Scholar
  11. Dawkins, R.: 1979, ‘Twelve Misunderstandings of Kin Selection’, Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie 51, 184–200.Google Scholar
  12. Dobzhansky, T.: 1968, ‘On Genetics and Politics’, Social Education 32, 142–146.Google Scholar
  13. Dobzhansky, T.: 1974, ‘Is Genetic Diversity Compatible with Human Equality?’, Social Biology 20, 280–288.Google Scholar
  14. Freedman, D.: 1979, Human Sociobiology: A Holistic Approach, The Free Press, New York.Google Scholar
  15. Ghiselin, M.: 1974, The Economy of Nature and the Evolution of Sex, University of California Press, Berkeley, CA.Google Scholar
  16. Gould, S. J.: 1977, ‘Caring Groups and Selfish Genes’, Natural History, December 1977.Google Scholar
  17. Gould, S. J.: 1981, The Mismeasure of Man, W. W. Norton, New York.Google Scholar
  18. Gould, S. J. and R. C. Lewontin: 1979, ‘The Spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian Paradigm: A Critique of the Adaptationist Programme’, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 205, 581–598.Google Scholar
  19. Graham, L. R.: 1979, ‘Political Ideology and Genetic Theory: Russia and Germany in 1920's’, Hastings Center Report 7, 30–39.Google Scholar
  20. Graham, L. R.: 1981, Between Science and Values, Columbia University Press, New York.Google Scholar
  21. Hampshire, S.: 1978, ‘The Illusion of Sociobiology’, The New York Review of Books, October 12, pp. 64–69.Google Scholar
  22. Haraway, D.: 1981–1982, ‘The High Cost of Information in Post-World War II Evolutionary Biology: Ergonomics, Semiotics and the Sociobiology of Communication Systems’, The Philosophical Forum 13, 244–278.Google Scholar
  23. Herrnstein, R.: 1973, IQ in the Meritocracy, Little, Brown, Boston.Google Scholar
  24. Jensen, A. R.: 1969, ‘How Much Can We Boost IQ and Scholastic Achievement?’, Harvard Educational Review 39, 1–123.Google Scholar
  25. Kamin, L.: 1974, The Science and Politics of IQ, Halsted Press, New York.Google Scholar
  26. Leach, E.: 1981, ‘Biology and Social Science: Wedding or Rape?’, Nature 291, 267–268.Google Scholar
  27. Levins, R.: 1968, Evolution in Changing Environments, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.Google Scholar
  28. Levins, R. and R. C. Lewontin: 1980, ‘Dialectics and Reductionism in Biology’, Synthese 43, 47–48.Google Scholar
  29. Levins, R. and R. C. Lewontin: 1985, The Dialectical Biologist, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
  30. Lewin, R.: 1981a, ‘Cultural Diversity Tied to Genetic Differences’, Science 212, 908–909.Google Scholar
  31. Lewin, R.: 1981b, ‘Do Jumping Genes Make Evolutionary Leaps?’, Science 213, 634–636.Google Scholar
  32. Lewontin, R. C.: 1961, ‘Evolution and the Theory of Games’, Journal of Theoretical Biology 1, 382–403.Google Scholar
  33. Lewontin, R. C. (ed.): 1968, Population Biology and Evolution, Syracuse University Press, Syracuse, NY.Google Scholar
  34. Lewontin, R. C.: 1970, ‘Race and Intelligence’, Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, March 1970.Google Scholar
  35. Lewontin, R. C.: 1972a, ‘Testing the Theory of Natural Selection’, Nature 236, 181–182.Google Scholar
  36. Lewontin, R. C.: 1972b, ‘The Apportionment of Human Diversity’, Evolutionary Biology 6, 381–398.Google Scholar
  37. Lewontin, R. C.: 1974a, The Genetic Basis of Evolutionary Change, Columbia University Press, New York.Google Scholar
  38. Lewontin, R. C.: 1974b, ‘The Analysis of Variance and the Analysis of Causes’, American Journal of Human Genetics 26, 400–411.Google Scholar
  39. Lewontin, R. C.: 1975a, ‘Genetic Aspects of Intelligence’, Annual Review of Genetics 9, 387–405.Google Scholar
  40. Lewontin, R. C.: 1975b, Transcript of NOVA program No. 211, WBGH, Boston. Transmission by PBS on February 2, 1975.Google Scholar
  41. Lewontin, R. C.: 1976, ‘Sociobiology: A Caricature of Darwinism’, in F. Suppe and P. Asquith (eds.), Proceedings of the Philosophy of Science Association 2, 22–31, Philosophy of Science Association, East Lansing, Mich.Google Scholar
  42. Lewontin, R. C.: 1977a, ‘Caricature of Darwinism’, Nature 266, 283–284.Google Scholar
  43. Lewontin, R. C.: 1977b, ‘Biological Determinism as a Social Weapon’, in Ann Arbor Science for the People Editorial Collective (eds.), Biology as a Social Weapon, Burgess Press, Minneapolis, Minn., pp. 6–17.Google Scholar
  44. Lewontin, R. C.: 1978, ‘Fitness, Survival and Optimality’, in D. H. Horn, R. Mitchell and G. R. Stairs (eds.), Analysis of Ecological Systems, Ohio State University Press, Columbus, OH.Google Scholar
  45. Lewontin, R. C.: 1979, ‘Sociobiology as an Adaptationist Program’, Behavioral Science 24, 5–14.Google Scholar
  46. Lewontin, R. C.: 1981a, ‘Sleight of Hand’, The Sciences, July/August, 23–26.Google Scholar
  47. Lewontin, R. C.: 1981b, ‘The Inferiority Complex’, The New York Review of Books, October 22.Google Scholar
  48. Lewontin, R. C.: 1982a, ‘Is Intelligence for Real? An Exchange’, The New York Review of Books, February 4.Google Scholar
  49. Lewontin, R. C.: 1982b, ‘Keeping It Clean’, Nature 300, 113–114.Google Scholar
  50. Lewontin, R. C.: 1983, ‘The Corpse in the Elevator’, The New York Review of Books, January 20, 34–37.Google Scholar
  51. Lewontin, R. C. and J. L. Hubby: 1966, ‘A Molecular Approach to the Study of Genetic Heterozygosity in Natural Populations’, Genetics 54, 595–609.Google Scholar
  52. Lewontin, R. C. and R. Levins: 1976, ‘The Problem of Lysenkoism’, in H. Rose and S. Rose (eds.), The Radicalization of Science, Macmillan, London.Google Scholar
  53. Lumsden, C. J. and E. O. Wilson: 1981a, Genes, Mind, and Culture: The Coevolutionary Process, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
  54. Lumsden, C. J. and E. O. Wilson: 1981b, ‘Genes, Mind, and Ideology’, The Science November, 6–8.Google Scholar
  55. MacArthur, R. H. and E. O. Wilson: 1967, The Theory of Island Biogeography, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.Google Scholar
  56. Mackintosh, N. J.: 1979, ‘A Proffering of Underpinnings’, Science 204, 735–737.Google Scholar
  57. Maynard Smith, J.: 1975, ‘Survival through Suicide’, New Scientist 28, 496–497.Google Scholar
  58. Maynard Smith, J.: 1978a, ‘Constraints on Human Behavior’, Nature 276, 120–121.Google Scholar
  59. Maynard Smith, J.: 1978b, ‘Optimization Theory in Evolution’, Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 9, 31–56.Google Scholar
  60. Maynard Smith, J. and N. Warren: 1982, ‘Models of cultural and Genetic Change’, Evolution 36, 620–627.Google Scholar
  61. Medawar, P. B.: 1981, ‘Stretch Genes’, The New York Review of Books, July 16.Google Scholar
  62. Midgley, M.: 1980, ‘Rival Fatalisms: The Hollowness of the Sociobiology Debate’, in A. Montagu (ed.), Sociobiology Examined, Oxford University Press, Oxford and New York.Google Scholar
  63. Russett, C.: 1966, The Concept of Equilibrium in American Social Thought, Yale University Press, New Haven, Conn.Google Scholar
  64. Samelson, F.: 1982, ‘Intelligence of Man’, Science 215, 656–657.Google Scholar
  65. Segerstrale, U.: 1983, ‘Whose Truth Shall Prevail? Moral and Scientific Interests in the Sociobiology Controversy’, unpublished Ph.D. Thesis, Harvard University.Google Scholar
  66. Sociobiology Study Group of Science for the People: 1976, ‘Sociobiology — Another Biological Determinism’, BioScience 26, No. 3.Google Scholar
  67. Stent, G. S.: 1978, Paradoxes of Progress, Freeman, San Francisco, CA.Google Scholar
  68. Thoday, J. M.: 1981, ‘Probity in Science: the Case of Cyril Burt’, Nature 291, 517.Google Scholar
  69. Van den Berghe, P.: 1980, ‘Sociobiology: Several Views’, Bioscience 31, 406.Google Scholar
  70. Wade, N.: 1976, ‘Sociobiology: Troubled Birth for New Discipline’, Science 191, 1151–1158.Google Scholar
  71. Walsh, J.: 1976, ‘Science for the People: Comes the Evolution’, Science 191, 1033–1035.Google Scholar
  72. Wartofsky, M. W.: 1979, ‘Metaphysics as Heuristic for Science’, in R. S. Cohen and M. W. Wartofsky (eds.), Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science Vol. 129, D. Reidel, Dordrecht.Google Scholar
  73. Werskey, P. G.: 1978, The Visible College, Allen Lane, London.Google Scholar
  74. Wilson, E. O.: 1971a, The Insect Societies, Belknap Press, Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
  75. Wilson, E. O.: 1971b, ‘The Prospects for a Unified Sociobiology’, American Scientist 59, 400–403.Google Scholar
  76. Wilson, E. O.: 1971c, ‘Competitive and Aggressive Behavior’, in J. Eisenberg and W. Dillon (eds.), Man and Beast, Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
  77. Wilson, E. O.: 1975a, Sociobiology: The New Synthesis, Belknap Press, Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
  78. Wilson, E. O.: 1975b, ‘Human Decency Is Animal’, The New York Times Magazine, October 12.Google Scholar
  79. Wilson, E. O.: 1975c, ‘For Sociobiology’, The New York Review of Books, December 11.Google Scholar
  80. Wilson, E. O.: 1976, ‘Academic Vigilantism and the Political significance of sociobiology’, BioScience 26, 183–190.Google Scholar
  81. Wilson, E. O.: 1977, ‘The Social Instinct’, Bulletin of the American Academy for Arts and Sciences 30, 11–25.Google Scholar
  82. Wilson, E. O.: 1978a, On Human Nature, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
  83. Wilson, E. O.: 1978b, ‘The Attempt to Suppress Human Behavioral Genetics’, The Journal of General Education 29, 277–287.Google Scholar
  84. Wilson, E. O.: 1980, ‘The Relation of Science to Theology’, Zygon 15, 425–434.Google Scholar
  85. Wilson, E. O.: 1985, ‘Autobiographical Essay’, in Phillip L. Burman (ed.), The Courage of Conviction, Dodd, Meed, New York.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© D. Reidel Publishing Company 1986

Authors and Affiliations

  • Ullica Segerstrale
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Sociology and AnthropologySmith CollegeNorthamptonU.S.A.

Personalised recommendations