Abstract
In this paper we analyse Brexit in relation to changes in British national identity since World War II. We begin by analysing how the concept of “tradition” relates to “nation”, and then examine current discourses surrounding Brexit and national identity. We trace the ways in which British national identity has been renegotiated since World War II through contests over nationality, citizenship, cultural diversity, and Europe. Finally, we ask why British political actors have struggled to negotiate the dilemmas of post-Imperial British identity, and what lessons can be learned. We look at changing coalitions within British political parties, which we connect to philosophical tensions in their underlying intellectual traditions, and to changes brought about by globalisation. We conclude that Brexit and the broader crisis of liberal democracy of which it is a part have deep historical and philosophical roots, and that attempts to unite our policy through a single national identity will be unsuccessful.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
For example by Herder, Benedict Anderson, and David Miller. The phrase “national identity” in the singular is therefore problematic, as it functions as a broad generalization of the beliefs of a vast number of individuals and thus risks losing empirical traction (Ashcroft and Bevir 2018b).
For an account of “British exceptionalism” and its relationship to “Whig imperialism” see Ashcroft and Bevir (2019b).
While historians still debate the precise impact of imperialism on British domestic culture, we believe it is clear that the Empire was a fundamental part of British national identity from at least the mid-Victorian period up until the mid-twentieth century. As well as Colley (1992) see MacKenzie (1999) and Catherine Hall (2001, pp. 27–39).
The roots of postwar citizenship lay in the feudal concept of subjecthood, whereby individuals owed direct allegiance to the sovereign. Calvin’s Case (1608) established the principle of jus soli in the common law, meaning that those born with the dominion of the Crown naturally possessed all the rights and duties of subjecthood. The gradual expansion of individual rights over time meant, however, that while British law was still structured around subjecthood, it was common to refer to “British citizenship”.
In particular, the “traditional” policy framework has been subject to widespread criticism that it has damaged social cohesion following race riots in Northern England and the fallout out from the “war on terror” in the early 2000s. While it is debatable whether British multiculturalism is currently undergoing a “retreat” or a “rebalancing” (Meer and Modood 2019), it is clearly currently subject to pressure from more homogenizing forms of liberal nationalism, “muscular liberalism,” and overt nativism. See Ashcroft and Bevir (2018a, 2019b), BBC News (2011, 2017), Croucher (2016), Mason (2016), Matthew (2016), and Rudd (2016) for illustrations of this point.
Save, perhaps, in that the collapse of their vote in favour of the Conservatives in 2015 meant that Cameron did not require them as partners in government, and therefore was not able to use them to block the referendum he had promised to his backbenchers from actually occurring.
Many of whom benefited from Thatcher’s sale of former council properties in the 1980′s, another part of the key economic changes in the UK over the postwar period.
Elements of universalism, internationalism, and cosmopolitanism can be found in each of conservatism, liberalism and socialism, yet all three contain countervailing strands of thought that emphasize ethical pluralism, national interests and obligations, and more local forms of culture and social organization (Bevir 2012).
References
Ashcroft, Lord. 2016. How the United Kingdom Voted on Thursday...and Why. http://lordashcroftpolls.com/2016/06/how-the-united-kingdom-voted-and-why/. June 24, 2016.
Ashcroft, Richard, and Mark Bevir. 2016. Pluralism, National Identity and Citizenship: Britain after Brexit. The Political Quarterly 87: 355–359.
Ashcroft, R.T., and M. Bevir. 2018a. Britain, Brexit and beyond. In Multiculturalism in Contemporary Britain: Policy, Law and Theory, ed. R.T. Ashcroft and M. Bevir, 2018. Abingdon: Routledge.
Ashcroft, Richard T., and Mark Bevir. 2018b. Liberal Democracy, Nationalism and Culture: Multiculturalism and Scottish Independence. Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 21 (1): 65–86.
Ashcroft, R.T., and M. Bevir. 2019a. What is postwar multiculturalism in theory and practice? In Multiculturalism in the British Commonwealth: Comparative Perspectives on Theory and Practice, ed. R.T. Ashcroft and M. Bevir. California: University of California Press.
Ashcroft, R.T., and M. Bevir. 2019b. British multiculturalism after empire: immigration, nationality, and citizenship. In Multiculturalism in the British Commonwealth: Comparative Perspectives on Theory and Practice, ed. R.T. Ashcroft and M. Bevir, 2019. California: University of California Press.
Ashcroft, R.T., and M. Bevir. 2019c. Comparative perspectives on the theory and practice of multiculturalism: lessons from the commonwealth. In Multiculturalism in the British Commonwealth: Comparative Perspectives on Theory and Practice, ed. R.T. Ashcroft and M. Bevir, 2019. California: University of California Press.
Backhouse, Roger E., Bradley W. Bateman, and Tamotsu Nishizawa. 2017. Liberalism and the welfare State in Britain, 1890–1945. In Liberalism and the Welfare State: Economists and Arguments for the Welfare State, ed. Roger E. Backhouse, Bradley W. Bateman, Tamotsu Nishizawa, and Dieter Plehwe. Oxford: Oxford university Press.
BBC News. 2011. State multiculturalism has failed, says David Cameron. February 5, 2011.
BBC News. 2017. Shared Values Unite UK People, Says PM in Easter Message. April 16, 2017.
Beech, Matthew. 2019 A Kingdom Divided Against Itself—Brexit and the Reimagining of Labour’s Ideational Traditions. Presented at the Annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Washington DC, August 29, 2019.
Bevir, Mark. 1999. The Logic of the History of Ideas. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bevir, Mark. 2007. National Histories: Prospects for Critique and Narrative. Journal of the Philosophy of History 1: 293–317.
Bevir, Mark, ed. 2012. Modern Pluralism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Calvin's Case, 7 Co. Rep. 1a, 77 ER 377. 1826. The Reports of Sir Edward Coke, In Thirteen Parts, A New Edition, vol. 4, p. 1. London: Joseph Butterworth and Son.
Checkel, Jeffrey J., and Peter J. Katzenstein. 2009. European Identity. Cambridge university Press.
Clarke, Harold D., Matthew Goodwin, and Paul Whiteley. 2017. Brexit: Why Britain Voted to Leave the European Union. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Cockburn, Harry. 2016. Amber Rudd Speech Likened to Hitler’s Mein Kampf. The Independent. October 5, 2016
Colley, Linda. 1992. Britons: Forging the Nation 1707–1837. Bath: The Bath Press.
Costa, Olivier, and Nathalie Brack. 2019. How the EU Really Works, 2nd ed. Abingdon: Routledge.
Croucher, Shane. 2016. British Jobs for British Workers: How a Far-Right Meme Went Mainstream. International Business Times. October 6, 2016.
Davies, Will. 2019. England’s new rentier alliance. Political Economy Research Centre blog, August 1, 2019. http://www.perc.org.uk/project_posts/englands-rentier-alliance/.
Farage, N. 2016. Why You Should Vote for Brexit this Thursday. The Independent, June 20, 2016. (https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/eu-referendum-brexit-nigel-farage-on-why-you-should-vote-to-leave-a7091021.html).
Favell, Adrian. 2009. Immigration, migration, and free movement in the making of Europe. In European Identity, ed. Jeffrey T. Checkel and Peter J. Katzenstein. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Finn, Mike. 2016. Dunkirk, Bond and All That: The Brexit Myth of British Exceptionalism. LSE politics blog, August 23, 2016
Fligstein, Neil. 2009. Who are the Europeans and how does this matter for politics? In European Identity, ed. Jeffrey T. Checkel and Peter J. Katzenstein. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Furlong, Jamie. 2019. The changing electoral geography of England and Wales: Varieties of “left-behindedness. Political Geography, Volume 75, November 2019.
Goodhart, David. 2006. Progressive Nationalism: Citizenship and the Left. London: Demos.
Goodhart, David. 2014. The British Dream. London: Atlantic Books.
Gove, Michael. 2009a. 1688 and All That. In Being British: The Search for the Values That Bind the Nation, ed. Matthew d’Ancona and Gordon Brown, 197–207. Edinburgh: Mainstream.
Gove, Michael. 2009b. What do Britons Have in Common?. Paper presented at Quilliam Foundation Conference, 23 April 23, 2009.
Gove, Michael. 2010. All Pupils Will Learn Our Island Story. Speech, October 5, 2010.
Hall, Catherine. 2001. British cultural identities and the legacy of empire. In British Cultural Studies: Geography, Nationality and Identity, ed. David Morley and Kevin Robins, 27–39. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hall, Matthew. 2011. Political Traditions and UK Politics. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
Hall, Macer. 2015. Immigration helps our children's understanding of the world, claims Corbyn. Daily Express, 25 August 2015. https://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/600725/Jeremy-Corbyn-Labour-migrants-Britain-benefit.
Hall, Matthew, David Marsh, and Emma Vines. 2018. A Changing Democracy: Contemporary Challenges to the British Political Tradition. Policy Studies 39 (4): 365–382.
Hampshire, James. 2005. Citizenship and Belonging. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Hansen, Randall. 2000. Citizenship and Immigration in Post-War Britain. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hickson, Kevin. 2019. Brexit and the Reordering of British Politics. Presented at the Annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Washington DC, August 29, 2019.
Hix, Simon, and Bjorn Høyland. 2013. Empowerment of the European Parliament. Annual Review of Political Science 16: 171–189.
Holmes, Douglas R. 2009. Experimental identities (after Maastricht). In European Identity, ed. Jeffrey T. Checkel and Peter J. Katzenstein, 2009. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
House of Commons Debates, Fifth Series, vol. 410, 15 May, 1945, cols. 2305–2307.
Joppke, Christian. 1999. Immigration and the Nation-State: The United States, Germany, and Great Britain. New York: Oxford University Press.
Joppke, Christian. 2010. Citizenship and Immigration. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Karatani, Rieko. 2003. Defining British Citizenship: Empire, Commonwealth, and Modern Britain. London: Frank Cass.
Kavanagh, Denis. 1992. The Postwar Consensus. Twentieth Century British History 3 (2): 175–190.
MacKenzie, John. 1999. Empire and metropolitan cultures. In The Oxford History of the British Empire, vol. III, ed. Andrew Porter, 270–293. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Marquand, David. 1995. After Whig Imperialism: Can There Be a New British Identity? Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 21 (2): 183–193.
Marsh, David, and Matthew Hall. 2007. The British Political Tradition: Explaining the Fate of New Labour’s Constitutional Reform Agenda. British Politics 2 (3): 215–238.
Marsh, David, and Matthew Hall. 2016. The British Political Tradition and the Material-Ideational Debate. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations 18 (1): 125–142.
Marshall, T.H. 1950. Citizenship and Social Class. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mason, R. 2016. Tories divided by Boris Johnson's EU-Hitler comparison. The Guardian, May 15 2016. (https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/may/16/tories-divided-by-boris-johnsons-eu-hitler-comparison).
Mathew, Shaj. 2016. Brexit Exposes Britain’s Massive Inferiority Complex. New Republic, June 22, 2016. https://newrepublic.com/article/134513/brexit-exposes-britains-massive-inferiority-complex.
May, T. 2017. The Independent, 17 January 2017. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/full-text-theresa-may-brexit-speech-global-britain-eu-european-union-latest-a7531361.html.
McDonnell, Adam and Curtis, Chris. 2019. How Britain voted in the 2019 general election. YouGov, December 17 2019. https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articlesreports/2019/12/17/how-britain-voted-2019-general-election.
Meer, N., and T. Modood. 2019. Accentuating Multicultural Britishness—an open or closed activity? In Multiculturalism in the British Commonwealth Since 1945: Comparative Perspectives on Theory and Practice, ed. R.T. Ashcroft and M. Bevir. California: University of California Press.
Morefield, Jeanne. 2005. Covenants without Swords: Idealist Liberalism and the Spirit of Empire. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Moravcsik, Andrew. 2002. In Defence of the ‘Democratic Deficit’: Reassessing Legitimacy in the European Union. Journal of Common Market Studies 40 (4): 603–624.
Mudde, Cas. 2016a. Jean-Claude Juncker and the populist zeitgeist in European politics. In On Extremism and Democracy in Europe. Routledge 53–55.
Mudde, Cas. 2016b. Europe’s Populist Surge: A Long Time in the Making. Foreign Affairs 95: 25–30.
Peden, George. 2017. Liberal economists and the British welfare state: from beveridge to the new right. In Liberalism and the Welfare State: Economists and Arguments for the Welfare State, ed. Roger E. Backhouse, Bradley W. Bateman, Tamotsu Nishizawa, and Dieter Plehwe. Oxford: Oxford university Press.
Pitcher, Ben. 2009. The Politics of Multiculturalism: Race and Racism in Contemporary Britain. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Rudd, Amber. 2016. Speech at the Conservative Party conference. October 4, 2016. https://blogs.spectator.co.uk/2016/10/full-text-amber-rudds-conference-speech/.
Scharpf, Fritz. 2011. Monetary union, fiscal crisis and the disabling of democratic accountability. In Politics in the Age of Austerity, ed. Armin Schäfer and Wolfgang Streeck, 108–142. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Schimmelfennig, Frank. 2001. The Community Trap: Liberal Norms, Rhetorical Action, and the Eastern Enlargement of the European Union. International Organization 55 (1): 47–80.
Spencer, Ian R.G.. 1997. British Immigration Policy Since The Making of Multiracial Britain. New York: Routledge.
Triadafilopoulos, Triadafilos. 2011. Illiberal Means to Liberal Ends? Understanding Recent Immigrant Integration Policies in Europe. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 37 (6): 861–880.
Ward, Stuart James. 2001a. Australia and the British Embrace: The Demise of the Imperial Ideal. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.
Ward, Stuart James, ed. 2001b. British Culture and the End of Empire. Bath: Manchester University Press.
Ward, Stuart James. 2001c. A Matter of Preference: The EEC and the Erosion of the ‘Old Commonwealth’ Relationship. In Britain, the Commonwealth and Europe, ed. Alex May, 156–180. Palgrave: Basingstoke.
Ward, Stuart James. 2007a. Imperial Identities Abroad. In The British Empire: Themes and Perspectives, ed. Sarah Stockwell, 219–243. Oxford: Blackwell.
Ward, Stuart James. 2007b. The “New Nationalism” in Australia, Canada and New Zealand: civic culture in the wake of the British World. In Britishness Abroad: Transnational Movements and Imperial Culture, ed. Kate Darian-Smith, Patricia Grimshaw, and Stuart Macintyre, 231–263. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.
Weale, A. 2018. The Will of the People: A Modern Myth . Cambridge: Polity.
Whale, S. 2016. Michael Gove's full Brexit speech on Today programme. Politics Home, April 19 2016. (https://www.politicshome.com/news/uk/foreign-affairs/news/73978/michael-goves-full-brexit-speech-today-programme).
Wren-Lewis, Simon. 2019. Is Brexit a culture war or a class war?. In Mainly Macro, Tuesday, 2 July 2019. https://mainlymacro.blogspot.com/2019/07/is-brexit-culture-war-or-class-war.html.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ashcroft, R.T., Bevir, M. Brexit and the Myth of British National Identity. Br Polit 16, 117–132 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41293-021-00167-7
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41293-021-00167-7