Abstract
In 2000, The Clay Minerals Society established a biennial quantitative mineralogy round robin. The so-called Reynolds Cup competition is named after Bob Reynolds for his pioneering work in quantitative clay mineralogy and exceptional contributions to clay science. The first contest was run in 2002 with 40 sets of three samples, which were prepared from mixtures of purified, natural, and synthetic minerals that are commonly found in clay-bearing rocks and soils and represent realistic mineral assemblages. The rules of the competition allow any method or combination of methods to be used in the quantitative analysis of the mineral assemblages. Throughout the competition, X-ray diffraction has been the method of choice for quantifying the mineralogy of the sample mixtures with a multitude of other techniques used to assist with phase identification and quantification. In the first twelve years of the Reynolds Cup competition (2002 to 2014), around 14,000 analyses from 448 participants have been carried out on a total of 21 samples. The data provided by these analyses constitute an extensive database on the accuracy of quantitative mineral analyses and also has given enough time for the progression of improvements in such analyses. In the Reynolds Cup competition, the accuracy of a particular quantification is judged by calculating a “bias” for each phase in an assemblage. Determining exactly the true amount of a phase in the assemblage would give a bias of zero. Generally, the higher placed participants correctly identified all or most of the mineral phases present. Conversely, the worst performers failed to identify or misidentified phases. Several contestants reported a long list of minor exotic phases, which were likely reported by automated search/match programs and were mineralogically implausible. Not surprisingly, clay minerals were among the greatest sources of error reported. This article reports on the first 12 years of the Reynolds Cup competition results and analyzes the competition data to determine the overall accuracy of the mineral assemblage quantities reported by the participants. The data from the competition were also used to ascertain trends in quantification accuracy over a 12 year period and to highlight sources of error in quantitative analyses.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Altomare, A., Burla, M. C., Giacovazzo, C., Guagliardi, A., Moliterni, A. G. G., Polidori, G., and Rizzi, R. (2001) Quanto: a Rietveld program for quantitative phase analysis of polycrystalline mixtures. Journal of Applied Crystallography, 34, 392–397.
Aplin, A.C., Matenaar, I.F., McCarty, D.K., and van der Pluijm, B.A. (2006) Influence of mechanical compaction and clay mineral diagenesis on the microfabric and porescale properties of deep-water Gulf of Mexico mudstones. Clays and Clay Minerals, 54, 500–514.
Bergmann, J. and Kleeberg, R. (1998) Rietveld analysis of disordered layer silicates. Materials Science Forum, 278-281(1), 300–305.
Blanc, P., Legendre, O., and Gaucher, E.C. (2007) Estimate of clay minerals amounts from XRD pattern modelling: The Arquant model. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, 32, 135–144.
Calvert, C.S., Palkowsky, D.A., and Pevear, D.R. (1989) A combined X-ray powder diffraction and chemical method for the quantitative mineral analysis of geological samples. Pp. 154–166 in: CMS Workshop Lectures, Volume 1, Quantitative Mineral Analysis of Clays. (D.R. Pevear and F.A. Mumpton, editors). The Clay Minerals Society, Evergreen, Colorado.
Chipera, S.J. and Bish, D.L. (2002) FULLPAT: A full-pattern quantitative analysis program for X-ray powder diffraction using measured and calculated patterns. Journal of Applied Crystallography, 35, 744–749.
Chung, F.H. (1974) Quantitative interpretation of X-ray diffraction patterns of mixtures. I. Matrix-flushing method for quantitative multicomponent analysis. Journal of Applied Crystallography, 7, 519–525.
Eberl, D.D. (2003) User’s guide to Rockjock a program for determining quantitative mineralogy from powder X-ray diffraction data. US Geological Survey, Open-File Report 03–78.
Harvey, C.C. and Lagaly, G. (2013) Industrial applications. Pp. 451–490 in: Handbook of Clay Science (F. Bergaya and G. Lagaly, editors). Developments in Clay Science. Vol. 5. Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Hillier, S. (2003) Quantitative analysis of clay and other minerals in sandstones by X-ray powder diffraction (XRPD). Pp. 213–251 in: Clay Mineral Cements in Sandstones (R.H. Worden and S. Morad, editors). Special Publication 34, International Association of Sedimentologists. Wiley-Blackwell.
Hubbard, C.R. and Snyder, R.L. (1988) RIR — Measurement and use in quantitative XRD. Powder Diffraction, 3(2), 74–77.
Hughes, H. and Hurley, P.W. (1987) Precision and accuracy of test methods and the concept of K-factors in chemical analysis. Analyst, 112, 1445–1449.
ISO (1994) Accuracy (trueness and precision) of measurement methods and results. Part 2: Basic method for the determination of repeatability and reproducibility of a standard measurement method. ISO Standard 5725-2:1994(E), section 7.5.
Kleeberg, R. (2005) Results of the second Reynolds Cup contest in quantitative mineral analysis. IUCr. CPD Newsletter, 30, 22–26
Larson, A.C. and Von Dreele, R.B. (2000) General Structure Analysis System (GSAS), Los Alamos National Laboratory Report LAUR 86–748.
Lutterotti, L., Matthies, S., and Wenk, H.-R. (1999) MAUD: a friendly Java program for material analysis using diffraction. IUCr CPD Newsletter, 21, 14–15.
Madsen, I.C., Scarlett, N.V.Y., Cranswick, L.M.D., and Lwin, T., (2001) Outcomes of the International Union of Crystallography Commission on Powder Diffraction round robin on quantitative phase analysis: samples 1a to 1h. Journal of Applied Crystallography, 34, 409–426.
McCarty, D.K. (2002) Quantitative mineral analysis of claybearing mixtures: The “Reynolds Cup” contest. IUCr CPD Newsletter, 27, 12–16.
Moore, D.M. and Reynolds, R.C. (1997) X-ray Diffraction and the Identification and Analysis of Clay Minerals. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Mystkowski, K., Środoń, J., and McCarty, D.K. (2002) Application of evolutionary programming to automatic XRD quantitative analysis of clay-bearing rocks. The Clay Minerals Society 39th Annual Meeting, Boulder, Colorado, Abstracts with Programs.
Omotoso, O., McCarty, D.K., Hillier, S., and Kleeberg, R. (2006) Some successful approaches to quantitative mineral analysis as revealed by the 3rd Reynolds Cup contest. Clays and Clay Minerals, 54, 751–763.
Ottner, F., Gier, S., Kuderna, M., and Schwaighofer, B. (2000) Results of inter-laboratory comparison of methods for quantitative clay analysis. Applied Clay Science, 17, 223–243.
Rancort, D.G. and Dang, M. (2005) Absolute quantification by powder X-ray diffraction of complex mixtures of crystalline and amorphous phases for applications in the Earth sciences. American Mineralogist, 90, 1571–1586.
Raven, M.D. and Self, P.G. (2012) Outcomes of the 2012 Reynolds Cup quantitative mineralogy competition. The Clay Minerals Society 49th Annual Meeting, Golden Colorado, Abstracts with Programs (http://csmfiles.com/dlcms.php?cms49_2011_golden_colorado_raven_abstract-20120430-0608.docx).
Reynolds, R.C. (1983) Calculation of absolute diffraction intensities for mixed-layered clays. Clays and Clay Minerals, 31, 233–234.
Rodriguez-Carvajal, J. and Roisnel, T. (1998) FullProf.98 and WinPLOTR: new windows 95/NT applications for diffraction, IUCr CPD Newsletter 20 (https://doi.org/www.mx.iucr.org/iucr-top/comm/cpd/Newsletters/no20summer1998/art24/art24.htm).
Scarlett, N.V.Y., Madsen, I.C., Cranswick, L.M.D., Lwin, T., Groleau, E., Stephenson, G., Alymore, M., and Agron-Olshina, N. (2002) Outcomes of the International Union of Crystallography Commission on Powder Diffraction round robin on quantitative phase analysis: samples 2, 3, 4, synthetic bauxite, natural granodiorite and pharmaceuticals. Journal of Applied Crystallography, 35, 383–400.
Schwertmann, U. and Cornell, R.M. (2000) Iron Oxides in the Laboratory: Preparation and Characterization. Wiley-VCH, 137 pp.
Środoń, J., Drits V.A., McCarty D.K., Hsieh J.C.C., and Eberl D.D. (2001) Quantitative XRD analysis of clay-rich rocks from random preparations. Clays and Clay Minerals, 49, 514–528.
Zevin, L.S. and Kimmel, G (1995) Quantitative X-ray Diffractometry (I. Mureinik, editor). Springer-Verlag, New York.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Raven, M.D., Self, P.G. Outcomes of 12 Years of the Reynolds Cup Quantitative Mineral Analysis Round Robin. Clays Clay Miner. 65, 122–134 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1346/CCMN.2017.064054
Received:
Revised:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1346/CCMN.2017.064054