Abstract
Britain, Ireland and the Italian Risorgimento brings together scholars working in and across a range of academic disciplines in order to examine British and Irish responses to the Italian national question in the mid-nineteenth century, and the impact of the Risorgimento on mid-century British and Irish politics, society and culture. The book also considers British attitudes towards Italy in the decades immediately following Italian unification, and Italian views of Ireland and Britain during and after the Irish War of Independence, 1919–21. The book focusses on two key themes: nineteenth- and early twentieth-century nationalism and the construction of national identity (British, Irish and Italian); and the roles of religion, exile, politics and culture in shaping nationalist movements and national identities (both internally and externally perceived). As such, the book not only builds on the now well-established idea of the nation as an ‘imagined community’, but it also extends the methods and approaches of the ‘new cultural historians’ of the Italian Risorgimento such as Lucy Riall, Alberto Banti and Silvana Patriarca to the transnational context. In this respect, the book goes a step further than Riall and Patriarca’s The Risorgimento Revisited (2011), which explores how ‘the idea, or better the imaginary, of the nation [was] formulated, represented and expressed’ in Italy.1
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Notes
S. Patriarca and L. Riall (2011) ‘Introduction: Revisiting the Risorgimento’, in S. Patriarca and L. Riall (eds) The Risorgimento Revisited: Nationalism and Culture in Nineteenth-Century Italy (Basingstoke and New York: Palgrave Macmillan), p. 2.
G. Mazzini (2013) ‘Notes upon the Repeal Movement’, 1847, quoted in M. Finelli, ‘Intersections: The Historiography of Irish and Italian National Movements’, in C. Barr, M. Finelli and A. O’Connor (eds) Nation/Nazione: Irish Nationalism and the Italian Risorgimento (Dublin: University College Dublin Press), p. 22.
D. Mack Smith (1994) Mazzini (New Haven and London: Yale University Press), p. 86.
For general surveys by the historians listed see G. M. Trevelyan (1911) English Songs of Italian Freedom (London: Longmans, Green and Co.);
D. Mack Smith (2000) ‘Britain and the Italian Risorgimento’, in M. McLaughlin (ed.) Britain and Italy from Romanticism to Modernism: A Festschrift for Peter Brand (Oxford: Legenda), pp. 13–31;
D. Beales (1961) England and Italy, 1859–60 (London: Nelson), especially chapter 2;
P. Ginsborg (1995) ‘Il mito del Risorgimento nel mondo britannico: “la vera poesia della politica”’, Il Risorgimento, XLVII, 1–2, 384–99;
Christopher Duggan (2007) ‘Gran Bretagna e Italia nel Risorgimento’, in A. M. Banti and P. Ginsborg (eds) Il Risorgimento (Turin: Einaudi);
L. Riall (2012) ‘Anticattolicesimo e rinascita cattolica: la Gran Bretagna, l’Irlanda e gli Stati pontifici, 1850–1860’, in R. Balzani and A. Varni (eds) La Romagna nel Risorgimento. Politica, società e cultura al tempo dell’Unità (Rome-Bari: Laterza), pp. 5–23.
See also M. Isabella (2011) ‘Interlocking Patriotisms: Italy and England in the Long Nineteenth Century’, in C. Harrison and C. Newall (eds) The Pre-Raphaelites and Italy (Oxford and Farnham: Ashmolean Museum/Lund Humphries), pp. 36–40. For works on particular aspects of British opinion or policy by the historians listed see, for example,
D. Mack Smith (1971) ‘Cavour, Clarendon, and the Congress of Paris, 1856’ and ‘Palmerston and Cavour: British Policy in 1860’, in D. Mack Smith (ed.) Victor Emanuel, Cavour and the Risorgimento (London: Oxford University Press), pp. 77–91, 154–75;
D. Mack Smith (1987) ‘Gli inglesi e l’amore per l’Italia’, Rassegna Storica Toscana, 33, 1, 11–20;
H. Hearder (1966) ‘Politica e opinione pubblica inglese verso l’Italia dal luglio 1859 al marzo 1860’, Atti del XLII congresso di storica del Risorgimento italiano (Rome: Istituto per la storia del Risorgimento);
H. Hearder (1973) ‘Mazzini e l’Inghilterra’, Atti del XLVI congresso di storia del Risorgimento italiano (Rome: Istituto per la storia del Risorgimento);
D. Beales (1956) ‘Il Risorgimento protestante’, Rassegna storica del Risorgimento, 43, 4, pp. 231–3; D. Beales (1959) ‘Simpatie e incomprensioni dell’Inghilterra vitto-riana’, Osservatore politica letterario, 6;
D. Beales (1991) ‘Garibaldi in England: The Politics of Italian Enthusiasm’, in J. A. Davis and P. Ginsborg (eds) Society and Politics in the Age of the Risorgimento. Essays in Honour of Denis Mack Smith (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), pp. 184–216;
D. E. D. Beales (1998) ‘Gladstone and Garibaldi’, in P. J. Jagger (ed.) Gladstone (London: Hambledon Press), pp. 137–56;
J. A. Davis (1982) ‘Garibaldi and England’, History Today, 32, 12, pp. 21–6;
J. A. Davis (2008) ‘The Many English Lives of Giuseppe Garibaldi’, Atti del LXIII congresso di storia del Risorgimento italiano (Rome: Istituto per la storia del Risorgimento), pp. 339–60.
M. B. Urban (1938) British Opinion and Policy on the Unification of Italy, 1856–61 (Scottdale: Mennonite Press);
H. W. Rudman (1940) Italian Nationalism and English Letters: Figures of the Risorgimento and Victorian Men of Letters (London: Allen and Unwin).
N. Carter (1997) ‘Hudson, Malmesbury and Cavour: British Diplomacy and the Italian Question, February 1858–June 1859’, Historical Journal, 40, 2, pp. 389–413;
N. Carter (2000) ‘“More Italian than the Italians”? Sir James Hudson and British Policy in Italy before the Second War of Independence (February 1858–April 1859)’, Ricerche Storiche, XXX, 2, pp. 321–57;
O. J. Wright (2007) ‘Sea and Sardinia: Pax Britannica versus Vendetta in the New Italy (1870)’, European History Quarterly, 37, 3, pp. 398–416;
O. J. Wright (2008) ‘British Representatives and the Surveillance of Italian affairs, 1860–70’, Historical Journal, 51, 3, pp. 669–87;
D. Raponi (2009) ‘An “anti-Catholicism of free trade?” Religion and the Anglo–Italian negotiations of 1863’, European History Quarterly, 39, 4, pp. 633–52.
C. T. McIntire (1983) England Against the Papacy, 1858–1861 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press);
S. Matsumoto-Best (2003) Britain and the Papacy in the Age of Revolution, 1846–1851 (Woodbridge: Boydell Press for the Royal Historical Association). Interested readers are also directed to D. Raponi (forthcoming) Religion and Politics in the Risorgimento: Britain and the New Italy, 1861–1875 (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan).
M. O’Connor (1998) The Romance of Italy and the English Political Imagination (Basingstoke: Macmillan);
A. M. McAllister (2007) John Bull’s Italian Snakes and Ladders: English Attitudes to Italy in the Mid-Nineteenth Century (Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars);
L. Turner Voakes (2010) ‘The Risorgimento and English Literary History: The Liberal Heroism of Trevelyan’s Garibaldi’, Modern Italy, 15, 4, pp. 433–50.
G. Claeys (1989) ‘Mazzini, Kossuth, and British Radicalism, 1848–1854’, Journal of British Studies, 28, pp. 225–61;
D. Laven (2003) ‘Mazzini, Mazzinian Conspiracy and British Politics in the 1850s’, Bollettino storica mantovano, 2, pp. 267–82;
M. Isabella (2003) ‘Italian Exiles and British Politics Before and After 1848’, in S. Freitag (ed.) Exiles from European Revolutions: Refugees in Mid-Victorian England (Oxford: Berghahn), pp. 59–87;
M. Isabella (2009) Risorgimento in Exile: Italian Émigrés and the Liberal International in the Post-Napoleonic Era (Oxford: Oxford University Press);
M. P. Sutcliffe (2014) Victorian Radicals and Italian Democrats (Martlesham: Boydell and Brewer);
M. P. Sutcliffe (2010) ‘Negotiating the “Garibaldi Moment” in Newcastle-upon-Tyne (1854–1861)’, Modern Italy, 15, 2, pp. 129–44;
M. P. Sutcliffe (2013) ‘Marketing “Garibaldi Panoramas” in Britain (1860–1864)’, Journal of Modern Italian Studies, 18, 2, pp. 232–43;
M. P. Sutcliffe (2014) ‘Garibaldi in London’, History Today, 64, 4, pp. 42–50.
A. Colombo (1917) L’Inghilterra nel Risorgimento italiano, (Milan: Casa Editrice);
A. Signoretti (1940) Italia e Inghilterra durante il Risorgimento, (Milan: Istituto per gli Studi di Politica Internazionale);
E. Morelli (1954) ‘Mazzini in Inghilterra’, in Italia e Inghilterra nel Risorgimento (London: Institute of Italian Culture), pp. 46–58;
O. Barie (1954) ‘La politica inglese in Italia nel 1848–49’, in Italia e Inghilterra nel Risorgimento (London: Institute of Italian Culture), pp. 1–14;
G. Giarrizzo (1962) ‘La politica inglese verso l’Italia e il Regno di Sardegna nel 1857–1861’, Critica Storica, I, 4, pp. 399–420;
Massimo de Leonardis (1980) L’Inghilterra e la questione romana, 1859–1870 (Milan: Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore);
Carlo de Cugis (1967) ‘England and Italy a Century ago — A New Turn in Economic Relations’, in Catalogue of the Exhibition held during the British Week in Milan 9–17 October 1965 (Milan: Banca Commerciale Italiana);
F. Valsecchi (1979) ‘L’Inghilterra a il problema italiana nella politica europa del 1848’, Rassegna storica del Risorgimento, LXVI, 1, pp. 14–24;
Pietro Pastorelli (2011) 17 Marzo 1861: L’Inghilterra e l’unità d’Italia (Soveria Mannelli: Rubbettino)
and Elena Bacchin (2011) ‘Il Risorgimento oltremanica: nazionalismo cosmopolita nei meeting britannici di metà Ottocento’, Contemporanea, 2, pp. 173–212.
R. Dudley Edwards (ed.) (1960) Ireland and the Italian Risorgimento (Dublin: Italian Institute).
C. Barr and A. O’Connor (2013) ‘Introduction’, in Barr et al., Nation/Nazione, p. 9.
G. M. Trevelyan (1919) ‘Englishmen and Italians: Some Aspects of their Relations Past and Present. Annual Italian Lecture, 11 June 1919’, Proceedings of the British Academy, vol. IX (Oxford: Humphrey Milford/Oxford University Press), pp. 3, 8.
J. Fleming (1973) ‘Art Dealing and the Risorgimento — I’, Burlington Magazine, 115, 838, p. 5.
Hudson to Palmerston, 10 October 1851, Palmerston Papers, Hartley Library, University of Southampton, GC/HU/39. For more on Hudson’s role in the Risorgimento see E. Greppi and E. Pagella (eds) (2012) Sir James Hudson nel Risorgimento italiano (Soveria Mannelli: Rubbettino).
The letter is quoted in G. J. Holyoake (1892) Sixty Years of an Agitator’s Life, vol. 1 (London: Fisher Unwin), p. 101.
R. H. Super (1954) Walter Savage Landor: A Biography (New York: New York University Press), p. 483.
M. Foster (1988) Elizabeth Barrett Browning: A Biography (London: Chatto and Windus), p. 337.
L. McDonald (ed.) (2004) Florence Nightingale’s European Travels (Waterloo, Ontario: Wilfrid Laurier University Press), pp. 318, 324.
D. F. Mackay (1964) ‘Joseph Cowen e il Risorgimento’, Rassegna Storica del Risorgimento, LI, I, pp. 13–17.
G. J. Holyoake (1892) Sixty Years of an Agitator’s Life, vol. 2 (London: Fisher Unwin), pp. 19–25, 41. Details of the ill-fated British Garibaldi Legion in 1860 can be found in the Holyoake papers, Bishopsgate Institute and Library, Holyoake 11/1 and 11/4.
J. A. Davis (1982) ‘Garibaldi and England’, History Today, 32, 12, p. 22.
R. H. B. Jackson (1864) Welcome to Garibaldi (London: publisher unknown).
J. O’Brien (2005) ‘Irish Public Opinion and the Risorgimento, 1859–60’, Irish Historical Studies, 34, 135, p. 289.
A. Gavazzi (ed.) (1854) The Lectures Complete of Father Gavazzi, as Delivered in New York (New York: American and Foreign Christian Union), p. 271.
C. O’Carroll (2008) ‘The Irish Papal Brigade: Origins, Objectives and Fortunes’, in D. Keogh and A. McDonnell (eds) The Irish College, Rome and its World (Dublin: Four Courts Press), pp. 167–87; reprinted in Barr et al., Nation/Nazione, pp. 73–95 (p. 75).
C. Barr (2013) ‘Paul Cullen, Italy and the Irish Catholic Imagination, 1826–1870’, in Barr et al., Nation/Nazione, p. 134.
C. Barr (2008) ‘Giuseppe Mazzini and Irish Nationalism, 1845–70’, in C. A. Bayly and E. F. Biagini (eds) Giuseppe Mazzini and the Globalisation of Democratic Nationalism1830–1920 (Oxford: Oxford University Press), p. 133.
Barr, ‘Giuseppe Mazzini’, p. 137. For more on Duffy and Cullen see M. Ramon (2013) ‘Irish Nationalism and the Demise of the Papal States, 1848–1871’, in Barr et al., Nation/Nazione, pp. 180–2.
N. Whelehan (2012) The Dynamiters: Irish Nationalism and Political Violence in the Wider World, 1867–1900 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), pp. 51–3 (pp. 51–52).
A. O’Connor (2010) ‘The Dangerous Serpent: Garibaldi and Ireland 1860–1870’, Modern Italy, 15, 4, p. 402.
O’Carroll, ‘The Irish Papal Brigade’, p. 81; A. O’Connor (2013) ‘“Giant and Brutal Islanders”: The Italian Response to the Irish Papal Brigade’, in Barr et al., Nation/Nazione, p. 102.
O’Brien, ‘Irish Public Opinion’, p. 303; O’Carroll, ‘The Irish Papal Brigade’, pp. 88–9. See also A. O’Connor (2011) ‘The Pope, the Prelate, the Soldiers and the Controversy: Paul Cullen and the Irish Papal Brigade’, in D. Keogh and A. McDonnell (eds) Paul Cullen and his World (Dublin: Four Courts Press), pp. 329–49.
J. Black (1996) ‘Italy and the Grand Tour: The British Experience in the Eighteenth Century’, Annali d’Italianistica, 14, p. 538. There is an enormous literature on the Grand Tour in Italy, which lies beyond the scope of this book.
Duggan, ‘Gran Bretagna e Italia’, p. 784. For older intepretations along the lines of Duggan, Ginsborg and O’Connor see also C. P. Brand (1957) Italy and the English Romantics: The Italianate Fashion in Early Nineteenth-Century England (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), p. 202; Trevelyan, English Songs of Italian Freedom, pp. xvi–xviii.
Antinucci discusses the negative Italian stereotype in more detail in her contribution to this volume. For a fuller treatment of the subject see S. Patriarca (2010) Italian Vices: Nation and Character from the Risorgimento to the Republic (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
On the religious appeal of Mazzini to British Nonconformists see E. F. Biagini (1992) Liberalism, Retrenchment and Reform: Popular Liberalism in the Age of Gladstone, 1860–1880 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), p. 47;
E. F. Biagini (2008) ‘Mazzini and Anticlericalism: The English Exile’, in Bayly and Biagini, Giuseppe Mazzini and the Globalisation of Democratic Nationalism, pp. 145–66.
On the success of Mazzinian propaganda see L. Riall (2008) ‘The Politics of Italian Romanticism: Mazzini and the Making of a Nationalist Culture’, in Bayly and Biagini, Giuseppe Mazzini and the Globalisation of Democratic Nationalism, pp. 172–3.
On the ties between Mazzini and British radicalism see M. C. Finn (1993) After Chartism: Class and Nation in English Radical Politics, 1848–1874 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press); Claeys, ‘Mazzini, Kossuth and British Radicalism’.
For a more sceptical account of Mazzini’s influence on British radicalism see M. Taylor (1995) The Decline of British Radicalism, 1847–60 (Oxford: Clarendon Press), chapter 6. On Mazzini’s female support network see O’Connor The Romance of Italy, chapter 4;
R. Pesman (2012) ‘Mazzini and/in Love’, in Patriarca and Riall, The Risorgimento Revisited, pp. 97–114.
J. Rothney (1961) ‘La società degli amici d’Italia e la nuova riforma’, Rassegna Storica del Risorgimento, XLVIII, I, p. 27.
N. Gossman (1969) ‘British Aid to Polish, Italian, and Hungarian Exiles 1830–1870’, South Atlantic Quarterly, 63, 2, pp. 231–45.
L. Riall (2007) Garibaldi: Invention of a Hero (New Haven: Yale University Press).
For Conservative views on the Italian question see G. Hicks (2007) Peace, War and Politics: The Conservative Party and Europe, 1846–59 (Manchester: Manchester University Press), especially chapter 9.
McIntire, England Against the Papacy, pp. 172, 201; S. Gilley (1973) ‘The Garibaldi Riots of 1862’, Historical Journal, XVI, 4, p. 702.
D. M. Jackson (2001) ‘“Garibaldi or the Pope!” Newcastle’s Irish Riot of 1861’, North East History, 34, p. 54.
C. A. Coulombe (2008) The Pope’s Legion: The Multinational Force that Defended the Vatican (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan), pp. 121–2.
There have been some notable exceptions to this general rule. See, for example, Beales, ‘Il Risorgimento protestante’; G. Spini (1987) ‘Immagini dell’Inghilterra nel Risorgimento italiano’, Rassegna Storica Toscana, 33, 1, pp. 22–9;
G. Spini (1994) ‘Protestant Reactions to Italian Unification’, in T. Macquiban (ed.) Methodism in its Cultural Milieu: Proceedings of the Centenary Conference of the Wesley Historical Society in Conjunction with the World Methodist Historical Society (Oxford: Applied Theology Press), pp. 47–51; McIntire, England Against the Papacy. At the other extreme, religion is noticeable by its absence in the monographs by O’Connor and McAllister and in Duggan’s essay in Banti and Ginsborg’s influential edited collection, Il Risorgimento .
Riall, ‘Anticattolicesimo e rinascita cattolica’; Raponi, ‘An “Anti-Catholicism of Free Trade?”’; Raponi, Religion and Politics in the Risorgimento; J. Bush (2013) Papists and Prejudice: Popular Anti-Catholicism and Anglo –Irish Conflict in the North East of England, 1845–70 (Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars), chapter 4.
Frank Neal writes of ‘the endemic anti-Catholicism of Victorian England, at all levels of society’. F. Neal (1982) ‘The Birkenhead Garibaldi Riots of 1862’, Transactions of the Historic Society of Lancashire and Cheshire, 131, p. 89.
The Record, 26 August 1830, quoted in J. Wolffe (1991) The Protestant Crusade in Britain, 1829–1860 (Oxford: Clarendon Press), p. 109; Economist, 7 June 1851.
On the sources and character of mid-nineteenth-century popular anti-Catholicism see Bush, Papists and Prejudice, chapter 1; W. Ralls (1988) ‘The Papal Aggression of 1850: A Study in Victorian Anti-Catholicism’, in G. Parsons (ed.) Religion in Victorian Britain. Volume IV; Interpretations (Manchester: Manchester University Press), pp. 115–34.
E. G. Lengel (2002) The Irish Through British Eyes: Perceptions of Ireland in the Famine Era (Westport: Praeger), pp. 7–12.
Fleming, ‘Art Dealing and the Risorgimento’, n. 4, p. 4. John Wolffe has argued that Palmerston’s ‘objection was not to Roman Catholicism per se, but to politicised religion’. Palmerston’s allusion to the ‘white slave trade in minds’ would seem to suggest otherwise. J. Wolffe (2007) ‘Palmerston and the Church’, in D. Brown and M. Taylor (eds) Palmerston Studies I (Southampton: Hartley Institute, University of Southampton), p. 24. Lord John Russell and Gladstone also at times demonstrated an antipathy towards the pope that went beyond mere politics. As C. T. McIntire notes, ‘Russell himself led the anti-Catholic outrage’ during the ‘No Popery’ campaign against the Catholic hierarchy in 1850 (McIntire, England Against the Papacy, p. 30). Indeed, Russell’s letter to the bishop of Durham (4 November 1850) which was subsequently published in The Times (7 November 1850) has been described as the ‘most famous of all Victorian assaults on English Catholicism’. Ralls, ‘The Papal Aggression of 1850’, n. 3, p. 116. Gladstone was a long-standing critic of papal temporal rule on political grounds. Even he, though, could not resist writing to Panizzi on Christmas Eve, 1863: ‘Some of us I hope will live to see that Lucifer [Pius IX] fall from Heaven. How the spirit of Dante will rejoice!’ Gladstone to Panizzi, 24 December 1863, BM Add 36722.
T. P. Coogan (2001) Wherever Green is Worn: The Story of the Irish Diaspora (Basingstoke: Palgrave), p. 235.
Garibaldi recognised the value of playing to his British Protestant gallery. In a speech in Naples (31 October 1860), Garibaldi declared ‘I am a Christian as you are: yes, I am of that religion which has broken the bonds of slavery, and has proclaimed the freedom of men. The Pope, who oppresses his subjects and is an enemy of Italian independence, is no Christian: he denies the very principle of Christianity’. Garibaldi subsequently sanctioned the construction of an English Protestant church in Naples and gifted the land for the purpose. J. Weston (1864) General Garibaldi at Fishmongers’ Hall (London: William Clowes), pp. 11, 16. Even the ‘bigoted and grossly superstitious’ Victor Emanuel II became something of a Protestant hero in the mid-1850s — a result of Cavour’s on-going ‘war with the papacy’ in Piedmont. Spini, ‘Protestant Reactions to Italian Unification’, p. 50; Urban, British Opinion and Policy on the Unification of Italy, pp. 18–19.
For Gavazzi’s impact in Scotland see B. Aspinwall (2006) ‘Rev. Alessandro Gavazzi (1808–1889) and Scottish Identity: A Chapter in Nineteenth Century Anti-Catholicism’, Recusant History, 28, 1, pp. 129–52.
J. Fyfe (1978) ‘Scottish Volunteers with Garibaldi’, Scottish Historical Review, LVII, pp. 168, 181; Glasgow Herald, 31 August 1860 (my thanks to Giovanni Iamartino for this reference).
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Copyright information
© 2015 Nick Carter
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Carter, N. (2015). Introduction: Britain, Ireland and the Italian Risorgimento. In: Carter, N. (eds) Britain, Ireland and the Italian Risorgimento. Palgrave Macmillan, London. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137297723_1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137297723_1
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, London
Print ISBN: 978-1-349-67130-4
Online ISBN: 978-1-137-29772-3
eBook Packages: Palgrave History CollectionHistory (R0)