Abstract
Osteoarthritis is the most common degenerative joint condition, leading to articular cartilage (AC) degradation, chronic pain and immobility. The lack of appropriate therapies that provide tissue restoration combined with the limited lifespan of joint-replacement implants indicate the need for alternative AC regeneration strategies. Differentiation of human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) into AC progenitors may provide a long-term regenerative solution but is still limited due to the continued reliance upon growth factors to recapitulate developmental signalling processes. Recently, TTNPB, a small molecule activator of retinoic acid receptors (RARs), has been shown to be sufficient to guide mesodermal specification and early chondrogenesis of hPSCs. Here, we modified our previous differentiation protocol, by supplementing cells with TTNPB and administering BMP2 at specific times to enhance early development (referred to as the RAPID-E protocol). Transcriptomic analyses indicated that activation of RAR signalling significantly upregulated genes related to limb and embryonic skeletal development in the early stages of the protocol and upregulated genes related to AC development in later stages. Chondroprogenitors obtained from RAPID-E could generate cartilaginous pellets that expressed AC-related matrix proteins such as Lubricin, Aggrecan, and Collagen II, but additionally expressed Collagen X, indicative of hypertrophy. This protocol could lay the foundations for cell therapy strategies for osteoarthritis and improve the understanding of AC development in humans.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
Osteoarthritis (OA) is a chronic incurable skeletal disease that leads to degradation of the articular cartilage matrix, resulting in joint dysfunction and inflammation. It has been estimated to affect over 300 million people world-wide, with knee OA being the most prevalent1. Existing therapies rely mainly on pain management strategies or joint replacements, which have a limited lifespan2. Cell-based therapies, in which chondrogenic cells are transplanted to synthesise cartilaginous matrix in situ and repair damaged tissue, have been proposed as a long-term therapeutic approach. Human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs), including human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) and induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs), may be favourable cell sources for regenerative medicine approaches for OA, due to their indefinite proliferative potential and differentiation capacity3,4. Several approaches have been developed for the differentiation of hPSCs towards chondrogenic cells, with most relying upon treatment with cytokines and small molecules that mimic step-wise activation of pathways active during chondrocyte development5,6,7. One challenge for stem-cell based therapeutics for OA has been the generation of stable tissue that does not undergo hypertrophy and mineralisation. As articular chondrocytes of the long bone joints arise from limb bud mesenchymal cells from the lateral-plate mesoderm, we considered that recapitulation of limb and joint developmental signals are likely to be required to obtain true embryonic articular chondrocyte-like cells6,8,9.
Bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signalling is important for mesodermal patterning during early embryogenesis, specifying the lateral plate and driving limb bud outgrowth10,11,12. Moreover, temporally and spatially regulated BMP signalling is critical throughout chondrogenesis, driving expression and interacting with key chondrogenic transcription factors. BMP signals stimulate differentiation of proliferating chondrocytes which contribute to both the formation of transient growth plate cartilage and to the interzone, which will form the articular (permanent) cartilage. They regulate transcription leading to the synthesis of extra-cellular matrix (ECM) of the cartilage anlage13,14,15. Allowing for the prime importance of BMP signals for terminal hypertrophic differentiation of chondrocytes from murine and other models, various studies have demonstrated that it is also an essential ingredient at certain points for hPSC differentiation protocols aimed at generating articular cartilage (AC)5,6,16,17,18. Our group established a refined directed differentiation protocol (RAPID) that recapitulates the developmental systems that regulate limb bud mesenchymal development6. Cells derived from the RAPID protocol have demonstrated capacity to generate pre-chondrocyte and pre-osteoblast cells, indicating the presence of an osteochondral progenitor population. Pre-chondrocyte cells could be further cultured to generate cartilaginous pellets that expressed type II collagen, aggrecan and had surface localisation of lubricin. Although the RAPID protocol, and other similar chondrogenic hPSC differentiation protocols, rely upon the addition of BMP growth factors to drive differentiation, we have found BMPs to be subject to high batch-to-batch variability.
A recent study found that the use of two molecules, WNT pathway agonist CHIR99021 and retinoic acid receptor (RAR) pan agonist TTNPB, was sufficient to induce chondrogenic differentiation of hPSCs without the use of variable and costly growth factors19. The authors suggest that chondrogenic differentiation was primarily driven by TTNPB stimulation, in which active nuclear RAR complexes bound to a variety of enhancers and altered chromatin accessibility to promote mesodermal and chondrogenic differentiation. Although RA signalling has been demonstrated to suppress SOX9 expression and antagonise BMP signals that drive chondrogenesis20,21,22, it also controls expression of a variety of homeobox (HOX) genes and other genes crucial in early cell-fate specification, including in the limb23,24,25. Kawata and colleagues demonstrated via microarray that native BMP4 and BMP5 were significantly upregulated upon CHIR99021 and TTNPB stimulation, which then may have facilitated chondrogenic differentiation via enhanced chromatin accessibility. Thus, we investigated the adjustment of BMP signalling activation in the context of RAR activation during differentiation. We aimed to develop a protocol less dependent upon the addition of BMP growth factors and provide a more robust and representative model of limb-skeletal development and enhanced chondrogenesis.
Results
Activation of RAR signalling and specific timing of BMP2 addition improves chondrogenesis
BMP signalling plays a major role in human cartilage development and thus BMP family growth factors comprise a component of many in vitro hPSC chondrogenic differentiation protocols5,6,26. However, high variability of BMP2 activity between batches is a likely cause of unwanted variation in chondrogenic differentiation efficiency (Supplementary Fig. 1). To further understand the role of BMP and improve chondrogenic differentiation efficiency, we investigated adjusting the timing of BMP addition. Since activation of RAR signalling is crucial for limb development and has previously been shown to efficiently drive chondrogenic differentiation when used after Wnt pathway stimulation19, we also examined the influence of BMP in the context of RAR activation. Using our established chondrogenic differentiation protocol to drive hPSCs towards limb-derived, pre-articular chondrocytes6, we firstly evaluated the addition of a selective pan-RAR agonist, TTNPB (4-[(E)-2-(5,6,7,8-tetrahydro-5,5,8,8-tetramethyl-2-naphthalenyl)-1-propenyl]benzoic acid) in the absence of BMP2. Through transcriptional analysis of some key chondrogenic genes, we found that addition of TTNPB throughout the protocol significantly increased expression of SOX9, whilst significantly reducing expression of COL1A1 and RUNX2 at the end of the protocol (Fig. 1A). Although expression of COL2A1 was increased at day 8 compared to pluripotent cells, its expression then fell significantly by day 11.
As COL2A1 expression is essential for the generation of cartilaginous ECM and driven by BMP signals27,28,29, we investigated adding BMP2 back at different times during differentiation (Fig. 1B). Addition of BMP2 during the first stage of the protocol (day 1–2) significantly enhanced expression of SOX9 by day 11, but did not prevent a significant decrease in COL2A1 expression between day 8 and 11. However, we observed a significant increase in RUNX2 expression at day 11 compared with no addition of BMP2. Similarly, addition of BMP2 during either day 3–4 or day 7–8 increased expression of SOX9 and RUNX2 at day 11, but not COL2A1. We also observed an increase in COL1A1 expression at day 11 with early additions of BMP2. However, when BMP2 was added in the final stages of 2D differentiation (day 9–11), SOX9 expression was significantly increased, COL2A1 expression did not fall significantly between day 8 and 11, and we retained relatively low expression of COL1A1 and RUNX2 (Fig. 1B). We selected the protocol with TTNPB from day 1 to 10 and BMP2 from day 9 to 11 for further investigation, this protocol is referred to as RAPID-E from here onwards (Fig. 2A). When compared to the published RAPID protocol6, cells differentiated through RAPID-E expressed significantly higher COL2A1 combined with significantly lower COL1A1 and RUNX2 at day 11 (Fig. 2B). Cells were sub-cultured twice, which reflected a high proliferation rate up to day 8, with proliferation slowing by day 11 (Supplementary Fig. 2). To confirm reproducibility of the protocol, we subjected three hiPSC lines from different genetic backgrounds to the modified differentiation protocol alongside the RAPID protocol (Supplementary Fig. 3). Gene expression patterns were similar across all cell lines, demonstrating the robustness of differentiation towards chondrogenic cells.
RNAseq confirms chondrogenic differentiation of pluripotent stem cells with addition of TTNPB and early timed BMP addition
To investigate and characterise lineage specification and chondrogenic ability of our modified differentiation protocol involving TTNPB and BMP2 delivery at optimal stages, we performed RNAseq analysis of hPSCs at day 6 and day 11 with and without TTNPB (Fig. 3A). Cells at day 6 represent a limb-bud mesenchymal state, which we hypothesised would be responsive to TTNPB due to the importance of RA signalling during limb outgrowth. Therefore, we expected significant transcriptional differences with the addition of TTNPB. Principal component analysis (PCA) indicated distinct separation of the two differentiation stages and treatments, with differentiated cells separated from pluripotent cells on PC1, and samples treated with TTNPB separated from non-treated on PC2 (Fig. 3B). Hierarchical clustering analysis additionally highlighted the separation of cells treated with TTNPB from non-treated, although cells still clustered based upon differentiation stage (Supplementary Fig. 4). Differential gene expression (DEG) analysis indicated that D11 + T cells significantly upregulated genes critical for skeletal morphogenesis and chondrogenesis, such as SOX5, SOX6, SOX9 and COL2A1, alongside downregulation of pluripotency markers such as POU5F1, NANOG and SOX2 (Fig. 3C). Additionally, gene ontology (GO) analysis of significantly upregulated DEGs in D11 + T cells in comparison to pluripotent cells enriched for biological process terms associated with chondrogenesis, ECM synthesis and skeletal development (Fig. 3D). Therefore, the RAPID-E protocol was able to generate a chondrogenic-like population of cells by day 11 of differentiation.
Addition of TTNPB affects lineage specification and chondrogenic capacity
To evaluate the impact of TTNPB addition upon differentiation, we compared cells from our optimised RAPID-E protocol that were treated with TTNPB throughout to those without TTNPB, at day 6 and day 11. Addition of TTNPB induced a large number of transcriptional changes at both stages, with over 1000 significant DEGs (Supplementary Fig. 5A). To investigate the effect of transcriptional changes that were likely driven by increased RAR signalling, we identified the commonly up- and down-regulated DEGs, comparing cells treated with or without TTNPB at both day 6 and day 11 (Fig. 4A). We observed that 259 and 355 shared genes were up- and down-regulated respectively and therefore most likely affected by TTNPB addition. Drug signature database (DSigDB) enrichment analysis of our common upregulated DEGs using EnrichR revealed a significant over representation of genes previously shown to be regulated by Retinoic acid and TTNPB addition, verifying activation of known RA response genes (Supplementary Fig. 5B). Furthermore, some genes associated with RA signalling were upregulated in samples treated with TTNPB, such as RARA and RARB, although others were unchanged or diminished, such as RXRA, RXRB, RXRG and RARG (Supplementary Fig. 5C). Importantly however, GO term analysis of upregulated DEGs indicated that addition of TTNPB resulted in enrichment of terms associated with skeletal system morphogenesis, whilst downregulated DEGs enriched for terms associated with cardiac and muscle tissue development (Fig. 4B). Thus, TTNPB addition appeared to enhance specification of limb bud-like mesenchyme along the skeletal route.
As cells at day 6 of differentiation should exhibit a limb bud mesenchymal-like phenotype, we investigated differences in lineage marker expression between D6 and D6 + T cells (Fig. 5A). Analysis of lineage markers associated with limb formation indicated that the addition of TTNPB quickened lineage progression, with D6 cells in the absence of TTNPB exhibiting a more premature lateral-plate mesodermal phenotype while cells exposed to TTNPB expressed more genes associated with limb bud mesenchyme (Fig. 5B). In the presence of TTNPB, more than 70% of the population of D6 cells showed staining for the limb bud mesenchyme marker PRRX1 (Supplementary Fig. 6). The addition of TTNPB also appeared to induce significant differences in HOX gene expression by both day 6 and day 11 (Supplementary Fig. 7). However, most of these HOX genes were associated with anterior embryonic development, such as HOXA1-5 and HOXB2-9, suggesting these clusters were particularly sensitive to retinoic acid (RA) pathway stimulation. Similarly, we analysed differences in expression of individual chondrogenic genes at D11 between cells differentiated with or without TTNPB to confirm the pro-chondrogenic effect of TTNPB (Fig. 5C). Cells treated with TTNPB exhibited significantly higher expression of SOX9, COL11A1 and PTHLH, whilst exhibiting significantly lower expression of FGFR3, RUNX2 and PTH1R, genes that are associated with pre-hypertrophic chondrocytes within the growth plate (Fig. 5D, Supplementary Fig. 8). Therefore, cells appeared to exhibit a phenotype more associated with resting-zone chondrocytes, suggesting TTNPB helped drive a chondrogenic phenotype.
Cells differentiated with the RAPID-E protocol can generate cartilage-like matrix in vitro
To evaluate the capacity of cells differentiated with the RAPID-E protocol to generate cartilage-like matrix, we subjected day 11 cells to a further 28 days in pellet culture. Initially, we treated cells with TTNPB for a full 11 days before pellet culture. However, we found that cells would either not spontaneously form pellets at all or the aggregates disintegrated during the first week of pellet culture. Additionally, analysis of genes associated with cell matrix and cell adhesion suggested that TTNPB addition may inhibit matrix formation (Supplementary Fig. 9). Furthermore, if TTNPB was added to the 3D culture medium, pellets did not form properly. Therefore, we removed TTNPB from the differentiation medium at Day 10, thus cells were not treated with TTNPB for 1 day prior to pelleting. Using this approach, cells would form pellets approximately 3 days after centrifugation and these were still compact and spherical at 28 days. Gene expression analyses indicated that cells continued to express chondrogenic genes, with significant upregulation of SOX9, SOX5, COL2A1, and ACAN (Fig. 6A). However, pellets also exhibited expression of the fibrotic/hypertrophic-related gene RUNX2. Additionally, transcript for COL10A1, a marker of pre-hypertrophy, and the hyaline cartilage protein PRG4, were measurable but very low at day 28 (D28). Histological analyses of pellets at day 28 of culture indicated the presence of sulfated glycosaminoglycans, with pellets stained for Alcian blue, along with a dense collagen matrix, visualised through Picrosirius red staining and polarised light microscopy (Fig. 6B). Immunohistological analyses indicated that cells generated a cartilaginous matrix containing type II collagen and aggrecan, which was sometimes patchy, with negligible expression of type I collagen. Cells within the centre of the pellet expressed SOX9 and the matrix surrounding these cells stained strongest for type II collagen. However, pellets also stained for type X collagen, indicated that cells were beginning to undergo hypertrophy.
Discussion
Chondrogenic differentiation of hPSCs has been proposed as a regenerative medicine approach for the treatment of degenerated cartilage in OA. However, the efficiency and reproducibility of hPSC differentiation towards chondrocytes is still limited. We aimed to enhance the developmental relevance and chondrogenic output of our limb bud directed chondrogenic differentiation protocol through activating RAR signalling and modulating the timing of BMP supplementation. We initially attempted to incorporate TTNPB addition into our existing RAPID protocol in the absence of BMP2 addition. BMP signalling is essential for mesodermal and chondrogenic specification during development, enhancing mesenchymal proliferation, condensation and production of cartilage ECM30,31. Previous studies have indicated that early supplementation of BMP growth factors is required for induction of hPSCs to lateral-plate mesodermal-like a state6,7,32, whilst inhibition of BMP signals leads to paraxial mesoderm formation7,33,34,35. In recent years, other groups have demonstrated that stimulation of hPSCs with only CHIR99021 and TTNPB can efficiently induce mesodermal lineages, as the combination of both molecules induces expression of native BMP ligands, particularly BMP4 which is active during mesodermal specification19,36,37,38. Similarly, we observed significant upregulation of BMP1, BMP4 and BMP5 by day 6 of differentiation, which likely enabled the specification of lateral plate mesodermal lineages. However, the lack of controlled BMP pathway activation through direct stimulation can lead to population heterogeneity of both paraxial and lateral-plate mesodermal cells, as acknowledged by Kawata and colleagues19.
RNAseq analyses of RAPID-E differentiated cells at day 6, at which time they should exhibit a limb bud mesenchymal-like phenotype, indicated a lack of expression of notable paraxial mesoderm markers, including MSGN1 and TBX639,40, whilst lateral plate and limb bud markers, including FOXF1, HAND1 and PRRX1, were significantly upregulated. According to our previous findings6 and the work of Loh and colleagues6,7, we continued supplementation of additional factors that contribute to restriction of unwanted lineages and specification of mesoderm, in addition to TTNPB addition. For example, RA signalling41 and also Activin A, which we have used in early mesendoderm induction16,42, induce reduction of H3K27me3 levels in hESCs43, which likely establish an appropriate chromatin state for the activation of mesendodermal gene transcription16,42. Subsequently, we found at day 6 of differentiation that over 70% of the cell population were PRRX1 positive, a key marker of limb bud mesenchyme44. Thus, with continued stepwise adjustment of growth factor and small molecule combinations we were likely able to maintain induction of a primarily limb bud mesenchymal population even in the absence of BMP growth factor supplementation.
RA signalling plays an important role in skeletal tissue development, first regionalising the lateral plate mesoderm in the posterior and then guiding the forelimb formation process45,46,47,48. Post-cellular ingress, signal transduction involves binding of RA to a RAR, which then forms a heterodimeric complex with retinoid X receptor (RXR). RAR-RXR complexes then directly modulate transcription by binding to RA response elements (RAREs) within the enhancer regions of target genes47. In the absence of RA, RAR-RXR complexes act as transcriptional repressors, recruiting histone deacetylase (HDAC) and polycomb repressive complex 2 (PRC2) complexes, resulting in chromatin condensation and silencing49. Cells treated with TTNPB exhibited greater enrichment of biological process terms associated with limb and skeletal development, with a variety of HOX genes significantly upregulated. The kinetics of HOX gene expression during development is correlated to their response to retinoic acid50,51,52, with HoxA and HoxB clusters displaying a more rapid and stronger response to retinoic acid than HoxC and HoxD clusters53. Accordingly, RAPID-E cells exhibited high expression of limb-related HOX genes HOXA9 and HOXB954 at day 6, whilst at day 11 more posterior HOX genes, HOXC4-6, HOXC9 and HOXD9, which contribute to distal outgrowth after the formation of the apical ectodermal ridge55, exhibited their highest expression. Supplementation of RA has been reported to increase the expression of forelimb marker TBX5 in mouse ESC-derived limb bud cells54. However, compared to non-treated cells, TTNPB treated cells at day 6 exhibited lower expression of TBX5 and higher expression for hind limb marker TBX4. By day 11, TTNPB-treated cells exhibited high expression of TBX5 (similar to mouse ESC data) together with other HOX genes related to forelimb and did not express TBX4. This, along with the observed kinetics of HOX gene upregulation, suggests that retinoic acid polarisation of differentiation into forelimb takes longer than 2 days to occur. This suggests that a longer period for the limb induction in the RAPID-E protocol could improve the differentiation of cells into limb bud and consequently into chondroprogenitors, as reported by Yamada et al.56.
RA signalling has widely reported roles in a variety of developmental processes, including that of the nervous, pancreatic, neural, cardiac, renal and pulmonary systems57,58,59,60,61. Some off-target biological GO terms were significantly enriched in samples treated with TTNPB, such as nervous system development (GO:0007399). A recent study demonstrated that addition of 1µM TTNPB can improve the generation of neuronal progenitors from hESCs62, an effect that should be avoided in the RAPID-E protocol with an addition of only 100nM TTNPB. Furthermore, samples treated at day 11 showed high expression of RARβ, which has been showed to negatively regulate neuronal differentiation62. However, analysis of genes downregulated with addition of TTNPB also revealed an enrichment of terms associated with cardio- and myo-genesis, and expression of cardiac markers NKX2-5, TTNT2 , PECAM, and TBX20 was decreased, indicating that TTNPB supplementation reduces differentiation towards the heart field, supporting previous literature on retinoic acid signalling45,63. The restriction of the heart field by TTNPB supplementation may contribute to the channelling of differentiation towards cell populations more relevant to cartilage development.
Activation of RA signalling to drive chondrogenesis is controversial: its addition has been reported to suppress SOX9 and cartilage matrix synthesis in chondrocyte cultures21,64,65,66,67. Indeed, we found that removal of TTNPB from growth media was required to enable pellet formation at the end of the adherent phase of the RAPID-E protocol. However, other studies have reported that RA plays essential roles in limb bud formation and chondrogenesis during skeletal development46,48,68,69. Kawata and colleagues successfully induced hPSC-chondrogenic differentiation using only CHIR99021 and TTNPB, demonstrating through ATAC-seq and CHIP-seq the important roles of RARα in binding to enhancers of chondrogenic genes SOX9, SOX5, SOX619. Similarly, we found that addition of TTNPB significantly enhanced SOX9 expression alongside other associated chondrogenic genes, such as COL2A1 and COL11A2 at day 11. RA signalling has previously been demonstrated to accelerate hypertrophy in mesenchymal stem cells and directly initiate upregulation of COL10A170,71. However, we found that TTNPB-treated cells in adherent culture did not express known markers of hypertrophy and the growth plate, including COL10A1, IHH or MMP13, and additionally exhibited significantly lower expression of RUNX2, PTH1R, FGFR3 and VEGFA in comparison to non-treated samples72,73. This suggests that, at this stage, RA signalling had an effect in limiting hypertrophic cartilage differentiation.
Although we found that addition of TTNPB alone significantly enhanced expression of chondrogenic genes by day 6 of differentiation, maintenance of COL2A1 expression until day 11 was dependent upon BMP2 addition (in combination with GDF5). BMP signalling is known to drive expression of COL2A129,74 alongside other key chondrogenic genes17,28,75,76,77,78,79. Our findings are consistent with those of Yamada and colleagues who reported that stimulation of limb bud mesenchymal-like cells with BMP4 (alongside GDF5 and TGFβ1) was required to generate chondrogenic nodules56. Enhanced chondrogenesis by BMP2 stimulation at day 9 and 10 may be attributed to the high expression of SOX9 and low expression of RUNX2, which together limit BMP2-induced osteogenic differentiation while promoting chondrogenesis80,81,82,83. All the same, further refinement could avoid the evidence of hypertrophy in the chondrogenic pellets generated from RAPID-E cells. Hypertrophy likely occurred as a result of continued addition of BMP2 throughout the 3D phase, which we showed to have time dependent effects on expression of hypertrophic genes. Addition of ascorbic acid has been reported to increase COL10A1 expression in chondrogenic ATDC5 cells84 and chick chondrocytes85. A recent study, ceased ascorbic acid supplementation in micromass pellets destined for AC differentiation while maintaining it for pellets differentiated towards growth plate cartilage86. In light of this, modification of growth factor composition in later stages will be required to maintain a non-hypertrophic phenotype. It is worth noting that by immunohistochemistry, pellets showed abundant, although heterogeneous, type II collagen, Lubricin and Aggrecan expression, suggesting the presence of an AC-committed cell population.
In summary, the RAPID-E protocol represents a promising approach for the differentiation of hPSCs into chondrogenic cells for regenerative medicine applications. Its capability for differentiating cells into chondroprogenitors and its robustness across different hPSC lines make it a valuable tool for future research and potential therapeutic use. Further enrichment approaches may be required to refine the cell population generated in this protocol, allowing for the selection of a more homogeneous and articular cartilage committed progenitor population and cartilage tissue.
Materials and methods
Culture and maintenance of human pluripotent stem cells in feeder/xeno -free conditions
MAN13 is a clinical grade hESC line which has been well characterised87 (https://hpscreg.eu/cell-line/UMANe002-A) and was derived under local ethical approval (Central Manchester LREC favourable opinion 03/CM/684) and UK Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority license (HFEA licence R0171) with fully informed parental consent. Our chondrogenesis research work was approved by the MRC/UKSCB oversight committee for human embryonic stem cell use in research. MAN13 hESCs were expanded in 6-well cell culture plates previously coated with 5µg/ml Human Recombinant Vitronectin (Gibco, #A27940) in Dulbecco’s Phosphate Buffered Saline (PBS) modified without calcium chloride and magnesium chloride (Sigma-Aldrich, #D8537). Cells were cultured in mTeSR™1 basal medium (StemCell Technologies, #85851) with 20% O2 and 5% CO2 at 37 °C. Medium was replaced every 48 h, and cells passaged when 80–90% confluent. Cells were dissociated using 0.5 mM Ultrapure™ EDTA (Invitrogen, #15575–638) in PBS at 37°C for 3–5 min. HiPSCs (SW163D, SW171A) were derived in our laboratory as previously described88 and their use approved by the UK Integrated Research Application System (IRAS 114697) and University Ethics Committee. HiPSC line WIGW2 were obtained from the HipSci consortium89. HiPSCs were grown in 6-well plates pre-coated with 5 µg/ml human recombinant Vitronectin in PBS. The cells were maintained in TeSR™-E8™ medium (E8) (StemCell Technologies, #05990) at 20% O2 and 5% CO2 at 37 °C, E8 medium was replaced every other day. Cells were passaged every 4–7 days as described previously for hESCs.
2D chondrogenic differentiation of hESCs
The RAPID-E protocol was adapted from our previously published protocol6, in which TTNPB was supplemented daily into growth medium and the timing of BMP2 addition was adjusted. Briefly, cells were passaged onto vitronectin as described previously and cultured until approximately 50–60% confluent. Pluripotency maintenance medium was then removed and replaced with Advanced Differentiation Basal Medium (ADBM), consisting of Advanced DMEM F-12 (Thermo Fisher Scientific, #12634010) supplemented with 1% (v/v) L-Glutamine (Gibco, #25030081), 2% (v/v) B27 Supplement (Gibco, #17504001), 0.1 mM β-mercaptoethanol (Gibco, #31350010). Cells were sub-cultured on days 4 and 8 of differentiation onto human fibronectin (Merck Millipore, #FC010) coated plates at a ratio of 1:4. Growth factors and cytokines concentration are reported in supplemental experimental procedures Supplementary Table 1.
3D chondrogenic differentiation of hESCs derived chondroprogenitors
Chondroprogenitor cells at the end of the 2D phase of differentiation (Day 11) were dissociated using TryPLE™ express solution at 37 °C for 5 min. Meanwhile, 15 ml Falcon tubes were rinsed with Anti-adherence Rinsing Solution (StemCell Technology, #07010) to prevent cell adhesion to the tube. Cell number was determined using a NucleoCounter NC-200 (Chemometec, #900-0201). Cells were diluted in day 11 medium to achieve 1 × 106 cells/ml, and 1 ml of medium was added to each coated Falcon tube. Falcon tubes containing cells were spun at 100xg for 3 min and then incubated for 96 h at 20% O2 and 5% CO2 at 37 °C. After incubation, medium was replaced with ADBM containing 50µg/ml L-Ascorbic acid 2-phosphate, 20 ng/ml GDF5, 25 ng/ml BMP2 and 10 ng/ml TGFβ. The medium was refreshed every 72 h, and pellets were kept in culture for 28 days.
Histological analysis
Samples were processed using a tissue processor (Leica, #ASP300) and paraffin-embedded samples were cut into 5 μm sections using a microtome (Leica, #RM2255) and mounted on Superfrost Plus Adhesion Microscope Slides (Epredia™, # 12302108). Sections were initially subjected to consecutives washes with xylene and ethanol for deparaffinization and finished by washes with deionised water. Endogenous peroxidase activity was blocked in 1% hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) for 30 min. Antigen retrieval was conducted by incubating in Pepsin Reagent solution (Sigma-Aldrich #R2283) at room temperature for 15 min. The samples were then blocked for 1 h with 10% serum of the secondary antibody species at room temperature. The samples were subsequently incubated with primary antibodies (Supplementary Table 2), in 10% serum, overnight at 4 °C, and then incubated 1 h with secondary antibodies diluted 1:200 (Supplementary Table 2). The secondary antibody signal was amplified by incubation with Vectastain Elite ABC Reagent (Vector labs, PK-6100) for 30 min. The signal was developed using SIGMAFAST™ 3,3′-Diaminobenzidine (DAB) (Merck, #D4418) for up to 10 min at room temperature. Samples were counterstained incubating for 30 s in a Mayer’s Modified Haematoxylin solution (Abcam, #220365).
Alcian Blue/Eosin staining
Sections deparaffinised as reported above, were placed in acid-alcohol (1% hydrochloric acid in 70% Ethanol) for 30 s and drained briefly. Then they were incubated in 1% Alcian blue for 40 min and gently washed in distilled water, until it ran clear. After quick rinses in acid-alcohol and 0.5% ammonium water, sections were placed in 95% ethanol for 1 min. Slides were placed in Eosin (Abcam, #246,824) for 1 min and then dehydrated, cleared and mounted.
Flow cytometry analysis
Cells were dissociated using TryPLE™ at 37 °C for 5 min and counted as previously described. Cells were then transferred into 1.5 ml Eppendorf tubes at the required concentration (not less than 1.0 × 105 cells per tube). Before proceeding with intracellular staining, cells were first fixed with 4% paraformaldehyde (Thermo Fisher Scientific, #28908) for 10 min on ice, then permeabilised by incubating in 70% methanol at 4 °C for 7 min. For staining, cells were incubated on ice for 30 min in a 5% fetal bovine serum-PBS (FBS-PBS) staining solution containing PRRX1 (Abnova, #H00005396-W01P) primary antibody diluted 1:100. Incubation with Alexa Fluor 488 Goat Anti Rabbit (Thermo Fisher Scientific, #A11008) diluted at 1:400 followed under the same conditions as the primary. After incubation, cells were resuspended in 2% FBS-PBS and analysed by flow cytometry using an LSRFortessa™ (BD) and BD FACSDiva™ Software for Windows (Version 8.0). Cells of interest were identified based on their size and granularity through Forward vs Side Scatter (FSC vs SSC) gating. FSC-Height (FSC-H) vs FSC-Area (FSC-A) plots were used to exclude doublets. Unstained cells and single-stained compensation controls were used to set flow cytometer parameters and gating. At least 10,000 events per condition were collected. Data analysis was performed using FlowJo™ Software for Windows (Version 10.6.8.).
RNA extraction and gene expression analysis by RT-qPCR
Total RNA was extracted using Monarch® Total RNA Miniprep Kit (New England Biolabs inc. #T2010S) following manufacturer protocol. Reverse-transcription of 2 µg of RNA was performed using High Capacity cDNA Reverse Transcription Kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific, #4368814). Gene-specific primers were designed using Primer-BLAST online software90 and are reported in Supplementary Table 3. RT-qPCR for gene expression was assessed using 10 ng of cDNA, gene-specific primers and Power SYBR Green PCR Master Mix (Applied Biosystems, UK, #4309155) with a Bio-Rad C1000Touch™ Thermal Cycler. Gene expression was normalised to GAPDH, and relative gene expression was calculated using the 2-ΔCT method. At least three independent biological repeats analysed in triplicate were performed.
RNA-seq analysis
An analysis was performed on paired-end sequences from an Illumina HiSeq4000 sequencer using FastQC (http://www.bioinformatics.babraham.ac.uk/projects/fastqc/) by the Genomic Technologies Core Facility at the University of Manchester. Adapter sequences were removed and the reads were quality checked using Trimmomatic_0.39 (PMID: 24695404). Reads from the RNA-seq experiment were mapped against the reference human genome (hg38) and gene counts were determined using annotation from GENCODE 39 (http://www.gencodegenes.org) with STAR_2.7.7a (PMID: 23104886). Normalization, Principal Components Analysis, and differential expression were calculated using DESeq2_1.36.0 (PMID: 25516281). Gene enrichment analyses were performed with EnrichR91,92,93 submitting significant differentially expressed genes (adjusted p-value < 0.05) and upregulated or downregulated by at least onefold change (unless specified). Graphs were made using GraphPad Prism 9.4.1 or SRPlot, (http://www.bioinformatics.com.cn/srplot), an online platform for data analysis and visualization. Volcano Plots were made using VolcaNoseR94. Hierarchical clustering analysis was performed using Gene Cluster software95.
Assessment of BMP2 growth factor activity
To assess BMP2 growth factor activity, TC28a2-BRE-PEST cells (previously described96) were stimulated with BMP2 at a range of concentrations (0.1–1000 ng/ml). Nano-Glo® live cell assay system (Promega, #N2011) was used for analysis of luminescence after stimulation at different time points. Luminescence was measured in raw luminescent units (RLU) using a GloMax® multimodal plate reader (Promega). Reads across a time course were performed using separate wells.
Statistical analysis
Statistical analyses were conducted using GraphPad Prism 9.4.1 and data are presented as mean ± standard error of mean (SEM). The selection of statistical test in this study was based on the normality of the data and the number of groups being compared. Normality of the data was evaluated through the Shapiro–Wilk test. Data that met the assumption of normality were analysed using t-test, for two groups, and ANOVA for multiple groups. A p-value of < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Data availability
The datasets generated and analysed during the current study are available in the ArrayExpress repository (E-MTAB-13186).
References
James, S. L. et al. Global, regional, and national incidence, prevalence, and years lived with disability for 354 Diseases and Injuries for 195 countries and territories, 1990–2017: A systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017. Lancet 392(10159), 1789–1858 (2018).
Zhang, W., Ouyang, H., Dass, C. R. & Xu, J. Current research on pharmacologic and regenerative therapies for osteoarthritis. Bone Res. 4(October 2015), 15040 (2016).
Yamanaka, S. Pluripotent stem cell-based cell therapy—Promise and challenges. Cell Stem Cell 27(4), 523–531 (2020).
Jevotovsky, D. S., Alfonso, A. R., Einhorn, T. A. & Chiu, E. S. Osteoarthritis and stem cell therapy in humans: A systematic review. Osteoarthr. Cartil. 26(6), 711–729 (2018).
Craft, A. M. et al. Generation of articular chondrocytes from human pluripotent stem cells. Nat. Biotechnol. 33(6), 638–645 (2015).
Smith, C. A. et al. Directed differentiation of hPSCs through a simplified lateral plate mesoderm protocol for generation of articular cartilage progenitors. PLoS One 18(1), e0280024 (2023).
Loh, K. M. M. et al. Mapping the pairwise choices leading from pluripotency to human bone, heart, and other mesoderm cell types. Cell 166(2), 451–467 (2016).
Chijimatsu, R. & Saito, T. Mechanisms of synovial joint and articular cartilage development. Cell. Mol. Life Sci. 76(20), 3939–3952 (2019).
Humphreys, P. A. et al. Developmental principles informing human pluripotent stem cell differentiation to cartilage and bone. Semin. Cell Dev. Biol. 127(July 2021), 17–36 (2022).
Sumi, T., Tsuneyoshi, N., Nakatsuji, N. & Suemori, H. Defining early lineage specification of human embryonic stem cells by the orchestrated balance canonical Wnt/β-catenin, activin/Nodal and BMP signaling. Development 135(17), 2969–2979 (2008).
Row, R. H. et al. BMP and FGF signaling interact to pattern mesoderm by controlling basic helix-loop-helix transcription factor activity. Elife 7, 1–27 (2018).
Pignatti, E., Zeller, R. & Zuniga, A. To BMP or not to BMP during vertebrate limb bud development. Semin. Cell Dev. Biol. 32, 119–127 (2014).
Ray, A., Singh, P. N. P., Sohaskey, M. L., Harland, R. M. & Bandyopadhyay, A. Precise spatial restriction of BMP signaling is essential for articular cartilage differentiation. Development 142(6), 1169–1179 (2015).
Kobayashi, T., Lyons, K. M., McMahon, A. P. & Kronenberg, H. M. BMP signaling stimulates cellular differentiation at multiple steps during cartilage development. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 102(50), 18023–18027 (2005).
Yoon, B. S. & Lyons, K. M. Multiple functions of BMPs in chondrogenesis. J. Cell. Biochem. 93(1), 93–103 (2004).
Oldershaw, R. A. et al. Directed differentiation of human embryonic stem cells toward chondrocytes. Nat. Biotechnol. 28(11), 1187–1194 (2010).
Wang, T. et al. Enhanced chondrogenesis from human embryonic stem cells. Stem Cell Res. 39(May), 101497 (2019).
Diederichs, S., Klampfleuthner, F. A. M., Moradi, B. & Richter, W. Chondral differentiation of induced pluripotent stem cells without progression into the endochondral pathway. Front. Cell Dev. Biol. 7(November), 1–10 (2019).
Kawata, M. et al. Simple and robust differentiation of human pluripotent stem cells toward chondrocytes by two small-molecule compounds. Stem Cell Rep. 13(3), 530–544 (2019).
Weston, A. D., Chandraratna, R. A. S., Torchia, J. & Underhill, T. M. Requirement for RAR-mediated gene repression in skeletal progenitor differentiation. J. Cell Biol. 158(1), 39–51 (2002).
Pacifici, M., Cossu, G., Molinaro, M. & Tato, F. Vitamin A inhibits chondrogenesis but not myogenesis. Exp. Cell Res. 129(2), 469–474 (1980).
Hoffman, L. M. et al. BMP action in skeletogenesis involves attenuation of retinoid signaling. J. Cell Biol. 174(1), 101–113 (2006).
Langston, A. W. & Gudas, L. J. Retinoic acid and homeobox gene regulation. Curr. Opin. Genet. Dev. 4(4), 550–555 (1994).
Boncinelli, E., Simeone, A., Acampora, D. & Mavilio, F. HOX gene activation by retinoic acid. Trends Genet. 7(10), 329–334 (1991).
Bel-Vialar, S., Itasaki, N. & Krumlauf, R. Initiating Hox gene expression: In the early chick neural tube differential sensitivity to FGF and RA signaling subdivides the HoxB genes in two distinct groups. Development 129(22), 5103–5115 (2002).
Shen, P. et al. Rapid induction and long-term self-renewal of neural crest-derived ectodermal chondrogenic cells from hPSCs. npj Regen. Med. 7(1), 1–15 (2022).
Xu, S. C., Harris, M. A., Rubenstein, J. L. R., Mundy, G. R. & Harris, S. E. Bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) signaling to the Col2α1 gene in chondroblasts requires the homeobox gene Dlx-2. DNA Cell Biol. 20(6), 359–365 (2001).
Lafont, J. E., Poujade, F. A., Pasdeloup, M., Neyret, P. & Mallein-Gerin, F. Hypoxia potentiates the BMP-2 driven COL2A1 stimulation in human articular chondrocytes via p38 MAPK. Osteoarthr. Cartil. 24(5), 856–867 (2016).
Fernández-Lloris, R. et al. Induction of the Sry-related factor SOX6 contributes to bone morphogenetic protein-2- induced chondroblastic differentiation of C3H10T1/2 cells. Mol. Endocrinol. 17(7), 1332–1343 (2003).
Kim, H. S., Neugebauer, J., Mcknite, A., Tilak, A. & Christian, J. L. BMP7 functions predominantly as a heterodimer with BMP2 or BMP4 during mammalian embryogenesis. 1–22 (2019).
James, R. G. & Schultheiss, T. M. Bmp signaling promotes intermediate mesoderm gene expression in a dose-dependent, cell-autonomous and translation-dependent manner. Dev. Biol. 288(1), 113–125 (2005).
Huang, D., Li, J., Hu, F., Xia, C., Weng, Q., Wang, T. et al. Lateral plate mesoderm cell-based organoid system for NK cell regeneration from human pluripotent stem cells. Cell Discov. 8(1) (2022).
Xi, H. et al. In vivo human somitogenesis guides somite development from hPSCs. Cell Rep. 18(6), 1573–1585 (2017).
Wu, C. L. et al. Single cell transcriptomic analysis of human pluripotent stem cell chondrogenesis. Nat. Commun. 12(1), 362 (2021).
Umeda, K. et al. Human chondrogenic paraxial mesoderm, directed specification and prospective isolation from pluripotent stem cells. Sci. Rep. 2(455), 1–11 (2012).
Araoka, T., Mae, S. I., Kurose, Y., Uesugi, M., Ohta, A., Yamanaka, S. et al. Efficient and rapid induction of human iPSCs/ESCs into nephrogenic intermediate mesoderm using small molecule-based differentiation methods. PLoS One, 9(1), epub (1–14) (2014).
Zhang, P. et al. Short-term BMP-4 treatment initiates mesoderm induction in human embryonic stem cells. Blood 111(4), 1933–1941 (2008).
Winnier, G., Blessing, M., Labosky, P. A. & Hogan, B. L. M. Bone morphogenetic protein-4 is required for mesoderm formation and patterning in the mouse. Genes Dev. 9(17), 2105–2116 (1995).
Chalamalasetty, R. B. et al. Mesogenin 1 is a master regulator of paraxial presomitic mesoderm differentiation. Development 141(22), 4285–4297 (2014).
Chapman, D. L., Agulnik, I., Hancock, S., Silver, L. M. & Papaioannou, V. E. Tbx6, a mouse T-box gene implicated in paraxial mesoderm formation at gastrulation. Dev. Biol. 180(2), 534–542 (1996).
Kashyap, V. & Gudas, L. J. Epigenetic regulatory mechanisms distinguish retinoic acid-mediated transcriptional responses in stem cells and fibroblasts. J. Biol. Chem. 285(19), 14534–14548 (2010).
Cheng, A. et al. Cartilage repair using human embryonic stem cell-derived chondroprogenitors. Stem Cells Transl. Med. 3(11), 1287–1294 (2014).
Wang, L. et al. Activin/Smad2-induced histone H3 Lys-27 trimethylation (H3K27me3) reduction is crucial to initiate mesendoderm differentiation of human embryonic stem cells. J. Biol. Chem. 292(4), 1339–1350 (2017).
Fowler, D. A. & Larsson, H. C. E. The tissues and regulatory pattern of limb chondrogenesis. Dev. Biol. 463(2), 124–134 (2020).
Waxman, J. S., Keegan, B. R., Roberts, R. W., Poss, K. D. & Yelon, D. Hoxb5b acts downstream of retinoic acid signaling in the forelimb field to restrict heart field potential in zebrafish. Dev. Cell 15(6), 923–934 (2008).
Feneck, E. & Logan, M. The role of retinoic acid in establishing the early limb bud. Biomolecules 10(2) (2020).
Cunningham, T. J. & Duester, G. Mechanisms of retinoic acid signalling and its roles in organ and limb development. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 16(2), 110–123 (2015).
Nishimoto, S., Wilde, S. M., Wood, S. & Logan, M. P. O. RA acts in a coherent feed-forward mechanism with Tbx5 to control limb bud induction and initiation. Cell Rep. 12(5), 879–891 (2015).
Jepsen, K. et al. Combinatorial roles of the nuclear receptor corepressor in transcription and development. Cell 102(6), 753–763 (2000).
Simeone, A., Acampora, D., Arcioni, L., Andrews, P. W., Boncinelli, E. & Mavilio, F. Sequential activation of HOX2 homeobox genes by retinoic acid in human embryonal carcinoma cells. Nat. 1990 3466286, 346(6286), 763–766 (1990).
Kmita, M. & Duboule, D. Organizing axes in time and space; 25 years of colinear tinkering. Science (80-.) 301(5631), 331–333 (2003).
Papalopulu, N., Lovel-badage, R. & Krumlauf, R. The expression of murine Hox-2 genes is dependent on the differentiation pathway and displays a collinear sensitivity to retinoic acid in F9 cells and Xenopus embryos. Nucleic Acids Res. 19(20), 5497 (1991).
De, K. B. et al. Analysis of dynamic changes in retinoid-induced transcription and epigenetic profiles of murine Hox clusters in ES cells. Genome Res. 25(8), 1229–1243 (2015).
Mori, S. et al. Self-organized formation of developing appendages from murine pluripotent stem cells. Nat. Commun. 10(1), 1–13 (2019).
Sheth, R. et al. Decoupling the function of Hox and Shh in developing limb reveals multiple inputs of Hox genes on limb growth. Development 140(10), 2130–2138 (2013).
Yamada, D. et al. Induction and expansion of human PRRX1+ limb-bud-like mesenchymal cells from pluripotent stem cells. Nat. Biomed. Eng. 5(8), 926–940 (2021).
Rosselot, C. et al. Non-cell-autonomous retinoid signaling is crucial for renal development. Development 137(2), 283–292 (2010).
Jacobs, S. et al. Retinoic acid is required early during adult neurogenesis in the dentate gyrus. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 103(10), 3902–3907 (2006).
Wiesinger, A., Boink, G. J. J., Christoffels, V. M. & Devalla, H. D. Retinoic acid signaling in heart development: Application in the differentiation of cardiovascular lineages from human pluripotent stem cells. Stem Cell Rep. 16(11), 2589–2606 (2021).
Lorberbaum, D. S., Kishore, S., Rosselot, C., Sarbaugh, D., Brooks, E. P., Aragon, E. et al. Retinoic acid signaling within pancreatic endocrine progenitors regulates mouse and human β cell specification. Development 147(12) (2020).
Fernandes-Silva, H., Araújo-Silva, H., Correia-Pinto, J. & Moura, R. S. Retinoic acid: A key regulator of lung development. Biomolecules 10(1), 1–18 (2020).
Das, M. & Pethe, P. Differential expression of retinoic acid alpha and beta receptors in neuronal progenitors generated from human embryonic stem cells in response to TTNPB (a retinoic acid mimetic). Differentiation 121, 13–24 (2021).
Duong, T. B., Holowiecki, A. & Waxman, J. S. Retinoic acid signaling restricts the size of the first heart field within the anterior lateral plate mesoderm. Dev. Biol. 473, 119–129 (2021).
Sumitani, Y. et al. Inhibitory effect of retinoic acid receptor agonists on in vitro chondrogenic differentiation. Anat. Sci. Int. 95(2), 202–208 (2020).
Cho, S. H., Oh, C. D., Kim, S. J., Kim, I. C. & Chun, J. S. Retinoic acid inhibits chondrogenesis of mesenchymal cells by sustaining expression of N-cadherin and its associated proteins. J. Cell. Biochem. 89(4), 837–847 (2003).
He, N., Brysk, H., Tyring, S. K., Ohkubo, I. & Brysk, M. M. Transcriptional suppression of Sox9 expression in chondrocytes by retinoic acid. J. Cell. Biochem. 81(SUPPL. 36), 71–78 (2001).
Pacifici, M. Retinoid roles and action in skeletal development and growth provide the rationale for an ongoing heterotopic ossification prevention trial. Bone 109, 267–275 (2018).
Niederreither, K., Subbarayan, V., Dollé, P. & Chambon, P. Embryonic retinoic acid synthesis is essential for early mouse post-implantation development. Nat. Genet. 21(4), 444–448 (1999).
Niederreither, K., Vermot, J., Schuhbaur, B., Chambon, P. & Dollé, P. Embryonic retinoic acid synthesis is required for forelimb growth and anteroposterior patterning in the mouse. Development 129(15), 3563–3574 (2002).
Riedl, M., Witzmann, C., Koch, M., Lang, S., Kerschbaum, M., Baumann, F. et al. Attenuation of hypertrophy in human mscs via treatment with a retinoic acid receptor inverse agonist. Int. J. Mol. Sci. 21(4) (2020).
Cohen, A. J., Lassová, L., Golden, E. B., Niu, Z. & Adams, S. L. Retinoids directly activate the collagen X promoter in prehypertrophic chondrocytes through a distal retinoic acid response element. J. Cell. Biochem. 99(1), 269–278 (2006).
Zhang, W., Chen, J., Zhang, S. & Ouyang, H. W. Inhibitory function of parathyroid hormone-related protein on chondrocyte hypertrophy: The implication for articular cartilage repair. Arthritis Res. Ther. 14(4), 1–10 (2012).
Oh, C. D. et al. SOX9 regulates multiple genes in chondrocytes, including genes encoding ECM proteins, ECM modification enzymes, receptors, and transporters. PLoS One 9(9), 107577 (2014).
Timur, U. T., Caron, M., Akker van den, G., Windt van der, A., Visser, J., Rhijn van, L. et al. Increased TGF-β and BMP levels and improved chondrocyte-specific marker expression in vitro under cartilage-specific physiological osmolarity. Int. J. Mol. Sci. 20(4) (2019).
Shu, B. et al. BMP2, but not BMP4, is crucial for chondrocyte proliferation and maturation during endochondral bone development. J. Cell Sci. 124(20), 3428–3440 (2011).
Kramer, J. et al. Embryonic stem cell-derived chondrogenic differentiation in vitro: Activation by BMP-2 and BMP-4. Mech. Dev. 92(2), 193–205 (2000).
Murphy, M. K., Huey, D. J., Hu, J. C. & Athanasiou, K. A. TGF-β1, GDF-5, and BMP-2 stimulation induces chondrogenesis in expanded human articular chondrocytes and marrow-derived stromal cells. Stem Cells 33(3), 762–773 (2015).
Davidson, E. N. B. et al. Elevated extracellular matrix production and degradation upon bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) stimulation point toward a role for BMP-2 in cartilage repair and remodeling. Arthritis Res. Ther. 9(5), 1–11 (2007).
Gründer, T. et al. Bone morphogenetic protein (BMP)-2 enhances the expression of type II collagen and aggrecan in chondrocytes embedded in alginate beads. Osteoarthr. Cartil. 12(7), 559–567 (2004).
Liao, J., Hu, N., Zhou, N., Zhao, C., Liang, X., Chen, H., et al. Sox9 potentiates BMP2-induced chondrogenic differentiation and inhibits BMP2-induced osteogenic differentiation. Regen. Med. Plast. Surg. 263–280 (2019).
Phimphilai, M., Zhao, Z., Boules, H., Roca, H. & Franceschi, R. T. BMP signaling is required for RUNX2-dependent induction of the osteoblast phenotype. J. Bone Miner. Res. 21(4), 637–646 (2006).
Zhou, G. et al. Dominance of SOX9 function over RUNX2 during skeletogenesis. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 103(50), 19004–19009 (2006).
Haseeb, A. et al. SOX9 keeps growth plates and articular cartilage healthy by inhibiting chondrocyte dedifferentiation/ osteoblastic redifferentiation. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 118(8), 1–11 (2021).
Kirimoto, A., Takagi, Y., Ohya, K. & Shimokawa, H. Effects of retinoic acid on the differentiation of chondrogenic progenitor cells, ATDC5. J. Med. Dent. Sci. 52(3), 153–162 (2005).
Pacifici, M., Golden, E. B., Iwamoto, M. & Adams, S. L. Retinoic acid treatment induces type X collagen gene expression in cultured chick chondrocytes. Exp. Cell Res. 195(1), 38–46 (1991).
Richard, D. et al. Lineage-specific differences and regulatory networks governing human chondrocyte development. Elife 12, 79925 (2023).
Ye, J. et al. High quality clinical grade human embryonic stem cell lines derived from fresh discarded embryos. Stem Cell Res. Ther. 8(1), 1–13 (2017).
Woods, S. et al. Generation of human-induced pluripotent stem cells from anterior cruciate ligament. J. Orthop. Res. 38(1), 92–104 (2020).
Streeter I., Harrison P. W., Faulconbridge A., Consortium T. H. S., Flicek P., Parkinson H., et al. The human-induced pluripotent stem cell initiative—Data resources for cellular genetics. Nucleic Acids Res. 45 (D1), D691–D697 (2017).
Ye, J. et al. Primer-BLAST: A tool to design target-specific primers for polymerase chain reaction. BMC Bioinform. 13, 134 (2012).
Xie, Z. et al. Gene set knowledge discovery with enrichr. Curr. Protoc. 1(3), e90 (2021).
Kuleshov, M. V. et al. Enrichr: A comprehensive gene set enrichment analysis web server 2016 update. Nucleic Acids Res. 44(May), 90–97 (2016).
Chen, E. et al. Enrichr: Interactive and collaborative HTML5 gene list enrichment analysis tool. BMC Bioinform. 14(128), 1–14 (2013).
Goedhart J. & Luijsterburg M.S. VolcaNoseR is a web app for creating, exploring, labeling and sharing volcano plots. Sci. Rep. 2020 101, 10(1), 1–5 (2020).
Eisen, M. B., Spellman, P. T., Brown, P. O. & Botstein, D. Cluster analysis and display of genome-wide expression patterns. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 95(25), 14863–14868 (1998).
Humphreys, P. A. et al. Optogenetic control of the BMP signaling pathway. ACS Synth. Biol. 9(11), 3067–3078 (2020).
Acknowledgements
We thank the following for funding: UKRI EPSRC/MRC Centre for Doctoral training in Regenerative Medicine: Fabrizio E. Mancini, Susan J. Kimber EP/L014904/1; BBSRC: Paul E.A. Humphreys BB/W013940/1, Arthritis Research UK: Susan J. Kimber R20786; MRC UKRMP: Susan J. Kimber MR/K026666; UKRI MRC: Susan J. Kimber, Steven Woods MR/X002020/1; UKRI MRC: Susan J. Kimber MR/S002553/1. Great Ormond Street Hospital (GOSH): Sara Cuvertino. MRC UKRI Doctoral Training Programme: Julieta O’ Flaherty MR/N013751/11. Marco Domingos EP/R00 6 61X/1, EP/S019367/1, EP/P025021/1 and EP/P025498/1. We would like to thank Dr Leo Zeef for the bioinformatic analysis of the RNAseq data and Marie O’Brian for the processing and cutting of the histological samples and the HipSci consortium for iPSC cell line (IERP4, OAPD4 and WIGW2).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
F.E.M., S.J.K., P.E.A.H. and S.W. designed the experiments and provided input for experimental analyses and data interpretation. F.E.M. and P.E.A.H. wrote the main manuscript and prepared the figures. Editing of the manuscript performed by P.E.A.H., S.W., S.J.K. and F.E.M. F.E.M. conducted all the main experiments reported here. N.B. performed histological staining of 3D pellet samples. S.C. and P.E.A.H. performed the differentiation by RAPID-E on hiPSCs (SW171A, SW163D, WIGW2, JF191B, IERP4 and OAPD4). J.OF. generated the JF191B hiPSC line. S.W. generated the SW171A and SW163D hiPSC lines. S.J.K., M.A.N.D. and L.B. supervised the project. All authors reviewed and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher's note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Mancini, F.E., Humphreys, P.E.A., Woods, S. et al. Effect of a retinoic acid analogue on BMP-driven pluripotent stem cell chondrogenesis. Sci Rep 14, 2696 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-52362-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-52362-3
- Springer Nature Limited